Evaluating Hypotheses on the Evolution of Helping Behaviour in the Bell Miner (Manorina melanophrys)

In an analysis of the pattern of helping at the nest in bell miners (Manorina melanophrys), Clarke (1989) examined five hypotheses that could explain the evolution of helping behaviour in this species. We applaud the attempt by Clarke to consider many different hypotheses, but believe that more careful formulation of the hypotheses, more appropriate statistical analyses, and eventual experimental testing are required before his conclusions can be accepted.