Heterogeneity in arbuscular mycorrhizal fungal communities may contribute to inconsistent plant-soil feedback in a Neotropical forest

Background and aims

Plant-soil feedback may vary across host species and environmental gradients. The relative importance of these biotic versus abiotic drivers of feedback will determine the stability of plant and microbial communities across environments. If plant hosts are the main driver of soil microbial communities, plant-soil feedback may be stable across changing environments. However, if microbial communities vary with environmental gradients, feedback may also vary, limiting its capacity to predict plant distributions.

Methods

We characterized arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) fungi across tree plantations and a primary Neotropical rainforest. We then performed a plant-soil feedback pot experiment of AM fungi from these plantations on three plant species and related feedback and AM fungal communities in the field.

Results

In the field, temporal and spatial variation in AM fungal composition was similar in magnitude to variation across plant host species. Composition of AM fungi in the pot experiment significantly differed from the field plots. Furthermore, differential feedback was explained by shifts in AM fungal composition only for one plant host species (Hyeronima alchorneoides) in the pot experiment.

Conclusions

Natural AM fungal communities were temporally and spatially heterogeneous and AM fungal communities in the greenhouse did not reflect natural soils. These factors led to heterogeneous and unpredictable feedback responses, which suggests that applying greenhouse derived plant-soil feedback trends to predict plant coexistence in natural systems may be misleading.