Two signal model of self/not-self immune discrimination: an update.

From a consideration of the evolution of the first immune systems in simple organisms, it is proposed that mechanisms for self/not-self discrimination evolved at an early stage of evolution in prototypic B cells, prior to separation of the B cell and T cell lineages. After passing an MHC protein-limited self/not-self discrimination gate, T cells depend for fine self/not-self discrimination either on B cells (extracellular discrimination) or on cells harbouring pathogens (intracellular discrimination). Full activation of B cells needs interaction with T cells, but this evolved late and is not part of the self/not-self decision.     

Sense in antisense?

A correspondence between open reading frames in sense and antisense strands is expected from the hypothesis that the prototypic triplet code was of general form RNY, where R is a purine base, N is any base, and Y is a pyrimidine. A deficit of stop codons in the antisense strand (and thus long open reading frames) is predicted for organisms with high G + C percentages; however, two bacteria (Azotobacter vinelandii, Rhodobacter capsulatum) have larger average antisense strand open reading frames than predicted from (G + C)%. The similar Codon frequencies found in sense and antisense strands can be attributed to the wide distribution of inverted repeats (stem-loop potential) in natural DNA sequences.     

Isotope-dilution analysis of the effects of deoxyguanosine and deoxyadenosine on the incorpo?ation of thymidine and deoxycytidine by hydroxyurea-treated thymus cells

It is presumed that the dGTP and dATP needed for replicative DNA synthesis can be formed by way of either `salvage' pathways or biosynthesis de novo. This was examined by adding hydroxyurea to cultures of rat thymus cells to inhibit ribonucleoside diphosphate reductase, a key enzyme of the `de novo' pathway. Most of the inhibition of the incorporation of [Me-³H]thymidine and deoxy[5-³H]cytidine by low concentrations of hydroxyurea (100–500μm) was prevented by substrates of the salvage pathway (400μm-deoxyguanosine and, to a lesser extent, 200μm-deoxyadenosine). However, isotope-dilution studies indicated that the purine deoxyribonucleosides prevented inhibition by decreasing pyrimidine deoxyribonucleotide competitor pools. Evidence was obtained that a hydroxyurea-induced increase in the thymidine-competitor pool (probably dTTP) was prevented to an equal extent by deoxyguanosine and by the inhibitor of thymidylate synthase, deoxy-5-fluorouridine. These compounds had almost identical effects on hydroxyurea dose–response curves and on thymidine isotope-dilution plots. The evidence suggests that exogenous purine deoxyribonucleosides cannot prevent the inhibition by hydroxyurea of thymus-cell DNA synthesis. This could mean that, with respect to the metabolism of purine deoxyribonucleotides, ribonucleoside diphosphate reductase is tightly coupled to DNA polymerase in a multienzyme complex. The complex would not permit entry of exogenous metabolic intermediates into the `de novo' pathway, but would still be subject to the regulatory effects of these intermediates. Thus dGTP and dATP formed from exogenous purine deoxyribonucleosides by salvage pathways might deplete pyrimidine deoxyribonucleotide competitor pools by inhibiting relatively hydroxyurea-insensitive activities of ribonucleoside diphosphate reductase.     

Heat shock proteins as mediators of aggregation-induced 'danger' signals: implications of the slow evolutionary fine-tuning of sequences for the antigenicity of cancer cells

Organisms 'tune' to their environment through adaptations which confer a selective advantage. However, in complex systems, a primary change of positive adaptive value might have multiple minor secondary effects, usually of negative adaptive value, which could invoke further counter-adaptations. This 'fine-tuning', a 'debugging', mainly at the intracellular level, would appear an evolutionary burden detracting from the positive nature of the primary change. However, if the primary mutation is in a potential oncogene, secondary, short-term effects may include the recruitment, in an apparently random manner, of unmutated non-oncogene products into the antigenic repertoire of the cancer cell. This 'danger' signal, provided by the co-aggregation of oncogene and non-oncogene products, would be mediated by inducible heat-shock proteins (Hsps), and lead to display of corresponding MHC-peptide complexes. It was argued previously that T cells specific for peptides from most 'self' intracellular antigens are not eliminated during T cell 'education', and so would be available for subsequent immune activation by the corresponding peptides. These considerations might explain why cancer specific antigens have been so elusive, why cancer antigenicity is often individual specific, and why therapeutic approaches involving complexes of peptides with Hsps may be successful.     

Genomic Conflict Settled in Favour of the Species Rather Than the Gene at Extreme GC Percentage Values

Wada and colleagues have shown that, whether prokaryotic or eukaryotic, each gene has a "homostabilising propensity" to adopt a relatively uniform GC percentage (GC%). Accordingly, each gene can be viewed as a "microisochore" occupying a discrete GC% niche of relatively uniform base composition amongst its fellow genes. Although first, second and third codon positions usually differ in GC%, each position tends to maintain a uniform, gene-specific GC% value. Thus, within a genome, genic GC% values can cover a wide range. This is most evident at third codon positions, which are least constrained by amino acid encoding needs. In 1991, Wada and colleagues further noted that, within a phylogenetic group, genomic GC% values can also cover a wide range. This is again most evident at third codon positions. Thus, the dispersion of GC% values among genes within a genome matches the dispersion of GC% values among genomes within a phylogenetic group. Wada described the context-independence of plots of different codon position GC% values against total GC% as a "universal" characteristic. Several studies relate this to recombination. We have confirmed that third codon positions usually relate more to the genes that contain them than to the species. However, in genomes with extreme GC% values (low or high), third codon positions tend to maintain a constant GC%, thus relating more to the species than to the genes that contain them. Genes in an extreme-GC% genome collectively span a smaller GC% range, and mainly rely on first and second codon positions for differentiation as "microisochores". Our results are consistent with the view that differences in GC% serve to recombinationally isolate both genome sectors (facilitating gene duplication) and genomes (facilitating genome duplication, e.g. speciation). In intermediate-GC% genomes, conflict between the needs of the species and the needs of individual genes within that species is minimal. However, in extreme-GC% genomes there is a conflict, which is settled in favour of the species (i.e. group selection) rather than in favour of the gene (genic selection).     

Comparison of responses by bacteriophages and bacteria to pressures on the base composition of open reading frames

Differences in the base composition of genomes can occur because of GC pressure, purine-loading pressure (AG pressure) and RNY pressure, for which there are possible functional explanations, and because of the more abstract pressures exerted by individual bases. The graphical approach of Muto and Osawa was used to analyse how bacteriophages and bacteria balance potentially conflicting pressures on their genomes. Phages generally respond to AG pressure by increasing A while keeping T constant, and by decreasing C while keeping G constant. In contrast, bacteria generally increase both A and T, the former more so, and decrease both G and C, the latter more so. These differences largely occur at third codon positions, which are more responsive than first and second codon positions to AG pressure and GC pressure. Phages respond to AG pressure more in the third codon position than bacteria, whereas bacteria respond more in the first codon position than phages. Conversely, bacteria respond to GC pressure more in the third codon position than phages, whereas phages respond more in the first codon position than bacteria. As GC pressure increases, A is traded for C and AG pressure decreases; first and second codon positions, having more A than T, are most responsive to this negative effect of increased GC pressure; third positions either do not respond (phages) or respond weakly (bacteria). In a set of 48 phage-host pairs, degrees of purine loading were less correlated between phage and host than were GC percentages. These results suggest that pressures on conventional and genome phenotypes operate differentially in phages and bacteria, generating both general differences in base composition and specific differences characteristic of particular phage-host pairs. The reciprocal relationship between GC pressure and AG pressure implies that effects attributed to GC pressure may actually be due to AG pressure, and vice versa.     

Immunology (1955–1975): The Natural Selection Theory, the Two Signal Hypothesis and Positive Repertoire Selection

Observations suggesting the existence of natural antibody prior to exposure of an organism to the corresponding antigen, led to the natural selection theory of antibody formation of Jerne in 1955, and to the two signal hypothesis of Forsdyke in 1968. Aspects of these were not only first discoveries but also foundational discoveries in that they influenced contemporaries in a manner that, from our present vantage point, appears to have been constructive. Jerne’s later hypothesis (1971, European Journal of Immunology 1: 1–9), that antibody-like receptors on lymphocytes were selected over evolutionary time for reactivity with the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens of the species, was a first, but it was incorrect, and was foundational only to the extent that it emphasized the need to explain the Simonsen phenomenon. Although easily construed as derivative of Jerne (1971), the affinity/avidity model of Forsdyke (1975, Journal of Theoretical Biology 52: 187–198), which predicted that cell-surface components, including MHC antigens, would restrict antigen-reactivity by somatically shaping lymphocyte repertoires, was actually an extension of the two signal hypothesis. While presenting a mechanism for the positive selection of lymphocyte repertoires, and explaining the Simonsen phenomenon, the affinity/avidity model was not foundational in that it had to be independently rediscovered. For science to advance optimally we must seek to close temporal gaps so that first discoveries are also foundational. Listening to young scientists may be part of the solution.     

Microsatellites that violate Chargaff's second parity rule have base order-dependent asymmetries in the folding energies of complementary DNA strands and may not drive speciation

Models for meiotic recombination based on Crick's “unpairing postulate” require symmetrical extrusion of stem-loop structures from homologous DNA duplexes. The potential for such extrusion is abundant in many species and, for a given single-strand segment, can be quantitated as the “folding of natural sequence” (FONS) energy value. This, in turn, can be decomposed into base order-dependent and base composition-dependent components. The FONS values of top and bottom strands in most Caenorhabditis elegans segments are close, as are the corresponding base order-dependent and base composition-dependent components; any discrepancies are in the base composition-dependent component. This suggests that the strands would extrude with similar kinetics. However, interspersed among these segments and at the ends of chromosomes (telomeres) are segments containing short tandem repeats (microsatellites) which, by virtue of their high variability, have been postulated to inhibit the pairing of homologous chromosomes and hence drive speciation. In these segments, there are usually wide discrepancies between the FONS values of top and bottom strands, mainly attributable to differences in base order-dependent components. Analyses of artificial microsatellites of different unit sizes and base compositions show that this asymmetrical distribution of folding potential is greatest for microsatellites when the units are short and violate Chargaff's second parity rule. It is proposed that when there is folding asymmetry, recombination proceeds by special, strand-biased, somatic mechanisms analogous to those operating with Chi sequences in Escherichia coli. If meiotic recombination in the germ-line requires extrusion symmetry, then a general inhibitory influence of microsatellite-containing segments could mask the antirecombinational influence of their variability. Thus, microsatellites may not have driven speciation.