The mechanical significance of the occlusal geometry of great ape molars in food breakdown

Analyses of dental function are an essential component of the study of human evolution. However, with few exceptions, they have utilized the traditional analogizing method of comparative anatomy, and have assumed rather than demonstrated that proposed adaptive characters confer a performance benefit. Since food reduction is a mechanical process, it is appropriate to measure performance using mechanical parameters, specifically the ability of a given morphology to induce failure in food particle by either of the two major regimes: crush and shear, corresponding to simple stresses (tensile and compressive) and shear stress, respectively. We apply finite elements stress analysis to model the relationship between the angulation of the intercuspal occlusal surfaces in a “puncture crushing” mode of mastication. On the basis of morphological data acquired from sectioned great ape molars, we have predicted the nature, magnitude and distribution of stress in a standard food particle by models representing each morphotype. Results indicate that the blunt-cusped molars ofHomo, the gradually-sloping supporting (buccal) cusps but high-angled guiding (lingual) cusps of the lower molars ofPan, and the high angled occlusal surfaces ofGorillaare all more likely to fracture small food particles by shear, while the gradually sloping occlusal surfaces ofPongomolars are more likely to break them down by “crush”. Mechanisms of food failure induced by molars ofPanandHomowill vary according to the orientation of the tooth–food contacting surfaces, which in turn will vary according to the size of the food particle. These genera may be able to break food down either by shear or by “crush”.