Unsuspected cryptic polymorphism in the polychromatic Midas cichlid.

The Midas cichlid ( Cichlasoma citrinellum ) of Nicaragua shows stable polychromatism in that a consistent, small proportion of the fish in nature lose their melanophores and thereby become gold-coloured. Before metamorphosis, all fish look alike. We asked whether the pre-transformed offspring of gold and normal morphs might differ in their morphological and physiological responses to white and to black backgrounds despite looking the same. More chromatophores developed in all juveniles exposed for two weeks to a black than to a white background. When moved from one background to the other, the fish adjusted to white faster than to black. Most importantly, genetically normal fish (N) colour-matched quicker than genetically gold fish (G) irrespective of the direction of change. Adjustment in G was also more variable, indicating poorer control. A parallel pattern was recorded photometrically in melanophores of excised scales: aggregation of pigment was faster than dispersion. And pigment in the melanophores of N aggregated and dispersed swifter than did those of G. Therefore, pre-metamorphosed juvenile G could be more vulnerable to predation than are juvenile N. This reveals a possible source of selection against the offspring of gold morphs before they become gold-coloured.