Response of three phytoplankton bioassay techniques in experimental ponds of known limiting nutrient

In a controlled enrichment study of eight experimental ponds, results from the batch bioassay, primary productivity incubation bioassay, and chemostat techniques for measuring limiting factors of phytoplankton algae were compared to the change in the natural system with nutrient addition. In the ponds, rapid and dramatic increase in both phytoplankton biomass and primary productivity upon the addition of nitrogen and phosphorus fertilizer offered conclusive evidence that these nutrients were limiting in the control ponds to which no nutrients were added. Both the batch bioassay and chemostat techniques clearly indicated nitrogen and possibly phosphorus as the limiting factors; however, the primary productivity incubation bioassay technique showed no increase in ¹⁴C uptake with addition of these nutrients. A species- and/or nutrient-specific time lag between nutrient uptake and increased carbon fixation is suggested to explain the failure of the technique to yield positive results within the 4-hour incubation period used.