Phylogenesis of spermatogenesis in Annulipalpia caddisflies: An ultrastructural analysis on philopotamidae spermiogenesis

Characters currently used in phylogenetic analyses are insufficient for determining the status of several families of the order Trichoptera (caddisflies). Comparative spermatology can contribute to solving this problem. In the suborder Integripalpia, the sperm axoneme displays the pattern of 9 + 2 pairs of parallel microtubules found in many animal species. In the suborder Annulipalpia, however, axonemes bear remarkable aberrations. Consistently, in Chimarra florida (Philopotamidae, Annulipalpia) we found that the number of central microtubules varies from zero to four in axonemes of the spermatids and that spermatozoa lack axonemes. We propose that, similarly, the axoneme pattern became unstable in the Annulipalpia ancestor, from which branched two phylogenetic lines having different kinds of axoneme aberrations: (a) families in which the number of central microtubules of the axoneme exceeds two (e.g., Philopotamidae, Polycentropodidae) and (b) families in which the number of central microtubules of the axoneme does not exceed two (e.g., Hydropsychidae).