Kinetics of the reduction of C-9 substituted acridinium cations by 1,4-dihydronicotinamides

Second-order rate constants (k₂) are reported for the reduction of 9-R-10-methylacridinium cations (5:R = H, CH₃, CH₃CH₂, C₆H₅CH₂, (CH₃)₂CH, C₆H₅, 4-(CH₃)₂NC₆H₄) by 1-benzyl-1,4-dihydronicotinamide (2:R = C₆H₅CH₂) in 20% CH₃CN-80% H₂O at 25°C. All 5:R ≠ H are reduced in the range 20- to 140-fold more slowly than 5:R = H. However, there is no simple relationship between k₂ and the nature of R, nor between k₂ and the second-order rate constant for hydroxide ion attack at C-9 of these cations in pseudobase formation. Rates of reduction of 5 by 1-benzyl-4,4-dideuterio-1,4-dihydronicotinamide allow the calculation of the following kinetic isotope effects in this solvent medium: 5:R, $\text{k}{}^{\mathrm{<mtext>H</mtext>}}\text{k}{}^{\mathrm{<mtext>D</mtext>}}\text{:}\text{H}$, 1.56; C₆H₅CH₂, 2.7; C₆H₅, 5.4. Substituent effects upon k₂ were evaluated for the reduction of 5 by 1-(X-benzyl)-1,4-dihydronicotinamides, and lead to the following Hammett ? parameters: 5:R, ?: H, ?0.68; C₆H₅CH₂, ?0.92; C₆H₅, ?0.96. The latter two values require essentially complete unit positive charge generation on the nicotinamide moiety in the rate-determining transition state. It is shown that these Hammett ? values and the above isotope effects can only be rationalized by a two-step e^? + H^? mechanism for hydride transfer from 2 to 5 in this solvent system. This result contrasts with our earlier conclusion of direct, one-step hydride transfer in the reduction of isoquinolinium cations by 2, but is consistent with our observation that acridinium cations are reduced 37500-fold faster by 2 than predicted on the basis of the relative rates of nucleophilic attack (hydroxide ion) on acridinium and isoquinolinium cations. It is suggested that the availability of both Hammett ? values and primary kinetic isotope effects will generally allow the establishment of the mechanism of hydride transfer in these systems. Application of these ideas to literature data suggests that 5:R = H is reduced by direct hydride transfer in acetonitrile solution, in contrast to the above result in predominantly aqueous solution. The ready formation of acridanyl radicals by electron transfer to acridinium cations is demonstrated by the formation of Wurster's Blue radical cation upon mixing solutions of acridinium cations with N,N,N′,N′-tetramethyl-p-phenylenediamine.