Comparison of Effects of Compost Amendment and of Single-Strain Inoculation on Root Bacterial Communities of Young Cucumber Seedlings

Compost amendment and inoculations with specific microorganisms are fundamentally different soil treatment methods, commonly used in agriculture for the improvement of plant growth and health. Although distinct, both methods affect the rhizosphere and the plant roots. In the present study we used a 16S rRNA gene approach to achieve an overview of early consequences of these treatments on the assemblage of plant root bacterial communities. For this purpose, cucumber seedlings were grown, under controlled conditions, in perlite potting mix amended with biosolid compost or straw compost, or inoculated with Streptomyces spp. A uniform trend of response of root bacterial communities for all treatments was observed. Root bacterial density, measured as bacterial targets per plant tef gene by real-time PCR, was reduced in 31 to 67%. In addition, increased taxonomic diversity accompanied shifts in composition (α-diversity). The magnitude of change in these parameters relative to the perlite control varied between the different treatments but not in relation to the treatment method (compost amendments versus inoculations). Similarity between the compositions of root and of potting mix bacterial communities (β-diversity) was relatively unchanged. The abundance of Oxalobacteraceae was >50% of the total root bacterial community in the untreated perlite. Root domination by this group subsided >10-fold (straw compost) to >600-fold (Streptomyces sp. strain S1) after treatment. Thus, loss of dominance appears to be the major phenomenon underlining the response trend of the root bacterial communities.Environmental concern over conventional agricultural fertilization and disease control measures has led to increased interest in finding environmentally friendly alternatives. The most explored ones include compost amendments (18, 36) and the application of different microbial preparations (11, 19, 37). These are widely distinct applications. The first approach adds to the amended medium not only a rich and diverse consortium of biological agents but also organic matter and nutrients. It was confirmed that the efficacy of such treatments involves the response of the soil, the plant, and the rhizosphere microbial communities (19, 56). The activities of rhizosphere microorganisms alter the rhizosphere and thus affect plant health and root growth and development (24). Therefore, one of the main objectives of compost amendment or of inoculation with specific microbial strains is manipulation of the plant rhizosphere conditions, particularly via manipulation of the microbial community composition (32).The response of rhizosphere bacterial communities to different anthropogenic and other disturbances has been discussed in terms of resilience (3, 32). Generally, the introduction of new microorganisms produces only restricted spatial and temporal effects on the soil, rhizosphere, and root microbial communities (4, 29, 35). Thus, the plant growth-promoting effect of such treatments may be related to microbial events occurring during the early stages of plant development. Such early effects were pointed out for inoculants of different bacterial species (14, 42) and for compost amendment (15, 21, 50).Consequences of compost amendment or of single species inoculation often include shifts in the plant roots hormonal balance or a plant systemic response, namely, induced systemic resistance (8, 38, 52). Thus, direct or indirect activities of the introduced microorganisms may result in similar modifications of the root habitat. If so, bacterial assemblages of treated roots may share qualitative and quantitative characteristics different from those exhibited by untreated roots.The objective of the present study was therefore to describe and compare responses of bacterial communities of young plant roots to the application of compost or bacterial inoculants. This was performed in a simple model comprised of cucumber seedlings grown in potting mixes amended with compost or inoculated with Streptomyces spp. isolated from the two different composts.