Variation in the harvest index of tropical maize: evaluation of recent evidence from Mexico and Malawi

In temperate zones, the potential grain yield of wheat has increased during the twentieth century owing to progressive increases in the harvest index of new varieties, which are principally associated with reduction in plant stature. Crop biomass has not increased substantially. In contrast, the potential grain yield of maize in the USA has increased owing to progressive increases in biomass, principally associated with selection for grain yield at higher population density. Harvest index was already around 0.5 for recommended varieties in 1930, and has not increased significantly since. However, for both crops, the harvest index of a given variety has proved to be a highly‐heritable character, except under severe stress. Less is known about the physiology of tropical maize. This paper reviews evidence from Mexico and Malawi that tropical maize can respond to selection for reduced stature following the same pattern as temperate wheat, but, under other circumstances, the magnitude of harvest index is not highly heritable, varying inconsistently with season, management and environment. It is proposed that these differences arise out of the unique vulnerability of the grain‐setting process around flowering. The plasticity of harvest index under long, favourable conditions, however, remains to be explained, although it is probably also related to the events around grain setting. Nevertheless, to the subsistence farmer, higher harvest index may not be a high priority in crop improvement, because of the need for large quantities of high‐quality stover.