Plant Breeding and Drought in C3 Cereals: What Should We Breed For?

Drought is the main abiotic constraint on cereal yield. Analysingphysiological determinants of yield responses to water may helpin breeding for higher yield and stability under drought conditions.The traits to select (either for stress escape, avoidance ortolerance) and the framework where breeding for drought stressis addressed will depend on the level and timing of stress inthe targeted area. If the stress is severe, breeding under stress-freeconditions may be unsuccessful and traits that confer survivalmay become a priority. However, selecting for yield itself understress-alleviated conditions appears to produce superior cultivars,not only for optimum environments, but also for those characterizedby frequent mild and moderate stress conditions. This impliesthat broad avoidance/tolerance to mild–moderate stressesis given by constitutive traits also expressed under stress-freeconditions. In this paper, we focus on physiological traitsthat contribute to improved productivity under mild–moderatedrought. Increased crop performance may be achieved throughimprovements in water use, water-use efficiency and harvestindex. The first factor is relevant when soil water remainsavailable at maturity or when deep-rooted genotypes access waterin the soil profile that is not normally available; the twolatter conditions become more important when all available wateris exhausted by the end of the crop cycle. Independent of themechanism operating, a canopy able to use more water than anotherwould have more open stomata and therefore higher canopy temperaturedepression, and ¹³C discrimination (¹³C) in plant matter. Thesame traits would also seem to be relevant when breeding forhot, irrigated environments. Where additional water is not availableto the crop, higher water-use efficiency (WUE) appears to bean alternative strategy to improve crop performance. In thiscontext ¹³C constitutes a simple but reliable measure of WUE.However, in contrast to lines performing better because of increasedaccess to water, lines producing greater biomass due to superiorWUE will have lower ¹³C values. WUE may be modified not onlythrough a decrease in stomatal conductance, but also throughan increase in photosynthetic capacity. Harvest index is stronglyreduced by terminal drought (i.e. drought during grain filling).Thus, phenological traits increasing the relative amount ofwater used during grain filling, or adjusting the crop cycleto the seasonal pattern of rainfall may be useful. Augmentingthe contribution of carbohydrate reserves accumulated duringvegetative growth to grain filling may also be worthwhile inharsh environments. Alternatively, extending the duration ofstem elongation without changing the timing of anthesis wouldincrease the number of grains per spike and the harvest indexwithout changing the amount of water utilized by the crop.