Diet diversity among five co-existing fish species in a tropical river: integration of dietary and stable isotope data

Diets were estimated from stomach contents and the MixSIR model using stable isotope values for five co-existing and abundant benthic fishes in relation to potential prey from a riffle habitat in a tropical river in eastern Thailand. Collectively, aquatic insects were of greatest dietary importance based on stomach contents and, except for one fish species, predicted from the MixSIR. The most prominent functional feeding insect groups in fish diets were collector-filterers and scrapers and, to a lesser extent, predators. MixSIR predicted shrimp to be the most important single dietary constituent for all fishes in contrast to stomach contents, which indicated they are a major item for only one species. MixSIR predicted plant material to be more important in fish diets than stomach contents where the composition of detritus was a concern. Differences in temporal feeding schedules, prey availability, species adaptations and others are important in understanding diet and in the construction of food webs. Stable isotope and dietary analysis provides a more accurate assessment of the food web structure and dynamics of tropical river ecosystems than either method alone.