Catalytic Properties of RNase BN/RNase Z from Escherichia coli: RNase BN IS BOTH AN EXO- AND ENDORIBONUCLEASE*

Processing of the 3′ terminus of tRNA in many organisms is carried out by an endoribonuclease termed RNase Z or 3′-tRNase, which cleaves after the discriminator nucleotide to allow addition of the universal -CCA sequence. In some eubacteria, such as Escherichia coli, the -CCA sequence is encoded in all known tRNA genes. Nevertheless, an RNase Z homologue (RNase BN) is still present, even though its action is not needed for tRNA maturation. To help identify which RNA molecules might be potential substrates for RNase BN, we carried out a detailed examination of its specificity and catalytic potential using a variety of synthetic substrates. We show here that RNase BN is active on both double- and single-stranded RNA but that duplex RNA is preferred. The enzyme displays a profound base specificity, showing no activity on runs of C residues. RNase BN is strongly inhibited by the presence of a 3′-CCA sequence or a 3′-phosphoryl group. Digestion by RNase BN leads to 3-mers as the limit products, but the rate slows on molecules shorter than 10 nucleotides in length. Most interestingly, RNase BN acts as a distributive exoribonuclease on some substrates, releasing mononucleotides and a ladder of digestion products. However, RNase BN also cleaves endonucleolytically, releasing 3′ fragments as short as 4 nucleotides. Although the presence of a 3′-phosphoryl group abolishes exoribonuclease action, it has no effect on the endoribonucleolytic cleavages. These data suggest that RNase BN may differ from other members of the RNase Z family, and they provide important information to be considered in identifying a physiological role for this enzyme.Maturation of tRNA precursors requires the removal of 5′ and 3′ precursor-specific sequences to generate the mature, functional tRNA (1). In eukaryotes, archaea, and certain eubacteria, the 3′-processing step is carried out by an endoribonuclease termed RNase Z or 3′-tRNase (2–6). However, in some bacteria, such as Escherichia coli, removal of 3′ extra residues is catalyzed by any of a number of exoribonucleases (7, 8). The major determinant for which mode of 3′-processing is utilized appears to be whether or not the universal 3′-terminal CCA sequence is encoded (2, 9). Thus, for those tRNA precursors in which the CCA sequence is absent, endonucleolytic cleavage by RNase Z right after the discriminator nucleotide generates a substrate for subsequent CCA addition by tRNA nucleotidyltransferase (1–3, 10). In view of this role for RNase Z in 3′-tRNA maturation, it is surprising that E. coli, an organism in which the CCA sequence is encoded in all tRNA genes (2), nevertheless contains an RNase Z homologue (11), because its action would appear not to be necessary. In fact, the physiological function of this enzyme in E. coli remains unclear, because mutants lacking this protein have no obvious growth phenotype (12). Hence, there is considerable interest in understanding the enzymatic capabilities of this enzyme.The E. coli RNase Z homologue initially was identified as a zinc phosphodiesterase (11) encoded by the elaC gene (now called rbn) (13). Subsequent work showed that the protein also displayed endoribonuclease activity on certain tRNA precursors in vitro (6, 14). However, more recent studies revealed that this protein actually is RNase BN, an enzyme originally discovered in 1983 and shown to be essential for maturation of those bacteriophage T4 tRNA precursors that lack a CCA sequence (15, 16). Using synthetic mimics of these T4 tRNA precursors, RNase BN was found to remove their 3′-terminal residue as a mononucleotide to generate a substrate for tRNA nucleotidyltransferase. Based on these reactions RNase BN was originally thought to be an exoribonuclease (13, 15, 17). However, subsequent work by us and others showed that it can act as an endoribonuclease on tRNA precursors (13, 18). RNase BN is required for maturation of tRNA precursors in E. coli mutant strains devoid of all other 3′-tRNA maturation exoribonucleases, although it is the least efficient RNase in this regard (7, 19). Thus, under normal circumstances, it is unlikely that RNase BN functions in maturation of tRNA in vivo except in phage T4-infected cells (15, 16).To obtain additional information on what types of RNA molecules might be substrates for RNase BN and to clarify whether it is an exo- or endoribonuclease, we have carried out a detailed examination of its catalytic properties and substrate specificity. We show here that RNase BN has both exo- and endoribonuclease activity and that it can act on a wide variety of RNA substrates. These findings suggest that E. coli RNase BN may differ from other members of the RNase Z family of enzymes.