Chloroplast DNA phylogeny and phylogeography of the North American plums (Prunus subgenus Prunus section Prunocerasus, Rosaceae)

The North American plums are a closely related group that are not easily circumscribed, have overlapping morphologies, and are known to hybridize. We previously showed that the North American plums are a closely related, monophyletic group of taxa with little to no cpDNA sequence divergence between taxa. In that study, we came to the unanticipated conclusion that relationships inferred among the taxa contrast sharply with previously defined groups based on morphological characters. Here the aim was to determine if the primary cpDNA haplotypes identified in our earlier study are confined to the taxa in which they were initially observed. The cpDNA rpL16 intron was sequenced for 207 accessions of the 17 North American plum taxa plus Prunus texana. The results show that many taxa contain more than one of the three primary cpDNA haplotypes. Aside from the results found in sect. Prunocerasus, this study has broader implications for phylogenetics in general. The common practice of choosing a single exemplar to represent a taxon can be profoundly misleading in closely related groups. In hindsight, the possibility existed in our earlier study that we could have chosen a different combination of exemplars, which could have resulted in a different inferred phylogeny.