Theoretical analysis of the reason for unsatisfactory approximation of experimental data on fractionated effect of gamma-radiation and (or) neutrons on lymphocytes at the G0 and G1 stage

The causes were analyzed of unsatisfactory approximation, based on a mathematical model of cytogenetic effect of interaction of lesions induced by two doses of gamma-radiation and/or neutron in human blood lymphocytes at the stage G0 and G1. For the analysis the published data were used concerning the effect of inhibitors of protein and DNA synthesis on aberration yield in G0- and G1-cell cycle stages at different periods of time after their irradiation with different doses of gamma-rays and neutrons. It is assumed that the cause of the unsatisfactory approximation is the effect of the combined repair of lesions caused by two dose fractions under the process of replication repair caused by the first dose fraction.     

Cytogenetic effect of low-level 60Co gamma-irradiation of cultured human lymphocytes in the G1 phase of the mitotic cycle

The dose-dependence of the chromosome aberration frequency in human lymphocytes in vitro exposed to 60Co-gamma-radiation at the G1 stage of the mitotic cycle has proved to be unlike that obtained upon exposure of cells at the G0 stage of the cycle. The data obtained are accounted for by partial activation of the repair system at the G1 stage which is attributed mainly to chromatin decondensation.     

Evidence for similarities between radiation damage expressed by beta-araA and damage involved in the interaction effect observed after exposure of V79 cells to mixed neutrons and gamma radiation

Plateau-phase V79 cells were exposed sequentially to fast neutrons and gamma rays. A dose-dependent reduction in the shoulder width of the gamma-ray survival curve was observed after preexposure of cells to neutrons. A similar effect was demonstrated on the neutron survival curve when cells were preirradiated with gamma rays. Treatment of cells with 150 microM beta-araA after either gamma or neutron irradiation reduced primarily the shoulder of the survival curve. When beta-araA was given to the cells after exposure to mixed radiation modalities, survival curves similar to those observed after exposure to a single radiation modality and treatment with beta-araA were obtained. The kinetics of loss of the interaction observed after exposure of cells to gamma rays following neutron irradiation was similar to the kinetics of loss of sensitivity to beta-araA (T1/2 = 1 h) measured by delaying drug administration after exposure to gamma rays. The results suggest that the PLD expressed by beta-araA is at least partly involved in the interactive effect observed after combined exposure of plateau-phase V79 cells to neutrons and gamma rays.     

The response of ataxia-telangiectasia lymphoblastoid cells to neutron irradiation

The response of control and ataxia-telangiectasia (A-T) cells to increasing doses of high-linear-energy-transfer (LET) ionizing radiation (neutrons) was compared. Ataxia-telangiectasia cells were markedly more sensitive to neutron irradiation than were control cells. The D0 value for the two A-T cell lines was 0.4 Gy while the value for controls was approximately 1.4 Gy. Fast neutrons were considerably more effective than gamma rays in inducing cell death in both cell types, but the sensitivity factor remained approximately the same as with gamma rays. A minimal depression of DNA synthesis was observed in ataxia-telangiectasia cells after neutron irradiation, similar to that reported previously after gamma irradiation. The extent of inhibition was not significantly greater in control cells, contrary to that seen with gamma rays. In time-course experiments a significant difference in degree of inhibition of DNA synthesis was observed between the cell types. Low doses of fast neutrons induced a G2-phase delay in both cell types, but the degree and extent of this delay was greater in ataxia-telangiectasia cells as observed previously with low-LET radiation.     

Comparative study of chromosome aberration formation in lymphocytes culture under pulsed and continuous neutron irradiation

Frequencies of chromosome aberration induced by prolong (continuous) neutron radiation (dose-rate 0.17 Gy/min) and pulsed neutron radiation with ultra-high dose-rate (1-4) x 10(5) Gy/s have been studied in human blood lymphocytes at G0-stage. It was demonstrated that cytogenetic efficiency of pulsed neutrons (after the substraction of approximately 50% gamma-component from the total dose) was 2 times higher than that of continuous neutron radiation.     

A comparison of gamma and neutron irradiation on Raji cells: effects on DNA damage, repair, cell cycle distribution and lethality.

The Comet assay (microgel electrophoresis) was used to study DNA damage in Raji cells, a B-lymphoblastoid cell line, after treatment with different doses of neutrons (0.5 to 16 Gy) or gamma rays (1.4 to 44.8 Gy). A better growth recovery was observed in cells after gamma-ray treatments compared with neutron treatments. The relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of neutron in cell killing was determined to be 2.5. Initially, the number of damaged cells per unit dose was approximately the same after neutron and gamma-ray irradiation. One hour after treatment, however, the number of normal cells per unit dose was much lower for neutrons than for gamma rays, suggesting a more efficient initial repair for gamma rays. Twenty-four hours after treatment, the numbers of damaged cells per unit dose of neutrons or gamma rays were again at comparable level. Cell cycle kinetic studies showed a strong G2/M arrest at equivalent unit dose (neutrons up to 8 Gy; gamma rays up to 5.6 Gy), suggesting a period in cell cycle for DNA repair. However, only cells treated with low doses (up to 2 Gy) seemed to be capable of returning into normal cell cycle within 4 days. For the highest dose of neutrons, decline in the number of normal cells seen at already 3 days after treatment was deeper compared with equivalent unit doses of gamma rays. Our present results support different mechanisms of action by these two irradiations and suggest the generation of locally multiply damaged sites (LMDS) for high linear energy transfer (LET) radiation which are known to be repaired at lower efficiency.     

Damage susceptibility of human lymphocyte chromosomes at different stages of the mitotic cycle in combined exposure to fast neutrons and postradiation hyperthermia

The combined action of gamma rays (1-4 Gy) and postradiation hyperthermia on the human lymphocyte culture induces intensification of the damaging effect at the stage of DNA synthesis, i.e. at the most radioresistant stage of the mitotic cycle, the thermal intensification factor (TIF) being 1.7-2.0. After the neutron action (0.5-1.5 Gy) the hyperthermia has no effect on the chromosome aberration spectrum, the TIF being 1.8-2.5 at G1 phase and 1.8-2.4 at S phase, which testifies to the possible modification of neutron irradiation.     

Study on the repair of the radioinduced lesions involved in the formation of chromosomal aberrations in G0 human lymphocytes after exposure to gamma-rays and fast neutrons

Cytosine arabinoside (ara-C), an inhibitor of DNA synthesis and repair, has been used to study the mechanisms of formation of chromosomal aberrations after exposure to low- and high-LET radiation. When G0 human lymphocytes were exposed either to gamma-rays or to d(50 MeV)-Be neutrons and immediately treated with ara-C for increasing periods of time, the frequency of aberrations (dicentrics) increased sharply. For gamma-rays, the enhancement increased with the duration of the treatment up to 5 h, whereas for neutrons, an ara-C treatment lasting for 5 h was no more effective than treatment for 3 h. These results were confirmed by the second experiment in which ara-C was administered for 3 h with an increasing time delay following irradiation. Since no increase in the dicentric frequency was observed when ara-C was administered 5 h after gamma-irradiation, it is suggested that the induced breaks rejoined within that time. For neutrons, the data were conflicting since the repair was completed within 3 h after a dose of 0.5 Gy, and in approximately 5 h after a dose of 2.0 Gy. From both experiments, it appears that gamma-rays and fast neutrons produce similar types of lesions, as ara-C increased the frequencies of aberrations induced by both types of radiation. However, the ara-C treatment resulted in a smaller increase in aberrations following neutron irradiation. According to the enzymatic nature of break formation and the mode of action of ara-C on the polymerase activity, it is suggested that, in addition to double-strand breaks, single-strand breaks could be the lesions involved in the repair processes inhibited by ara-C. Single-strand breaks formed directly or by secondary reactions would, therefore, be one of the major lesions responsible for the aberrations produced by gamma and neutron radiations.     

Effect of Irradiation on Microorganisms in a Nuclear Reactor

The effects of irradiation in the JRR-1 (Japan Research Reactor No. 1, a homogeneous light water nuclear reactor; max. power, 50 KW) on microorganisms such as bacterial and fungal spores and yeast cells were investigated in comparison with those of ⁶⁰Co gamma radiation. As far as the lethal effect was concerned the dose rate of radiation in the experimental hole No. 16 of the JRR-1 was equivalent to 3.0×l0⁶~3.4×l0⁶ r/hr with ⁶⁰Co gamma radiation, and a ratio of the neutron effect to the gamma radiation effect on microorganisms in this hole was estimated to be approximately 3~5.4. The results different from those with gamma radiation were obtained in experiments such as post-NaCl treatment and spore germination. The considerable contribution of fast neutrons to the total biological effect of neutrons, in comparison with the thermal neutron effect, could be presumed from the microbiological experiments with the help of physical and chemical data. Morphological changes in post-irradiation growth were observed by means of phase contrast microscopy. No specific aftereffect was found.     

Dose-response modeling of life shortening in a retrospective analysis of the combined data from the JANUS program at Argonne National Laboratory

Life shortening was investigated in both sexes of the B6CF1 (C57BL/6 x BALB/c) mouse exposed to fission neutrons and 60Co gamma rays. Three basic exposure patterns for both neutrons and gamma rays were compared: single exposures, 24 equal once-weekly exposures, and 60 equal once-weekly exposures. Ten different dose-response models were fitted to the data for animals exposed to neutrons. The response variable used for all dose-response modeling was mean after-survival. A simple linear model adequately described the response to neutrons for females and males at doses less than or equal to 80 cGy. At higher neutron dose levels a linear-quadratic equation was required to describe the life-shortening response. An effect of exposure pattern was observed prior to the detection of curvature in the dose response for neutrons and emerged as a potentially significant factor at neutron doses in the range of 40-60 cGy. Augmentation of neutron injury with dose protraction was observed in both sexes and began at doses as low as 60 cGy. The life-shortening response for all animals exposed to gamma rays (22-1918 cGy) was linear and inversely dependent upon the protraction period (1 day, 24 weeks, 60 weeks). Depending on the exposure pattern used for the gamma-ray baseline, relative biological effectiveness (RBE) values ranged from 6 to 43. Augmentation, because it occurred only at higher levels of neutron exposure, had no influence on the estimation of RBEm.     

The induction by ionizing radiation of chromosomal aberrations in rhesus monkey pre-meiotic germ cells: effects of dose rate and radiation quality

The induction of reciprocal translocations in rhesus monkey stem-cell spermatogonia was studied using multivalent analysis at metaphase of primary spermatocytes. Animals were exposed to 1 Gy gamma-rays at dose rates of 140 and 0.2 mGy/min or to 0.25 Gy acute 2 MeV neutrons. Reduction of the dose rate from 140 mGy/min to 0.2 mGy/min did not result in a lowering of the frequencies of recovered translocations of 0.43%. The neutron data indicated an RBE (neutrons vs. X-rays) of 2.1, which is clearly lower than the value of 4 obtained in the mouse. It is made plausible that in general mammalian species with high sensitivities for the cytotoxic effects of ionizing radiation, such as the rhesus monkey, will exhibit relatively high threshold dose rates below which no further reduction in aberration yield occurs, whereas in more resistant species, such as the mouse, the threshold dose rate will be at a very low level. Similarly, resistant species will show relatively high RBE values for neutron irradiation and sensitive species low ones.     

Choice of model and uncertainties of the gamma-ray and neutron dosimetry in relation to the chromosome aberrations data in Hiroshima and Nagasaki

Chromosome data pertaining to blood samples from 1,703 survivors of the Hiroshima and Nagasaki A-bombs, were utilized and different models for chromosome aberration dose response investigated. Models applied included those linear or linear-quadratic in equivalent dose. Models in which neutron and gamma doses were treated separately (LQ-L model) were also used, which included either the use of a low-dose limiting value for the relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of neutrons of R(0)=70+/-10 or an RBE value of R(1)=15+/-5 at 1 Gy. The use of R(1) incorporates the assumption that it is much better known than R(0), with much less associated uncertainty. In addition, error-reducing transformations were included which were found to result in a 50% reduction of the standard error associated with one of the model fit parameters which is associated with the proportion of cells with at least one aberration, at 1 Gy gamma dose. Several justifiable modifications to the DS86 doses according to recent nuclear retrospective dosimetry measurements were also investigated. Gamma-dose modifications were based on published thermoluminescence measurements of quartz samples from Hiroshima and on a tentative reduction for Nagasaki factory worker candidates by a factor of 0.6. Neutron doses in Hiroshima were modified to become consistent with recent fast neutron activation data based on copper samples. The applied dose modifications result in an increase in non-linearity of the dose-response curve for Hiroshima, and a corresponding decrease in that for Nagasaki, an effect found to be most pronounced for the LQ-L models investigated. As a result the difference in the dose-response curves observed for both cities based on DS86 doses, is somewhat reduced but cannot be entirely explained by the dose modifications applied. The extent to which the neutrons contribute to chromosome aberration induction in Hiroshima depends significantly on the model used. The LQ-L model including an R(1) value of 15 at 1 Gy which is recommended here, would predict between 10% and 20% of the observed chromosome aberrations to be due to neutrons, at all doses. Because of the good agreement between DS86 predictions and the results of retrospective gamma and neutron dosimetry, the modifications applied here to DS86 doses are relatively small. Consequently, the choices of model and RBE values were found to be the major factors dominating the interpretation of the chromosome data for Hiroshima and Nagasaki, with the dose modifications resulting in a smaller influence.     

Comparative frequency of chromosome aberrations in a human lymphocyte culture depending on the mode of neutron irradiation

The study of the dose dependence of the incidence of chromosome aberrations in a human lymphocyte culture exposed at the G0 stage to pulsed neutrons of 0.7 MeV revealed no significant distinctions in the cytogenetic effect at the pulse frequency of 1 and 5 Hz, but at 100 Hz it was somewhat increased. As to the biological effectiveness, pulsed neutrons of 0.7 MeV occupied an intermediate position between 0.35 and 0.85 MeV static neutrons.     

Changes in G1-phase populations in human glioblastoma and neuroblastoma cell lines influence p66/Be neutron-induced micronucleus yield

Some photon resistant tumours are sensitive to neutrons but no predictive methods exist which could identify such tumours. In a recent study addressing this clinically important issue, we demonstrated that relative biologic effectiveness (RBE) values for p(66)/Be neutrons estimated from micronucleus (MN) data correlate positively with RBE values obtained from conventional clonogenic survival data. However, not all photon-resistant cell lines showed high RBE values when the MN endpoint was used. Now, we examine how the functional status of the p53 tumour suppressor gene and radiation-induced changes in cell cycle phase populations may contribute to this discrepancy. No significant association was established between p53 status and MN yield for both photon and neutron irradiation. The data demonstrated that neutron-, but not photon-, induced MN yield is dependent on the intrinsic ability of cells to activate a G1-phase arrest. In cell lines of comparable photon sensitivity, those showing more extensive depletion of the G1 population express significantly more micronuclei per unit dose of neutrons. These results suggest that differences in cell cycle kinetics, and not the p53 status, may constitute an important factor in damage induction by high linear energy transfer (LET) irradiation and need to be considered when radiation toxicity in clinical radiobiology or radiation protection is assessed using damage endpoints.     

Study of dose-rate effects of neutron radiation in a wild-type and a repair-deficient yeasts saccharomyces

We report here a comparative analysis of RBE for lethality of a single pulse (duration 65 micros) of fast neutron with ultra high dose rates (up to 6 x 10(6) Gy/s) and continuous neutron radiation (3.6 x 10(3) s) of the pulse reactor BARS-6. Three diploid strains, one haploid strain and three diploid repair-deficient strains (rad52-1/rad52-1; rad54/rad54; rad2/rad2) were used. The RBE values (D(0gamma)/1D(0n)) of a single pulse and continuous neutron irradiation were equal (1.7-1.8) with maximum RBE (4.1-3.1) in region of low doses (shoulder region). Haploid cells were found to be more (3 times) sensitive to both gamma-rays and neutrons than the wild type. There was no obvious decrease in the RBE of 1.9 in highly sensitive haploid cells as compared with highly resistant diploid cells. The repair-deficient strains (rad52-1/rad52-1; rad54/rad54) were more (up to 10 fold) sensitive to both neutrons and gamma-rays as compared with their parent line. The RBE values of 1.5-1.7 of neutrons for these mutants (independent by of the mode of irradiation) were found. The repair-deficient mutant rad2/rad2 had similar sensitivity as a wild type and a RBE value was 2.0. We have concluded that biological effectiveness of the neutrons of pulse reactor BARS-6 was independent of the dose-rate, differing up to 10(8) fold. The RBE didn't vary significantly with the capacity of cells to repair DNA damages.     

Lack of synergistic effect between X-ray and UV irradiation on the frequency of chromosome aberrations in PHA-stimulated human lymphocytes in the G1 stage.

PHA-stimulated human lymphocytes in the G1 stage were irradiated with UV radiation and X-rays, and the cells were analyzed for chromosomal aberrations in the first mitotic division. The frequency of dicentric chromosomes after single X-irradiation in the G1 stage was about twice the yield in the G0 stage. No increase in the yield of dicentrics was observed after combined irradiation with UV and X-rays. This is contrary to the finding for G0 lymphocytes, where a 2-fold increase of chromosome aberrations was observed. UV irradiation of G1 lymphocytes induced chromatid-type aberrations whereas no significant yield of dicentric chromosomes was observed. This is in agreement with previous findings in Chinese hamster cells in the G1 stage [7]. Irradiation of G0 lymphocytes with UV radiation induce a low frequency of dicentric chromosomes. Thus, the present data indicate that the ratio between chromosome-type and chromatid-type aberrations is different in the G1 and G0 stages in human lymphocytes irradiated with UV radiation.     

Susceptibility to damage of human lymphocyte chromosomes in different stages of the mitotic cycle when exposed to fast neutrons with an average energy of 6 MeV

Cytogenetic susceptibility of human lymphocytes in the culture to lesion is studied under the effect of neutrons with 6 MeV energy at different stages of the mitotic cycle. Radiosensitivity of human lymphocytes under the influence of gamma-quanta and neutrons is found to vary identically during the whole cycle. These variations are less expressed in the case of neutron irradiation. The data allow concluding that the repair system functions most actively at the S stage in case of both types of radiation.     

The quantitative patterns in the yield of chromosome aberrations in a human lymphocyte culture under fractionated gamma-neutron irradiation at different stages of the mitotic cycle. The cytogenetic effects at the G0 stage]

A study was made of the quantitative regularities of the interaction of cytogenetic damages induced, at the G0 stage of human lymphocyte culture, by fractionated gamma-neutron radiation, within a wide range of doses, delivered in the direct of reverse sequence at the intervals between fractions of 1 and 5 h. The results were compared with those obtained in experiments with single and fractionated gamma- or neutron irradiation within the same dose range.     

Retrospective dosimetry after criticality accidents using low-frequency EPR: a study of whole human teeth irradiated in a mixed neutron and gamma-radiation field

In the context of accidental or intentional radiation exposures (nuclear terrorism), it is essential to separate rapidly those individuals with substantial exposures from those with exposures that do not constitute an immediate threat to health. Low-frequency electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy provides the potential advantage of making accurate and sensitive measurements of absorbed radiation dose in teeth without removing the teeth from the potential victims. Up to now, most studies focused on the dose-response curves obtained for gamma radiation. In radiation accidents, however, the contribution of neutrons to the total radiation dose should not be neglected. To determine how neutrons contribute to the apparent dose estimated by EPR dosimetry, extracted whole human teeth were irradiated at the SILENE reactor in a mixed neutron and gamma-radiation field simulating criticality accidents. The teeth were irradiated in free air as well as in a paraffin head phantom. Lead screens were also used to eliminate to a large extent the contribution of the gamma radiation to the dose received by the teeth. The EPR signals, obtained with a low-frequency (1.2 GHz) spectrometer, were compared to dosimetry measurements at the same location. The contribution of neutrons to the EPR dosimetric signal was negligible in the range of 0 to 10 Gy and was rather small (neutron/gamma-ray sensitivity in the range 0-0.2) at higher doses. This indicates that the method essentially provides information on the dose received from the gamma-ray component of the radiation.     

Comet assay to sense neutron 'fingerprint'

The suitability of comet assay to identify DNA damage induced by neutrons of varying energy was tested. For this purpose, monoenergetic neutrons from Hiroshima University Radiobiological Research Accelerator (HIRRAC) were used to induce DNA damage in irradiated human peripheral blood lymphocytes. The level of damage was computed as tail moment for different doses (0.125-1 Gy) and compared with the effects resulting from irradiation with (60)Co gamma. The neutron-irradiated cells exhibited longer comet tails consisting of tiny pieces of broken DNA in contrast to the streaking tails generated by (60)Co gamma. The peak biological effectiveness occurred at 0.37 and 0.57 MeV; a further increase or decrease in neutron energy led to a reduced RBE value. The RBE values, as measured by the comet assay, were 6.3, 5.4, 4.7, 4.3, 2.6, and 1.7 for 0.37, 0.57, 0.79, 0.186, 1, and 2.3 MeV neutrons. The lower RBE value obtained by the comet assay when compared to that for other biological end points is discussed. This study reports the usefulness of the alkaline comet assay for identifying DNA damage induced by neutrons of the same radiation weighting factor. The comet assay is a potential tool for use in neutron therapy, as well as a method for the rapid screening of samples from individuals accidentally exposed to radiation.