What Can We Learn from the Evolution of Protein-Ligand Interactions to Aid the Design of New Therapeutics?

Efforts to increase affinity in the design of new therapeutic molecules have tended to lead to greater lipophilicity, a factor that is generally agreed to be contributing to the low success rate of new drug candidates. Our aim is to provide a structural perspective to the study of lipophilic efficiency and to compare molecular interactions created over evolutionary time with those designed by humans. We show that natural complexes typically engage in more polar contacts than synthetic molecules bound to proteins. The synthetic molecules also have a higher proportion of unmatched heteroatoms at the interface than the natural sets. These observations suggest that there are lessons to be learnt from Nature, which could help us to improve the characteristics of man-made molecules. In particular, it is possible to increase the density of polar contacts without increasing lipophilicity and this is best achieved early in discovery while molecules remain relatively small.     

On the tertiary structure of the extracellular domains of the epidermal growth factor and insulin receptors

Alignment of the sequences, the identification of conserved residue patterns and secondary structure predictions indicate that the extra-cellular regions of the human and Drosophila epidermal growth factor (EGF), c-erb-B2 and human insulin receptors each contain two large, homologous domains (L) which are probably comprised of at least four short alpha-helices followed by turns of conserved length and beta-strands. In the human and Drosophila EGF and c-erb-B2 receptors these homologous domains are each followed by a series of smaller cystine-rich domains (S) to give a gene-duplicated structure of L1S11S12S13L2S21S22S23. In the human insulin receptor, the second series of cystine domains is replaced by a different sequence. These duplicated structures are probably organised as a pseudo-symmetrical dimer. There are two 'hyper-variable' regions, one at the end of the large domains and one in the cystine-rich sequences, which are candidates for hormone or growth-factor binding.     

Surface interactions of gamma-crystallins in the crystal medium in relation to their association in the eye lens

A comparative study of intermolecular interactions in crystals of two homologous low molecular weight proteins, gamma-II and gamma-IIIb crystallins, from calf eye lens was carried out. Crystal packings for these proteins are very different: intermolecular contact areas compose about 33% of the total accessible surface area of gamma-II as compared with 13% in gamma-III. Two key residues seem to be mainly responsible for the differences in protein association in the crystal medium. These are Ser 103 and Leu 155 in gamma-II, which are replaced by Met 103 and His 155 in gamma-IIb. A similar substitution of these residues is observed in different gene products of gamma-crystallins from a number of vertebrates. This is consistent with the existence of a genetically controlled mechanism for determining intermolecular association of gamma-crystallins in the native medium of the lens.     

Interaction of the p85 subunit of PI 3-kinase and its N-terminal SH2 domain with a PDGF receptor phosphorylation site: structural features and analysis of conformational changes.

Circular dichroism and fluorescence spectroscopy were used to investigate the structure of the p85 alpha subunit of the PI 3-kinase, a closely related p85 beta protein, and a recombinant SH2 domain-containing fragment of p85 alpha. Significant spectral changes, indicative of a conformational change, were observed on formation of a complex with a 17 residue peptide containing a phosphorylated tyrosine residue. The sequence of this peptide is identical to the sequence surrounding Tyr751 in the kinase-insert region of the platelet-derived growth factor beta-receptor (beta PDGFR). The rotational correlation times measured by fluorescence anisotropy decay indicated that phosphopeptide binding changed the shape of the SH2 domain-containing fragment. The CD and fluorescence spectroscopy data support the secondary structure prediction based on sequence analysis and provide evidence for flexible linker regions between the various domains of the p85 proteins. The significance of these results for SH2 domain-containing proteins is discussed.     

Structure and evolution of insulins: implications for receptor binding.

Insulin is a member of a family of hormones, growth factors and neuropeptides which are found in both vertebrates and invertebrates. A common 'insulin fold' is probably adopted by all family members. Although the specificities of receptor binding are different, there is a possibility of co-evolution of polypeptides and their receptors.     

Environment-specific amino acid substitution tables: tertiary templates and prediction of protein folds.

The local environment of an amino acid in a folded protein determines the acceptability of mutations at that position. In order to characterize and quantify these structural constraints, we have made a comparative analysis of families of homologous proteins. Residues in each structure are classified according to amino acid type, secondary structure, accessibility of the side chain, and existence of hydrogen bonds from the side chains. Analysis of the pattern of observed substitutions as a function of local environment shows that there are distinct patterns, especially for buried polar residues. The substitution data tables are available on diskette with Protein Science. Given the fold of a protein, one is able to predict sequences compatible with the fold (profiles or templates) and potentially to discriminate between a correctly folded and misfolded protein. Conversely, analysis of residue variation across a family of aligned sequences in terms of substitution profiles can allow prediction of secondary structure or tertiary environment.     

Direct observation by X-ray analysis of the tetrahedral "intermediate" of aspartic proteinases.

We report the X-ray analysis at 2.0 A resolution for crystals of the aspartic proteinase endothiapepsin (EC 3.4.23.6) complexed with a potent difluorostatone-containing tripeptide renin inhibitor (CP-81,282). The scissile bond surrogate, an electrophilic ketone, is hydrated in the complex. The pro-(R) (statine-like) hydroxyl of the tetrahedral carbonyl hydrate is hydrogen-bonded to both active-site aspartates 32 and 215 in the position occupied by a water in the native enzyme. The second hydroxyl oxygen of the hydrate is hydrogen-bonded only to the outer oxygen of Asp 32. These experimental data provide a basis for a model of the tetrahedral intermediate in aspartic proteinase-mediated cleavage of the amide bond. This indicates a mechanism in which Asp 32 is the proton donor and Asp 215 carboxylate polarizes a bound water for nucleophilic attack. The mechanism involves a carboxylate (Asp 32) that is stabilized by extensive hydrogen bonding, rather than an oxyanion derivative of the peptide as in serine proteinase catalysis.