LATICIFER ULTRASTRUCTURE AND DIFFERENTIATION IN SEEDLINGS OF PAPAVER BRACTEATUM LINDL., POPULATION ARYA II (PAPAVERACEAE)

Laticifers of Papaver bracteatum Lindl., population Arya II, seedlings were examined by electron microscopy. Laticifers were first differentiated in procambium of the radicle associated with phloem about 72 hr after seeds were sown. Proliferation of membrane-bound vesicles of apparent endoplasmic reticulum origin distinguished laticifers from adjacent cells. Vesicles developed electron-dense caps from the internal condensation of small particles. Laticifer initials possessed the usual complement of organelles that became obscured in mature cells by the large, closely packed vesicles. Plastids contained an electron-dense, membrane-bound inclusion, but never developed lamellae or starch grains. Articulation and anastomoses between laticifer elements resulted from gradual removal of wall materials by both cells on opposite sides of the common walls at a perforation site. Differentiation of the laticifer initials and the micromorphology of the protoplast of P. bracteatum is similar to that reported for P. somniferum.     

PLASTID INCLUSIONS IN EPIDERMAL CELLS OF BETA

Inclusions were found in epidermal plastids of Beta vulgaris L., by the use of the electron microscope. One type of inclusion resembles the membrane-bound plastid inclusions found by others in various meristematic plant cells; the other does not appear to have been described before. The second type of inclusion is not membrane-bound and appears elongated and fibrillar in longisection. The elongated plastid inclusion sometimes becomes quite large. It is postulated that Beta epidermal cells may store two different proteins under some conditions.     

ULTRASTRUCTURE OF NON-ARTICULATED LATICIFERS IN MATURE EMBRYOS AND SEEDLINGS OF ASCLEPIAS SYRIACA L. (ASCLEPIADACEAE)

The protoplast of the non-articulated branched laticifer in the embryo and seedling of Asclepias syriaca L. was studied at the ultrastructural level and was found to differ from that of adjacent cell types. Embryonal laticifers possess numerous vesicles with electron-dense contents, but lack a large organized central vacuole. Plastids have few lamellae, possess phytoferritin, and accumulate small amounts of starch. Other organelles and membrane systems are similar to those in other cells. After germination, laticifers develop numerous elongated vacuoles by dilation of endoplasmic reticulum. Nuclei in laticifers within the hypocotyl of seedlings are highly lobed and possess dilated perinuclear spaces. Plastids and other organelles are similar to those observed in the protoplast of laticifers in the embryo. The latex or rubber component of the laticifer is not apparent in mature embryos of 72-hr seedlings.     

CYTOCHEMICAL STUDIES CONCERNING THE OCCURRENCE AND DISTRIBUTION OF RNA IN PLASTIDS OF ZEA MAYS

The occurrence of RNA in plastids from etiolated and green maize leaves was demonstrated cytochemically, with both the light and the electron microscope. Etiolated leaves were allowed to incorporate tritiated cytidine for several hours and were subsequently fixed in formalin. Radioautographs of leaf sections 2 µ thick showed silver grains over the regions of the cytoplasm containing plastids. Plastids in these sections appeared intensely basophilic when stained with azure B. Both the basophilia and radioactivity were removable with ribonuclease, clearly demonstrating the occurrence of RNA in these organelles. Examination under the electron microscope of similar plastids which had been fixed in formalin revealed a particulate component in the plastid measuring approximately 170 A in diameter. This particulate component was completely removable with ribonuclease. Thus,it was concluded that RNA occurs in a particulate form in plastids from etiolated leaves. Mature plastids, when stained with azure B, did not appear basophilic under the light microscope. Nevertheless, when formalin-fixed tissues were examined with the electron microscope, the mature plastids were seen to contain particles in the stroma, identical in appearance with those visible in the plastids in etiolated leaves. Osmium tetroxide-fixed tissues were also examined with the electron microscope. Particles similar to those seen in plastids fixed with formalin were observed, although the results obtained with this fixative were variable. It is concluded that plastids from etiolated and green maize leaves contain RNA in a particulate form which resembles ribosomes.     

GENETIC EVIDENCE FOR TRACE PATERNAL TRANSMISSION OF PLASTIDS IN LIRIODENDRON AND MAGNOLIA (MAGNOLIACEAE)

Transmission of plastids in Liriodendron and Magnolia was studied by examining inheritance of plastid DNA markers in interspecific crosses. In congeneric hybrids of Liriodendron and Magnolia, 2.9% and 11.1% of progeny, respectively, exhibited uniparental paternal transmission of plastids. This departure from strict uniparental maternal transmission of plastids indicates that mechanisms for the elimination of paternal plastids are not 100% efficient and that any proposed model for plastid transmission must account for a continuum of variation. Our results, and other results reviewed here, show a discrepancy with data obtained by cytological observations and point to the need of confirming the mode of plastid inheritance by genetic analysis. In addition, if paternal plastids are occasionally inherited, intensive sampling of plastid DNA in a putative hybrid population could identify both parents of hybrids and thereby aid in the phylogenetic reconstruction of hybrid zones.     

DEVELOPMENT OF CHLOROPLAST FINE STRUCTURE IN ASPEN TISSUE CULTURE

Chloroplast ontogeny has been examined in 42-day etiolated triploid aspen callus (Populus tremuloides Michx.) subjected to two different light conditions. White and low-intensity red illumination showed little differences in their stimulatory effects on plastid development, the red light-irradiated plastids developing only slightly more slowly. Asynchronous plastid development was noted in both lighting systems. Etioplasts contained an interconnected tubular net, phytoferritin aggregates, electron-transparent vesicles which seem to invaginate from the inner plastid membrane, membrane-bound homogeneous spheroids and starch grains. Irradiation caused various morphological changes within the proplastids; the tubular complex became transformed into the more ordered prolamellar body-like structure from which radiated membrane-bound sacs filled with electron-dense material. These sacs, characterized as thylakoid precursors, were transformed into a thylakoidal system typical of mature chloroplasts. This ontogenetic scheme represents an additional pathway for the development of photosynthetic lamellae. Other light-induced changes in the developing plastid include disappearance of phytoferritin particles and homogeneous spheroids, decrease in starch content, and appearance of osmiophilic droplets.     

ULTRASTRUCTURE OF DEVELOPING AND MATURE NONARTICULATED LATICIFERS IN THE MILKWEED ASCLEPIAS SYRIACA L. (ASCLEPIADACEAE)

The ultrastructure of developing and mature nonarticulated laticifers in Asclepias syriaca L. (the common milkweed) was studied by conventional fixation and staining techniques and by osmium impregnation techniques. The mature laticifer protoplast in A. syriaca possesses a large central vacuole with an intact vacuolar membrane. Formation of this vacuole apparently results from dilation and subsequent enlargement of endoplasmic reticulum and possibly in part by fusion of smaller vacuoles and limited cellular-lytic autophagy. Widespread digestion or autophagy of cytoplasm within vacuoles is not evident. Nuclei, mitochondria, dictyosomes, and small vesicles are the most prominent components distributed in the peripheral cytoplasm. Plastids appear to degenerate as the laticifer matures. The specialized cellular component, latex, which is the vacuolar content of the laticifer, is interpreted to be produced in the cytoplasm and subsequently incorporated into the large central vacuole. Rubber globules, the most prominent latex component, are surrounded by a membrane that does not have a trilaminate structure. Globules are associated with an electron-dense fibrillar component in the vacuole.     

THE ULTRASTRUCTURAL MORPHOLOGY AND ONTOGENY OF OAT COLEOPTILE PLASTIDS

Structurally similar proplastids occur in the shoot, scutellum, and root of the oat embryo at the start of germination. These proplastids follow several pathways of differentiation, depending on their location within an organ and on previous exposure to light. During the first 24 hr of germination morphologically similar amyloplasts are formed from the preexisting proplastids in most of the cells of the seedling. After about 24 hr in the light, unique chloroplasts begin to develop in a subepidermal ring of small cortical parenchyma cells in the coleoptile and give the organ a pale green color. At 48 and 72 hr the coleoptile chloroplasts and etioplasts are conspicuously different from the corresponding leaf plastids in morphology and ontogeny but contain typical photosynthetic grana and prolamellar bodies. Study of the ontogeny of plastids in the epidermal and nongreening parenchymal regions of dark grown coleoptiles shows that these plastids undergo significant losses in starch content, and some increase of membranes within the plastid, related to the age of the cell. Light has little effect on the structure of these plastids. It is suggested that the ontogeny of all the plastid types of the oat seedling begins with a common precursor—a relatively simple proplastid that is present at the time of germination. Starch grains showing two distinct types of erosion, apparently enzymatic, were observed in oat coleoptile plastids. In one type (grooved appearance) the starch grains are consistently associated with plastid membranes, while in the other type (irregular, spiny appearance) the starch grains are associated with the plastid stroma only. We suggest that there are two enzyme systems for metabolizing starch in oat plastids—one membrane-bound and the other free in the stroma.     

ULTRASTRUCTURE OF THE MATURE UNGERMINATED RICE (ORYZA SATIVA) CARYOPSIS. THE GERM

An in-depth transmission electron microscope study of the ungerminated, unimbibed rice germ was conducted. All tissues in the germ were examined. Plastids were similar in all cells; many contained osmiophilic globules and phytoferritin, some displayed a limited thylakoid system, and all contained cytoplasmic tubular and vesicular inclusions formed by invaginations of the outer plastid membranes. Filament bundles were found in cells of the coleoptile, plumule, mesocotyl, radicle, and epiblast. Three general categories of cells could be identified in the germ based on protein body characteristics and on lipid body distribution: 1) Cells having inclusions in protein bodies and having numerous lipid bodies scattered throughout the cytoplasm; 2) Cells having or lacking protein body inclusions and possessing peripheral lipid bodies and/or having electron-dense deposits in the lipid bodies; and 3) Cells lacking protein bodies and having peripheral lipid bodies.     

FINE STRUCTURE OF PROTEIN-STORING PLASTIDS IN BEAN ROOT TIPS

The fine structure of leucoplasts in root tip cells of Phaseolus vulgaris L. has been studied in material fixed in glutaraldehyde followed by osmium tetroxide and poststained in uranyl acetate and lead citrate. Plastid development has been followed from the young stages in and near the meristematic region, through an ameboid stage, to the larger forms with more abundant storage products in the outermost cells. The plastids contain a dense stroma penetrated by tubules and cisternae arising from the inner membrane of the plastid envelope. Also located in the stroma are lamellae, ribosome-like particles, phytoferritin granules, and fine fibrils in less dense regions. In some elongate plastids microfilaments run lengthwise in the stroma near the surface. The same plastids store both starch and protein, but in a strikingly different manner. The starch is deposited in the stroma, while the protein always is accumulated within membrane-bounded sacs. These sacs arise as outgrowths from a complex of interconnected tubules which in turn appears to originate by coalescence and proliferation of tubules and cisternae arising from the inner plastid membrane. This "tubular complex" bears a strong resemblance to the prolamellar body of etiolated chloroplasts, but is smaller and ordinarily less regularly organized, and is apparently light-insensitive. Crystallization of the protein commonly occurs in the sacs and occasionally takes place within the tubules of the complex as well. The fine structure of the leucoplasts is discussed in relation to that of etiolated chloroplasts. Suggestions are made concerning the function of the tubular complex, role of the ameboid plastid forms, and manner of accumulation of the storage protein in the plastids.     

THE ULTRASTRUCTURAL DEVELOPMENT OF THE DIMORPHIC PLASTIDS OF ZEA MAYS L.

The development of the dimorphic chloroplasts of Zea mays L. in adult foliage leaves is described, and a method of correlating ultrastructural stages by means of leaf chlorophyll is presented. In addition, the developmental changes in chlorophyll a/b ratio are discussed. Both the mesophyll and the bundle sheath plastids contain small grana at the earliest stages of plastid development. As the plastids enlarge, the mesophyll grana stacks increase in both length of the appressed membrane and in the number of thylakoids per granum. Initially, the grana stacks in the bundle sheath plastids also enlarge, but as the plastids approach full size, most of the membrane appression is lost. However, the remaining areas of appression in the bundle sheath plastids show an increase in the number of thylakoids in each small granum.     

Carotenoid-deficient young wheat etioplasts are able to bind precursor proteins on the plastid surface but are impaired in their translocation ability

Young carotenoid-deficient etioplasts, isolated from Norflurazon (NF)-treated wheat seedlings, were used to study the role of coloured carotenoids in the binding and import reactions of different nuclear-encoded plastid proteins. Plastids from control seedlings exhibited significantly higher import efficiencies than did plastids from NF-treated plants. Etioplasts containing normal levels of carotenoids imported approximately 2000 and 800 molecules per plastid of the precursors of the small Rubisco subunit (pSS) and the Rieske FeS protein (pFeS), respectively. Plastids from NF-treated plants imported approximately 100 and 70 pSS and pFeS molecules per plastid, respectively. In addition, a maximum binding capacity of NF-treated plastids of 1200 protein molecules per plastid was observed for both pSS and pFeS when assayed at 25°C: and a maximum binding capacity of approximately 1300 molecules per plastid was noted at 4°C. For control plastids, a similar amount of binding, or approximately 1400 protein molecules per plastid, could only be observed if import was inhibited by low ATP concentrations at 4°C. When these plastids were washed and transferred to conditions promoting import at 25°C and 10 mM Mg-ATP, close to 60% of the envelope-associated precursor protein molecules were imported. These results indicate that control and NF-treated young etioplasts contain similar amounts of binding sites for precursor proteins. However, only in the case of control plastids the binding was productive and lead to import and processing in the stroma upon transfer to conditions promoting import. Plastids isolated from wheat seedlings grown in weak red light and containing different amounts of carotenoids, were assayed for their ability to bind and import a protein with unusual import characteristics, the Chlamydomonas reinhardtii PsaF precursor of PSI (pPsaF) and transit peptide deletion constructs. The PsaF protein was imported in a transit peptide-dependent manner into control etioplasts, whereas import of pPsaF into young wheat etioplasts isolated from NF-treated plants was inhibited at low levels of plastid carotenoids.     

菜豆花粉发育中质体和线粒体及其DNA存在的状况——着重阐明质体遗传的细胞学基础

应用电镜和DNA的DAPI荧光检测技术研究了菜豆(Phaseolus vulgaris L.)小孢子/花粉发育中质体和线粒体及其DNA存在的状况。观察表明:在小孢子分裂时质体全部分配到营养细胞中,初形成的生殖细胞已不含质体。线粒体和质体的DNA在花粉发育中也先后降解,生殖细胞从刚形成时发育至成熟花粉时期这两种细胞器DNA均不存在。研究结果为菜豆质体母系遗传提供了确切的细胞学证据。遗传分析的研究曾确定菜豆质体为双亲遗传,对与本研究结论不同的原因进行了讨论。     

CHANGES IN PLASTID AND MITOCHONDRION CONTENT DURING MATURATION OF GENERATIVE CELLS OF SOLANUM (SOLANACEAE)

A study was made of the number of plastids and mitochondria present in generative cells of Solanum immediately after microspore mitosis, and the fate of these organelles during development of the pollen was determined. Changes were followed via electron microscopy of anthers of S. chacoense and S. tuberosum Group Phureja × S. chacoense. In earliest stages the generative cells were oval and had one surface along the intine and other surfaces in contact with the vegetative cell. As the pollen matured the generative cells elongated, became spindle-shaped, and were completely engulfed in the vegetative cells. At the earliest stages studied, both mitochondria and plastids were present in the generative cell. Plastids of the generative cell were, in contrast to those of the vegetative cells, fewer, smaller, and lacking in starch. Through the maturation stages the content of these organelles in the vegetative cells remained unchanged. While the generative cells retained mitochondria until anthesis, their plastids disappeared completely during maturation. This selective loss during generative cell maturation could lead to transmission of those characteristics encoded in plastid DNA through the pistillate parent only. The mechanism could explain earlier genetic evidence that plastid characters of Solanum were transmitted uniparentally.     

ULTRASTRUCTURAL FEATURES OF DEVELOPING SIEVE ELEMENTS IN LEMNA MINOR L.—THE PROTOPLAST

The occurrence and precise arrangement of phloem tissue is reported for the first time in the root of the duckweed, Lemna minor L. Since these plants are small enough to be prepared intact for electron microscopy, the induction of artifacts as a result of mechanical manipulation during specimen preparation is virtually eliminated. Ultrastructural features of the complete sequence of sieve-element development are presented and are in some respects similar to what has been described in other monocotyledons (e.g., nuclear degeneration, aggregation of ER, elaboration of electron-dense crystalline plastid inclusions). Mature sieve elements in Lemna are enucleate, lack P-protein, contain a plasmalemma, ER-aggregations, mitochondria, plastids and, in many instances, intact vacuoles. It is suggested that structural modification required for the sieve element to assume a transport function may not be very drastic, apart from the degeneration of the nucleus.     

PLASTID ORGANIZATION IN PHENOTYPICALLY GREEN LEAF TISSUE OF A GENETIC ALBINO STRAIN OF NICOTIANA (SOLANACEAE)

Plastid organization within phenotypically green leaf tissue that forms in albino plants of a genetic albino strain of Nicotiana has been examined with the transmission electron microscope. Studies revealed the presence of plastids with and without thylakoids. When present, thylakoids were loosely and irregularly scattered in the stroma or organized either into several large spindle-shaped grana or into a single compound granum with deeply indented margins. Plastids without thylakoids were vesiculated and resembled the typical genetic albino type. Plastid types were not segregrated into individual cells and no plastid type appeared to be typical for the mutant tissue. Orientation of grana and thylakoid membrane associations were noted as well as the presence of osmiophilic globules, starch grains and DNA-like fibrillar areas.     

CYANOPHYTE AND CYANELLE DNA: A SEARCH FOR THE ORIGINS OF PLASTIDS1

Cyanophyte-like prokaryotes are widely presumed to be the progenitors of eukaryote plastids. A few rare protistan species bearing cyanophyte-like cyanelles may represent intermediate stages in the evolution of true organelles. Cyanophyte DNA disposition in the cell, so far as is known from electron microscopy, seems uniform within the group and distinctly different from the several known arrangements of DNA in plastids. Therefore a survey of representative cyanophytes and protistan cyanelles was undertaken to determine whether forms reminiscent of plastids could be found. DNA-specific fluorochromes were utilized, along with epifluorescent microscopy, to study the DNA arrangement in situ in whole cells. Only the endospore (baeocyte)-forming Cyanophyta contained more than one, centrally located DNA skein per cell, and then only for the period just preceding visible baeocyte formation. Such forms might, with modification, presage the “scattered nucleoid” DNA disposition found in plastids of several groups, including Rhodophytes, Cryptophytes, Chlorophytes and higher plants. The DNA arrangement in cyanelles of two protists, Cyanophora and Glaucocystis, appear different from each other and possibly related to, respectively, the cyanophytes Gloeobacter and Synechococcus. Cyanelles of the third protist, Glaucosphaera, like the cells of the unique prokaryote Prochloron, appear to have multiple sites of DNA, somewhat similar to those of the “scattered nucleoid” line of plastid evolution. No obvious precursor of the “ring nucleoid” or other types of plastid DNA conformation was found.     

WEIGHING THE EVIDENCE FOR A SINGLE ORIGIN OF PLASTIDS1

The Journal of Phycology recently published a research paper entitled “A single origin of plastids revisited: convergent evolution in organellar genome content” ( Stiller et al. 2003 ). Also appearing in that issue was a minireview by Jeffrey D. Palmer ( Palmer 2003 ), “The symbiotic birth and spread of plastids: how many times and whodunit?” In his review, Palmer discussed evidence in support of a single endosymbiotic origin, in light of our analyses showing that similarities in plastid genome content are explained better by convergent evolution than by shared evolutionary history. Palmer raised a number of important issues that were not addressed in our paper, including the point that, in his view, no real evidence has been cited against a single plastid origin. After carefully considering Palmer's arguments, and this key point in particular, I am prompted to offer a few additional comments in the spirit of furthering a useful discussion begun in the February issue.     

THE SYMBIOTIC BIRTH AND SPREAD OF PLASTIDS: HOW MANY TIMES AND WHODUNIT?

I discuss the evidence for a single origin of primary plastids in the context of a paper in this issue challenging this view, and I review recent evidence concerning the number of secondary plastid endosymbioses and the controversy over whether the relic plastid of apicomplexans is of red or green algal origin. A broad consensus has developed that the plastids of green algae, red algae, and glaucophytes arose from the same primary, cyanobacterial endosymbiosis. Although the analyses in this issue by Stiller and colleagues firmly undermine one of many sources of data, gene content similarities among plastid genomes used to argue for a monophyletic origin of primary plastids, the overall evidence still clearly favors monophyly. Nonetheless, this issue should not be considered settled and new data should be sought from better sampling of cyanobacteria and glaucophytes, from sequenced nuclear genomes, and from careful analysis of such key features as the plastid import apparatus. With respect to the number of secondary plastid symbioses, it is completely unclear as to whether the secondary plastids of euglenophytes and chlorarachniophytes arose by the same or two different algal endosymbioses. Recent analyses of certain plastid and nuclear genes support the chromalveolate hypothesis of Cavalier-Smith, namely, that the plastids of heterokonts, haptophytes, cryptophytes, dinoflagellates, and apicomplexans all arose from a common endosymbiosis involving a red alga. However, another recent paper presents intriguing conflicting data on this score for one of these groups—apicomplexans—arguing instead that they acquired their plastids from green algae.     

PLASTID DEVELOPMENT IN IOJAP- AND CHLOROPLAST MUTATOR-AFFECTED MAIZE PLANTS

Plastids affected by either iojap or chloroplast mutator fail to green, and altered plastids are maternally transmitted to subsequent generations. The ultrastructure of iojap-affected plastids indicates that these plastids contain no ribosomes and are capable of supporting little internal membrane organization in either light or dark-grown plants. Chloroplast mutator-affected plastids of light-grown plants contain some organized internal membrane structures. In dark-grown plants, chloroplast mutator-aftected plastids contain a crystalline prolamellar body, numerous vesicles, and osmiophilic granules. The chloroplast mutator-affecled etioplasts display an abnormal distribution of lamellar membranes; these membranes, rather than radiating in a spokelike pattern from the prolamellar body, are condensed into a portion of the organelle. Light causes disruption of the prolamellar body in chloroplast mutator-affected plastids without promoting the organization of a normal thylakoid membrane system. The effects of iojap and chloroplast mutator are cell autonomous and apparently influence the individual plastid, as evidenced by the persistence of heteroplastidic cells containing normal and affected plastids.