Succession of Selected Strains of Acetobacter pasteurianus and Other Acetic Acid Bacteria in Traditional Balsamic Vinegar

The application of a selected Acetobacter pasteurianus strain for traditional balsamic vinegar production was assessed. Genomic DNA was extracted from biofilms after enrichment cultures on GYC medium (10% glucose, 1.0% yeast extract, 2.0% calcium carbonate) and used for PCR/denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis, 16S rRNA gene sequencing, and enterobacterial repetitive intergenic consensus/PCR sequencing. Results suggested that double-culture fermentation is suitable for traditional balsamic vinegar acetification.The use of selected starter cultures (SSC) in fermented food production is widely applied throughout the food industry, in particular for wine, dairy products, sausages, and a variety of vegetables (3, 11). The advantages of their use are related to the improvement of the process control, hygiene, and quality with respect to fermented foods obtained through indigenous fermentation. Vinegar is one of the fermented beverages produced without SSC inoculation, in both small- and large-scale production, mainly for the following reasons: (i) the majority of vinegars have low commercial value, and often technological innovation is not considered profitable, and (ii) there is limited knowledge of the ecophysiology of acetic acid bacteria (AAB) due to the difficulty in accessing, sampling, isolating, and preserving strains (2, 12, 15, 16, 17). Among vinegars, traditional balsamic vinegar (TBV) is an Italian aged condiment produced by “seed vinegar,” the so-called “mother of vinegar” that is an indigenous starter culture withdrawn from acetifying vinegar through back-slopping procedures. The raw material is a fermented and cooked grape must (here indicated as must) at a soluble solids content ranging from 20 to 60°Bx (10). TBV production is regulated by denomination of protected origin guidelines that specify procedures and final product features. In particular, the raw material characteristics, the production process (e.g., must cooking, alcoholic fermentation, acetic oxidation, and ageing), features of the production area (no environmental condition management is permitted), and analytical and sensorial parameters are stated as follows: acidity (not less than 4.5% [wt/wt], expressed as grams of acetic acid per 100 g of product), density at 20°C (not less than 1.240 g per liter), color, aroma, and taste. The production is performed in wood barrels, and the process is carried out by sequential refilling to acetify the must and replace the volume lost by evaporation. AAB grow on the surface of liquid by biofilm formation. No addition of any substance can be made except for the acetifying must as a starter (7). Microbial studies of TBV reported culture-dependent and -independent approaches to evaluating AAB occurrence in TBV musts (5, 10). These studies highlighted the occurrence of Gluconacetobacter europaeus as a widespread indigenous species, as well as Acetobacter pasteurianus, Acetobacter aceti, and Acetobacter malorum. However, no comprehensive studies of AAB diversity and the correlation between species occurrence and technological steps of TBV production have been published, due mainly to the difficulty of easy access to AAB microflora in vinegar matrix by both culture-dependent and -independent approaches.Regarding production technology, at least one drawback of current production procedures has been acknowledged. It concerns the difficulty of start-up acetification, which affects the minimum acidity value required for the final product. In fact, some studies showed that many variables regulate AAB growth and activity. Above all is the sugar concentration among substrates and the temperature among physical parameters. To efficiently control the acetification start-up, it is necessary to understand the function of AAB responsible for the initial colonization of musts and to investigate the microbial succession suitable to complete the acetification. Our previous researches on TBV showed that AAB strains exhibit different growing abilities. In particular, strains of Acetobacter pasteurianus grow quickly on laboratory synthetic media, wine, and cooked must. In contrast, strains belonging to G. europaeus do not grow or grow very slowly on cooked and fermented must (9, 10).The goal of this study was to implement a laboratory SSC to test it on a factory scale for TBV production purposes. In particular, we focused our attention on the effect of A. pasteurianus strain AB0220 on the acetification and dynamics of species at the end of the process. The SSC effectiveness was assessed by monitoring analytical parameters (acetic acid, ethanol, and pH), species succession, and strain persistence during three stages by the following molecular analyses: PCR/denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE), 16S rRNA gene sequencing, and enterobacterial repetitive intergenic consensus (ERIC)/PCR sequencing using genomic DNA extracted from biofilms recovered on GYC (10% glucose, 1.0% yeast extract, 2.0% calcium carbonate) plates.