Thermodynamics of denaturation of hisactophilin, a beta-trefoil protein

Hisactophilin is a histidine-rich pH-dependent actin-binding protein from Dictyostelium discoideum. The structure of hisactophilin is typical of the beta-trefoil fold, a common structure adopted by diverse proteins with unrelated primary sequences and functions. The thermodynamics of denaturation of hisactophilin have been measured using fluorescence- and CD-monitored equilibrium urea denaturation curves, pH-denaturation, and thermal denaturation curves, as well as differential scanning calorimetry. Urea denaturation is reversible from pH 5.7 to pH 9.7; however, thermal denaturation is highly reversible only below pH approximately 6.2. Reversible denaturation by urea and heat is well fit using a two-state transition between the native and the denatured states. Urea denaturation curves are best fit using a quadratic dependence of the Gibbs free energy of unfolding upon urea concentration. Hisactophilin has moderate, roughly constant stability from pH 7.7 to pH 9.7; however, below pH 7.7, stability decreases markedly, most likely due to protonation of histidine residues. Enthalpic effects of histidine ionization upon unfolding also appear to be involved in the occurrence of cold unfolding of hisactophilin under relatively mild solution conditions. The stability data for hisactophilin are compared with data on hisactophilin function, and with data for two other beta-trefoil proteins, human interleukin-1beta, and basic fibroblast growth factor.     

Thermodynamics of carp metmyoglobin unfolding

The conformational free energy of carp lateral muscle metmyoglobin at 25 degrees C pH 8 is 9.0 +/- 0.5 kcal/mol as estimated from isothermal unfolding by both urea and guanidinium chloride. A novel procedure for the simultaneous analysis of acid and guanidinium chloride unfolding data is described. Acid denaturation data suggest that binding of five protons to histidyl residues occurs on unfolding. Correlation of sequences and conformational stabilities of several myoglobins according to the tertiary structure of sperm whale myoglobin suggests an evolutionary turnover of side chain-side chain interactions.     

Salt-induced stabilization of apoflavodoxin at neutral pH is mediated through cation-specific effects

Electrostatic contributions to the conformational stability of apoflavodoxin were studied by measurement of the proton and salt-linked stability of this highly acidic protein with urea and temperature denaturation. Structure-based calculations of electrostatic Gibbs free energy were performed in parallel over a range of pH values and salt concentrations with an empirical continuum method. The stability of apoflavodoxin was higher near the isoelectric point (pH 4) than at neutral pH. This behavior was captured quantitatively by the structure-based calculations. In addition, the calculations showed that increasing salt concentration in the range of 0 to 500 mM stabilized the protein, which was confirmed experimentally. The effects of salts on stability were strongly dependent on cationic species: K(+), Na(+), Ca(2+), and Mg(2+) exerted similar effects, much different from the effect measured in the presence of the bulky choline cation. Thus cations bind weakly to the negatively charged surface of apoflavodoxin. The similar magnitude of the effects exerted by different cations indicates that their hydration shells are not disrupted significantly by interactions with the protein. Site-directed mutagenesis of selected residues and the analysis of truncation variants indicate that cation binding is not site-specific and that the cation-binding regions are located in the central region of the protein sequence. Three-state analysis of the thermal denaturation indicates that the equilibrium intermediate populated during thermal unfolding is competent to bind cations. The unusual increase in the stability of apoflavodoxin at neutral pH affected by salts is likely to be a common property among highly acidic proteins.     

Conformational free energy of armadillo metmyoglobin

The conformational free energy of armadillo metmyoglobin was examined over a pH range of 4.4-8.0 and a guanidinium chloride concentration of 0-2.3 M. For isothermal unfolding at 25 degrees essentially the same value was obtained for the conformational free energy from all the data: 27 +/- 2 kJ/mol. These data suggest that the armadillo has the least stable metmyoglobin of any mammal thus far examined. The cooperativity of the unfolding with respect to denaturant is considerably less than for other mammalian myoglobins. On unfolding only three to four side chains with a pKA of 6 in the unfolded protein are protonated instead of the six found for horse and sperm whale myoglobins.     

Linkage of proton binding to the thermal unfolding of Sso7d from the hyperthermophilic archaebacterium Sulfolobus solfataricus.

In this study the pH dependence of the thermal stability of Sso7d from Sulfolobus solfataricus is analyzed. This small globular protein of 63 residues shows a very marked dependence of thermal stability on pH: the denaturation temperature passes from 65.2 degrees C at pH 2.5 to 97.9 degrees C at pH 4.5. Analysis of the data points out that the binding of at least two protons is coupled to the thermal unfolding. By linking the proton binding to the conformational unfolding equilibrium, a thermodynamic model, which is able to describe the dependence upon the solution pH of both the excess heat capacity function and the denaturation Gibbs energy change for Sso7d, is developed. The decreased stability in very acid conditions is due to the binding of two protons on identical and noninteracting sites of the unfolded state. Actually, such sites are two carboxyl groups possessing very low pKa values in the native structure, probably involved in salt-bridges on the protein surface.     

Linear free-energy model description of the conformational stability of uracil-DNA glycosylase inhibitor A thermodynamic characterization of interaction with denaturant and cold denaturation.

The equilibrium unfolding of uracil DNA glycosylase inhibitor (Ugi), a small acidic protein of molecular mass 9474 Da, has been studied by a combination of thermal-induced and guanidine hydrochloride (GdnCl)-induced denaturation. The analysis of the denaturation data provides a measure of the changes in conformational free energy, enthalpy, entropy and heat capacity DeltaCp that accompany the equilibrium unfolding of Ugi over a wide range of temperature and GdnCl concentration. The unfolding of Ugi is a simple two-state, reversible process. The protein undergoes both low-temperature and high-temperature unfolding even in the absence of GdnCl but more so in the presence of denaturant. The data are consistent with the linear free-energy model and with a temperature independent DeltaCp over the large temperature range of unfolding. The small DeltaCp (6.52 kJ.mol-1.K-1) for the unfolding of Ugi, is perhaps a reflection of a relatively small, buried hydrophobic core in the folded form of this small monomeric protein. Despite a relatively low value of DeltaG(H2O), 7.40 kJ.mol-1 at pH 8.3, Ugi displays considerable stability with the temperature of maximum stability being 301.6 K.     

Use of protein unfolding studies to determine the conformational and dimeric stabilities of HIV-1 and SIV proteases.

The free energies of dimer dissociation of the retroviral proteases (PRs) of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) and simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) were determined by measuring the effects of denaturants on the protein fluorescence upon the unfolding of the enzymes. HIV-1 PR was more stable to denaturation by chaotropes and extremes of pH and temperature than SIV PR, indicating that the former enzyme has greater conformational stability. The urea unfolding curves of both proteases were sigmoidal and single phase. The midpoints of the transition curves increased with increasing protein concentrations. These data were best described by and fitted to a two-state model in which folded dimers were in equilibrium with unfolded monomers. This denaturation model conforms to cases in which protein unfolding and dimer dissociation are concomitant processes in which folded monomers do not exist [Bowie, J. U., & Sauer, R. T. (1989) Biochemistry 28, 7140-7143]. Accordingly, the free energies of unfolding reflect the stabilities of the protease dimers, which for HIV-1 PR and SIV PR were, respectively, delta GuH2O = 14 +/- 1 kcal/mol (Ku = 39 pM) and 13 +/- 1 kcal/mol (Ku = 180 pM). The binding of a tight-binding, competitive inhibitor greatly stabilized HIV-1 PR toward urea-induced unfolding (delta GuH2O = 19.3 +/- 0.7 kcal/mol, Ku = 7.0 fM). There were also profound effects caused by adverse pH on the protein conformation for both HIV-1 PR and SIV PR, resulting in unfolding at pH values above and below the respective optimal ranges of 4.0-8.0 and 4.0-7.0     

Thermodynamics of alligator metmyoglobin unfolding

The conformational free energy of alligator metmyoglobin was examined over a pH range of 4.4-8.0, a temperature range of 18-48 degrees C, and a guanidinium chloride concentration of 0-2.3 M. For isothermal unfolding at 25 degrees C essentially the same value was obtained for the conformational free energy from all the data: 7.0 +/- 0.5 kcal/mol. The cooperativity of the unfolding with respect to denaturant is considerably less than for mammalian myoglobins. On unfolding three to four side chains with a pKa of 6.3 in the unfolded protein are protonated instead of the six expected. The temperature at which delta H (unfolding) is zero is much lower than for previously characterized myoglobins. Alligator metmyoglobin, considerably less stable than other previously characterized myoglobins, may not be as compactly folded.     

Comparison of the stability of fish light meromyosins by guanidine hydrochloride denaturation

The guanidine hydrochloride denaturation of light meromyosins (LMMs) of fish (carp, sardine and greenling) and rabbit was investigated to determine their structural stability quantitatively. The circular dichroism (CD) and fluorescence spectroscopies were applied to monitor denaturation. The CD results indicate that the LMM α-helix undergoes a two-step unfolding. The free energy of denaturation was calculated based on the linear extrapolation method and the denaturant binding model. Total free energies of the two-step unfolding of the α-helix are related to the water temperatures in which the fish live and the body temperature of rabbit. The stability of α-helical structure of LMM was in the following descending order: rabbit>carp>sardine>greenling. The free energies of denaturation obtained by tryptophan fluorescence differ from the free energies of the unfolding α-helix. The data from the two spectroscopic measurements are discussed along with the conformational changes of LMMs.     

Calculating pH-dependent free energy of proteins by using Monte Carlo protonation probabilities of ionizable residues

Protein folding, stability, and function are usually influenced by pH. And free energy plays a fundamental role in analysis of such pH-dependent properties. Electrostatics-based theoretical framework using dielectric solvent continuum model and solving Poisson-Boltzmann equation numerically has been shown to be very successful in understanding the pH-dependent properties. However, in this approach the exact computation of pH-dependent free energy becomes impractical for proteins possessing more than several tens of ionizable sites (e.g.>30), because exact evaluation of the partition function requires a summation over a vast number of possible protonation microstates. Here we present a method which computes the free energy using the average energy and the protonation probabilities of ionizable sites obtained by the well-established Monte Carlo sampling procedure. The key feature is to calculate the entropy by using the protonation probabilities. We used this method to examine a well-studied protein (lysozyme) and produced results which agree very well with the exact calculations. Applications to the optimum pH of maximal stability of proteins and protein–DNA interactions have also resulted in good agreement with experimental data. These examples recommend our method for application to the elucidation of the pH-dependent properties of proteins.     

Protein stability and electrostatic interactions between solvent exposed charged side chains

To investigate the contribution to protein stability of electrostatic interactions between charged surface residues, we have studied the effect of substituting three negatively charged solvent exposed residues with their side-chain amide analogs in bovine calbindin D9k--a small (Mr 8,500) globular protein of the calmodulin superfamily. The free energy of urea-induced unfolding for the wild-type and seven mutant proteins has been measured. The mutant proteins have increased stability towards unfolding relative to the wild-type. The experimental results correlate reasonably well with theoretically calculated relative free energies of unfolding and show that electrostatic interactions between charges on the surface of a protein can have significant effects on protein stability.     

Four-state equilibrium unfolding of an scFv antibody fragment

The conformational stability of a single-chain Fv antibody fragment against a hepatitis B surface antigen (anti-HBsAg scFv) has been studied by urea and temperature denaturation followed by fluorescence and circular dichroism. At neutral pH and low protein concentration, it is a well-folded monomer, and its urea and thermal denaturations are reversible. The noncoincidence of the fluorescence and circular dichroism transitions indicates the accumulation in the urea denaturation of an intermediate (I(1)) not previously described in scFv molecules. In addition, at higher urea concentrations, a red-shift in the fluorescence emission maximum reveals an additional intermediate (I(2)), already reported in the denaturation of other scFvs. The urea equilibrium unfolding of the anti-HBsAg scFv is thus four-state. A similar four-state behavior is observed in the thermal unfolding although the intermediates involved are not identical to those found in the urea denaturation. Global analysis of the thermal unfolding data suggests that the first intermediate displays substantial secondary structure and some well-defined tertiary interactions while the second one lacks well-defined tertiary interactions but is compact and unfolds at higher temperature in a noncooperative fashion. Global analysis of the urea unfolding data (together with the modeled structure of the scFv) provides insights into the conformation of the chemical denaturation intermediates and allows calculation of the N-I(1), I(1)-I(2), and I(2)-D free energy differences. Interestingly, although the N-D free energy difference is very large, the N-I(1) one, representing the "relevant" conformational stability of the scFv, is small.     

Thermodynamic characterization of the human acidic fibroblast growth factor: evidence for cold denaturation.

The thermodynamic parameters characterizing the conformational stability of the human acidic fibroblast growth factor (hFGF-1) have been determined by isothermal urea denaturation and thermal denaturation at fixed concentrations of urea using fluorescence and far-UV CD circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy. The equilibrium unfolding transitions at pH 7.0 are adequately described by a two-state (native <--> unfolded state) mechanism. The stability of the protein is pH-dependent, and the protein unfolds completely below pH 3.0 (at 25 degrees C). hFGF-1 is shown to undergo a two-state transition only in a narrow pH range (pH 7.0-8.0). Under acidic (pH <6.0) and basic (pH >8.0) conditions, hFGF-1 is found to unfold noncooperatively, involving the accumulation of intermediates. The average temperature of maximum stability is determined to be 295.2 K. The heat capacity change (DeltaC(p)()) for the unfolding of hFGF-1 is estimated to be 2.1 +/- 0.5 kcal.mol(-1).K(-1). Temperature denaturation experiments in the absence and presence of urea show that hFGF-1 has a tendency to undergo cold denaturation. Two-dimensional (1)H-(15)N HSQC spectra of hFGF-1 acquired at subzero temperatures clearly show that hFGF-1 unfolds under low-temperature conditions. The significance of the noncooperative unfolding under acidic conditions and the cold denaturation process observed in hFGF-1 are discussed in detail.     

Non-linear effects of temperature and urea on the thermodynamics and kinetics of folding and unfolding of hisactophilin

Extensive measurements and analysis of thermodynamic stability and kinetics of urea-induced unfolding and folding of hisactophilin are reported for 5-50 degrees C, at pH 6.7. Under these conditions hisactophilin has moderate thermodynamic stability, and equilibrium and kinetic data are well fit by a two-state transition between the native and the denatured states. Equilibrium and kinetic m values decrease with increasing temperature, and decrease with increasing denaturant concentration. The betaF values at different temperatures and urea concentrations are quite constant, however, at about 0.7. This suggests that the transition state for hisactophilin unfolding is native-like and changes little with changing solution conditions, consistent with a narrow free energy profile for the transition state. The activation enthalpy and entropy of unfolding are unusually low for hisactophilin, as is also the case for the corresponding equilibrium parameters. Conventional Arrhenius and Eyring plots for both folding and unfolding are markedly non-linear, but these plots become linear for constant DeltaG/T contours. The Gibbs free energy changes for structural changes in hisactophilin have a non-linear denaturant dependence that is comparable to non-linearities observed for many other proteins. These non-linearities can be fit for many proteins using a variation of the Tanford model, incorporating empirical quadratic denaturant dependencies for Gibbs free energies of transfer of amino acid constituents from water to urea, and changes in fractional solvent accessible surface area of protein constituents based on the known protein structures. Noteworthy exceptions that are not well fit include amyloidogenic proteins and large proteins, which may form intermediates. The model is easily implemented and should be widely applicable to analysis of urea-induced structural transitions in proteins.     

The entropic nature of protein thermal stabilization

We performed thermodynamic analysis of temperature-induced unfolding of mesophilic and thermophilic proteins. It was shown that the variability in protein thermostability associated with pH-dependent unfolding or linked to the substitution of amino acid residues on the protein surface is evidence of the governing role of the entropy factor. Numerical values of conformational components in enthalpy, entropy and free energy which characterize protein unfolding in the “gas phase” were obtained. Based on the calculated absolute values of entropy and free energy, a model of protein unfolding is proposed in which the driving force is the conformational entropy of native protein, as an energy of the heat motion (T·S^NC) increasing with temperature and acting as an factor devaluating the energy of intramolecular weak bonds in the transition state.     

Conformational plasticity of cryptolepain: accumulation of partially unfolded states in denaturants induced equilibrium unfolding

pH and chemical denaturant dependent conformational changes of a serine protease cryptolepain from Cryptolepis buchanani are presented in this paper. Activity measurements, near UV, far UV CD, fluorescence emission spectroscopy, and ANS binding studies have been carried out to understand the folding mechanism of the protein in the presence of denaturants. pH and chemical denaturants have a marked effect on the stability, structure, and function of many globular proteins due to their ability to influence the electrostatic interactions. The preliminary biophysical study on cryptolepain shows that major elements of secondary structure are beta-sheets. Under neutral conditions the enzyme was stable in urea while GuHCl-induced equilibrium unfolding was cooperative. Cryptolepain shows little ANS binding even under neutral conditions due to more hydrophobicity of beta-sheets. Multiple intermediates were populated during the pH-induced unfolding of cryptolepain. Temperature-induced denaturation of cryptolepain in the molten globule like state is non-cooperative, contrary to the cooperativity seen with the native protein, suggesting the presence of two parts, possibly domains, in the molecular structure of cryptolepain, with different stability that unfolds in steps. Interestingly, the GuHCl-induced unfolding of A state (molten globule state) of cryptolepain is unique, as lower concentration of denaturant, not only induces structure but also facilitate transition from one molten globule like state (MG(1)) into another (MG(2)). The increase of pH drives the protein into alkaline denatured state characterized by the absence of any ANS binding. GuHCl- and urea-induced unfolding transition curves at pH 12.0 were non-coincidental indicating the presence of an intermediate in the unfolding pathway.     

Stability and physicochemical properties of the bovine brain phosphatidylethanolamine-binding protein.

The equilibrium behaviour of the bovine phosphatidylethanolamine-binding protein (PEBP) has been studied under various conditions of pH, temperature and urea concentration. Far-UV and near-UV CD, fluorescence and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopies indicate that, in its native state, PEBP is mainly composed of beta-sheets, with Trp residues mostly localized in a hydrophobic environment; these results suggest that the conformation of PEBP in solution is similar to the three-dimensional structure determined by X-ray crystallography. The pH-induced conformational changes show a transition midpoint at pH 3.0, implying nine protons in the transition. At neutral pH, the thermal denaturation is irreversible due to protein precipitation, whereas at acidic pH values the protein exhibits a reversible denaturation. The thermal denaturation curves, as monitored by CD, fluorescence and differential scanning calorimetry, support a two-state model for the equilibrium and display coincident values with a melting temperature Tm = 54 degrees C, an enthalpy change DeltaH = 119 kcal.mol-1 and a free energy change DeltaG(H2O, 25 degrees C) = 5 kcal.mol-1. The urea-induced unfolding profiles of PEBP show a midpoint of the two-state unfolding transition at 4.8 M denaturant, and the stability of PEBP is 4.5 kcal.mol-1 at 25 degrees C. Moreover, the surface active properties indicate that PEBP is essentially a hydrophilic protein which progressively unfolds at the air/water interface over the course of time. Together, these results suggest that PEBP is well-structured in solution but that its conformation is weakly stable and sensitive to hydrophobic conditions: the PEBP structure seems to be flexible and adaptable to its environment.     

Interpretation of DSC data on protein denaturation complicated by kinetic and irreversible effects

Thermal denaturation of Kunitz soybean trypsin inhibitor (KTI) and ribulose-1,5-biphosphate carboxylase (RBPC) from tobacco leafs was studied by the method of high-sensitivity differential scanning calorimetry (HS-DSC). The dependence of the denaturation temperature on the heating rate reveals in the case of both proteins a non-equilibrium character of the denaturation transition in applied conditions. Developed kinetic approach allows the determination of an equilibrium transition temperature as well as the rate constants of denaturation and renaturation from the complex data of HS-DSC. This method was applied to the analysis of the pH-induced change of the conformational stability of KTI within pH range from 2.0 to 11.0. It allowed the determination of the pH dependencies: of the excess free energy of denaturation, of the activation enthalpy and entropy of denaturation as well as of the denaturation rate constant. Conclusions have been made suggesting the contribution of side-chain hydrogen bonds in the stabilisation of the native and activated states of KTI.     

Thermodynamic analysis of the structural stability of phage 434 Cro protein

Thermodynamic parameters describing the phage 434 Cro protein have been determined by calorimetry and, independently, by far-UV circular dichroism (CD) measurements of isothermal urea denaturations and thermal denaturations at fixed urea concentrations. These equilibrium unfolding transitions are adequately described by the two-state model. The far-UV CD denaturation data yield average temperature-independent values of 0.99 +/- 0.10 kcal mol(-)(1) M(-)(1) for m and 0.98 +/- 0.05 kcal mol(-)(1) K(-)(1) for DeltaC(p)()(,U), the heat capacity change accompanying unfolding. Calorimetric data yield a temperature-independent DeltaC(p)()(,U) of 0.95 +/- 0.30 kcal mol(-)(1) K(-)(1) or a temperature-dependent value of 1.00 +/- 0.10 kcal mol(-)(1) K(-)(1) at 25 degrees C. DeltaC(p)()(,U) and m determined for 434 Cro are in accord with values predicted using known empirical correlations with structure. The free energy of unfolding is pH-dependent, and the protein is completely unfolded at pH 2.0 and 25 degrees C as judged by calorimetry or CD. The stability of 434 Cro is lower than those observed for the structurally similar N-terminal domain of the repressor of phage 434 (R1-69) or of phage lambda (lambda(6)(-)(85)), but is close to the value reported for the putative monomeric lambda Cro. Since a protein's structural stability is important in determining its intracellular stability and turnover, the stability of Cro relative to the repressor could be a key component of the regulatory circuit controlling the levels and, consequently, the functions of the two proteins in vivo.     

Oxidation of methionine residues in recombinant human interleukin-1 receptor antagonist: implications of conformational stability on protein oxidation kinetics

Oxidation of methionine residues is involved in several biochemical processes and in degradation of therapeutic proteins. The relationship between conformational stability and methionine oxidation in recombinant human interleukin-1 receptor antagonist (rhIL-1ra) was investigated to document how thermodynamics of unfolding affect methionine oxidation in proteins. Conformational stability of rhIL-1ra was monitored by equilibrium urea denaturation, and thermodynamic parameters of unfolding (DeltaGH2O, m, and Cm) were estimated at different temperatures. Methionine oxidation induced by hydrogen peroxide at varying temperatures was monitored during "coincubation" of rhIL-1ra with peptides mimicking specific regions of the reactive methionine residues in the protein. The coincubation study allowed estimation of oxidation rates in protein and peptide at each temperature from which normalized oxidation rate constants and activation energies were calculated. The rate constants for buried Met-11 in the protein were lower than for methionine in the peptide with an associated increase in activation energy. The rate constants and activation energy of solvent exposed methionines in protein and peptide were similar. The results showed that conformational stability, monitored using the Cm value, has an effect on oxidation rates of buried methionines. The rate constant of buried Met-11 correlated well with the Cm value but not DeltaGH2O. No correlation was observed for the oxidation rates of solvent-exposed methionines with any thermodynamic parameters of unfolding. The findings presented have implications in protein engineering, in design of accelerated stability studies for protein formulation development, and in understanding disease conditions involving protein oxidation.