Behavioral plasticity in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) with divergent coping styles: when doves become hawks

Consistent and heritable individual differences in reaction to challenges, often referred to as stress coping styles, have been extensively documented in vertebrates. In fish, selection for divergent post-stress plasma cortisol levels in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) has yielded a low (LR) and a high responsive (HR) strain. A suite of behavioural traits is associated with this physiological difference, with LR (proactive) fish feeding more rapidly after transfer to a new environment and being socially dominant over HR (reactive) fish. Following transport from the UK to Norway, a switch in behavioural profile occurred in trout from the 3rd generation; HR fish regained feeding sooner than LR fish in a novel environment and became dominant in size-matched HR–LR pairs. One year after transport, HR fish still fed sooner, but no difference in social dominance was found. Among offspring of transported fish, no differences in feeding were observed, but as in pre-transported 3rd generation fish, HR fish lost fights for social dominance against size-matched LR opponents. Transported fish and their offspring retained their distinctive physiological profile throughout the study; HR fish showed consistently higher post-stress cortisol levels at all sampling points. Altered risk-taking and social dominance immediately after transport may be explained by the fact that HR fish lost more body mass during transport than did LR fish. These data demonstrate that some behavioural components of stress coping styles can be modified by experience, whereas behavioural plasticity is limited by genetic effects determining social position early in life story.     

Cortisol receptor expression differs in the brains of rainbow trout selected for divergent cortisol responses

In rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss), selection for divergent post-stress plasma cortisol levels has yielded low (LR)- and high (HR) responsive lines, differing in behavioural and physiological aspects of stress coping. For instance, LR fish display prolonged retention of a fear response and of previously learnt routines, compared to HR fish. This study aims at investigating putative central nervous system mechanisms controlling behaviour and memory retention. The stress hormone cortisol is known to affect several aspects of cognition, including memory retention. Cortisol acts through glucocorticoid receptors 1 and 2 (GR1 and 2) and a mineralcorticoid receptor (MR), all of which are abundantly expressed in the salmonid brain. We hypothesized that different expressions of MR and GRs in LR and HR trout brains could be involved in the observed differences in cognition. We quantified the mRNA expression of GR1, GR2 and MR in different brain regions of stressed and non-stressed LR and HR trout. The expression of MR was higher in LR than in HR fish in all brain parts investigated. This could be associated with reduced anxiety and enhanced memory retention in LR fish. MR and GR1 expression was also subject to negative regulation by stress in a site-specific manner.     

Behavioral and Neuroendocrine Correlates of Selection for Stress Responsiveness in Rainbow Trout--a Review

In rainbow trout the magnitude of the cortisol response to stressshows both consistency over time and a moderate to high degreeof heritability, and high responding (HR) and low responding(LR) lines of rainbow trout have been generated by individualselection for consistently high or low post-stress cortisolvalues. Using 2nd and 3rd generation fish, we tested the hypothesisthat differential stress responsiveness is associated with behavioralalterations in the HR-LR trout model. LR fish showed a tendencyto become socially dominant, a rapid recovery of food intakeafter transfer to a novel environment, and a reduced locomotorresponse in a territorial intrusion test. Furthermore, stressinduced elevation of brain stem and optic tectum concentrationsof the monoamine neurotransmitters serotonin, dopamine, andnorepinephrine and their metabolites suggests that both synthesisand metabolism of these transmitters were elevated after stressto a larger degree in HR than in LR trout. A divergent patternwas seen in the hypothalamus, where LR fish displayed elevatedlevels of 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid (a serotonin metabolite)and 3-methoxy-4-hydroxyphenylglycol (a norepinephrine metabolite).Thus, selection for a single trait, cortisol responsiveness,in rainbow trout is associated with concurrent changes in bothbehavior and central signaling systems. The apparent parallelto genetically determined stress coping styles in mammals, andthe existence of similar trait associations in unselected populationsof rainbow trout, suggests an evolutionarily conserved correlationbetween multiple traits. Continuing studies on the HR and LRtrout lines are aimed at providing the physiological and geneticbasis for new marker-assisted selection strategies in the rapidlydeveloping finfish aquaculture industry, as well as increasedknowledge of the function and evolution of central neuroendocrinesignaling systems.     

Divergence in behavioural responses to stress in two strains of rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) with contrasting stress responsiveness

The aim of this study was to establish whether two lines of rainbow trout divergent for their plasma cortisol response to a standardized stressor would show consistent differences in their behavioural response to a range of challenging situations. Our results show that the high- and low-responding (HR and LR) lines of rainbow trout did not differ in the aggression shown towards an intruder or in their response to the introduction of a novel object to their home environment. However, there was a difference in behaviour between the two selection lines when they were exposed to two unfamiliar environments. These results suggest that the behaviour of the HR and LR fish differs when they are challenged in unfamiliar environments, while their behaviour does not differ when they are challenged in their home environment. These observations are in agreement with studies on mammals that show that individuals with reactive coping styles perform similarly to proactive animals when they are challenged in a familiar environment, while they show different behaviour when they are challenged in unfamiliar environments. Thus, these results provide further evidence that the HR and LR selection lines of rainbow trout exemplify the two different coping styles described in mammals.     

Effects of maternal stress coping style on offspring characteristics in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss)

Maternal size, age, and allostatic load influence offspring size, development, and survival. Some of these effects have been attributed to the release of glucocorticoids, and individual variation in these stress hormones is related to a number of traits. Correlated traits are often clustered and used to define the proactive and reactive stress coping styles. Although stress coping styles have been identified in a number of animal groups, little is known about the coupling between stress coping style and offspring characteristics. In the present study, plasma cortisol levels in ovulated mothers and cortisol levels in non-fertilized eggs from two rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) strains selected for high (HR) and low (LR) post-stress plasma cortisol levels were compared. Offspring characteristics such as egg size, larval growth, and energy reserves also were compared between the two strains. Maternal plasma and egg cortisol levels were correlated, but no difference between the HR and LR strains was detected in either parameter. LR females produced larger eggs, and larvae with larger yolk sacs compared to HR females, however no differences in larval body size (excluding the yolk) was detected between strains. Considering that the HR and LR strains have a number of correlated behavioral and physiological traits that resemble the reactive and proactive stress coping styles, respectively, the results suggest that proactive mothers invest more energy into their offspring, producing larvae with larger energy reserves. It is possible that larger energy reserves in proactive larvae support the energy requirement for establishing and defending territory in salmonid fish. Furthermore, in the present study we found a positive relationship between mother plasma cortisol and egg cortisol; however neither mother plasma cortisol nor egg cortisol differed between strains. These results indicate that cortisol endowment from the mother to the offspring plays a minor role in the transfer of the behavioral and physiological traits which separates these strains.     

Stress effects on AVT and CRF systems in two strains of rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) divergent in stress responsiveness

The aim for this study was to examine whether the F4 generation of two strains of rainbow trout divergent in their plasma cortisol response to confinement stress (HR: high responder or LR: low responder) would also differ in stress-induced effects on forebrain concentrations of mRNA for corticotropin-releasing factor (CRF), arginine vasotocin (AVT), CRF receptor type 1 (CRF-R1), CRF receptor type 2 (CRF-R2) and AVT receptor (AVT-R). In addition, plasma cortisol concentrations, brainstem levels of monoamines and monoamine metabolites, and behaviour during confinement were monitored. The results confirm that HR and LR trout differ in their cortisol response to confinement and show that fish of these strains also differ in their behavioural response to confinement. The HR trout displayed significantly higher locomotor activity while in confinement than LR trout. Moreover, following 180 min of confinement HR fish showed significantly higher forebrain concentrations of CRF mRNA than LR fish. Also, when subjected to 30 min of confinement HR fish showed significantly lower CRF-R2 mRNA concentrations than LR fish, whereas there were no differences in CRF-R1, AVT or AVT-R mRNA expression between LR and HR fish either at 30 or 180 min of confinement. Differences in the expression of CRF and CRF-R2 mRNA may be related to the divergence in stress coping displayed by these rainbow trout strains.     

Extinction of a conditioned response in rainbow trout selected for high or low responsiveness to stress

Two lines of rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) that exhibit divergent endocrine responsiveness to stressors also display disparate behavioral traits. To investigate whether the high-responding (HR) and low-responding (LR) fish also differ in cognitive function, the rate of extinction of a conditioned response was compared between the two lines. Groups of HR and LR fish were exposed to a paired conditioned stimulus (CS; water off) and unconditioned stimulus (US; confinement stressor). After exposure to 18 CS-US pairings, at least 70% of individuals of both lines acquired a conditioned response (CR) manifested as an elevation of blood cortisol levels on presentation of the CS only. Post-conditioning, the fish were tested by presentation of the CS at weekly intervals, for 4 weeks, with no further reinforcement, and the extinction of the CR in the two lines was compared. The decline in mean plasma cortisol levels after exposure to the CS over successive tests suggested that the CR was retained for a shorter period among the HR (<14 days) than LR fish (<21 days). The frequency of individuals within each line whose plasma cortisol levels indicated a stress response when exposed to the CS was significantly greater among the LR than HR fish at 14 and 21 days with no HR fish falling into this category at 21 days. At 28 days post-conditioning, there were no HR fish and only three LR fish were categorized as "stressed". These results suggest that there are differences in cognitive function between the two lines. Possible mechanisms underlying these differences are discussed.     

Linking physiological and cellular responses to thermal stress: β-adrenergic blockade reduces the heat shock response in fish

When faced with stress, animals use physiological and cellular strategies to preserve homeostasis. We were interested in how these high-level stress responses are integrated at the level of the whole animal. Here, we investigated the capacity of the physiological stress response, and specifically the β-adrenergic response, to affect the induction of the cellular heat shock proteins, HSPs, following a thermal stress in vivo. We predicted that blocking β-adrenergic stimulation during an acute heat stress in the whole animal would result in reduced levels of HSPs in red blood cells (RBCs) of rainbow trout compared to animals where adrenergic signaling remained intact. We first determined that a 1 h heat shock at 25 °C in trout acclimated to 13 °C resulted in RBC adrenergic stimulation as determined by a significant increase in cell swelling, a hallmark of the β-adrenergic response. A whole animal injection with the β₂-adrenergic antagonist, ICI-118,551, successfully reduced this heat-induced RBC swelling. The acute heat shock caused a significant induction of HSP70 in RBCs of 13 °C-acclimated trout as well as a significant increase in plasma catecholamines. When heat-shocked fish were treated with ICI-118,551, we observed a significant attenuation of the HSP70 response. We conclude that circulating catecholamines influence the cellular heat shock response in rainbow trout RBCs, demonstrating physiological/hormonal control of the cellular stress response.     

Stress responsiveness affects dominant-subordinate relationships in rainbow trout.

The magnitude by which plasma cortisol levels increase following exposure to a stressor is a heritable trait in rainbow trout. The relative growth in coculture of F1 lines selected for high responsiveness (HR) and low responsiveness (LR) to a confinement stressor suggested that behavioral characteristics related to food acquisition, aggression, or competitive ability might differ between the two lines. This hypothesis was tested using the F2 generation of the selected lines. The F2 lines clearly exhibited the characteristics of the F1 parents, displaying significantly divergent plasma cortisol responses to a 1-h confinement stressor and a high heritability for the trait. Behavioral differences between the lines were assessed by observing the outcome of staged fights for dominance in size-matched pairs of HR and LR fish. The identification of dominant and subordinate fish within each pair on the basis of their behavior was supported by the levels of blood cortisol in the fish attributed to each group (dominant < subordinate). Fish from the LR line were identified as dominant in significantly more trials than were HR individuals. The results suggest that behavioral attributes that affect the outcome of rank-order fights are closely linked to the magnitude of the plasma cortisol response to stress in rainbow trout. Whether the link is causal or circumstantial is not yet evident.     

Physiological and genetic correlates of boldness: characterising the mechanisms of behavioural variation in rainbow trout, Oncorhynchus mykiss

Bold, risk-taking animals have previously been putatively linked with a proactive stress coping style whereas it is suggested shyer, risk-averse animals exhibit a reactive coping style. The aim of this study was to investigate whether differences in the expression of bold-type behaviour were evident within and between two lines of rainbow trout, Oncorhynchus mykiss, selectively bred for a low (LR) or high (HR) endocrine response to stress, and to link boldness and stress responsiveness with the expression of related candidate genes. Boldness was determined in individual fish over two trials by measuring the latency to approach a novel object. Differences in plasma cortisol concentrations and the expression of eight novel candidate genes previously identified as being linked with divergent behaviours or stress were determined. Bold and shy individuals, approaching the object within 180 s or not approaching within 300 s respectively, were evident within each line, and this was linked with activity levels in the HR line. Post-stress plasma cortisol concentrations were significantly greater in the HR line compared with the LR line, and six of the eight tested genes were upregulated in the brains of LR fish compared with HR fish. However, no direct relationship between boldness and either stress responsiveness or gene expression was found, although clear differences in stress physiology and, for the first time, gene expression could be identified between the lines. This lack of correlation between physiological and molecular responses and behavioural variation within both lines highlights the complexity of the behavioural-physiological complex.     

Parental stress‐coping styles affect the behaviour of rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss at early developmental stages

This work examined behavioural responses in yolk‐sac rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss larvae originating from strains selected for high (HR) or low (LR) plasma cortisol response to a standardized stressor. The results showed that yolk‐sac larvae originating from the HR strain were more sensitive to environmental stressors, in that they showed a shorter reaction time to low oxygen levels. Previous studies on adult and juvenile individuals from these strains demonstrated a number of correlated physiological and behavioural differences. In yolk‐sac larvae, growth and development depended mainly on internal factors, which suggest that at least some aspects of stress‐coping styles are inherent to the individual, before factors such as social experience or variable access to food resources could modify behavioural strategy.     

ACTH does not mediate divergent stress responsiveness in rainbow trout.

Two lines of rainbow trout selected for high (HR) and low (LR) responsiveness to a standardised confinement stressor displayed a sustained divergence in plasma cortisol levels during a 3-h period of confinement (max.: HR: 167+/-13 ng ml(-1); LR: 103+/-8 ng ml(-1); P<0.001). However, no significant difference in plasma ACTH levels was evident (max: HR: 153+/-9 pg ml(-1); LR: 142+/-7 pg ml(-1)). Dexamethasone (DEX) was administered to HR and LR fish to block endogenous adrenocorticotropin (ACTH) release. Administration of a weight-adjusted dose of ACTH to the DEX-blocked fish elevated plasma cortisol levels to a significantly greater extent in HR (233+/-24 ng ml(-1)) than LR (122+/-14 ng ml(-1)) fish (P<0.001). Plasma cortisol levels in DEX-blocked HR and LR fish after sham injection were low but also significantly different (HR: 6.7+/-1 ng ml(-1); LR: 2.2+/-0.2 ng ml(-1); P<0.001). These results indicate that modulation of cortisol responsiveness to stressors in HR and LR fish resides, at least in part, downstream of the hypothalamic-pituitary axis.     

Agonistic encounters and cellular angst: social interactions induce heat shock proteins in juvenile salmonid fish

Juvenile salmonid fish readily form dominance hierarchies when faced with limited resources. While these social interactions may result in profound behavioural and physiological stress, it is unknown if this social stress is evident at the level of the cellular stress response—specifically, the induction of stress or heat shock proteins (Hsps). Thus, the goal of our study was to determine if Hsps are induced during hierarchy formation in juvenile rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). To this end, we measured levels of three Hsps, Hsp70, Hsc (heat shock cognate)70 and Hsp90 in the white muscle, liver and brain of trout that had been interacting for 36 h, 72 h or 6 days. Our data indicate that Hsps are induced in both dominant and subordinate fish in a time- and tissue-specific manner. In further mechanistic experiments on fasted and cortisol-treated fish, we demonstrated that high plasma cortisol does not affect Hsp induction in trout white muscle or liver, but both conditions may be part of the mechanism for Hsp induction with social stress in the brain. We conclude that the behavioural and physiological stress experienced by juvenile rainbow trout in dominance hierarchies can be extended to the induction of Hsps.     

Heat shock protein expression in fish

Heat shock proteins (HSP) are a family of proteins expressed in response to a wide range of biotic and abiotic stressors. They are thus also referred to as stress proteins. Their extraordinarily high degree of identity at the amino acid sequence level and the fact that this cellular stress response has been described in nearly all organisms studied, make this group of proteins unique. We provide a brief historical overview of HSP research, as a background to summarizing what is known about HSP expression in fish. The expression of HSPs in fish has been described in cell lines, primary cultures of various cells, and in the tissues of whole organisms. Collectively, the data show that the expression of HSPs are affected in a wide variety of fish cells and tissues, in response both to biological stressors such as infectious pathogens, as well as to abiotic stressors such as heat and cold shock, and environmental contaminants. HSP research in fish is in its early stages and many studies are describing the expression of proteins in response to various stressors. Several studies have contributed to our understanding of the molecular nature and the molecular biology of HSPs in fish. Recent studies have shown a relationship between HSP expression and the generalized stress response in fish, but further research is needed to clarify the complex relationships between stress hormones and the cellular HSP response. In general, the HSP response seems to be related to the sensing of the stressor and the subsequent cellular effects which may adapt the cells to cope with the stressors. Consequently, such data may be of central importance in understanding the significance of HSP expression to the whole organism. We conclude with sections on laboratory methods used in HSP research and on potential applications of this knowledge in biomonitoring.     

Food-deprivation induces HSP70 and HSP90 protein expression in larval gilthead sea bream and rainbow trout

Heat shock proteins (HSPs) expression is commonly used as indicators of cellular stress in animals. However, very little is known about either the expression patterns of HSPs or their role in the stress-tolerance phenomenon in early life stages of fish. To this end, we examined the impact of food-deprivation (12 h), reduced oxygen levels (3.5 mg/L for 1 h) and heat shock (HS: + 5 °C for 1 h) on HSP70 and HSP90 protein expression in early life stages of the gilthead sea bream (Sparus aurata), a warm-water aquaculture species. Also, we investigated HSP70 and HSP90 response to food-deprivation (7 days) in early life stages of rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss), a cool-water aquaculture species, and the tolerance of this larvae to heat shock (either + 5 or + 10 °C for 1 h). Our results clearly demonstrate that food-deprivation enhances HSP70 and HSP90 protein expression in larvae of both species. In gilthead sea bream larvae, the stressors-induced HSP70 and HSP90 (only in the reduced oxygen group) protein expression returned to unstressed levels after 24 h recovery. In fed trout larvae, a + 5 °C heat shock did not elevate HSP70 and HSP90 expression, whereas 100% mortality was evident with a + 10 °C HS. However, food-deprived trout larvae, which had higher HSP70 and HSP90 protein content, survived HS and showed HS-dependent increases in HSP70, but not HSP90 expression. Overall, HSP70 and HSP90 protein expression in early life stages of fish have the potential to be used as markers of nutritional stress, while elevation of the tissue HSPs content may be used as a means to increase stress tolerance during larval rearing.     

Analysis of stress-induced hepatic gene expression in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) selected for high- and low-responsiveness to stress

The production and welfare of intensively reared fish would be improved by reducing stress responsiveness. One approach to achieving this goal is selective breeding utilising stress-responsive genes as direct genetic markers of the desirable trait. As a first step in this process, microarray analysis has been carried out on liver tissues of rainbow trout selectively bred for high (HR) or low (LR) responsiveness to a stressor. Microarray hybridizations provided gene expression profiles for pooled samples of fish confined for 6 h, 24 h and 168 h and for individual fish (168 h only). 161 genes were shown to be differentially regulated in HR and LR fish during confinement exposure and eight of these gene expression profiles were validated by quantitative PCR. Genes of particular interest included intelectin-2 precursor which showed greater than 100-fold higher expression in HR fish compared to LR fish irrespective of whether the fish were confined or not; interferon inducible transmembrane protein 3 which was differentially stress-induced between the two lines; and hepatic pro-opiomelanocortin B (POMC B) which was upregulated during stress in HR fish but downregulated in LR fish. All these offer potential as direct markers of low stress responsiveness in a marker-assisted selection scheme.