Allozymic differentiation in the land snail Arianta arbustorum (Stylommatophora, Helicidae): historical inferences

The intraspecific genetic differentiation depends to a large part on historical factors. The mode of dispersal is an important determinant of the genetic diversity especially of newly founded populations. Fast long-distance colonization of formerly unsuitable habitats results in reduced genetic diversity and lineages originating from different glacial refugia form well-defined hybrid zones, where they meet. Slow dispersers, on the other hand, preserve their refugial genetic diversity. Paleontological findings and a previous analysis of mtDNA suggest that the land snail Arianta arbustorum, which today is widely spread across Europe, has survived the Pleistocene glaciations within the boundaries of permafrost. In the present paper, we asked, whether the differentiation of nuclear markers, i.e. allozymes, supports these results. We investigated the allozymic differentiation at 15 polymorphic loci in 14 Alpine and one English populations of the land snail A. arbustorum. Various tests of genetic population differentiation yielded ambiguous results. Allele frequencies differed significantly across populations and all but five pairwise F_ST values were significant. Genetic distances between populations were comparatively high. On the other hand, an exact test of population differentiation found no differences and the assignment of individuals to their populations of origin was poor. This indicates that allozymic differentiation is constrained. Whether these constraints are of natural or methodological nature remains open. Matrices of genetic and geographical distances were correlated only after removal of the English population from the analysis. Similarly, with one exception F_ST values increased as the number of regions included in the calculations increased. Thus, on a regional scale, we largely observed a pattern of isolation by distance, which does no longer hold on a larger scale. This is well in accordance with the previous findings based on mtDNA. Mitochondrial lineages were widely distributed across Europe and overlapped extensively. Considering the low potential for dispersal of a land snail, the patchy distribution of lineages, and the high genetic diversity also found in the present study suggests that A. arbustorum has survived the Pleistocene within the boundaries of permafrost.