Apparent phytotoxicity of mononuclear hydroxy-aluminum to four dicotyledonous species

It has long been assumed that Al³⁺ is an important rhizotoxic ion in acid soils around the world, but the toxicity of Al³⁺ relative to mononuclear hydroxy-Al AlOH²⁺ and Al(OH)⁺₂] has been examined in detail only for an Al-sensitive wheat variety ( Triticum aestivum L. cv. Tyler). That plant appears to be sensitive to Al³⁺ but not to AlOH²⁺ and Al(OH)⁺₂. New experiments, and reanalyses of previously published experiments, provide evidence that dicotyledonous species may be sensitive to mononuclear hydroxy-Al and that Al³⁺ may be nontoxic, or less toxic, to those plants. Despite these consistently measured differences between wheat and the dicotyledons, the determination of relative toxicities (Al³⁺ vs mononuclear hydroxy-Al) may be an intractable problem. Because of hydrolysis equilibria, (AlOH²⁺) and (Al(OH)⁺₂) are equivalent to (Al³⁺)k₁(H⁺)⁻¹ and (l³⁺)k₂(H⁺)⁻², respectively, in which k₁ and k₂ are the first and second hydrolysis constants (braces denote activities). Thus, any expression of root elongation as a function of mononuclear hydroxy-Al can be alternatively expressed as a function of (Al³⁺) and (H⁺). Toxicity attributed to mononuclear hydroxy-Al may actually be Al³⁺ toxicity that increases as pH rises (i.e. Al³⁺ toxicity ameliorated by H⁺).