Dynamics of female choice for parental care in a fish species where care is facultative

In the peacock wrasse (Symphodus tinca), females either placetheir eggs in a nest under the care of a male or disperse theireggs widely so that they receive no protection. The same femalecan spawn in both modes. Females appear to prefer males withnests early in the nesting cycle, and they spawn less oftenthan expected in late-cycle nests and with non-nesting males.Survival and hatching success are consistently higher for eggsplaced in early nests, particularly in mid-season when egg predationis intense and hatching times are relatively long. Nevertheless,30%-80% of females place their eggs outside nests, even whenhatching success is more than four times greater with care.A model incorporating search time for nests correctly predictedthe qualitative changes in the tendency of females to choosecare or no care over the course of the mating season. Extensionsof the model suggest that in the early part of the season, whennests are rare and the relative survival advantage of parentalcare is small, females should sample no more than one nest beforeopting for no care. In mid-season, when the advantages of careare highest and between-nest travel times are low, females areestimated to visit at least 8 nests before abandoning the effort,corresponding to a giving-up time of about 43 min of search.Later in the season, when short hatching times reduce the relativebenefit of care, females are estimated to visit between 4 and5 nests before giving up, corresponding to about 31 min of search.We suggest that the variability in parental care in this speciesarises from seasonal changes in relative costs and benefitsof care for the two sexes.