The roles of ethylene, auxin, abscisic acid, and gibberellin in the hyponastic growth of submerged Rumex palustris petioles

Rumex palustris responds to complete submergence with upward movement of the younger petioles. This so-called hyponastic response, in combination with stimulated petiole elongation, brings the leaf blade above the water surface and restores contact with the atmosphere. We made a detailed study of this differential growth process, encompassing the complete range of the known signal transduction pathway: from the cellular localization of differential growth, to the hormonal regulation, and the possible involvement of a cell wall loosening protein (expansin) as a downstream target. We show that hyponastic growth is caused by differential cell elongation across the petiole base, with cells on the abaxial (lower) surface elongating faster than cells on the adaxial (upper) surface. Pharmacological studies and endogenous hormone measurements revealed that ethylene, auxin, abscisic acid (ABA), and gibberellin regulate different and sometimes overlapping stages of hyponastic growth. Initiation of hyponastic growth and (maintenance of) the maximum petiole angle are regulated by ethylene, ABA, and auxin, whereas the speed of the response is influenced by ethylene, ABA, and gibberellin. We found that a submergence-induced differential redistribution of endogenous indole-3-acetic acid in the petiole base could play a role in maintenance of the response, but not in the onset of hyponastic growth. Since submergence does not induce a differential expression of expansins across the petiole base, it is unlikely that this cell wall loosening protein is the downstream target for the hormones that regulate the differential cell elongation leading to submergence-induced hyponastic growth in R. palustris.     

Plant movement. Submergence-induced petiole elongation in Rumex palustris depends on hyponastic growth

The submergence-tolerant species Rumex palustris (Sm.) responds to complete submergence by an increase in petiole angle with the horizontal. This hyponastic growth, in combination with stimulated elongation of the petiole, can bring the leaf tips above the water surface, thus restoring gas exchange and enabling survival. Using a computerized digital camera set-up the kinetics of this hyponastic petiole movement and stimulated petiole elongation were studied. The hyponastic growth is a relatively rapid process that starts after a lag phase of 1.5 to 3 h and is completed after 6 to 7 h. The kinetics of hyponastic growth depend on the initial angle of the petiole at the time of submergence, a factor showing considerable seasonal variation. For example, lower petiole angles at the time of submergence result in a shorter lag phase for hyponastic growth. This dependency of the hyponastic growth kinetics can be mimicked by experimentally manipulating the petiole angle at the time of submergence. Stimulated petiole elongation in response to complete submergence also shows kinetics that are dependent on the petiole angle at the time of submergence, with lower initial petiole angles resulting in a longer lag phase for petiole elongation. Angle manipulation experiments show that stimulated petiole elongation can only start when the petiole has reached an angle of 40 degrees to 50 degrees. The petiole can reach this "critical angle" for stimulated petiole elongation by the process of hyponastic growth. This research shows a functional dependency of one response to submergence in R. palustris (stimulated petiole elongation) on another response (hyponastic petiole growth), because petiole elongation can only contribute to the leaf reaching the water surface when the petiole has a more or less upright position.     

A kinetic analysis of hyponastic growth and petiole elongation upon ethylene exposure in Rumex palustris

Background and Aims

Complete submergence is an important stress factor for many terrestrial plants, and a limited number of species have evolved mechanisms to deal with these conditions. Rumex palustris is one such species and manages to outgrow the water, and thus restore contact with the atmosphere, through upward leaf growth (hyponasty) followed by strongly enhanced petiole elongation. These responses are initiated by the gaseous plant hormone ethylene, which accumulates inside plants due to physical entrapment. This study aimed to investigate the kinetics of ethylene-induced leaf hyponasty and petiole elongation.

Methods

Leaf hyponasty and petiole elongation was studied using a computerized digital camera set-up followed by image analyses. Linear variable displacement transducers were used for fine resolution monitoring and measurement of petiole growth rates.

Key Results

We show that submergence-induced hyponastic growth and petiole elongation in R. palustris can be mimicked by exposing plants to ethylene. The petiole elongation response to ethylene is shown to depend on the initial angle of the petiole. When petiole angles were artificially kept at 0°, rather than the natural angle of 35°, ethylene could not induce enhanced petiole elongation. This is very similar to submergence studies and confirms the idea that there are endogenous, angle-dependent signals that influence the petiole elongation response to ethylene.

Conclusions

Our data suggest that submergence and ethylene-induced hyponastic growth and enhanced petiole elongation responses in R. palustris are largely similar. However, there are some differences that may relate to the complexity of the submergence treatment as compared with an ethylene treatment.     

New perspectives in flooding research: the use of shade avoidance and Arabidopsis thaliana

BACKGROUND: Complete submergence of Rumex palustris leads to hyponastic (upward) petiole growth followed by enhanced petiole elongation. Previous pharmacological experiments have provided insights into the signal transduction pathway leading to this combined 'escape' response. It will, however, be difficult to gain further knowledge using these methods. Consequently, new approaches are required. SCOPE: Here we propose that different environmental signals resulting in similar phenotypes can help to understand better the submergence response. In this review, we show that both ethylene and shade induce similar growth responses in R. palustris and Arabidopsis thaliana. We illustrate how this can be exploited to unravel novel signalling components in submergence-induced elongation growth. Furthermore, we illustrate the potential of arabidopsis as a useful model in submergence research based on similarities with submergence-tolerant species such as R. palustris and the molecular opportunities it presents. This is illustrated by examples of current work exploring this concept. CONCLUSIONS: Incorporating different model systems, such as arabidopsis and shade avoidance, into submergence research can be expected to create powerful tools to unravel signal transduction routes determining submergence tolerance.     

Contrasting interactions between ethylene and abscisic acid in Rumex species differing in submergence tolerance

Complete submergence of flooding-tolerant Rumex palustris plants strongly stimulates petiole elongation. This escape response is initiated by the accumulation of ethylene inside the submerged tissue. In contrast, petioles of flooding-intolerant Rumex acetosa do not increase their elongation rate under water even though ethylene also accumulates when they are submerged. Abscisic acid (ABA) was found to be a negative regulator of enhanced petiole growth in both species. In R. palustris, accumulated ethylene stimulated elongation by inhibiting biosynthesis of ABA via a reduction of RpNCED expression and enhancing degradation of ABA to phaseic acid. Externally applied ABA inhibited petiole elongation and prevented the upregulation of gibberellin A(1) normally found in submerged R. palustris. In R. acetosa submergence did not stimulate petiole elongation nor did it depress levels of ABA. However, if ABA concentrations in R. acetosa were first artificially reduced, submergence (but not ethylene) was then able to enhance petiole elongation strongly. This result suggests that in Rumex a decrease in ABA is a prerequisite for ethylene and other stimuli to promote elongation.     

GROWTH AND GRAVITATIONAL RESPONSE IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF LEAF BLADE HYPONASTY

Rapid (4 hr) auxin-induced hyponastic curvature of primary leaves of Phaseolus vulgaris is shown to depend on a positive increase in growth of the lower portion of the blade. The curvature involves laminar growth as well as vein growth and is not due to simple turgor changes. The response is sensitive to gravitational orientation, as inversion and horizontal rotation reduce the auxin-induced curvature. The ethylene-generating compound, 2-chloroethylphosphonic acid, had no hyponastic effect on the leaves when applied to either the upper or lower surface and it inhibited auxin-induced hyponasty. This inhibition was additive to that of inversion. Long-term (24–48 hr) effects of 1 mM auxin depend on the surface of the leaf treated. Application to the upper surface results in epinasty, lower surface application in hyponasty, although the initial response in each case is a hyponastic curvature. A dorsi-ventral auxin transport system and differential auxin sensitivity of upper and lower portions of the leaf blade are postulated to account for these responses.     

Ethylene Sensitivity and Response Sensor Expression in Petioles of Rumex Species at Low O2 and High CO2 Concentrations

Rumex palustris, a flooding-tolerant plant, elongates its petioles in response to complete submergence. This response can be partly mimicked by enhanced ethylene levels and low O2 concentrations. High levels of CO2 do not markedly affect petiole elongation in R. palustris. Experiments with ethylene synthesis and action inhibitors demonstrate that treatment with low O2 concentrations enhances petiole extension by shifting sensitivity to ethylene without changing the rate of ethylene production. The expression level of the R. palustris gene coding for the putative ethylene receptor (RP-ERS1) is up-regulated by 3% O2 and increases after 20 min of exposure to a low concentration of O2, thus preceding the first significant increase in elongation observable after 40 to 50 min. In the flooding-sensitive species Rumex acetosa, submergence results in a different response pattern: petiole growth of the submerged plants is the same as for control plants. Exposure of R. acetosa to enhanced ethylene levels strongly inhibits petiole growth. This inhibitory effect of ethylene on R. acetosa can be reduced by both low levels of O2 and/or high concentrations of CO2.     

The contrasting role of auxin in submergence-induced petiole elongation in two species from frequently flooded wetlands

The involvement of auxin in the submergence-induced petiole elongation has been investigated in Rumex palustris and Ranunculus sceleratus. Both wetland species are capable of enhanced petiole elongation upon submergence or treatment with exogenous ethylene (5μl l⁻¹). Treatment of intact Rumex palustris plants with 1-naphthalene acetic acid (NAA) at 10⁻⁴ M enhanced petiole elongation, while treatment with N -1-naphthylphthalamic acid (NPA) had no effect on petiole elongation. The elongation response after NAA or NPA treatment was comparable for plants in both submerged and drained conditions. Pre-ageing of detached petioles of Rumex palustris for 3 h in light or in dark conditions had no effect on the submergence-induced elongation. In comparison to intact plants, detached petioles of Rumex palustris , with or without lamina, did not show significant differences in responsiveness to IAA between drained or submerged conditions. This was in contrast to Ranunculus sceleratus where submergence caused a clear increase in responsiveness towards IAA. Removal of the lamina, the putative source of auxin, or treatment with NPA did not hinder the submergence-induced elongation of detached Rumex palustris petioles, but severely inhibited elongation of detached Ranunculus sceleratus petioles. This inhibition could be restored by application of NAA, suggesting the specific involvement of auxin in the submergence response of Ranunculus sceleratus. It is concluded that, in contrast to Ranunculus sceleratus , auxin is probably not involved in the submergence-induced petiole elongation of Rumex palustris.     

THE TIMING OF AND EFFECT OF TEMPERATURE ON AUXIN-INDUCED HYPONASTIC CURVATURE OF THE BEAN PRIMARY LEAF BLADE

Detailed examination of the hyponastic curvature of the primary bean leaf blade in response to indoleacetic acid (IAA) shows that curvature begins within 15 min after application and increases to a maximal rate at 20 to 30 min. A second application of IAA results in a second curvature maximum when applied 1.5 hr or more after the first. Washing experiments indicate IAA uptake is largely complete by about 20 min after application, suggesting the return to planar form is accompanied by the uptake and passage of a wave of IAA through the responding cells. The rate of curvature decreases as the temperature is lowered, particularly below 14 C; at low concentrations (10^–4 m) the rate of response to 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid and 2,4,5-trichlorophenoxypropionic acid is slower than that for IAA and naphthaleneacetic acid. These differences are proposed to reflect the involvement of the polar auxin transport system in the response. The leaves of bean seedlings exposed to 4 C develop hyponastic curvatures when returned to normal growth temperature; 5 min treatment is sufficient to induce this response, and with longer treatments, greater curvatures are obtained. This curvature is inhibited by application of 2,3,5-triiodobenzoic acid (TIBA) to the undersurface of the leaf at the beginning of the cold treatment. The results are consistent with a model of planar plageotropic growth regulation in the leaf blade in which auxin produced by cells in the upper portion of the blade is transported by the polar transport system through cells in the lower portion that are growth limited by auxin supply. The hyponastic and epinastic effects caused by exogenous application of auxin or TIBA and of cold treatments are considered to result from changes in this auxin supply.     

Long-term inhibition by auxin of leaf blade expansion in bean and Arabidopsis

The role of auxin in controlling leaf expansion remains unclear. Experimental increases to normal auxin levels in expanding leaves have shown conflicting results, with both increases and decreases in leaf growth having been measured. Therefore, the effects of both auxin application and adjustment of endogenous leaf auxin levels on midrib elongation and final leaf size (fresh weight and area) were examined in attached primary monofoliate leaves of the common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris) and in early Arabidopsis rosette leaves. Aqueous auxin application inhibited long-term leaf blade elongation. Bean leaves, initially 40 to 50 mm in length, treated once with alpha-naphthalene acetic acid (1.0 mm), were, after 6 d, approximately 80% the length and weight of controls. When applied at 1.0 and 0.1 mm, alpha-naphthalene acetic acid significantly inhibited long-term leaf growth. The weak auxin, beta-naphthalene acetic acid, was effective at 1.0 mm; and a weak acid control, benzoic acid, was ineffective. Indole-3-acetic acid (1 microm, 10 microm, 0.1 mm, and 1 mm) required daily application to be effective at any concentration. Application of the auxin transport inhibitor, 1-N-naphthylphthalamic acid (1% [w/w] in lanolin), to petioles also inhibited long-term leaf growth. This treatment also was found to lead to a sustained elevation of leaf free indole-3-acetic acid content relative to untreated control leaves. Auxin-induced inhibition of leaf growth appeared not to be mediated by auxin-induced ethylene synthesis because growth inhibition was not rescued by inhibition of ethylene synthesis. Also, petiole treatment of Arabidopsis with 1-N-naphthylphthalamic acid similarly inhibited leaf growth of both wild-type plants and ethylene-insensitive ein4 mutants.     

Growth responses of Rumex species in relation to submergence and ethylene

Abstract. Submergence stimulates growth of the petioles of Rumex palustris and Rumex crispus under field, greenhouse and laboratory conditions. Growth of Rumex acetosa petioles was hardly influenced by submergence. These growth responses under flooded conditions can be partially mimicked by exposing non-submerged Rumex plants to ethylene-air mixtures. Submergence of intact plants in a solution of AgNO₃ inhibited the elongation of all petioles of R. palustris and the youngest petiole of R. crispus and stimulated growth of the youngest petiole of R. acetosa , The ethylene-air mixture experiments, the effect of AgNO₃ and observed increase of the endogenous ethylene concentration during submergence suggest that ethylene plays a regulatory role in the growth responses of these Rumex species under submerged conditions. The three Rumex species showed a gradient in elongation responses to submergence, which correlates with the field distribution of the three species in a flooding gradient.     

Abscission: the initial effect of ethylene is in the leaf blade

The leaf blade of cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L. cv. Stoneville 213) was investigated as the initial site of ethylene action in abscission. Ethylene applied at 14 μl/l to intact 3-week-old plants caused abscission of the third true leaf within 3 days. However, keeping only the leaf blade of this leaf in air during ethylene treatment of the rest of the plant completely prevented its abscission for up to 7 days. This inhibition of abscission was apparently the result of continued auxin production in the blade since (a) the application of an auxin transport inhibitor to the petiole of the air-treated leaf blade restored ethylene sensitivity to the leaf in terms of abscission; (b) repeated applications of naphthaleneacetic acid to the leaf blade of the third true leaf, when the entire plant was exposed to ethylene, had the same preventive effect on abscission of this leaf as keeping its leaf blade in air; and (c) the inhibitory effect of ethylene on auxin transport in the petiole, which is reduced by auxin treatment, was also reduced by placing the leaf blade in air.     

Abscisic acid antagonizes ethylene-induced hyponastic growth in Arabidopsis

Ethylene induces enhanced differential growth in petioles of Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana), resulting in an upward movement of the leaf blades (hyponastic growth). The amplitude of this effect differs between accessions, with Columbia-0 (Col-0) showing a large response, while in Landsberg erecta (Ler), hyponastic growth is minimal. Abscisic acid (ABA) was found to act as an inhibitory factor of this response in both accessions, but the relationship between ethylene and ABA differed between the two; the ability of ABA to inhibit ethylene-induced hyponasty was significantly more pronounced in Col-0. Mutations in ABI1 or ABI3 induced a strong ethylene-regulated hyponastic growth in the less responsive accession Ler, while the response was abolished in the ABA-hypersensitive era1 in Col-0. Modifications in ABA levels altered petiole angles in the absence of applied ethylene, indicating that ABA influences petiole angles also independently from ethylene. A model is proposed whereby the negative effect of ABA on hyponastic growth is overcome by ethylene in Col-0 but not in Ler. However, when ABA signaling is artificially released in Ler, this regulatory mechanism is bypassed, resulting in a strong hyponastic response in this accession.     

THE INTERACTION OF AUXIN AND ETHYLENE IN THE MAINTENANCE OF LEAF BLADE FORM IN PHASEOLUS VULGARIS L. VAR. PINTO

Auxin treatment results in hyponastic curvature of the primary leaves of Phaseolus vulgaris L. var pinto. Ethylene production by hyponastic leaves is detected within 1 hr after treatment with IAA in concentrations at or above 1 μm. The amount of ethylene detected is proportional to the concentration of auxin applied. Untreated control leaves and leaves treated with 2,3,5-tri-iodobenzoic acid or gibberellic acid did not produce ethylene detectable by our equipment. The hyponastic curvature induced by auxin treatment can be inhibited by exogenous application of ethylene or ethylene-generating compounds, and these treatments produce epinasty in auxin-treated leaves. Treatment with inhibitors of ethylene synthesis or action, such as aminoethoxy-vinylglycine, carbon dioxide, or heat treatment, prolong hyponasty. The planar form, therefore, appears to be affected by both hyponastic auxin effect and an epinastic ethylene effect.     

Ethylene-induced differential growth of petioles in Arabidopsis. Analyzing natural variation, response kinetics, and regulation

Plants can reorient their organs in response to changes in environmental conditions. In some species, ethylene can induce resource-directed growth by stimulating a more vertical orientation of the petioles (hyponasty) and enhanced elongation. In this study on Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana), we show significant natural variation in ethylene-induced petiole elongation and hyponastic growth. This hyponastic growth was rapidly induced and also reversible because the petioles returned to normal after ethylene withdrawal. To unravel the mechanisms behind the natural variation, two contrasting accessions in ethylene-induced hyponasty were studied in detail. Columbia-0 showed a strong hyponastic response to ethylene, whereas this response was almost absent in Landsberg erecta (Ler). To test whether Ler is capable of showing hyponastic growth at all, several signals were applied. From all the signals applied, only spectrally neutral shade (20 micromol m(-2) s(-1)) could induce a strong hyponastic response in Ler. Therefore, Ler has the capacity for hyponastic growth. Furthermore, the lack of ethylene-induced hyponastic growth in Ler is not the result of already-saturating ethylene production rates or insensitivity to ethylene, as an ethylene-responsive gene was up-regulated upon ethylene treatment in the petioles. Therefore, we conclude that Ler is missing an essential component between the primary ethylene signal transduction chain and a downstream part of the hyponastic growth signal transduction pathway.     

Submergence-Induced Ethylene Synthesis,Entrapment, and Growth in Two Plant Species with Contrasting Flooding Resistances

Submergence-induced ethylene synthesis and entrapment were studied in two contrasting Rumex species, one flood-resistant (Rumex palustris) and the other flood-sensitive (Rumex acetosa). The application of a photoacoustic method to determine internal ethylene concentrations in submerged plants is discussed. A comparison with an older technique (vacuum extraction) is described. For the first time ethylene production before, during, and after submergence and the endogenous concentration during submergence were continuously measured on a single intact plant without physical perturbation. Both Rumex species were characterized by enhanced ethylene concentrations in the shoot after 24 h of submergence. This was not related to enhanced synthesis but to continued production and physical entrapment. In R. palustris, high endogenous ethylene levels correlated with enhanced petiole and lamina elongation. No dramatic change in leaf growth rate was observed in submerged R. acetosa shoots. After desubmergence both species showed an increase in ethylene production, the response being more pronounced in R. palustris. This increase was linked to the enhanced postsubmergence growth rate of leaves of R. palustris. Due to the very rapid escape of ethylene out of desubmerged plants to the atmosphere (90% disappeared within 1 min), substantial underestimation of internal ethylene concentrations can be expected using more conventional vacuum extraction techniques.     

Auxin perception and polar auxin transport are not always a prerequisite for differential growth

Using time-lapse photography, we studied the response kinetics of low light intensity-induced upward leaf-movement, called hyponastic growth, in Arabidopsis thaliana. This response is one of the traits of shade avoidance and directs plant organs to more favorable light conditions. Based on mutant- and pharmacological data we demonstrated that among other factors, functional auxin perception and polar auxin transport (PAT) are required for the amplitude of hyponastic growth and for maintenance of the high leaf angle, upon low light treatment. Here, we present additional data suggesting that auxin and PAT antagonize the hyponastic growth response induced by ethylene treatment. We conclude that ethylene- and low light-induced hyponastic growth occurs at least partly via separate signaling routes, despite their strong similarities in response kinetics.Key words: hyponastic growth, petiole, Arabidopsis, ethylene, low light, auxin, polar auxin transport, differential growthUpward leaf movement (hyponastic growth) is a trait of several plant species to escape from growth-limiting conditions.^1,2 Interestingly, Arabidopsis thaliana induces a marked hyponastic growth response triggered by various environmental stimuli, including complete submergence, high temperature, canopy shade and spectral neutral low light intensities (Fig. 1).^3–6 The paper of Millenaar et al. in the New Phytologist 2009,⁷ provides a detailed analysis of low light intensity-induced hyponastic growth and components of the signal transduction are characterized using time-lapse photography. Low light intensity-induced hyponastic growth is a component of the so-called shade avoidance syndrome. Light-spectrum manipulations and mutant analyses indicated that predominantly the blue light wavelength region affects petiole movement and fast induction of hyponastic growth to low light conditions involves the photoreceptor proteins Cryptochrome 1 (Cry1), Cry2, Phytochrome-A (PhyA) and PhyB. Moreover, we show that also photosynthesis-derived signals can induce differential growth.Open in a separate windowFigure 1Typical hyponastic growth phenotype of Arabidopsis thaliana. Side view of Columbia-0 plants treated 10 h with ethylene (5 µl l⁻¹) or low light (20 µmol m⁻² s⁻¹). Plants in control light conditions were in 200 µmol m⁻² s⁻¹. Both stimuli induce a clear leaf inclination (hyponasty) relative to the horizontal by differential growth of the petioles. Plants kept in control conditions only show modest diurnal leaf movement and leaf angles gradually decline over time due to maturation of the leaves. Note that the paint droplets were applied to facilitate quantitative measurement of leaf angle kinetics in a time-lapse camera setup.⁷The hyponastic growth response to low light intensity was not affected in several ethylene-insensitive mutant lines. Moreover, low light did not affect expression of ethylene inducible marker genes nor differences in ethylene release were noted. Therefore, we concluded that low light-induced hyponastic growth is independent of ethylene signaling. This is perhaps surprising, because ethylene is the main trigger of hyponastic growth induced by complete submergence in several species. Interestingly, both ethylene and low light can induce hyponastic growth in Arabidopsis with similar kinetics.³We showed that plants mutant in auxin perception components (transport inhibitor response1 (tir1) and tir1 afb1 afb2 afb3 quadruple, containing additional mutant alleles of TIR1 homologous F-box proteins) and plants mutant in (polar) auxin transport (tir3-1, pin-formed3 (pin3) and pin7) components had a lower hyponastic growth amplitude in low light conditions.⁷ Moreover, these mutants were less able to maintain the high leaf angles after the response maximum. Both characteristics were also noted in plants pre-treated with the polar auxin transport (PAT) inhibitor 2,3,5-triiodobenzoic acid (TIBA). We therefore concluded that auxin perception and PAT are involved in the regulation of low light-induced hyponastic growth.⁷ Interestingly, we observed that TIBA pretreatment did not inhibit ethylene-induced hyponastic growth. In fact, the response upon ethylene treatment was even modestly enhanced. In agreement with this observation, we show here that the above mentioned auxin perception and PAT mutants also showed a slightly enhanced hyponastic growth response upon ethylene treatment (Fig. 2).Open in a separate windowFigure 2Auxin involvement in ethylene induced hyponasty. Effect of exposure to ethylene (5 µl l⁻¹) on the kinetics of hyponastic petiole growth (A) in Arabidopsis thaliana Columbia-0 plants treated with 50 µm TIBa (open circles) or a mock treatment (line) adapted from Supporting Information Figure S3 of Millenaar et al. (2009)⁷ and (B–F) in Arabidopsis auxin signaling and polar auxin transport mutants (closed circles), compared to the wild type response to low light (lines). Petiole angles are pair wise subtracted, which corrects for diurnal petiole movement in control conditions. For details on this procedure, growth conditions, treatments, data acquirement and analysis see.^7,13 Error bars represent standard errors; n ≥ 12. mutants were obtained from the Nottingham Arabidopsis Stock Center (accession numbers are shown between brackets) or from the authors describing the lines. tir1-1 (n3798,¹⁴), tir1-1 afb1-1 afb2-1 (in a mixed Columbia/Wassilewskija background),¹⁵ tir3-1,¹⁴ pin3-4 (n9363,¹⁶) and pin7-1 (n9365,¹⁰).Despite that auxin and PAT are required for many differential growth responses such as phototropism and gravitropism,^8,11 these data indicate that auxin perception and PAT are not obligatory for ethylene-induced hyponasty in Arabidopsis per se. In fact, one might even conclude that auxin and PAT antagonizes ethylene-induced hyponasty. These results are partly in agreement with observations on the wetland species Rumex palustris, were pretreatment with the auxin-efflux carrier 1-naphthylphthalamic acid (NPA) resulted in doubling of the lag-phase for hyponastic growth under water, but hardly affected the amplitude of the response.¹²Together, this indicates that auxin is not always a prerequisite for differential growth responses. Based on the apparent contrasting effects of auxin perception and PAT in low light- and ethylene-induced hyponastic growth, we conclude that ethylene and low light induce hyponastic growth, at least partly, via separate signaling routes.