Mutant yields and mutational spectra of the heterocyclic amines MeIQ and PhIP at the S1 locus of human-hamster AL cells with activation by chick embryo liver (CELC) co-cultures

Cooking meat and fish at high temperature creates heterocyclic amines (HA) including 2-amino-3,4-dimethylimidazo[4,5-f]quinoline (MeIQ) and 2-amino-1-methyl-6-phenylimidazo[4,5-b]pyridine (PhIP). Several HA are mutagens in the Ames' S9/Salmonella assay. While PhIP is a substantial Ames' test mutagen, it is 1000-fold less active than the extraordinarily potent MeIQ. In contrast, MeIQ is significantly less mutagenic than PhIP in several mammalian cell assays, especially in repair-deficient Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. HA are suspect human carcinogens on the basis of (i) epidemiological evidence, (ii) induction of tumors in rodents and monkeys, (iii) DNA adduct formation and (iv) mutagenic capacity. In this study, MeIQ and PhIP were significant mutagens at the S1 locus of co-cultivated human/hamster hybrid AL cells following metabolic activation by beta-napthoflavone (betaNF)-induced chick embryonic liver cultures (CELC). MeIQ was more mutagenic than PhIP in the CELC+AL cell assay. The mutant response curves increase with dose and then plateau (PhIP), or decrease (MeIQ). The inflections in these response curves coincide with dose-dependent decreases in cytochrome CYP1A1 activity. Molecular analysis of S1- mutants indicates that a substantial fraction, >65%, of the mutations induced by PhIP are deletions of 4.2 to 133 (Mbp); half are larger than 21 Mbp. Mutations induced by MeIQ were smaller, most (56%) being less than 5.7 Mbp. When appropriate metabolic activation is combined with a target locus, which can detect both small and large chromosomal mutations, both MeIQ and PhIP are significant mutagens and clastogens in repair proficient mammalian cells.