Benomyl: Effectiveness against the microsporidian Nosema heliothidis in the corn earworm,Heliothis zea

The fungicide benomyl was studied as a possible antimicrobial agent for obtaining Nosema heliothidis-free laboratory colonies of Heliothis zea. Newly hatched, transovarially infected larvae were placed on artificial diets containing 250, 500, or 1000 ppm benomyl. While late-stage larvae were found to be free of Nosema spores, low-level infections were found in pupae and newly emerged adults. The reduced intensity of infection in adults reared as larvae on treated diets was not correlated with a significant reduction in the efficiency of transovarian transmission. The chemical effect of benomyl was manifested by aberrant spores and vegetative stages and a rapid reduction in the number of microsporidian stages. However, small, isolated centers of infection in various host tissues resulted in a rapid resurgence of the microsporidiosis in pupae and adults. Thus, at the concentrations tested, benomyl was not effective in eliminating infection by N. heliothidis in H. zea. A discussion of the necessity for careful evaluation of the apparent suppression of microsporidioses by antimicrobial agents is also presented.