Time-resolved Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy of the nucleotide-binding domain from the ATP-binding Cassette transporter MsbA: ATP hydrolysis is the rate-limiting step in the catalytic cycle

MsbA is an essential Escherichia coli ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporter involved in the flipping of lipid A across the cytoplasmic membrane. It is a close homologue of human P-glycoprotein involved in multidrug resistance, and it similarly accepts a variety of small hydrophobic xenobiotics as transport substrates. X-ray structures of three full-length ABC multidrug exporters (including MsbA) have been published recently and reveal large conformational changes during the transport cycle. However, how ATP hydrolysis couples to these conformational changes and finally the transport is still an open question. We employed time-resolved FTIR spectroscopy, a powerful method to elucidate molecular reaction mechanisms of soluble and membrane proteins, to address this question with high spatiotemporal resolution. Here, we monitored the hydrolysis reaction in the nucleotide-binding domain of MsbA at the atomic level. The isolated MsbA nucleotide-binding domain hydrolyzed ATP with V(max) = 45 nmol mg(-1) min(-1), similar to the full-length transporter. A Hill coefficient of 1.49 demonstrates positive cooperativity between the two catalytic sites formed upon dimerization. Global fit analysis of time-resolved FTIR data revealed two apparent rate constants of ~1 and 0.01 s(-1), which were assigned to formation of the catalytic site and hydrolysis, respectively. Using isotopically labeled ATP, we identified specific marker bands for protein-bound ATP (1245 cm(-1)), ADP (1101 and 1205 cm(-1)), and free phosphate (1078 cm(-1)). Cleavage of the β-phosphate-γ-phosphate bond was found to be the rate-limiting step; no protein-bound phosphate intermediate was resolved.     

Molecular Disruption of the Power Stroke in the ATP-binding Cassette Transport Protein MsbA

ATP-binding cassette transporters affect drug pharmacokinetics and are associated with inherited human diseases and impaired chemotherapeutic treatment of cancers and microbial infections. Current alternating access models for ATP-binding cassette exporter activity suggest that ATP binding at the two cytosolic nucleotide-binding domains provides a power stroke for the conformational switch of the two membrane domains from the inward-facing conformation to the outward-facing conformation. In outward-facing crystal structures of the bacterial homodimeric ATP-binding cassette transporters MsbA from Gram-negative bacteria and Sav1866 from Staphylococcus aureus, two transmembrane helices (3 and 4) in the membrane domains have their cytoplasmic extensions in close proximity, forming a tetrahelix bundle interface. In biochemical experiments on MsbA from Escherichia coli, we show for the first time that a robust network of inter-monomer interactions in the tetrahelix bundle is crucial for the transmission of nucleotide-dependent conformational changes to the extracellular side of the membrane domains. Our observations are the first to suggest that modulation of tetrahelix bundle interactions in ATP-binding cassette exporters might offer a potent strategy to alter their transport activity.     

Characterization of the LSGGQ and H motifs from the Escherichia coli lipid A transporter MsbA

ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporters make up one of the largest superfamilies of proteins known and have been shown to transport substrates ranging from lipids and antibiotics to sugars and amino acids. The dysfunction of ABC transporters has been linked to human pathologies such as cystic fibrosis, hyperinsulinemia, and macular dystrophy. Several bacterial ABC transporters are also necessary for bacterial survival and transport of virulence factors in an infected host. MsbA is a 65 kDa protein that forms a functional homodimer consisting of two six-helix transmembrane domains and two approximately 250 amino acid nucleotide-binding domains (NBD). The NBDs contain several conserved regions such as the Walker A, LSGGQ, and H motif that bind directly to ATP and align it for hydrolysis. MsbA transports lipid A, its native substrate, across the inner membrane of Gram-negative bacteria. The loss or dysfunction of MsbA results in a toxic accumulation of lipid A inside the cell, leading to cell-membrane instability and cell death. Using site-directed spin labeling electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy, conserved motifs within the MsbA NBD have been evaluated for structure and dynamics upon substrate binding. It has been determined that the LSGGQ NBD consensus sequence is consistent with an alpha-helical conformation and that these residues maintain extensive tertiary contacts throughout hydrolysis. The dynamics of the LSGGQ and the H-motif region have been studied in the presence of ATP, ADP, and ATP plus vanadate to identify the residues that are directly affected by interactions with the substrate before, after, and during hydrolysis, respectively.     

Luminescence resonance energy transfer spectroscopy of ATP-binding cassette proteins

The ATP-binding cassette (ABC) superfamily includes regulatory and transport proteins. Most human ABC exporters pump substrates out of cells using energy from ATP hydrolysis. Although major advances have been made toward understanding the molecular mechanism of ABC exporters, there are still many issues unresolved. During the last few years, luminescence resonance energy transfer has been used to detect conformational changes in real time, with atomic resolution, in isolated ABC nucleotide binding domains (NBDs) and full-length ABC exporters. NBDs are particularly interesting because they provide the power stroke for substrate transport. Luminescence resonance energy transfer (LRET) is a spectroscopic technique that can provide dynamic information with atomic-resolution of protein conformational changes under physiological conditions. Using LRET, it has been shown that NBD dimerization, a critical step in ABC proteins catalytic cycle, requires binding of ATP to two nucleotide binding sites. However, hydrolysis at just one of the sites can drive dissociation of the NBD dimer. It was also found that the NBDs of the bacterial ABC exporter MsbA reconstituted in a lipid bilayer membrane and studied at 37 °C never separate as much as suggested by crystal structures. This observation stresses the importance of performing structural/functional studies of ABC exporters under physiologic conditions. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Beyond the Structure-Function Horizon of Membrane Proteins edited by Ute Hellmich, Rupak Doshi and Benjamin McIlwain.     

Review. Structure and mechanism of ATP-binding cassette transporters

ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporters constitute a large superfamily of integral membrane proteins that includes both importers and exporters. In recent years, several structures of complete ABC transporters have been determined by X-ray crystallography. These structures suggest a mechanism by which binding and hydrolysis of ATP by the cytoplasmic, nucleotide-binding domains control the conformation of the transmembrane domains and therefore which side of the membrane the translocation pathway is exposed to. A basic, conserved two-state mechanism can explain active transport of both ABC importers and ABC exporters, but various questions remain unresolved. In this article, I will review some of the crystal structures and the mechanistic insight gained from them. Future challenges for a better understanding of the mechanism of ABC transporters will be outlined.     

Structure and mechanism of ABC transporter proteins

ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporters are ubiquitous membrane proteins that couple the transport of diverse substrates across cellular membranes to the hydrolysis of ATP. The crystal structures of four ABC transporters have recently been determined. They reveal similar arrangements of the conserved ATP-hydrolyzing nucleotide-binding domains, but unrelated architectures of the transmembrane domains, with the notable exception of a common 'coupling helix' that is essential for transmitting conformational changes. The structures suggest a mechanism that rationalizes ATP-driven transport: While binding of ATP appears to trigger an outward-facing conformation, dissociation of the hydrolysis products may promote an inward-facing conformation. This basic scheme can, in principle, explain nutrient import by ABC importers and drug extrusion by ABC exporters.     

The Lipid Bilayer Modulates the Structure and Function of an ATP-binding Cassette Exporter

ATP-binding cassette exporters use the energy of ATP hydrolysis to transport substrates across membranes by switching between inward- and outward-facing conformations. Essentially all structural studies of these proteins have been performed with the proteins in detergent micelles, locked in specific conformations and/or at low temperature. Here, we used luminescence resonance energy transfer spectroscopy to study the prototypical ATP-binding cassette exporter MsbA reconstituted in nanodiscs at 37 °C while it performs ATP hydrolysis. We found major differences when comparing MsbA in these native-like conditions with double electron-electron resonance data and the crystal structure of MsbA in the open inward-facing conformation. The most striking differences include a significantly smaller separation between the nucleotide-binding domains and a larger fraction of molecules with associated nucleotide-binding domains in the nucleotide-free apo state. These studies stress the importance of studying membrane proteins in an environment that approaches physiological conditions.     

Structural consequences of ATP hydrolysis on the ABC transporter NBD dimer: molecular dynamics studies of HlyB

ABC transporters are a large and important family of membrane proteins involved in substrate transport across the membrane. The transported substrates are quite diverse, ranging from monatomic ions to large biomolecules. Consequently, some ABC transporters are involved in biomedically relevant situations, from genetic diseases to multidrug resistance. The most conserved domains in ABC transporters are the nucleotide binding domains (NBDs), which form a dimer responsible for the binding and hydrolysis of ATP, concomitantly with substrate translocation. To elucidate how ATP hydrolysis structurally affects the NBD dimer, and consequently the transporter, we performed a molecular dynamics study on the NBD dimer of the HlyB ABC exporter. We have observed a change in the contact surface between the monomers after hydrolysis, even though we have not seen dimer opening in any of the five 100 ns simulations. We have also identified specific regions that respond to ATP hydrolysis, in particular the X-loop motif of ABC exporters, which has been shown to be in contact with the coupling helices of the transmembrane domains (TMDs). We propose that this motif is an important part of the NBD-TMD communication in ABC exporters. Through nonequilibrium analysis, we have also identified gradual conformational changes within a short time scale after ATP hydrolysis.     

Dissection of the conformational cycle of the multidrug/lipidA ABC exporter MsbA

Recent crystal structures of the multidrug ATP‐binding cassette (ABC) exporters Sav1866 from Staphylococcus aureus, MsbA from Escherichia coli, Vibrio cholera, and Salmonella typhimurium, and mouse ABCB1a suggest a common alternating access mechanism for export. However, the molecular framework underlying this mechanism is critically dependent on assumed conformational relationships between nonidentical crystal structures and therefore requires biochemical verification. The structures of homodimeric MsbA reveal a pair of glutamate residues (E208 and E208′) in the intracellular domains of its two half‐transporters, close to the nucleotide‐binding domains (NBDs), which are in close proximity of each other in the outward‐facing state but not in the inward‐facing state. Using intermolecular cysteine crosslinking between E208C and E208C′ in E. coli MsbA, we demonstrate that the NBDs dissociate in nucleotide‐free conditions and come close on ATP binding and ADP·vanadate trapping. Interestingly, ADP alone separates the half‐transporters like a nucleotide‐free state, presumably for the following catalytic cycle. Our data fill persistent gaps in current studies on the conformational dynamics of a variety of ABC exporters. Based on a single biochemical method, the findings describe a conformational cycle for a single ABC exporter at major checkpoints of the ATPase reaction under experimental conditions, where the exporter is transport active. Proteins 2010. © 2010 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Nucleotide dependent packing differences in helical crystals of the ABC transporter MsbA

Bacterial ATP binding cassette (ABC) exporters fulfill a wide variety of transmembrane transport roles and are homologous to the human multidrug resistance P-glycoprotein. Recent X-ray structures of the exporters MsbA and Sav1866 have begun to describe the conformational changes that accompany the ABC transport cycle. Here we present cryo-electron microscopy structures of MsbA reconstituted into a lipid bilayer. Using ATPase inhibitors, we captured three nucleotide transition states of the transporter that were subsequently reconstituted into helical arrays. The enzyme–substrate complex (trapped by ADP-aluminum fluoride or AMPPNP) crystallized in a different helical lattice than the enzyme–product complex (trapped by ADP-vanadate). 20 Å resolution maps were calculated for each state and revealed MsbA to be a dimer with a large channel between the membrane spanning domains, similar to the outward facing crystal structures of MsbA and Sav1866. This suggests that while there are likely structural differences between the nucleotide transition states, membrane embedded MsbA remains in an outward facing conformation while nucleotide is bound.     

Comparison of mechanistic transport cycle models of ABC exporters

ABC (ATP binding cassette) transporters, ubiquitous in all kingdoms of life, carry out essential substrate transport reactions across cell membranes. Their transmembrane domains bind and translocate substrates and are connected to a pair of nucleotide binding domains, which bind and hydrolyze ATP to energize import or export of substrates. Over four decades of investigations into ABC transporters have revealed numerous details from atomic-level structural insights to their functional and physiological roles. Despite all these advances, a comprehensive understanding of the mechanistic principles of ABC transporter function remains elusive. The human multidrug resistance transporter ABCB1, also referred to as P-glycoprotein (P-gp), is one of the most intensively studied ABC exporters. Using ABCB1 as the reference point, we aim to compare the dominating mechanistic models of substrate transport and ATP hydrolysis for ABC exporters and to highlight the experimental and computational evidence in their support. In particular, we point out in silico studies that enhance and complement available biochemical data. “This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Beyond the Structure-Function Horizon of Membrane Proteins edited by Ute Hellmich, Rupak Doshi and Benjamin McIlwain.”     

The Nucleotide-Free State of the Multidrug Resistance ABC Transporter LmrA: Sulfhydryl Cross-Linking Supports a Constant Contact,Head-to-Tail Configuration of the Nucleotide-Binding Domains

ABC transporters are integral membrane pumps that are responsible for the import or export of a diverse range of molecules across cell membranes. ABC transporters have been implicated in many phenomena of medical importance, including cystic fibrosis and multidrug resistance in humans. The molecular architecture of ABC transporters comprises two transmembrane domains and two ATP-binding cassettes, or nucleotide-binding domains (NBDs), which are highly conserved and contain motifs that are crucial to ATP binding and hydrolysis. Despite the improved clarity of recent structural, biophysical, and biochemical data, the seemingly simple process of ATP binding and hydrolysis remains controversial, with a major unresolved issue being whether the NBD protomers separate during the catalytic cycle. Here chemical cross-linking data is presented for the bacterial ABC multidrug resistance (MDR) transporter LmrA. These indicate that in the absence of nucleotide or substrate, the NBDs come into contact to a significant extent, even at 4°C, where ATPase activity is abrogated. The data are clearly not in accord with an inward-closed conformation akin to that observed in a crystal structure of V. cholerae MsbA. Rather, they suggest a head-to-tail configuration ‘sandwich’ dimer similar to that observed in crystal structures of nucleotide-bound ABC NBDs. We argue the data are more readily reconciled with the notion that the NBDs are in proximity while undergoing intra-domain motions, than with an NBD ‘Switch’ mechanism in which the NBD monomers separate in between ATP hydrolysis cycles.     

Structural insights into ABC transporter mechanism

ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporters utilize the energy from ATP hydrolysis to transport substances across the membrane. In recent years, crystal structures of several ABC transporters have become available. These structures show that both importers and exporters oscillate between two conformations: an inward-facing conformation with the substrate translocation pathway open to the cytoplasm and an outward-facing conformation with the translocation pathway facing the opposite side of the membrane. In this review, conformational differences found in the structures of homologous ABC transporters are analyzed to understand how alternating-access is achieved. It appears that rigid-body rotations of the transmembrane subunits, coinciding with the opening and closing of the nucleotide-binding subunits, couples ATP hydrolysis to substrate translocation.     

Asymmetry in the homodimeric ABC transporter MsbA recognized by a DARPin

ABC transporters harness the energy from ATP binding and hydrolysis to translocate substrates across the membrane. Binding of two ATP molecules at the nucleotide binding domains (NBDs) leads to the formation of an outward-facing state. The conformational changes required to reset the transporter to the inward-facing state are initiated by sequential hydrolysis of the bound nucleotides. In a homodimeric ABC exporter such as MsbA responsible for lipid A transport in Escherichia coli, sequential ATP hydrolysis implies the existence of an asymmetric conformation. Here we report the in vitro selection of a designed ankyrin repeat protein (DARPin) specifically binding to detergent-solubilized MsbA. Only one DARPin binds to the homodimeric transporter in the absence as well as in the presence of nucleotides, suggesting that it recognizes asymmetries in MsbA. DARPin binding increases the rate of ATP hydrolysis by a factor of two independent of the substrate-induced ATPase stimulation. Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) measurements are found to be in good agreement with the available crystal structures and reveal that DARPin binding does not affect the large nucleotide-driven conformational changes of MsbA. The binding epitope was mapped by cross-linking and EPR to the membrane-spanning part of the transmembrane domain (TMD). Using cross-linked DARPin-MsbA complexes, 8-azido-ATP was found to preferentially photolabel one chain of the homodimer, suggesting that the asymmetries captured by DARPin binding at the TMDs are propagated to the NBDs. This work demonstrates that in vitro selected binders are useful tools to study the mechanism of membrane proteins.     

Allosteric transitions of ATP‐binding cassette transporter MsbA studied by the adaptive anisotropic network model

The transporter MsbA is a kind of multidrug resistance ATP‐binding cassette transporter that can transport lipid A, lipopolysaccharides, and some amphipathic drugs from the cytoplasmic to the periplasmic side of the inner membrane. In this work, we explored the allosteric pathway of MsbA from the inward‐ to outward‐facing states during the substrate transport process with the adaptive anisotropic network model. The results suggest that the allosteric transitions proceed in a coupled way. The large‐scale closing motions of the nucleotide‐binding domains occur first, accompanied with a twisting motion at the same time, which becomes more obvious in middle and later stages, especially for the later. This twisting motion plays an important role for the rearrangement of transmembrane helices and the opening of transmembrane domains on the periplasmic side that mainly take place in middle and later stages respectively. The topological structure plays an important role in the motion correlations above. The conformational changes of nucleotide‐binding domains are propagated to the transmembrane domains via the intracellular helices IH1 and IH2. Additionally, the movement of the transmembrane domains proceeds in a nonrigid body, and the two monomers move in a symmetrical way, which is consistent with the symmetrical structure of MsbA. These results are helpful for understanding the transport mechanism of the ATP‐binding cassette exporters. Proteins 2015; 83:1643–1653. © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

The ATP switch model for ABC transporters

ABC transporters mediate active translocation of a diverse range of molecules across all cell membranes. They comprise two nucleotide-binding domains (NBDs) and two transmembrane domains (TMDs). Recent biochemical, structural and genetic studies have led to the ATP-switch model in which ATP binding and ATP hydrolysis, respectively, induce formation and dissociation of an NBD dimer. This provides an exquisitely regulated switch that induces conformational changes in the TMDs to mediate membrane transport.     

Catalytic activity of MsbA reconstituted in nanodisc particles is modulated by remote interactions with the bilayer

ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporters couple hydrolysis of ATP with vectorial transport across the cell membrane. We have reconstituted ABC transporter MsbA in nanodiscs of various sizes and lipid compositions to test whether ATPase activity is modulated by the properties of the bilayer. ATP hydrolysis rates, Michaelis-Menten parameters, and dissociation constants of substrate analog ATP-γ-S demonstrated that physicochemical properties of the bilayer modulated binding and ATPase activity. This is remarkable when considering that the catalytic unit is located ~50? from the transmembrane region. Our results validated the use of nanodiscs as an effective tool to reconstitute MsbA in an active catalytic state, and highlighted the close relationship between otherwise distant transmembrane and ATPase modules.     

Uptake or extrusion: crystal structures of full ABC transporters suggest a common mechanism

ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporters are integral membrane proteins that move diverse substrates across cellular membranes. ABC importers catalyse the uptake of essential nutrients from the environment, whereas ABC exporters facilitate the extrusion of various compounds, including drugs and antibiotics, from the cytoplasm. How ABC transporters couple ATP hydrolysis to the transport reaction has long remained unclear. The recent crystal structures of four complete ABC transporters suggest that a key step of the molecular mechanism is conserved in importers and exporters. Whereas binding of ATP promotes an outward-facing conformation, the release of the hydrolysis products ADP and phosphate promotes an inward-facing conformation. This basic scheme can in principle explain ATP-driven drug export and binding protein-dependent nutrient uptake.     

Subunit interactions in ABC transporters: towards a functional architecture

The ABC superfamily is a diverse group of integral membrane proteins involved in the ATP-dependent transport of solutes across biological membranes in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Although ABC transporters have been studied for over 30 years, very little is known about the mechanism by which the energy of ATP hydrolysis is used to transport substrate across the membrane. The recent report of the high resolution crystal structure of HisP, the nucleotide-binding subunit of the histidine permease complex of Salmonella typhimurium, represents a significant breakthrough toward the elucidation of the mechanism of solute translocation by ABC transporters. In this review, we use data from the crystallographic structures of HisP and other nucleotide-binding proteins, combined with sequence analysis of a subset of atypical ABC transporters, to argue a new model for the dimerisation of the nucleotide-binding domains that embraces the notion that the C motif from one subunit forms part of the ATP-binding site in the opposite subunit. We incorporate this dimerisation of the ATP-binding domains into our recently reported beta-barrel model for P-glycoprotein and present a general model for the cooperative interaction of the two nucleotide-binding domains and the translocation of mechanical energy to the transmembrane domains in ABC transporters.     

ABC transporters, mechanisms and biology: an overview

This chapter concentrates mainly on structural and mechanistic aspects of ABC (ATP-binding cassette) transporters and, as an example of the physiological significance of these proteins, on lipid transport, vitally important for human health. The chapter considers those aspects of ABC transporter function that appear reasonably well established, those that remain controversial and what appear to be emerging themes. Although we have seen dramatic progress in ABC protein studies in the last 20 years, we are still far from a detailed molecular understanding of function. Nevertheless two critical steps - capture and release of allocrites (transport substrates) involving a binding cavity in the membrane domain, and hydrolysis of ATP by the NBD (nucleotide-binding domain) dimer - are now described by persuasive and testable models: alternating access, and sequential firing of catalysis sites respectively. However, these need to be tested rigorously by more structural and biochemical studies. Other aspects considered include the level at which ATP binding and dimer activation are controlled, the nature of the power stroke delivering mechanical energy for transport, and some unexpected and intriguing differences between importers and exporters. The chapter also emphasizes that some ABC transporters, although important for elimination of toxic compounds (xenobiotics), are also increasingly seen to play crucial roles in homoeostatic regulation of membrane biogenesis and function through translocation of endogenous allocrites such as cholesterol. Another emerging theme is the identification of accessory domains and partners for ABC proteins, resulting in a corresponding widening of the range of activities. Finally, what are the prospects for translational research and ABC transporters?