THE PROBLEM OF PLOIDY IN ECHEVERIA (CRASSULACEAE) I. DIPLOIDY IN E. CILIATA

The largely Mexican genus Echeveria is characterized by an extensive series of dysploid chromosome numbers, with every gametic number from 12 to 34 known in at least one species. Within this nearly three-fold range of numbers, the boundary between diploidy and tetraploidy is not immediately apparent. However, species of Echeveria can be hybridized in an extraordinary number of combinations, both among themselves and with related genera, and study of the morphology of the hybrids and the pairing of their chromosomes provides information that helps to identify the ploidy of the parents. This paper reports observations from study of 80 hybrids between E. ciliata (n = 25) and 73 other species and/or cytotypes. Hybrids between E. ciliata and definite diploids are all nicely intermediate morphologically, whatever the chromosome numbers. In these same hybrids, most chromosomes become involved in pairing at meiosis, and the number of paired elements (bivalents and multivalents) approaches or equals, but never exceeds, the number of chromosomes received from the lower-numbered parent. In most cells, relatively few univalents are present, sometimes none. These observations are considered to indicate that all paired elements include at least one chromosome from each parent and therefore that pairing occurs between chromosomes of different parents only (allosyndesis). Since none of the 25 gametic chromosomes of E. ciliata is able to pair with any other, although they do pair very extensively with chromosomes from many other species having a wide range of numbers, E. ciliata is considered to be diploid in spite of its relatively high chromosome number. On the other hand, hybrids of E. ciliata with definite polyploids resemble the latter much more closely in their morphology, and at meiosis most or all pairing occurs by autosyndesis between chromosomes received from the polyploid parent, while the chromosomes from E. ciliata generally remain unpaired. In these respects most, but not all, species of Echeveria having as many as 34 gametic chromosomes have the same properties as E. ciliata and also are considered to be diploid. The ancestral chromosome number in the genus is not clear, but it is probably near the upper end of the series of dysploid numbers.