Microbial Factors Rather Than Bioavailability Limit the Rate and Extent of PAH Biodegradation in Aged Crude Oil Contaminated Model Soils

The rate and extent of polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH) biodegradation in a set of aged model soils that had been contaminated with crude oil at the high concentrations (i.e.,>20,000?mg/kg) normally found in the environment were measured in 90-week slurry bioremediation experiments. Soil properties such as organic matter content, mineral type, particle diameter, surface area, and porosity did not significantly influence the PAH biodegradation kinetics among the 10 different model soils. A comparison of aged and freshly spiked soils indicates that aging affects the biodegradation rate and extent only for higher-molecular-weight PAHs, while the effects of aging are insignificant for 4-ring PAHs and total PAHs. In all model soils with the exception of kaolinite clay, the rate of abiotic desorption was faster than the rate of biodegradation during the initial phase of bioremediation treatment, indicating that PAH biodegradation was limited by microbial factors. Similarly, any of the higher-molecular-weight PAHs that were still present after 90 weeks of treatment were released rapidly during abiotic desorption tests, which demonstrates that bioavailability limitations were not responsible for the recalcitrance of these hydrocarbons. Indeed, an analysis of microbial counts indicates that a severe reduction in hydrocarbon degrader populations may be responsible for the observed incomplete PAH biodegradation. Therefore, it can be concluded that the recalcitrance of PAHs during bioremediation is not necessarily due to bioavailability limitations and that these residual contaminants therefore might pose a greater risk to environmental receptors than previously thought.