Methodologic Implications of the Precautionary Principle: Causal Criteria

Applying the Precautionary Principle to public health requires a re-evaluation of the methods of inference currently used to make claims about disease causation from epidemiologic and other forms of scientific evidence. In current thinking, a well-established, near-certain causal relationship implies highly consistent statistically significant results across many different studies, large relative risk estimates, extensive understanding of biological mechanisms and dose-response relationships, positive prevention trial results, a clear temporal relationship between cause and effect, and other conditions spelled out in terms of the widely-used causal criteria. The Precautionary Principle, however, states that preventive measures are to be taken when cause and effect relationships are not fully established scientifically. What evidentiary conditions, as reflected in the causal criteria, will be certain enough to warrant precautionary preventive action? This paper argues that minimum evidentiary requirements for causation need to be articulated if the Precautionary Principle is to be successfully incorporated into public health practice. Two precautionary changes to criteria-based methods of causal inference are examined: reducing the number of criteria and weakening the rules of inference accompanying the criteria. Such changes point in the direction of identifying minimum evidentiary conditions, but would be premature without better understanding how well current methods of causal inference work.     

Genomic and experimental evidence for multiple metabolic functions in the RidA/YjgF/YER057c/UK114 (Rid) protein family

Background

It is now recognized that enzymatic or chemical side-reactions can convert normal metabolites to useless or toxic ones and that a suite of enzymes exists to mitigate such metabolite damage. Examples are the reactive imine/enamine intermediates produced by threonine dehydratase, which damage the pyridoxal 5''-phosphate cofactor of various enzymes causing inactivation. This damage is pre-empted by RidA proteins, which hydrolyze the imines before they do harm. RidA proteins belong to the YjgF/YER057c/UK114 family (here renamed the Rid family). Most other members of this diverse and ubiquitous family lack defined functions.

Results

Phylogenetic analysis divided the Rid family into a widely distributed, apparently archetypal RidA subfamily and seven other subfamilies (Rid1 to Rid7) that are largely confined to bacteria and often co-occur in the same organism with RidA and each other. The Rid1 to Rid3 subfamilies, but not the Rid4 to Rid7 subfamilies, have a conserved arginine residue that, in RidA proteins, is essential for imine-hydrolyzing activity. Analysis of the chromosomal context of bacterial RidA genes revealed clustering with genes for threonine dehydratase and other pyridoxal 5''-phosphate-dependent enzymes, which fits with the known RidA imine hydrolase activity. Clustering was also evident between Rid family genes and genes specifying FAD-dependent amine oxidases or enzymes of carbamoyl phosphate metabolism. Biochemical assays showed that Salmonella enterica RidA and Rid2, but not Rid7, can hydrolyze imines generated by amino acid oxidase. Genetic tests indicated that carbamoyl phosphate overproduction is toxic to S. enterica cells lacking RidA, and metabolomic profiling of Rid knockout strains showed ten-fold accumulation of the carbamoyl phosphate-related metabolite dihydroorotate.

Conclusions

Like the archetypal RidA subfamily, the Rid2, and probably the Rid1 and Rid3 subfamilies, have imine-hydrolyzing activity and can pre-empt damage from imines formed by amine oxidases as well as by pyridoxal 5''-phosphate enzymes. The RidA subfamily has an additional damage pre-emption role in carbamoyl phosphate metabolism that has yet to be biochemically defined. Finally, the Rid4 to Rid7 subfamilies appear not to hydrolyze imines and thus remain mysterious.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12864-015-1584-3) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

酵母双杂交系统筛选与RapGAP相互作用的蛋白质

目的筛选与Rap GAP相互作用的蛋白质,为进一步研究人源Rap1GAP介导的信号转导通路、揭示其与肿瘤的关系提供实验依据。方法选用与Rap1GAP同源的来自美丽线虫的Rap GAP作为饵蛋白,以来源于美丽线虫的c DNA文库作为靶蛋白,应用p PC97、p PC86组成的酵母双杂交系统筛选c DNA文库中与Rap GAP相互作用的蛋白质。结果通过营养缺陷平板(-LTH)筛选出63个拟似阳性菌落。经过Lac Z鉴定,19个菌落为阳性,其中7个为强阳性。提取来自19个酵母菌落中的重组DNA,经PCR扩增,12个菌落出现阳性结果。将该19个重组DNA分别电转化入DH5α细菌,涂板培养后,每板挑取4~10个克隆,通过Sal I和Not I双酶切鉴定进行阳性克隆筛选。将阳性克隆的重组DNA进行序列测定。测序结果与Gen Bank比较,其中4个克隆的DNA片段为Y39b6a基因片段、2个为Rap GAP、1个为苯丙氨酸-4-羟化酶、1个为细胞色素C氧化酶,还有1个DNA片段编码美丽线虫特有的小分子蛋白的基因片段,其余11个DNA片段不编码已知蛋白质。结论初步筛选出与Rap GAP相互作用的蛋白质,特别是其中有2个克隆为Rap GAP,提示Rap GAP可能以二聚体的方式存在。     

Multi-photon Imaging of Tumor Cell Invasion in an Orthotopic Mouse Model of Oral Squamous Cell Carcinoma

Loco-regional invasion of head and neck cancer is linked to metastatic risk and presents a difficult challenge in designing and implementing patient management strategies. Orthotopic mouse models of oral cancer have been developed to facilitate the study of factors that impact invasion and serve as model system for evaluating anti-tumor therapeutics. In these systems, visualization of disseminated tumor cells within oral cavity tissues has typically been conducted by either conventional histology or with in vivo bioluminescent methods. A primary drawback of these techniques is the inherent inability to accurately visualize and quantify early tumor cell invasion arising from the primary site in three dimensions. Here we describe a protocol that combines an established model for squamous cell carcinoma of the tongue (SCOT) with two-photon imaging to allow multi-vectorial visualization of lingual tumor spread. The OSC-19 head and neck tumor cell line was stably engineered to express the F-actin binding peptide LifeAct fused to the mCherry fluorescent protein (LifeAct-mCherry). Fox1^nu/nu mice injected with these cells reliably form tumors that allow the tongue to be visualized by ex-vivo application of two-photon microscopy. This technique allows for the orthotopic visualization of the tumor mass and locally invading cells in excised tongues without disruption of the regional tumor microenvironment. In addition, this system allows for the quantification of tumor cell invasion by calculating distances that invaded cells move from the primary tumor site. Overall this procedure provides an enhanced model system for analyzing factors that contribute to SCOT invasion and therapeutic treatments tailored to prevent local invasion and distant metastatic spread. This method also has the potential to be ultimately combined with other imaging modalities in an in vivo setting.     

Effects of leaf and root herbivory by potential insect biological control agents on the performance of invasive Vincetoxicum spp.

The European leaf-feeding moth Abrostola asclepiadis and root-feeding beetle Eumolpus asclepiadeus are promising biological control agents for two European swallow-worts (Vincetoxicum rossicum and Vincetoxicum nigrum) in North America, however, their impact on plant performance is uncertain. Densities of each herbivore were manipulated in a common garden to determine whether leaf and root herbivory affect the performance of these plants. During the second year of the experiment, V. rossicum and V. nigrum unexpectedly became infected with the fungal pathogens Ascochyta sp. and Cercospora sp. (Ascomycota), respectively. Although pathogen infection mainly reduced shoot height and delayed reproduction, herbivore effects on plant growth were still evident. Leaf herbivory by A. asclepiadis had no effect on plant growth 1 year after defoliation. Root herbivory by E. asclepiadeus reduced shoot height and plant biomass and decreased the ability of plants to compensate for pathogen attack. Pathogen infection prevented detection of herbivore effect on reproduction. Due to its substantial impact on plant biomass, E. asclepiadeus should be further evaluated as a biological control agent against Vincetoxicum spp. populations invading open habitats in North America. Further research is needed to evaluate the impact of A. asclepiadis in combination with E. asclepiadeus and plant competition under high and low light conditions.