Growth response of Trifolium repens L. and Lolium perenne L. as monocultures and bi-species mixture to free air CO2 enrichment and management

Trifolium repens L. and Lolium perenne L. were grown in monocultures and bi-species mixture in a Free Air Carbon Dioxide Enrichment (FACE) experiment at elevated (60 Pa) and ambient (35 Pa) CO₂ partial pressure (pCO₂) for three years. The effects of defoliation frequencies (4 and 7 cuts in 1993; 4 and 8 cuts in 1994/95) and nitrogen fertilization (10 and 42 g m^–2 y^–1 N in 1993; 14 and 56 g m^–2 y^–1 N in 1994/95) on the growth response to pCO₂ were investigated. There were significant interspecific differences in the CO₂ responses during the first two years, while in the third growing season, these interspecific differences disappeared. Yield of T. repens in monocultures increased in the first two years by 20% when grown at elevated pCO₂. This CO₂ response was independent of defoliation frequency and nitrogen fertilization. In the third year, the CO₂ response of T. repens declined to 11%. In contrast, yield of L. perenne monocultures increased by only 7% on average over three years at elevated pCO₂. The yield response of L. perenne to CO₂ changed according to defoliation frequency and nitrogen fertilization, mainly in the second and third year. The ratio of root/yield of L. perenne increased under elevated pCO₂, low N fertilizer rate, and frequent defoliation, but it remained unchanged in T. repens. We suggest that the more abundant root growth of L. perenne was related to increased N limitation under elevated pCO₂. The consequence of these interspecific differences in the CO₂ response was a higher proportion of T. repens in the mixed swards at elevated pCO₂. This was evident in all combinations of defoliation and nitrogen treatments. However, the proportion of the species was more strongly affected by N fertilization and defoliation frequency than by elevated pCO₂. Based on these results, we conclude that the species proportion in managed grassland may change as the CO₂ concentration increases. However, an adapted management could, at least partially, counteract such CO₂ induced changes in the proportion of the species. Since the availability of mineral N in the soil may be important for the species’ responses to elevated pCO₂, more long-term studies, particularly of processes in the soil, are required to predict the entire ecosystem response.