Characterization of self-compatibility in sweet cherry varieties by crossing experiments and molecular genetic analysis

Self-compatibility is a major breeding objective in sweet cherry. The identification and characterization of new sources of self-compatibility will be useful for breeding and research purposes. In this work, self-compatibility of four local Spanish sweet cherry varieties was investigated by crossing experiments and molecular genetic analysis of two self-incompatibility loci. Crossing experiments included self- and cross-pollinations in the laboratory followed by microscopic observation of pollen tube growth and fruit set assay in the field. After crossing experiments, two accessions, ‘Son Miró’ and ‘Talegal Ahín’, were self-compatible while the other two were self-incompatible. Inheritance of S-locus and microsatellite EMPaS02 (linked to self-compatibility, Sc) were investigated in self-pollination progeny of both self-compatible genotypes. Results indicate that self-compatibility in ‘Talegal Ahín’ is similar to self-compatibility described in sweet cherry ‘Cristobalina’ and may be caused by the same mutation. That is a pollen part mutation not linked to the S-locus but linked to microsatellite EMPaS02 in cherry LG3. In ‘Son Miró’ self-compatibility seems more complex, affecting pollen and style function, and probably involving more than one mutation not described previously in sweet cherry. Together with ‘Cristobalina’, the newly described self-compatible varieties ‘Son Miró’ and ‘Talegal Ahín’ confirm the existence of unique self-compatible plant material in local germplasm from Spain that should be conserved and characterized for its use in breeding and research.     

Pollen tube growth in the self‐compatible sweet cherry genotype, ‘Cristobalina’, is slowed down after self‐pollination

Sweet cherry is a self‐incompatible fruit tree species in the Rosaceae. As other species in the family, sweet cherry exhibits S‐RNase‐based gametophytic self‐incompatibility. This mechanism is genetically determined by the S‐locus that encodes the pollen and pistil determinants, SFB and S‐RNase, respectively. Several self‐compatible sweet cherry genotypes have been described and most of them have mutations at the S‐locus leading to self‐compatibility. However, ‘Cristobalina’ sweet cherry is self‐compatible due to a mutation in a pollen function modifier that is not linked to the S‐locus. To investigate the physiology of self‐compatibility in this cultivar, S‐locus segregation in crosses involving ‘Cristobalina’ pollen, and pollen tube growth in self‐ and cross‐pollinations, were studied. In the crosses with genotypes sharing only one S‐haplotype, the non‐self S‐haplotype was inherited more frequently than the self S‐haplotype. Pollen tube growth studies revealed that the time to travel the whole length of the style was longer for self‐pollen tubes than for cross‐pollen tubes. Together, these results suggest that ‘Cristobalina’ pollen tube growth is slower after self‐pollination than after cross‐pollination. This reproductive strategy would allow self‐fertilisation in the absence of compatible pollen but would promote cross‐fertilisation if cross‐compatible pollen is available, a possible case of cryptic self‐incompatibility. This bet‐hedging strategy might be advantageous for an ecotype that is native to the mountains of the Spanish Mediterranean coast, in the geographical limits of the distribution of this species. ‘Cristobalina’ blooming takes place very early in the season when mating possibilities are scarce and, consequently, self‐compatibility may be the only possibility for this genotype to produce offspring.     

Selbstfertile Diploide aus Polyploiden selbststeriler Petunien; Die Duplikation desS-Locus

Summary Crosses between self-incompatible triploidPetunia hybrida-plants and selfincompatible diploid ones produce self-compatible trisomics.Self-pollinations of the self-compatible trisomics give a great number of self-compatible diploid individuals which are constant self-compatible in further generations.It is supposed that self-compatibility is caused by a duplication of theS-locus. According to the results the duplication as well of identical as of not identicalS-Alleles must cause the break-down of the inhibition-reaction.Further it is supposed that the influence of the alleles in a duplicated locus both in pollen tubes and in styles is not sufficient to eliminate the inhibition-effect of normalS-genes which are presented in the reaction partner.

---

---

Dissertation der Mathematisch-naturwissenschaftlichen Fakultät der Universität zu Köln.     

Inheritance and interactions of incompatibility alleles in the tetraploid sour cherry

Three progenies of sour cherry (Prunus cerasus) were analysed to correlate self-(in)compatibility status with S-RNase phenotype in this allotetraploid hybrid of sweet and ground cherry. Self-(in)compatibility was assessed in the field and by monitoring pollen tube growth after selfing. The S-RNase phenotypes were determined by isoelectric focusing of stylar proteins and staining for RNase activity and, for the parents, confirmed by PCR. Seedling phenotypes were generally consistent with disomic segregation of S-RNase alleles. The genetic arrangements of the parents were deduced to be ‘Köröser’ (self-incompatible) S ₁ S ₄ .S _B S _D , ‘Schattenmorelle’ (self-compatible) S ₆ S ₁₃ .S _B S _B , and clone 43.87 (self-compatible) S ₄ S ₁₃ .S _B S _B , where “.” separates the two homoeologous genomes. The presence of S ₄ and S ₆ alleles at the same locus led to self-incompatibility, whereas S ₁₃ and S _B at homoeologous loci led to self-compatibility. The failure of certain heteroallelic genotypes in the three crosses or in the self-incompatible seedlings indicates that S ₄ and S ₆ are dominant to S _B . However, the success of S ₁₃ S _B pollen on styles expressing corresponding S-RNases indicates competitive interaction or lack of pollen-S components. In general, the universal compatibility of S ₁₃ S _B pollen may explain the frequent occurrence of S ₁₃ and S _B together in sour cherry cultivars. Alleles S _B and S _D , that are presumed to derive from ground cherry, and S ₁₃ , presumably from sweet cherry, were sequenced. Our findings contribute to an understanding of inheritance of self-(in)compatibility, facilitate screening of progenies for self-compatibility and provide a basis for studying molecular interactions in heteroallelic pollen.     

PCR markers for mutated <Emphasis Type="Italic">S</Emphasis>-haplotypes enable discrimination between self-incompatible and self-compatible sour cherry selections

Tetraploid sour cherry (Prunus cerasus L.) exhibits gametophytic self-incompatibility (GSI) whereby the specificity of self-pollen rejection is controlled by alleles of the stylar and pollen specificity genes, the S-RNase and SFB (S haplotype-specific F-box protein gene), respectively. As sour cherry selections can be either self-compatible (SC) or self-incompatible (SI), polyploidy per se does not result in SC. Instead, the genotype dependent loss of SI in sour cherry is due to the accumulation of non-functional S-haplotypes. The presence of two or more non-functional S-haplotypes within sour cherry 2x pollen renders that pollen SC. We previously determined that sour cherry has non-functional S-haplotypes for the S ₁ -, S ₆ - and S ₁₃ -haplotypes that are also present in diploid sweet cherry (P. avium L.). The mutations underlying these non-functional S-haplotypes have been determined to be structural alterations of either the S-RNase or SFB. Based on these structural alterations we designed derived cleaved amplified polymorphic sequence (dCAPS) markers and S-haplotype specific primer pairs that took advantage of either the length polymorphisms between S-haplotypes, differential S-haplotype sequences, or differential restriction enzyme cut sites. These primer pairs can discriminate among the mutant and wild-type S-haplotypes thereby enabling the identification of the S-haplotypes present in a sour cherry individual. This information can be used to determine whether the individual is either SC or SI. In a sour cherry breeding program, the ability to discriminate between SI and SC individuals at the seedling stage so that SI individuals can be discarded prior to field planting, dramatically increases the program’s efficiency and cost-effectiveness.     

Self-compatibility and incompatibility in tetraploid sour cherry (Prunus cerasus L.)

. Gametophytic self-incompatibility (GSI) typically "breaks down" due to polyploidy in many Solanaceous species, resulting in self-compatible (SC) tetraploid individuals. However, sour cherry (Prunus cerasus L.), a tetraploid species resulting from hybridization of the diploid sweet cherry (P. avium L.) and the tetraploid ground cherry (P. fruticosa Pall.), is an exception, consisting of both self-incompatible (SI) and SC individuals. Since sweet cherry exhibits GSI with 13 S-ribonucleases (S-RNases) identified as the stylar S-locus product, the objectives were to compare sweet and sour cherry S-allele function, S-RNase sequences and linkage map location as initial steps towards understanding the genetic basis of SI and SC in sour cherry. S-RNases from two sour cherry cultivars that were the parents of a linkage mapping population were cloned and sequenced. The sequences of two S-RNases were identical to those of sweet cherry S-RNases, whereas three other S-RNases had unique sequences. One of the S-RNases mapped to the Prunus linkage group 6, similar to its location in sweet cherry and almond, whereas two other S-RNases were linked to each other but were unlinked to any other markers. Interspecific crosses between sweet and sour cherry demonstrated that GSI exists in sour cherry and that the recognition of common S-alleles has been maintained in spite of polyploidization. It is hypothesized that self-compatibility in sour cherry is caused by the existence of non-functional S-RNases and pollen S-genes that may have arisen from natural mutations.     

INTERSPECIFIC INCOMPATIBILITY IN SOLANUM SPECIES

Pandey , K.K. (Crop Res. Div., D.S. & I.R., Lincoln, Christchurch, New Zealand.) Interspecific incompatibility in Solanum species. Amer. Jour. Bot. 49(8): 874–882. Illus. 1962.—A diallel cross involving 11 self-incompatible and 3 self-compatible species of Solanum was made to study the genetic basis of interspecific incompatibility. Interspecific incompatibility was not limited to crosses in which a self-compatible species was used as the male parent onto a self-incompatible species (unilateral incompatibility). A number of crosses between self-incompatible species were incompatible. In one cross, Q vernei X verrucosum, a self-compatible species was successful as a pollen parent with a self-incompatible species. Unlike other hybrids between self-compatible and self-incompatible species, which are self-incompatible, these F₁ hybrids were self-fertile, and cross-fertile among themselves and with both parents. The self-fertile S. polyadenium was cross-incompatible as a female as well as a male parent with all other species. It is suggested that the unilateral incompatibility is a property of the allele S_C which originated as a consequence of one kind of breakdown of the S_I gene; the S_C allele produces “bare” pollen growth substances which are inactivated in an incompatible style. It is proposed that the failure of the principle of unilateral interspecific incompatibility in solanaceous species may be due to the action of alleles at the second incompatibility locus revealed in certain Mexican species. It is assumed that the South American species are selected intraspecifically only for the action of S alleles but that in certain interspecific crosses and rarely in intraspecific crosses the alleles at the second locus may be expressed, thus interfering with the usual action of S alleles. The F₁ hybrids Q verrucosum (self-fertile) X simplicifolium (self-sterile) were self-incompatible at the tetraploid as well as the diploid level, and their cross-compatibility behavior was consistent with the expected activity of the S_C and S_I alleles of the 2 parents respectively.     

A new self-compatibility haplotype in the sweet cherry 'Kronio', S5', attributable to a pollen-part mutation in the SFB gene

'Kronio' is a Sicilian cultivar of sweet cherry (Prunus avium), nominally with the incompatibility genotype S(5)S(6), that is reported to be naturally self-compatible. In this work the cause of its self-compatibility was investigated. Test selfing confirmed self-compatibility and provided embryos for analysis; PCR with consensus primers designed to amplify S-RNase and SFB alleles showed that the embryos were of two types, S(5)S(5) and S(5)S(6), indicating that S(6) pollen failed, but S(5) succeeded, perhaps because of a mutation in the pollen or stylar component. Stylar RNase analysis indicated active S-RNases for both S(5) and S(6). The S-RNase alleles were cloned and sequenced; and sequences encode functional proteins. Cloning and sequencing of SFB alleles showed that S(6) was normal but S(5) had a premature stop codon upstream of the variable region HVa resulting in a truncated protein. Therefore, the self-compatibility can be attributed to a pollen-part mutation of S(5), designated S(5)', the first reported case of breakdown of self-incompatibility in diploid sweet cherry caused by a natural mutation at the S-locus. The second intron of the S-RNase associated with S(5)' contained a microsatellite smaller than that associated with S(5); primers designed to amplify across this microsatellite effectively distinguished S(5) from S(5)'. Analysis of some other Sicilian cherries with these primers indicated that S(5)' is also present in the Sicilian cultivar 'Maiolina a Rappu', and this proved to be self-compatible.     

Wild and Rare Self-Incompatibility Allele S17 Found in 24 Sweet Cherry (Prunus avium L.) Cultivars

The pollination of self-incompatible diploid sweet cherry is determined by the S-locus alleles. We resolved the S-alleles of 50 sweet cherry cultivars grown in Estonia and determined their incompatibility groups, which were previously unknown for most of the tested cultivars. We used consensus primers SI-19/20, SI-31/32, PaConsI, and PaConsII followed by allele-specific primers and sequencing to identify sweet cherry S-genotypes. Surprisingly, 48% (24/50) of the tested cultivars, including 17 Estonian cultivars, carry the rare S-allele S₁₇, which had initially been described in wild sweet cherries in Belgium and Germany. The S₁₇-allele in Estonian cultivars could originate from ‘Leningradskaya tchernaya’ (S₆|S₁₇), which has been extensively used in Estonian sweet cherry breeding. Four studied cultivars carrying S₁₇ are partly self-compatible, whereas the other 20 cultivars with S₁₇ have not been reported to be self-compatible. The recommended pollinator of seven self-incompatible sweet cherries is of the same S-genotype, including four with S₁₇-allele, suggesting heritable reduced effectiveness of self-infertility. We classified the newly genotyped sweet cherry cultivars into 15 known incompatibility groups, and we proposed four new incompatibility groups, 64–67, for S-locus genotypes S₃|S₁₇, S₄|S₁₇, S₅|S₁₇, and S₆|S₁₇, respectively, which makes them excellent pollinators all across Europe. Alternatively, the frequency of S₁₇ might be underestimated in Eastern European populations and some currently unidentified sweet cherry S-alleles might potentially be S₁₇.

     

Self-compatibility in aLycopersicon peruvianum variant (LA2157) is associated with a lack of style S-RNase activity

A series of crosses between a naturally-occurring self-compatible accession ofLycopersicon peruvianum and a closely-related self-incompatible accession were used to demonstrate that the mutation to self-compatibility is located at the S-locus. Progeny of the crosses contain abundant style proteins of about 30 kDa that segregate with the S₆and S₇-alleles from the SI parent and the S_c-allele from the SC parent. The S₆and S₇-associated proteins have ribonuclease activity whereas the S_c-associated protein is not an active ribonuclease. This finding indicates that S-RNases are determinants of self-incompatibility in the style and that the ribonuclease activity is essential for their function.     

Expression level of the SLG gene is not correlated with the self-incompatibility phenotype in the class II S haplotypes of Brassica oleracea

In Brassica, the S-locus glycoprotein (SLG) gene has been strongly implicated in the self-incompatibility reaction. Several alleles of this locus have been sequenced, and accordingly grouped as class I (corresponding to dominant S-alleles) and class II (recessive). We recently showed that a self-compatible (Sc) line of Brassica oleracea expressed a class II-like SLG (SLG-Sc) gene. Here, we report that the SLG-Sc glycoprotein is electrophoretically and immunochemically very similar to the recessive SLG-S15 glycoprotein, and is similarly expressed in stigmatic papillae. Moreover, by seed yield analysis, we observe that both alleles are associated with a self-compatibility response, in contrast with the other known recessive S haplotypes (S2 and S5). By genomic DNA blot analysis, we show the existence of molecular homologies between the Sc and S15 haplotypes, but demonstrate that they are not identical. On the other hand, we also report that the S2 haplotype expresses very low amounts of SLG glycoproteins, although it exhibits a self-incompatible phenotype. These results strongly question the precise role of the SLG gene in the molecular mechanisms that control the self-incompatibility reaction of Brassica.     

Protein expression of a self-compatible allele from Lycopersicon peruvianum: introgression and behavior in a self-incompatible background

Lycopersicon peruvianum (wild tomato) is a gametophytic self-incompatible (SI) species. One natural population has been shown to harbor a self-compatible (SC) allele. A stylar protein associated with the self-compatibility allele has been elucidated using SDS-PAGE. The temporal and spatial expression of this protein is presented and compared with protein expression of two SI alleles. Hybrids containing the SC and SI alleles were used in a backcrossing program to introgress the SC allele into SI backgrounds in six independent lines. Controlled pollinations and SDS-PAGE were used to identify and select classes of progeny. After four backcross generations (approximately 97% recovery of the SI backgrounds) the SC allele still confers self-fertility in lines that contain this allele, providing evidence that the mutation to SC occurred at the S-locus and that the associated protein is likely responsible.     

<Emphasis Type="Italic">S</Emphasis> genotyping and <Emphasis Type="Italic">S</Emphasis> screening utilizing <Emphasis Type="Italic">SFB</Emphasis> gene polymorphism in Japanese plum and sweet cherry by dot-blot analysis

Most Rosaceae fruit trees such as Japanese plum and sweet cherry have a gametophytic self-incompatibility (GSI) system controlled by a single S locus containing at least two linked genes with multiple alleles, i.e., S-RNase as a pistil determinant and SFB (S-haplotype-specific F-box gene) as a candidate for the pollen S determinant. For identification of S genotypes, many methods based on polymerase chain reaction (PCR) utilizing polymorphism in length of the S-RNase and SFB gene have been developed. In this study, we developed two dot-blot analysis methods for S-haplotype identification utilizing allele-specific oligonucleotides based on the SFB-HVa region, which has high sequence polymorphism. Dot-blotting of allele-specific oligonucleotides hybridized with digoxigenin-labeled PCR products allowed S genotyping of plants with nine S haplotypes (S-a, S-b, S-c, S-e, S-f, S-h, S-k, S-7 and S-10) in Japanese plum and ten S haplotypes (S-1, S-2, S-3, S-4, S-4′, S-5, S-6, S-7, S-9 and S-16) in sweet cherry (dot-blot-S-genotyping). In addition, dot-blotting of PCR products of SFB probed with the allele-specific oligonucleotides, occasionally utilizing competitive hybridization, was successful in screening for a desirable S haplotype in sweet cherry (dot-blot-S-screening).     

A segmental duplication encompassing S-haplotype triggers pollen-part self-compatibility in Japanese pear (Pyrus pyrifolia)

Self-compatible mutants of self-incompatible crops have been extensively studied for research and agricultural purposes. Until now, the only known pollen-part self-compatible mutants in Rosaceae subtribe Pyrinae, which contains many important fruit trees, were polyploid. This study revealed that the pollen-part self-compatibility of breeding selection 415-1, a recently discovered mutant of Japanese pear (Pyrus pyrifolia) derived from γ-irradiated pollen, is caused by a duplication of an S-haplotype. In the progeny of 415-1, some plants had three S-haplotypes, two of which were from the pollen parent. Thus, 415-1 was able to produce pollen with two S-haplotypes, even though it was found to be diploid: the relative nuclear DNA content measured by flow cytometry showed no significant difference from that of a diploid cultivar. Inheritance patterns of simple sequence repeat (SSR) alleles in the same linkage group as the S-locus (LG 17) showed that some SSRs closely linked to S-haplotypes were duplicated in progeny containing the duplicated S-haplotype. These results indicate that the pollen-part self-compatibility of 415-1 is not caused by a mutation of pollen S factors in either one of the S-haplotypes, but by a segmental duplication encompassing the S-haplotype. Consequently, 415-1 can produce S-heteroallelic pollen grains that are capable of breaking down self-incompatibility (SI) by competitive interaction between the two different S factors in the pollen grain. 415-1 is the first diploid pollen-part self-compatible mutant with a duplicated S-haplotype to be discovered in the Pyrinae. The fact that 415-1 is not polyploid makes it particularly valuable for further studies of SI mechanisms.     

Characterization and mapping of non-S gametophytic self-compatibility in sweet cherry (Prunus avium L.)

Self-incompatibility in Prunus (Rosaceae) species, such as sweet cherry, is controlled by a multiallelic locus (S), in which two tightly linked genes, S-RNase and SFB (S haplotype-specific F-box), determine the specificity of the pollen and the style. Fertilization in these species occurs only if the S-specificities expressed in the pollen and the pistils are different. However, modifier genes have been proposed to be necessary for a full manifestation of the self-incompatibility response. 'Cristobalina' is a spontaneous self-compatible sweet cherry cultivar that originated in Eastern Spain. Previous studies with this genotype suggested that pollen modifier gene(s), not linked to the S-locus, may be the cause of self-incompatibility breakdown. In this work, an F(1) population from 'Cristobalina' that segregates for this trait was used to identify molecular markers linked to self-compatibility by bulked segregant analysis. One simple sequence repeat (SSR) locus (EMPaS02) was found to be linked to self-compatibility in this population at 3.2?cM. Two additional populations derived from 'Cristobalina' were used to confirm the linkage of this marker to self-compatibility. Since EMPaS02 has been mapped to the sweet cherry linkage group 3, other markers located on the same linkage group were analysed in these populations to confirm the location of the self-compatibility locus.     

Origin and dissemination of the pollen-part mutated SC haplotype which confers self-compatibility in apricot (Prunus armeniaca)

In China, its centre of origin, apricot (Prunus armeniaca) is self-incompatible. However, most European cultivars are self-compatible. In most cases, self-compatibility is a result of a loss-of-function mutation within the pollen gene (SFB) in the SC haplotype. Controlled pollinations performed in this work revealed that the cross 'Ceglédi óriás' (S8S9)x'Ceglédi arany' (SCS9) set well, as expected, but the reciprocal cross did not. Apricot S8, S9 and SC haplotypes were analysed using a multilevel approach including fruit set evaluation, pollen tube growth analysis, RNase activity assays, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) analysis and DNA sequencing of the S-RNase and SFB alleles. SFB8 was revealed to be the first known progenitor allele of a naturally occurring self-compatibility allele in Prunus, and consequently SC=The first intron of SC-RNase is a phase one intron, indicating its more recent evolutionary origin compared with the second intron. Sequence analysis of different cultivars revealed that more single nucleotide polymorphisms accumulated in SC-RNase than in SFBC. New methods were designed to allow high-throughput analysis of S genotypes of apricot cultivars and selections. S-RNase sequence data from various sources helped to elucidate the putative origin and dissemination of self-compatibility in apricot conferred by the SC haplotype.     

A stylar ribonuclease assay to detect self-compatible seedlings in almond progenies

Six almond progenies, each the product of a cross between a self-compatible and a self-incompatible parent, were analysed for stylar ribonucleases. Proteins were extracted and separated using non-equilibrium pH gradient electrofocusing (NEPHGE), and the gels were stained for ribonuclease activity. Most seedlings showed either two principal bands, interpreted as corresponding to two incompatibility alleles, or a single band. The seedlings were also bagged in the field at flowering time to determine fruit set after selfing, and some were also examined for the growth of pollen-tubes in selfed styles using UV fluorescence microscopy. With very few exceptions, those seedlings showing single-banded zymograms were found to be self-compatible according to field and microscope studies, and those with two bands were found to be self-incompatible. We conclude that the allele for self-compatibility in almond does not code for ribonuclease activity and that the ribonuclease isoenzyme assay is a convenient technique for predicting self-compatibility in segregating progenies. A novel band in two derivatives of ’Ferrastar’ was ascribed to a new incompatibility allele, S ₁₀ . Received: 19 January 1999 / Accepted: 30 January 1999     

Breakdown of self-incompatibility in tetraploid Lycopersicon peruvianum: inheritance and expression of S-related proteins

 Lycopersicon peruvianum displays gametophytic self-incompatibility (GSI). We have isolated self-compatible (SC) tetraploids of L. peruvianum from tissue-cultured leaves and have explored the expression and inheritance of their S-related proteins. The Srelated protein profiles of styles of SC tetraploids were indistinguishable from the diploid self-incompatible (SI) explant source based on SDS-PAGE. All progeny obtained from self-fertilization of two tetraploids were SC. Cloned cDNA sequences of the S-related proteins were used to determine the inheritance of this locus in these progeny through Southern hybridization. The allelic ratio, as determined from the intensity of DNA restriction fragments, was consistent with the predicted ratio if only pollen bearing two different alleles was successful in achieving fertilization. All progeny obtained had at least one copy of each allele, and individuals fully homozygous for either allele were not found, indicating that pollen grains bearing two identical alleles were inhibited. In addition, the level of expression of the S-related proteins in the progeny correlated with the allelic dosage at the DNA level. We demonstrate that the observed self-compatibility in the tetraploids was not caused by an alteration in the expression of S-related proteins. Received: 11 September 1996 / Accepted: 21 March 1997