Seasonal variation in pathways of CH4 production and in CH4 oxidation in rice fields determined by stable carbon isotopes and specific inhibitors

Flooded rice fields, which are an important source of the atmospheric methane, have become a model system for the study of interactions between various microbial processes. We used a combination of stable carbon isotope measurements and application of specific inhibitors in order to investigate the importance of various methanogenic pathways and of CH₄ oxidation for controlling CH₄ emission. The fraction of CH₄ produced from acetate and H₂/CO₂ was calculated from the isotopic signatures of acetate, carbon dioxide (CO₂) and methane (CH₄) measured in porewater, gas bubbles, in the aerenchyma of the plants and/or in incubation experiments. The calculated ratio between both pathways reflected well the ratio determined by application of methyl fluoride (CH₃F) as specific inhibitor of acetate‐dependent methanogenesis. Only at the end of the season, the theoretical ratio of acetate: H₂ = 2 : 1 was reached, whereas at the beginning H₂/CO₂‐dependent methanogenesis dominated. The isotope discrimination was different between rooted surface soil and unrooted deep soil. Root‐associated CH₄ production was mainly driven by H₂/CO₂. Porewater CH₄ was found to be a poor proxy for produced CH₄. The fraction of CH₄ oxidised was calculated from the isotopic signature of CH₄ produced in vitro compared to CH₄ emitted in situ, corrected for the fractionation during the passage from the aerenchyma to the atmosphere. Isotope mass balances and in situ inhibition experiments with difluoromethane (CH₂F₂) as specific inhibitor of methanotrophic bacteria agreed that CH₄ oxidation was quantitatively important at the beginning of the season, but decreased later. The seasonal pattern was consistent with the change of potential CH₄ oxidation rates measured in vitro. At the end of the season, isotope techniques detected an increase of oxidation activity that was too small to be measured with the flux‐based inhibitor technique. If porewater CH₄ was used as a proxy of produced CH₄, neither magnitude nor seasonal pattern of in situ CH₄ oxidation could be reproduced. An oxidation signal was also found in the isotopic signature of CH₄ from gas bubbles that were released by natural ebullition. In contrast, bubbles stirred up from the bulk soil had preserved the isotopic signature of the originally produced CH₄.