Identification of collagen fibril fusion during vertebrate tendon morphogenesis. The process relies on unipolar fibrils and is regulated by collagen-proteoglycan interaction

The synthesis of an extracellular matrix containing long (approximately mm in length) collagen fibrils is fundamental to the normal morphogenesis of animal tissues. In this study we have direct evidence that fibroblasts synthesise transient early fibril intermediates (approximately 1 micrometer in length) that interact by tip-to-tip fusion to generate long fibrils seen in older tissues. Examination of early collagen fibrils from tendon showed that two types of early fibrils occur: unipolar fibrils (with carboxyl (C) and amino (N) ends) and bipolar fibrils (with two N-ends). End-to-end fusion requires the C-end of a unipolar fibril. Proteoglycans coated the shafts of the fibrils but not the tips. In the absence of proteoglycans the fibrils aggregated by side-to-side interactions. Therefore, proteoglycans promote tip-to-tip fusion and inhibit side-to-side fusion. This distribution of proteoglycan along the fibril required co-assembly of collagen and proteoglycan prior to fibril assembly. The study showed that collagen fibrillogenesis is a hierarchical process that depends on the unique structure of unipolar fibrils and a novel function of proteoglycans.     

The precision of lateral size control in the assembly of corneal collagen fibrils

Collagen fibrils in the corneal stroma have been recognised to have a high degree of uniformity of diameter and spatial arrangement compared with those in other mature connective tissues. The precision of this lateral size control has been determined in this study by mass per unit length measurements on fibrils isolated from adult bovine corneal stroma. At the molecular level, however, there are substantial variations in lateral size, both between fibrils and along individual fibrils. The mean mass per unit length was measured to be 304 kDa nm(-1), equivalent to 347 collagen molecules in transverse section and had a standard deviation of 8.3%. The variation of lateral size along individual fibrils was measured as a mass slope over approximately 7 microm lengths (100 D-periods) and had a mean mass slope equivalent to 0.56 molecules per D-period. Smoothly tapered tips of length approximately 7 microm were also observed with a mass slope of about approximately three molecules per D-period. The frequency of these tips was used to estimate a mean fibril length of approximately 940 microm in the sample tissue. Observations of molecular polarity within the fibril shafts and tips were used to consider possible models of fibril assembly.     

Control of collagen fibril diameters in tissues.

It is proposed that radial growth of collagen fibrils, which takes place in all connective tissues to varying extents, according to the tensile stresses exerted on them, proceeds mainly by aggregation of protofibrils (approximately 10 nm) and existing fibrils. In young tissues, fibrils are prevented from making frequent intimate contacts which would lead to aggregation by abundant interfibrillar proteoglycan, that keeps the fibrils apart. Collagen fibrils are probably unable to fuse except when the molecules within them are packed in the same sense, i.e. fusing fibrils are parallel. The roughly equal numbers of parallel and antiparallel fibrils seen in several tissues must limit radial fibril growth in older tissues, where proteoglycan is usually less abundant. Possible origins of the balance of fibril polarities, which must be conserved after fibril nucleation on cell or non-cell templates, are analysed. The two controlling factors, ambient proteoglycan and fibril polarity, working against the tendency of fibrils to fuse, account for many features of the observed distributions of collagen fibril diameters in diverse tissues and at different ages.     

Influence of fibril taper on the function of collagen to reinforce extracellular matrix

Collagen fibrils provide tensile reinforcement for extracellular matrix. In at least some tissues, the fibrils have a paraboloidal taper at their ends. The purpose of this paper is to determine the implications of this taper for the function of collagen fibrils. When a tissue is subjected to low mechanical forces, stress will be transferred to the fibrils elastically. This process was modelled using finite element analysis because there is no analytical theory for elastic stress transfer to a non-cylindrical fibril. When the tissue is subjected to higher mechanical forces, stress will be transferred plastically. This process was modelled analytically. For both elastic and plastic stress transfer, a paraboloidal taper leads to a more uniform distribution of axial tensile stress along the fibril than would be generated if it were cylindrical. The tapered fibril requires half the volume of collagen than a cylindrical fibril of the same length and the stress is shared more evenly along its length. It is also less likely to fracture than a cylindrical fibril of the same length in a tissue subjected to the same mechanical force.     

Different architectures of the collagen fibril: morphological aspects and functional implications

Several tissues known to contain collagen fibrils with a ‘helical’ arrangement were studied by t.e.m. and freeze-fracture. In all the tissues examined, the diameter of the collagen fibrils appeared to be tissue-specific and fairly constant within the same tissue. No statistical differences, on the contrary, were detectable in the coiling angle which appeared similar in all the tissues and independent of both diameter and age of the fibril. Rat tail tendon was also examined under the same technical conditions and showed collagen fibrils of large and very heterogeneous diameter and with a consistent ‘straight’ arrangement. These data seem to suggest that the ‘helical’ and ‘straight’ arrangements may actually identify different types of collagen fibrils. The authors discuss the possible functional significance of these arrangements and present two hypotheses on the three-dimensional structure of the ‘helical’ fibril.     

Collagen fibril morphology and organization: implications for force transmission in ligament and tendon.

Connective tissue mechanical behavior is primarily determined by the composition and organization of collagen. In ligaments and tendons, type I collagen is the principal structural element of the extracellular matrix, which acts to transmit force between bones or bone and muscle, respectively. Therefore, characterization of collagen fibril morphology and organization in fetal and skeletally mature animals is essential to understanding how tissues develop and obtain their mechanical attributes. In this study, tendons and ligaments from fetal rat, bovine, and feline, and mature rat were examined with scanning electron microscopy. At early fetal developmental stages, collagen fibrils show fibril overlap and interweaving, apparent fibril ends, and numerous bifurcating/fusing fibrils. Late in fetal development, collagen fibril ends are still present and fibril bundles (fibers) are clearly visible. Examination of collagen fibrils from skeletally mature tissues, reveals highly organized regions but still include fibril interweaving, and regions that are more randomly organized. Fibril bifurcations/fusions are still present in mature tissues but are less numerous than in fetal tissue. To address the continuity of fibrils in mature tissues, fibrils were examined in individual micrographs and consecutive overlaid micrographs. Extensive microscopic analysis of mature tendons and ligaments detected no fibril ends. These data strongly suggest that fibrils in mature ligament and tendon are either continuous or functionally continuous. Based upon this information and published data, we conclude that force within these tissues is directly transferred through collagen fibrils and not through an interfibrillar coupling, such as a proteoglycan bridge.     

A computational remodeling approach to predict the physiological architecture of the collagen fibril network in corneo-scleral shells

Organized collagen fibrils form complex networks that introduce strong anisotropic and highly nonlinear attributes into the constitutive response of human eye tissues. Physiological adaptation of the collagen network and the mechanical condition within biological tissues are complex and mutually dependent phenomena. In this contribution, a computational model is presented to investigate the interaction between the collagen fibril architecture and mechanical loading conditions in the corneo-scleral shell. The biomechanical properties of eye tissues are derived from the single crimped fibril at the micro-scale via the collagen network of distributed fibrils at the meso-scale to the incompressible and anisotropic soft tissue at the macro-scale. Biomechanically induced remodeling of the collagen network is captured on the meso-scale by allowing for a continuous re-orientation of preferred fibril orientations and a continuous adaptation of the fibril dispersion. The presented approach is applied to a numerical human eye model considering the cornea and sclera. The predicted fibril morphology correlates well with experimental observations from X-ray scattering data.     

Echinoderm collagen fibrils grow by surface-nucleation-and-propagation from both centers and ends

Collagen fibrils from sea cucumber (class Holothuroidea) dermis were previously found to grow by coordinated monomer addition at both centers and ends. This analysis of sea urchin (class Echinoidea) collagen fibrils was undertaken to compare the growth characteristics of fibrils from two classes of echinoderms, and to determine whether a single growth model could account for the main features of fibrils from these two taxa. Native collagen fibrils (37-431 micrometer long) from the spine ligaments of the sea urchin Eucidaris tribuloides were studied by scanning transmission electron microscopy and image analysis. The analyses revealed the mass per unit length, and hence the number of molecules in cross-section, along the entire length of each fibril. The fibrils were symmetrically spindle shaped. The maximum mass per unit length occurred in the center of each fibril, where the fibril contains anti-parallel molecules in equal numbers. The two pointed tips of each fibril showed similar linear axial mass distributions, indicating that the two tips retain shape and size similarity throughout growth. The linear axial mass distributions showed that the tips were paraboloidal, similar to those of vertebrate and sea cucumber fibrils. The computed maximum diameters of the fibrils increased linearly with fibril length. The overall shapes of the fibrils showed that they retain geometric similarity throughout growth. Computer modeling showed that the simplest self-assembly mechanism that can account for the features of these fibrils, and of the sea cucumber fibrils that have been described, is one in which the fibril tips produce independent axial growth, while lateral growth takes place through a surface nucleation and propagation mechanism. This mechanism produces coordinated growth in length and diameter as well as geometric similarity, characteristic features of echinoderm collagen fibrils.     

Extracellular compartments in tendon morphogenesis: collagen fibril, bundle, and macroaggregate formation

The formation of collagen fibrils, fibril bundles, and tissue-specific collagen macroaggregates by chick embryo tendon fibroblasts was studied using conventional and high voltage electron microscopy. During chick tendon morphogenesis, there are at least three extracellular compartments responsible for three levels of matrix organization: collagen fibrils, bundles, and collagen macroaggregates. Our observations indicate that the initial extracellular events in collagen fibrillogenesis occur within narrow cytoplasmic recesses, presumably under close cellular regulation. Collagen fibrils are formed within these deep, narrow recesses, which are continuous with the extracellular space. Where these narrow recesses fuse with the cell surface, it becomes highly convoluted with folds and processes that envelope forming fibril bundles. The bundles laterally associate and coalesce, forming aggregates within a third cell-defined extracellular compartment. Our interpretation is that this third compartment forms as cell processes retract and cytoplasm is withdrawn between bundles. These studies define a hierarchical organization within the tendon, extending from fibril assembly to fascicle formation. Correlation of different levels of extracellular compartmentalization with tissue architecture provides insight into the cellular controls involved in collagen fibril and higher order assembly and a better understanding of how collagen fibrils are collected into structural groups, positioned, and woven into functional tissue-specific collagen macroaggregates.     

Type V collagen controls the initiation of collagen fibril assembly

Vertebrate collagen fibrils are heterotypically composed of a quantitatively major and minor fibril collagen. In non-cartilaginous tissues, type I collagen accounts for the majority of the collagen mass, and collagen type V, the functions of which are poorly understood, is a minor component. Type V collagen has been implicated in the regulation of fibril diameter, and we reported recently preliminary evidence that type V collagen is required for collagen fibril nucleation (Wenstrup, R. J., Florer, J. B., Cole, W. G., Willing, M. C., and Birk, D. E. (2004) J. Cell. Biochem. 92, 113-124). The purpose of this study was to define the roles of type V collagen in the regulation of collagen fibrillogenesis and matrix assembly. Mouse embryos completely deficient in pro-alpha1(V) chains were created by homologous recombination. The col5a1-/- animals die in early embryogenesis, at approximately embryonic day 10. The type V collagen-deficient mice demonstrate a virtual lack of collagen fibril formation. In contrast, the col5a1+/- animals are viable. The reduced type V collagen content is associated with a 50% reduction in fibril number and dermal collagen content. In addition, relatively normal, cylindrical fibrils are assembled with a second population of large, structurally abnormal collagen fibrils. The structural properties of the abnormal matrix are decreased relative to the wild type control animals. These data indicate a central role for the evolutionary, ancient type V collagen in the regulation of fibrillogenesis. The complete dependence of fibril formation on type V collagen is indicative of the critical role of the latter in early fibril initiation. In addition, this fibril collagen is important in the determination of fibril structure and matrix organization.     

Type III collagen can be present on banded collagen fibrils regardless of fibril diameter

Monoclonal antibodies that recognize an epitope within the triple helix of type III collagen have been used to examine the distribution of that collagen type in human skin, cornea, amnion, aorta, and tendon. Ultrastructural examination of those tissues indicates antibody binding to collagen fibrils in skin, amnion, aorta, and tendon regardless of the diameter of the fibril. The antibody distribution is unchanged with donor age, site of biopsy, or region of tissue examined. In contrast, antibody applied to adult human cornea localizes to isolated fibrils, which appear randomly throughout the matrix. These studies indicate that type III collagen remains associated with collagen fibrils after removal of the amino and carboxyl propeptides, and suggests that fibrils of skin, tendon, and amnion (and presumably many other tissues that contain both types I and III collagens) are copolymers of at least types I and III collagens.     

Relationship between collagen fibril diameters and body size

Summary Suspensions of collagen fibrils obtained from derma of Elasmobranchia and Actinopterygia of different body sizes and developmental stages were examined by transmission electron microscopy. Fibril diameters were measured and classified into groups comprising a 20 nm diameter interval. Diagrams showing fibril populations of each fish were made. The measurements were averaged and their confidence intervals and standard errors determined. For each species other diagrams were plotted in which the mean diameters were correlated to the body length of each sample. The results show that: 1) a correlation exists between an increase in diameter of collagen fibrils and somatic growth until sexual maturity is reached; 2) fibril populations are subsequently spread over a wider range due to the presence in the derma of classes of newly formed and therefore thinner fibrils. The deposition of new fibrils is possibly influenced by individual factors; 3) no relationship exists between mean fibril diameter and body size; 4) no relationship exists between phylogenetic position and pattern of diameter distribution.Research supported by a grant from C.N.R. Roma (69.02087.0115.1150)     

Assembly of type I collagen: fusion of fibril subunits and the influence of fibril diameter on mechanical properties.

Structural stability of the extracellular matrix is primarily a consequence of fibrillar collagen and the extent of cross-linking. The relationship between collagen self-assembly, consequent fibrillar shape and mechanical properties remains unclear. Our laboratory developed a model system for the preparation of self-assembled type I collagen fibers with fibrillar substructure mimicking the hierarchical structures of tendon. The present study evaluates the effects of pH and temperature during self-assembly on fibrillar structure, and relates the structural effects of these treatments on the uniaxial tensile mechanical properties of self-assembled collagen fibers. Results of the analysis of fibril diameter distributions and mechanical properties of the fibers formed under the different incubation conditions indicate that fibril diameters grow via the lateral fusion of discrete approximately 4 nm subunits, and that fibril diameter correlates positively with the low strain modulus. Fibril diameter did not correlate with either the ultimate tensile strength or the high strain elastic modulus, which suggests that lateral aggregation and consequently fibril diameter influences mechanical properties during small strain mechanical deformation. We hypothesize that self-assembly is mediated by the formation of fibrillar subunits that laterally and linearly fuse resulting in fibrillar growth. Lateral fusion appears important in generating resistance to deformation at low strain, while linear fusion leading to longer fibrils appears important in the ultimate mechanical properties at high strain.     

Modeling the effect of collagen fibril alignment on ligament mechanical behavior

Ligament mechanical behavior is primarily regulated by fibrous networks of type I collagen. Although these fibrous networks are typically highly aligned, healthy and injured ligament can also exhibit disorganized collagen architecture. The objective of this study was to determine whether variations in the collagen fibril network between neighboring ligaments can predict observed differences in mechanical behavior. Ligament specimens from two regions of bovine fetlock joints, which either exhibited highly aligned or disorganized collagen fibril networks, were mechanically tested in uniaxial tension. Confocal microscopy and FiberFit software were used to quantify the collagen fibril dispersion and mean fibril orientation in the mechanically tested specimens. These two structural parameters served as inputs into an established hyperelastic constitutive model that accounts for a continuous distribution of planar fibril orientations. The ability of the model to predict differences in the mechanical behavior between neighboring ligaments was tested by (1) curve fitting the model parameters to the stress response of the ligament with highly aligned fibrils and then (2) using this model to predict the stress response of the ligament with disorganized fibrils by only changing the parameter values for fibril dispersion and mean fibril orientation. This study found that when using parameter values for fibril dispersion and mean fibril orientation based on confocal imaging data, the model strongly predicted the average stress response of ligaments with disorganized fibrils (\(R^{2}=0.97\)); however, the model only successfully predicted the individual stress response of ligaments with disorganized fibrils in half the specimens tested. Model predictions became worse when parameters for fibril dispersion and mean fibril orientation were not based on confocal imaging data. These findings emphasize the importance of collagen fibril alignment in ligament mechanics and help advance a mechanistic understanding of fibrillar networks in healthy and injured ligament.     

Collagen fibril structure is affected by collagen concentration and decorin

Collagen fibrils were obtained in vitro by aggregation from acid-soluble type I collagen at different initial concentrations and with the addition of decorin core or intact decorin. All specimens were observed by scanning electron microscopy and atomic force microscopy. In line with the findings of other authors, lacking decorin, collagen fibrils undergo an extensive lateral association leading to the formation of a continuous three-dimensional network. The addition of intact decorin or decorin core was equally effective in preventing lateral fusion and restoring the normal fibril appearance. In addition, the fibril diameter was clearly dependent on the initial collagen concentration but not on the presence/absence of proteoglycans. An unusual fibril structure was observed as a result of a very low initial collagen concentration, leading to the formation of huge, irregular superfibrils apparently formed by the lateral coalescence of lesser fibrils, and with a distinctive coil-structured surface. Spots of incomplete fibrillogenesis were occasionally found, where all fibrils appeared made of individual, interwined subfibrils, confirming the presence of a hierarchical association mechanism.     

Murine model of the Ehlers-Danlos syndrome. col5a1 haploinsufficiency disrupts collagen fibril assembly at multiple stages

The most commonly identified mutations causing Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (EDS) classic type result in haploinsufficiency of proalpha1(V) chains of type V collagen, a quantitatively minor collagen that co-assembles with type I collagen as heterotypic fibrils. To determine the role(s) of type I/V collagen interactions in fibrillogenesis and elucidate the mechanism whereby half-reduction of type V collagen causes abnormal connective tissue biogenesis observed in EDS, we analyzed mice heterozygous for a targeted inactivating mutation in col5a1 that caused 50% reduction in col5a1 mRNA and collagen V. Comparable with EDS patients, they had decreased aortic stiffness and tensile strength and hyperextensible skin with decreased tensile strength of both normal and wounded skin. In dermis, 50% fewer fibrils were assembled with two subpopulations: relatively normal fibrils with periodic immunoreactivity for collagen V where type I/V interactions regulate nucleation of fibril assembly and abnormal fibrils, lacking collagen V, generated by unregulated sequestration of type I collagen. The presence of the aberrant fibril subpopulation disrupts the normal linear and lateral growth mediated by fibril fusion. Therefore, abnormal fibril nucleation and dysfunctional fibril growth with potential disruption of cell-directed fibril organization leads to the connective tissue dysfunction associated with EDS.     

Reduction of type V collagen using a dominant-negative strategy alters the regulation of fibrillogenesis and results in the loss of corneal- specific fibril morphology

A number of factors have been implicated in the regulation of tissue- specific collagen fibril diameter. Previous data suggest that assembly of heterotypic fibrils composed of two different fibrillar collagens represents a general mechanism regulating fibril diameter. Specifically, we hypothesize that type V collagen is required for the assembly of the small diameter fibrils observed in the cornea. To test this, we used a dominant-negative retroviral strategy to decrease the levels of type V collagen secreted by chicken corneal fibroblasts. The chicken alpha 1(V) collagen gene was cloned, and retroviral vectors that expressed a polycistronic mRNA encoding a truncated alpha 1(V) minigene and the reporter gene LacZ were constructed. The efficiency of viral infection was 30-40%, as determined by assaying beta- galactosidase activity. To assess the expression from the recombinant provirus, Northern analysis was performed and indicated that infected fibroblasts expressed high steady-state levels of retroviral mRNA. Infected cells synthesized the truncated alpha 1(V) protein, and this was detectable only intracellularly, in a distribution that colocalized with lysosomes. To assess endogenous alpha 1(V) protein levels, infected cell cultures were assayed, and these consistently demonstrated reductions relative to control virus-infected or uninfected cultures. Analyses of corneal fibril morphology demonstrated that the reduction in type V collagen resulted in the assembly of large- diameter fibrils with a broad size distribution, characteristics similar to fibrils produced in connective tissues with low type V concentrations. Immunoelectron microscopy demonstrated the amino- terminal domain of type V collagen was associated with the small- diameter fibrils, but not the large fibrils. These data indicate that type V collagen levels regulate corneal fibril diameter and that the reduction of type V collagen is sufficient to alter fibril assembly so that abnormally large-diameter fibrils are deposited into the matrix.     

Control of heterotypic fibril formation by collagen V is determined by chain stoichiometry.

Although the collagen V heterotrimer is known to be involved in the control of fibril assembly, the role of the homotrimer in fibrillar organization has not yet been examined. Here, the production of substantial amounts of recombinant collagen V homotrimer has allowed a detailed study of its role in homotypic and heterotypic fibril formation. After removal of terminal regions by pepsin digestion, both the collagen V heterotrimer and homotrimer formed thin homotypic fibrils, thus showing that diameter limitation is at least in part an intrinsic property of the collagen V triple helix. When mixed with collagen I, however, various complementary approaches indicated that the collagen V heterotrimer and homotrimer exerted different effects in heterotypic fibril formation. Unlike the heterotrimer, which was buried in the fibril interior, the homotrimer was localized as thin filamentous structures at the surface of wide collagen I fibrils and did not regulate fibril assembly. Its localization at the fibril surface suggests that the homotrimer can act as a molecular linker between collagen fibrils or macromolecules in the extracellular matrix or both. Thus, depending on their respective distribution in tissues, the different collagen V isoforms might fulfill specific biological functions.     

Bone stiffness explained by the liquid crystal model for the collagen fibril

A liquid crystal model for the structure of the collagen fibril explains how calcium phosphate crystals are capable of stiffening collagen fibrils in bone. Collagen fibrils consist of an oriented array of parallel rod-shaped collagen molecules. According to the liquid crystal model fibrils respond to tensile stress, applied in the axial direction, by some of the molecules tilting and changing their side-to-side arrangement. In bone the presence of crystals packed between the collagen molecules hinders the side-to-side rearrangement so that the response of the fibrils to stress is inhibited. Therefore the fibrils are stiffer in bone than in uncalcified tissue.     

Effect of age on collagen fibril diameter in rabbit patellar tendon repair

The effect of aging on soft tissue repair is poorly understood. We examined collagen fibril diameter in repairing patellar tendons from young adult and aging rabbits. We hypothesized that repairing tendons from older (geriatric) rabbits would have similar diameter fibrils compared with the younger (young adult) rabbits. Full-length, full-thickness, central-third (2.5 to 3 mm) patellar tendon injuries were made by cutting out the center of the tendon in twelve 1-y-old and thirteen 4- to 5.5 (average, 4.25)-y-old female New Zealand White rabbits. The contralateral tendon served as an unoperated control. The rabbits were euthanized at 6, 12, and 26 wk after surgery. The collagen fibril diameter was examined by electron microscopy at the patellar end, middle, and tibial end of the patellar tendon. There was no significant decline in collagen fibril diameter at any location in the aging rabbit healing patellar tendons compared with those of the 1-y-old rabbits. This study found that collagen fibril diameter was not altered with increasing age in the healing rabbit patellar tendon.