Floral development of the model legume <Emphasis Type="Italic">Medicago truncatula</Emphasis>: ontogeny studies as a tool to better characterize homeotic mutations

This work provides new evidence of the complex genetic regulation necessary to accomplish flower development in legumes. Using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) analysis, we have characterized the early developmental events of the wild type Medicago truncatula flower and selected morphological characters as markers to break it down into eight different developmental stages. The order of floral organ initiation in M. truncatula and pea (Pisum sativum L.), in contrast to Arabidopsis and Antirrhinum, is unidirectional in all whorls starting from the abaxial position of the flower with a high degree of overlap. Another main difference is the existence of four common primordia from which petals and stamens differentiate. The formation of common primordia, as opposed to discrete petal and stamen primordia, has been described in many legume and non-legume plants. The main differences between pea and M. truncatula floral ontogeny are in carpel and fruit development. We also used these morphological markers as tools to characterize early alterations in the flower development of a male-sterile M. truncatula floral homeotic mutant named mtapetala. This mutant displays a phenotype resembling those of weak class B mutants with homeotic conversions of floral organ whorls 2 and 3 into sepaloid and carpelloid structures, respectively. Ontogeny studies of the mtapetala mutant flowers showed similarities with the effects of previously described loss-of-B-function mutations. Differences between ontogeny of wild type and mtapetala flowers could not be detected during the first stages (1-5) of flower development. In late stage 5, abnormal-shaped petals with acute lobes and trichomes as well as abnormal-shaped stamens were visible in whorls 2 and 3. At stage 6, the morphology of petals began to change, developing enlarged sepaloid structures bearing trichomes and first the antesepalous stamens and then the antepetalous stamens began to differentiate carpelloid anthers from filaments. Third whorl organs presented different degrees of carpelloidy. The present study should provide tools for the characterization and comparative analyses of new Medicago floral homeotic mutants and could be useful in elucidating how floral organ identity functions work in legumes.     

Gene trap lines define domains of gene regulation in Arabidopsis petals and stamens

To identify genes involved in Arabidopsis thaliana petal and stamen organogenesis, we used a gene trap approach to examine the patterns of reporter expression at each stage of flower development of 1765 gene trap lines. In 80 lines, the reporter gene showed petal- and/or stamen-specific expression or lack of expression, or expression in distinct patterns within the petals and/or the stamens, including distinct suborgan domains of expression, such as tissue-specific lines marking epidermis and vasculature, as well as lines demarcating the proximodistal or abaxial/adaxial axes of the organs. Interestingly, reporter gene expression was typically restricted along the proximodistal axis of petals and stamens, indicating the importance of this developmental axis in patterning of gene expression domains in these organs. We identified novel domains of gene expression along the axis marking the midregion of the petals and apical and basal parts of the anthers. Most of the genes tagged in these 80 lines were identified, and their possible functions in petal and/or stamen differentiation are discussed. We also scored the floral phenotypes of the 1765 gene trap lines and recovered two mutants affecting previously uncharacterized genes. In addition to revealing common domains of gene expression, the gene trap lines reported here provide both useful markers and valuable starting points for reverse genetic analyses of the differentiation pathways in petal and stamen development.     

Negative regulation of the Arabidopsis homeotic gene AGAMOUS by the APETALA2 product.

We characterized the distribution of AGAMOUS (AG) RNA during early flower development in Arabidopsis. Mutations in this homeotic gene cause the transformation of stamens to petals in floral whorl 3 and of carpels to another ag flower in floral whorl 4. We found that AG RNA is present in the stamen and carpel primordia but is undetectable in sepal and petal primordia throughout early wild-type flower development, consistent with the mutant phenotype. We also analyzed the distribution of AG RNA in apetela2 (ap2) mutant flowers. AP2 is a floral homeotic gene that is necessary for the normal development of sepals and petals in floral whorls 1 and 2. In ap2 mutant flowers, AG RNA is present in the organ primordia of all floral whorls. These observations show that the expression patterns of the Arabidopsis floral homeotic genes are in part established by regulatory interactions between these genes.     

The ASK1 gene regulates development and interacts with the UFO gene to control floral organ identity in Arabidopsis.

Normal flower development likely requires both specific and general regulators. We have isolated an Arabidopsis mutant ask1-1 (for -Arabidopsis skp1-like1-1), which exhibits defects in both vegetative and reproductive development. In the ask1-1mutant, rosette leaf growth is reduced, resulting in smaller than normal rosette leaves, and internodes in the floral stem are shorter than normal. Examination of cell sizes in these organs indicates that cell expansion is normal in the mutant, but cell number is reduced. In the mutant, the numbers of petals and stamens are reduced, and many flowers have one or more petals with a reduced size. In addition, all mutant flowers have short stamen filaments. Furthermore, petal/stamen chimeric organs are found in many flowers. These results indicate that the ASK1 gene affects the size of vegetative and floral organs. The ask1 floral phenotype resembles somewhat that of the Arabidopsis ufo mutants in that both genes affect whorls 2 and 3. We therefore tested for possible interactions between ASK1 and UFO by analyzing the phenotypes of ufo-2 ask1-1 double mutant plants. In these plants, vegetative development is similar to that of the ask1-1 single mutant, whereas the floral defects are more severe than those in either single mutant. Interior to the first whorl, the double mutant flowers have more sepals or sepal-like organs than are found in ufo-2, and less petals than ask1-1. Our results suggest that ASK1 interacts with UFO to control floral organ identity in whorls 2 and 3. This is very intriguing because ASK1 is very similar in sequence to the yeast SKP1 protein and UFO contains an F-box, a motif known to interact with SKP1 in yeast. Although the precise mechanism of ASK1 and UFO action is unknown, our results support the hypothesis that these two proteins physically interact in vivo.     

Stamenless, a tomato mutant with homeotic conversions in petals and stamens

A tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) monogenic semidominant mutation, stamenless (sl), which results in homeotic conversions in two adjacent floral whorls, was studied. When grown at standard temperature, flowers of sl/sl plants showed sepaloid petals in the second whorl and strong transformation of stamens to carpels in whorl three. These transformed carpels were fused with each other and with the genuine carpels in the fourth whorl to form a unique gynoecium. The mutation is semidominant since heterozygous plants showed a phenotype intermediate between that of the wild type (WT) and that of homozygous mutant plants, with nearly WT petals but with feminized stamens bearing naked ovules on the base of their adaxial face. The initiation and position of organ primordia in sl/sl flowers were not altered when compared with WT primordia although development of organ primordia in the second and third whorls deviated from WT at an early stage as observed by scanning electron microscopy. The mutant phenotype is temperature sensitive and when sl/sl plants were cultured at low temperature, the morphology of some flowers resembled that of the WT. This reversion of the mutant phenotype is also induced by treatment of young sl/sl plants with gibberellic acid, providing evidence that gibberellin synthesis or sensitivity could mediate the effect of low temperature on the mutant phenotype. Southern blot analyses using a Deficiens-homologous gene from Solanum tuberosum as a probe showed a restriction-fragment-length polymorphism (RFLP) linked to the sl mutation. This result indicates that the mutation affects a Deficiens-like gene that controls the identity of petals and stamens. Received: 10 December 1998 / Accepted: 29 March 1999     

Ectopic expression of SUPERMAN suppresses development of petals and stamens

The floral regulatory gene SUPERMAN (SUP) encodes a C2H2 type zinc finger protein that is required for maintaining boundaries between floral organs in Arabidopsis. It has been proposed that the main function of SUP is to balance cell proliferation in the third and fourth whorl of developing flowers, thereby maintaining the boundaries between the two whorls. To gain further insight into the function of SUP, we have ectopically expressed SUP using the promoter of APETALA1 (AP1), a gene that is initially expressed throughout floral meristems and later becomes restricted to the first and second whorls. Flowers of AP1::SUP plants have fewer floral organs, consistent with an effect of SUP on cell proliferation. In addition, the AP1::SUP transgene caused the conversion of petals to sepals and suppressed the development of stamens. The expression of the B function homeotic gene APETALA3 (AP3) and its regulator UNUSUAL FLORAL ORGANS (UFO) were delayed and reduced in AP1::SUP flowers. However, SUP does not act merely through UFO, as constitutive expression of UFO did not rescue the defects in petal and stamen development in AP1::SUP flowers. Together, these results suggest that SUP has both indirect and direct effects on the expression of B function homeotic genes.     

THE DEVELOPMENTAL BASIS OF TRISTYLY IN EICHHORNIA PANICULATA (PONTEDERIACEAE)

Eichhornia paniculata is a tristylous, self-compatible, emergent aquatic. A given plant produces flowers with either long, mid or short styles and two levels of stamens equal in length to the styles not found in that flower. Flowers of each morph have two whorls of three tepals, six stamens and three fused carpels. The six stamens differentiate into two sets of three stamens each. A relatively short set, having either short- or mid-level stamens, occurs on the upper side of the flower, while a relatively long set, having either mid- or long-level stamens, occurs on the lower side. Stamen level depends on differences among stamens in filament length and position of insertion on the floral tube. Floral parts arise in whorls of three, but the two stamen whorls do not form the two sets of stamens found in each mature flower. Instead, stamens from both whorls make up a given set. Floral differences among morphs are not present at flower origin or floral organ initiation. Morphological differences arise first among stamen sets. The two sets within a flower differ prior to meiosis in the size, number, and timing of comparable developmental events in the sporogenous cells. After these initial differences arise, anther size diverges. In later developmental stages differences in filament and floral tube length, cell size, and cell number, as well as differences in the length, cell size, and cell number of styles, develop among morphs. This sequence of developmental events suggests that the genes controlling development in different morphs do not control flower and floral organ initiation but are first morphologically visible in sporogenous cell differentiation.     

The corona of the daffodil Narcissus bulbocodium shares stamen‐like identity and is distinct from the orthodox floral whorls

The structural homology of the daffodil corona has remained a source of debate throughout the history of botany. Over the years it has been separately referred to as a modified petal stipule, stamen and tepal. Here we provide insights from anatomy and molecular studies to clarify the early developmental stages and position of corona initiation in Narcissus bulbocodium. We demonstrate that the corona initiates as six separate anlagen from hypanthial tissue between the stamens and perianth. Scanning electron microscope images and serial sections demonstrate that corona initiation occurs late in development, after the other floral whorls are fully developed. To define more precisely the identity of the floral structures, daffodil orthologues of the ABC floral organ identity genes were isolated and expression patterns were examined in perianth, stamens, carpel, hypanthial tube and corona tissue. Coupled with in situ hybridisation experiments, these analyses showed that the expression pattern of the C‐class gene NbAGAMOUS in the corona is more similar to that of the stamens than that of the tepals. In combination, our results demonstrate that the corona of the daffodil N. bulbocodium exhibits stamen‐like identity, develops independently from the orthodox floral whorls and is best interpreted as a late elaboration of the region between the petals and stamens associated with epigyny and the hypanthium.     

Flower development in the organ number mutant clavata1-1 of Arabidopsis thaliana (Brassicaceae)

Flowers of the organ number (meristic) mutant clavata1-1 of Arabidopsis thaliana (Brassicaceae) were studied to examine timing and patterns of floral organogenesis as compared to the wild type. All clavata1-1 flowers examined had four- instead of two-loculed gynoecia; half showed increased numbers of stamens; and 10% formed increased numbers of sepals. An inflorescence plastochron index was used to establish the timing of developmental events during flower organogenesis. clavata1-1 flowers initiate faster but grow more slowly than in the wild type. The stages of sepal and stamen initiation were prolonged compared to those of the wild type. Although gynoecial initiation was not prolonged, the preceding stage was and it was characterized by a proliferation of meristematic cells above the initiating stamens. The clavata1-1 flower apex did not become wider than that of the wild type until after the establishment of the gynoecium. We propose that clavata1-1 is a heterochronic mutant, where flower organ number increases are due partly to prolongation of organ initiation stages.     

NORMAL FLORAL ONTOGENY AND COOL TEMPERATURE-INDUCED ABERRANT FLORAL DEVELOPMENT IN GLYCINE MAX (FABACEAE)

Floral onset in soybean (Glycine max cv. Ransom) is characterized by precocious initiation of axillary meristems in the axils of the most recently initiated leaf primordium. During floral transition, leaf morphology changes from trifoliolate leaf with stipules, to a three-lobed bract, to an unlobed bract. Soybean flowers initiated at 26/22 C day/night temperatures are normal, papilionaceous, and pentamerous. Sepal, petal, and stamen whorls are initiated unidirectionally from the abaxial to adaxial side of the floral apex. The median sepal is located abaxially and the median petal adaxially on the meristem. The organogeny of ‘Ransom’ flowers was found to be: sepals, petals, outer stamens plus carpel, inner stamens; or, sepals, petals, carpel, outer stamens, inner stamens. The outer stamen whorl and the carpel show possible overlap in time of initiation. Equalization of organ size occurs only within the stamen whorls. The sepals retain distinction in size, and the petals exhibit an inverse size to age relationship. The keel petals postgenitally fuse along part of their abaxial margins; their bases, however, remain free. Soybean flowers initiated at cool day/night temperatures of 18/14 C exhibited abnormalities and intermediate organs in all whorls. The gynoecium consisted of one to ten carpels (usually three or four), and carpel connation varied. Fusion of keel petals was often lacking, and stamen filaments fused erratically. Multiple carpellate flowers developed into multiple pods that were separate or variously connate. Intermediate type organs had characteristics only of organs in adjacent whorls. These aberrant flowers demonstrate that the floral meristem of soybean is not fixed or limited in its developmental capabilities and that it has the potential to produce alternate morphological patterns.     

The expression and promoter specificity of the birch homologs for PISTILLATA/GLOBOSA and APETALA3/DEFICIENS

B-function genes determine the identity of petals and stamens in the flowers of model plants such as Arabidopsis and Antirrhinum . Here, we show that a putative B-function gene BpMADS2 , a birch homolog for PISTILLATA , is expressed in stamens and carpels of birch inflorescences. We also present a novel birch gene BpMADS8 , a homolog for APETALA3 / DEFICIENS , which is expressed in stamens. Promoter-GUS analysis revealed that BpMADS2 promoter is active in the receptacle of Arabidopsis flower buds while BpMADS8 promoter is highly specific in mature stamens. BpMADS2 promoter:: BARNASE construct prevented floral organ development in Arabidopsis and tobacco. In birch, inflorescences with degenerated stamens and carpels were obtained. BpMADS8::BARNASE resulted in degeneration of stamens in Arabidopsis and birch causing male sterility. In tobacco, only sepals were developed instead of normal flowers. The results show that the BpMADS2::BARNASE construct can be used to specifically disrupt floral organ development in phylogenetically distant plant species. The stamen-specific promoter of BpMADS8 is a promising tool for biotechnological applications in inducing male sterility or targeting gene expression in the late stamen development.     

Homeosis in floral development of Sanguinaria canadensis and S. canadensis ‘Multiplex’ (Papaveraceae)

Sanguinaria canadensis is a member of the Papaveraceae that normally has eight petals rather than four as is usual in the family. Using epi-illumination microscopy to study floral development, we show that the four additional petal primordia are initiated in positions that correspond to the first four stamen positions in species of the Papaveraceae with four petals. Also, these additional petal primordia share early developmental features with stamen primordia: at inception they are circular in outline, and the relationship between organ length and width while very young is similar. The developmental pathway of the additional petals combines both stamen and petal features: initially stamenlike in appearance, they develop into typical petals. The additional petals of S. canadensis can therefore be interpreted as homeotic because petal features are expressed in stamen positions. Organogenesis in the ‘Multiplex’ cultivar is similar to that of its wild progenitor, but during development all primordia in the androecial region become petals. This cultivar, as well as variants within natural populations, show that replacement of stamens with petals occurs within the species.     

Conversion of leaves into petals in Arabidopsis

More than 200 years ago, Goethe proposed that each of the distinct flower organs represents a modified leaf [1]. Support for this hypothesis has come from genetic studies, which have identified genes required for flower organ identity. These genes have been incorporated into the widely accepted ABC model of flower organ identity, a model that appears generally applicable to distantly related eudicots as well as monocot plants. Strikingly, triple mutants lacking the ABC activities produce leaves in place of flower organs, and this finding demonstrates that these genes are required for floral organ identity [2]. However, the ABC genes are not sufficient for floral organ identity since ectopic expression of these genes failed to convert vegetative leaves into flower organs. This finding suggests that one or more additional factors are required [3, 4]. We have recently shown that SEPALLATA (SEP) represents a new class of floral organ identity genes since the loss of SEP activity results in all flower organs developing as sepals [5]. Here we show that the combined action of the SEP genes, together with the A and B genes, is sufficient to convert leaves into petals.     

臭椿花器官分化的初步研究

利用扫描电镜(SEM)和光镜(LM)对臭椿花序及花器官的分化和发育进行了初步研究,表明:1)臭椿花器官分化于当年的4月初,为圆锥花序;2)分化顺序为花萼原基、花冠原基、雄蕊原基和雌蕊原基。5个萼片原基的发生不同步,并且呈螺旋状发生;5个花瓣原基几乎同步发生且其生长要比雄蕊原基缓慢;雄蕊10枚,两轮排列,每轮5个原基的分化基本是同步的;雌蕊5,其分化速度较快;3)在两性花植株中,5个心皮顶端粘合形成柱头和花柱,而在雄株中,5个心皮退化,只有雄蕊原基分化出花药和花丝。本研究着重观察了臭椿中雄花及两性花发育的过程中两性花向单性花的转变。结果表明,臭椿两性花及单性花的形成在花器官的各原基上是一致的(尽管时间上有差异),雌雄蕊原基同时出现在每一个花器官分化过程中,但是,可育性结构部分的形成取决于其原基是否分化成所应有的结构:雄蕊原基分化形成花药与花丝,雌蕊原基分化形成花柱、柱头和子房。臭椿单性花的形成是由于两性花中雌蕊原基的退化所造成,其机理有待于进一步研究。     

FLORAL DEVELOPMENT OF HYDROCHARIS MORSUS-RANAE (HYDROCHARITACEAE)

In both male and female flowers of H. morsus-ranae the primordia of the floral appendages appear in an acropetal succession consisting of alternating trimerous whorls. In the male flower a whorl of sepals is followed by a whorl of petals, three whorls of stamens, and a whorl of filamentous staminodes. The mature androecial arrangement therefore consists of two antisepalous stamen whorls, an antipetalous whorl of stamens, and antipetalous staminodes. Shortly before anthesis, basal meristematic upgrowth between filaments of adjacent whorls produces paired stamens, joining Whorls 1 and 3, and Whorl 2 with the staminodial whorl. A central domelike structure develops between the closely appressed filaments of the inner stamen and staminodial whorl, giving the structure a lobed appearance. After petal inception in the female flower a whorl of antisepalous staminodes develop, each of which may bifurcate to form a pair of staminodes. During staminode development a girdling primordium arises by upgrowth at the periphery of the floral apex. The girdling primordium rapidly forms six gynoecial primordia, which then go on to produce six free styles with bifid stigmas. Intercalary meristem activity, below the point of floral appendage attachment, leads to the production of a syncarpous inferior ovary with six parietal placentae. The styles and carpels remain open along their ventral sutures. During the final stages of female floral development, several hundred ovules develop along the carpel walls, and three nectaries develop dorsally and basally on the three antipetalous styles.     

单瓣与重瓣垂丝海棠花器官形态发育比较观察

为探究垂丝海棠重瓣花成花原因,该研究以单瓣垂丝海棠和重瓣垂丝海棠为实验材料,应用体式显微镜和扫描电镜观察垂丝海棠单瓣、重瓣品种花器官分化过程;解剖观察重瓣垂丝海棠大蕾期的花与盛开的花,统计其花器官的形态与数目;应用R语言对重瓣垂丝海棠的花瓣数目与其余各轮花器官数目进行相关性分析。结果显示：(1)单瓣和重瓣垂丝海棠的花器官分化均分为萼片原基分化期、花瓣原基分化期、雄蕊原基分化期、雌蕊原基分化期,且各轮花器官按照向心顺序依次分化发育。(2)在花瓣原基分化期,单瓣垂丝海棠仅分化出一轮(5枚)均匀分布于两枚萼片交汇处的花瓣原基,而重瓣垂丝海棠分化出两轮分布散列的花瓣原基,第一轮为5~7枚,第二轮为7~10枚。(3)在重瓣垂丝海棠各轮花器官中存在较多萼片瓣化、雄蕊瓣化、雌雄蕊异常发育的情况。(4)重瓣垂丝海棠各轮花器官数目间相关性分析结果显示,其花瓣数目与雄蕊数目以及瓣化中的雄蕊数目间存在明显的正相关关系,该现象与常规雄蕊瓣化植物表现的雄蕊数目减少、花瓣数目增多的现象不同。研究表明,重瓣垂丝海棠花瓣数目的增多并不完全依赖于雄蕊变瓣,暗示垂丝海棠重瓣花成花原因的多元性与复杂性。     

Multiple AGAMOUS homologs from cucumber and petunia differ in their ability to induce reproductive organ fate.

The C function in Arabidopsis, which specifies stamen and carpel identity, is represented by a single gene called AGAMOUS (AG). From both petunia and cucumber, two MADS box genes have been isolated. Both share a high degree of amino acid sequence identity with the Arabidopsis AG protein. Their roles in specifying stamen and carpel identity have been studied by ectopic expression in petunia, resulting in plants with different floral phenotypes. Cucumber MADS box gene 1 (CUM1) induced severe homeotic transformations of sepals into carpelloid structures and petals into stamens, which is similar to ectopic AG expression in Arabidopsis plants. Overexpression of the other cucumber AG homolog, CUM10, resulted in plants with partial transformations of the petals into antheroid structures, indicating that CUM10 is also able to promote floral organ identity. From the two petunia AG homologs pMADS3 and Floral Binding Protein gene 6 (FBP6), only pMADS3 was able to induce homeotic transformations of sepals and petals. Ectopic expression of both pMADS3 and FBP6, as occurrs in the petunia homeotic mutant blind, phenocopies the pMADS3 single overexpresser plants, indicating that there is no additive effect of concerted expression. This study demonstrates that in petunia and cucumber, multiple AG homologs exist, although they differ in their ability to induce reproductive organ fate.