On the evolutionary ecology of marking pheromones

Summary Many parasitic insects mark hosts with a pheromone after oviposition. The evolutionary ecology of such marking pheromones was studied to determine (i) under what ecological and behavioral conditions such pheromones could evolve and (ii) why so many of these marking pheromones are water-soluble and thus short-lived. We used a number of different techniques. First, the fitness values of individual normal (nonmarking) and mutant (marking) insects foraging for hosts were computed using dynamic state-variable models. Second, population level models were used to study when a population of non-marking individuals can be invaded by marking individuals. Third, behavior-rich simulations (developed originally for apple maggot,Rhagoletis pomonella) were used to test experimentally some of the hypotheses generated using the individual and population-level models. Finally, we developed a model for the benefit over time to an individual by marking. This model shows that when benefit is measured in terms of larval survival, nearly all of the benefit to a mother is obtained from short-lived marks. Genetical theories of pheromone evolution and the connection between our results and existing theories of altruistic behavior are discussed.