Determination of the Diversity of Rhodopirellula Isolates from European Seas by Multilocus Sequence Analysis

In the biogeography of microorganisms, the habitat size of an attached-living bacterium has never been investigated. We approached this theme with a multilocus sequence analysis (MLSA) study of new strains of Rhodopirellula sp., an attached-living planctomycete. The development of an MLSA for Rhodopirellula baltica enabled the characterization of the genetic diversity at the species level, beyond the resolution of the 16S rRNA gene. The alleles of the nine housekeeping genes acsA, guaA, trpE, purH, glpF, fumC, icd, glyA, and mdh indicated the presence of 13 genetically defined operational taxonomic units (OTUs) in our culture collection. The MLSA-based OTUs coincided with the taxonomic units defined by DNA-DNA hybridization experiments. BOX-PCR supported the MLSA-based differentiation of two closely related OTUs. This study established a taxon-area relationship of cultivable Rhodopirellula species. In European seas, three closely related species covered the Baltic Sea and the eastern North Sea, the North Atlantic region, and the southern North Sea to the Mediterranean. The last had regional genotypes, as revealed by BOX-PCR. This suggests a limited habitat size of attached-living Rhodopirellula species.The biogeography of microorganisms describes the habitat size of the species and the distribution of microorganisms on Earth. The experimental approaches depend on the focus of the studies. Habitats are often analyzed by environmental microbiologists with genetic-fingerprinting techniques, with up to 200 bands or fragments representing the whole community. Although the taxonomic resolution of these operational taxonomic units (OTUs) is limited, the studies revealed a community biogeography (22). Medical microbiologists analyze the alleles of housekeeping genes of microorganisms to gain insight into the epidemiology of pathogens, the population biogeography (2). This strain-specific, fine-scale taxonomic resolution within a species is well suited to observance of recent dispersal events. At the species level, multilocus sequence typing (MLST) and analysis (MLSA), which were developed for intraspecies and intragenus specific studies, respectively, consist of the sequences of several (at least seven) housekeeping gene fragments concatenated to an approximately 5-kilobase alignment (17). Recent MLSA studies revealed its applicability to marine isolates and the analysis of biogeographic patterns: Alteromonas macleodii isolates could be grouped in an epipelagic and an abyssal clade (6), and strains of Pseudomonas aeruginosa were genetically well separated into groups of coastal and oceanic origin (8). However, for Salinibacter ruber strains, biogeographical distinctness was not resolved in an MLSA study but showed allopatry in a metabolic analysis (31). Several studies used MLSA together with DNA-DNA hybridization (DDH) for the delineation of new species, e.g., for Vibrio and Ensifer spp. (20, 36).In the biogeography of microorganisms, the experimental proof of a local genetic evolution was first revealed at sample sites that were physically separated by over 18,000 km (39). Large populations and the small size of microbes have been considered as facilitators for dispersal over long distances, eventually establishing cosmopolitan microbial populations. On the other hand, the smallest spatial scale of a microbial species in an open system has not been investigated. Attached-living bacteria disperse only during a distinct, short time span in their lives. This limitation of the dispersal time stimulated this study of the biogeography of Rhodopirellula baltica in European seas.R. baltica is a planctomycete with typical morphological features. The peptidoglycanless bacteria have an intracellular compartmentation: the riboplasm with the nucleoid is separated by a membrane from the surrounding paryphoplasm. Cells attach with a holdfast substance to surfaces or, in culture, to themselves, forming typical rosettes. Proliferation occurs by budding, and offspring cells live free in the water column: they are motile with a flagellum until they settle on the sediment (4).Seventy recently isolated strains affiliated according to the 16S rRNA gene analysis with R. baltica SH1^T as the closest validly described species (40). The 16S rRNA gene sequences do not offer sufficient information at the species level. A dissimilarity of the 16S rRNA genes of more than 3%, recently reduced to 1.3% (34, 35), indicates that the strains under consideration belong to two species. These thresholds yielded in our strain collection, according to an ARB-based calculation, five or eight operational taxonomic units besides the species R. baltica (40). For strains with highly identical sequences, whole-genome DDH experiments have to be performed to identify the affiliation to established species. Recently, multilocus sequence analyses have emerged as a possible alternative method. Our strain collection comprised many strains with a 16S rRNA gene sequence very closely related to that of R. baltica SH1^T. To gain insight into the genetic identity of the isolates on the species level and the habitat sizes of the species, we developed a multilocus sequence analysis and applied it to the strain collection. The MLSA results were calibrated with a DDH study. The closely related strains were additionally characterized by BOX-PCR, a fingerprinting method (15). Transmission electron microscopy (EM) was performed on some isolates to support the identification as Planctomycetes and to visualize morphological differences between strains.