Expression of Distinct Self-Incompatibility Specificities in Arabidopsis thaliana

The interplay of balancing selection within a species and rapid gene evolution between species can confound our ability to determine the functional equivalence of interspecific and intergeneric pairs of alleles underlying reproduction. In crucifer plants, mating specificity in the barrier to self-fertilization called self-incompatibility (SI) is controlled by allele-specific interactions between two highly polymorphic and co-evolving proteins, the S-locus receptor kinase (SRK) and its S-locus cysteine rich (SCR) ligand. These proteins have diversified both within and between species such that it is often difficult to determine from sequence information alone if they encode the same or different SI specificity. The self-fertile Arabidopsis thaliana was derived from an obligate outbreeding ancestor by loss of self-incompatibility, often in conjunction with inactivation of SRK or SCR. Nevertheless, some accessions of A. thaliana can express self-incompatibility upon transformation with an SRK–SCR gene pair isolated from its self-incompatible close relative A. lyrata. Here we show that several additional and highly diverged SRK/SCR genes from A. lyrata and another crucifer plant, Capsella grandiflora, confer self-incompatibility in A. thaliana, either as intact genes isolated from genomic libraries or after manipulation to generate chimeric fusions. We describe how the use of this newly developed chimeric protein strategy has allowed us to test the functional equivalence of SRK/SCR gene pairs from different taxa and to assay the functionality of endogenous A. thaliana SRK and SCR sequences.MATING reactions in plants, fungi, and animals are strongly influenced by molecular recognition machineries that act as gauges of genetic relatedness (Brown and Casselton 2001; Nasrallah 2005; Yamazaki and Beauchamp 2007). Many plants with hermaphroditic flowers have evolved inbreeding avoidance mechanisms, known as self-incompatibility (SI) systems. These systems are based on the ability of the female reproductive apparatus (the pistil) to discriminate among genetically distinct pollen grains, resulting in the failure of self-pollination despite functional female and male reproductive structures. In the Brassicaceae (crucifers), specific recognition of pollen by the epidermal cells of the stigma (a structure located at the tip of the pistil) is controlled by haplotypes of the S locus, and activation of the SI response leading to inhibition of pollen tube growth occurs if pollen and stigma are derived from plants that express the same S-locus haplotype (S haplotype). Within self-incompatible crucifer species, the number of S haplotypes and corresponding SI specificities is usually high, with >50 reported in some species (Watanabe et al. 2000), and SI dictates that self-incompatible plants are typically heterozygous and carry two S haplotypes. Each S haplotype is composed of two highly polymorphic genes that are the determinants of SI specificity in stigma and pollen (Stein et al. 1991; Schopfer et al. 1999). The S-locus receptor kinase (SRK) gene encodes a single-pass transmembrane serine/threonine kinase localized on the surface of stigma epidermal cells, and the S-locus cysteine-rich protein (SCR) gene encodes a small peptide localized in the pollen coat. SCR is the ligand for SRK and will bind to the extracellular domain of SRK (hereafter eSRK) only if both proteins are encoded by the same S-locus haplotype (Kachroo et al. 2001; Takayama et al. 2001; Chookajorn et al. 2004). The binding of SCR to its cognate eSRK triggers an intracellular phosphorylation cascade that results in pollen rejection by a poorly understood mechanism.A mechanistic understanding of the recognition phase of SI requires detailed structure–function analyses of SRK and SCR aimed at identifying the amino acid residues that determine their allele-specific interaction and explaining the puzzling dominance/recessive interactions exhibited by different SRK alleles in the heterozygous stigmas of self-incompatible plants (Hatakeyama et al. 2001; Mable et al. 2003; Prigoda et al. 2005). Such structure–function studies require an experimental system that allows efficient in vivo functional analysis of large numbers of SRK and SCR sequence variants generated in vitro by site-directed mutagenesis or domain swapping between proteins that determine different SI specificities. The recent transfer of the SI trait into Arabidopsis thaliana has established this species as a model organism for mechanistic and evolutionary studies of mating systems in crucifers (Nasrallah et al. 2002, 2004). However, to date, only one SI specificity, that which is determined by the Sb haplotype of A. lyrata, has been successfully introduced into A. thaliana and shown to alter the plant''s mating reaction from strict autogamy to full SI. To exploit fully the A. thaliana transgenic SI model, additional S haplotypes must be introduced into this species. In addition to facilitating mechanistic studies of the SRK–SCR interaction and dominance relationships, the expression of multiple SI specificities in A. thaliana promises to shed light on processes underlying the diversification of SRK and SCR genes. For example, expression in A. thaliana of SI specificities derived from different crucifer species will allow direct assays of the functional equivalence or nonequivalence of the corresponding S haplotypes, an issue that is difficult to resolve on the basis of sequence information alone.Although conceptually simple, expressing different SI specificities by transformation with different SRK/SCR gene pairs is not a straightforward proposition. Difficulties stem largely from the availability of appropriate cloned SRK/SCR variants for use in transformation experiments. A large number of SRK/SCR gene pairs are available from Brassica species as a result of extensive and long-standing studies of SI. However, attempts to restore SI in transgenic A. thaliana using Brassica S-locus genes had met with failure (Bi et al. 2000; J. B. Nasrallah, unpublished data), possibly because of the inability of Brassica SRKs to interact productively with A. thaliana components of the SI signal transduction pathway. In the past few years, studies of SI were initiated in self-incompatible species more closely related to A. thaliana, such as A. lyrata, A. halleri, and Capsella grandiflora. However, with a few exceptions, these studies produced only partial SRK and SCR sequences amplified from genomic DNA (Schierup et al. 2001; Prigoda et al. 2005; Bechsgaard et al. 2006; Paetsch et al. 2006). The challenging task of cloning the very highly polymorphic SCR sequences and complete SRK and SCR genes, which requires genomic library construction and in many cases chromosome walking, has only been accomplished for two S haplotypes of A. lyrata, Sb (hereafter AlSb, which was used in previous transformation studies (Nasrallah et al. 2002, 2004), and Sa (AlSa; Kusaba et al. 2001), and for the S7 haplotype of C. grandiflora (CgS7; Nasrallah et al. 2007).In this article, we report the isolation of two new SRK/SCR gene pairs from genomic libraries of A. lyrata and expression of the corresponding SI specificities in A. thaliana. We also describe a novel strategy for rapid and efficient transfer of several distinct SI specificities into A. thaliana, which only requires knowledge of the eSRK sequence and SCR second-exon sequences that encode the mature SCR protein.