Population structure and genetic diversity of red deer (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Cervus elaphus</Emphasis>) in forest fragments in north-western France

Red deer have been subjected to anthropogenic interference for many centuries. Most populations are managed according to hunting schedules, some have been kept long-term in enclosures and other populations have been restocked with foreign deer. The red deer in the Brittany region of north-western France only occupy the largest forests in the region, reaching quite high densities in restricted areas. Here, we aimed to assess the extent of the genetic variability of the populations in four forest fragments and investigate their population genetic structure. We show that, despite relatively large expected heterozygosity values, these geographically isolated populations are genetically impoverished relative to individuals from large continuous forests in other parts of Western Europe. We provide evidence for population genetic structure with large genetic differentiation between geographically close populations, suggesting the absence of effective exchange between the forests. Using samples from the most likely source population, we show that at least two populations were non-indigenous. In order to limit further loss of genetic diversity, it should be a management objective to reduce isolation of the different forests, rather than further increase it by fences and hunting practices that could limit free movement of red deer.     

Genetic differentiation between introduced Central European sika and source populations in Japan: effects of isolation and demographic events

Japanese sika deer (Cervus nippon nippon) were introduced at the turn of nineteenth and twentieth century to many countries in Eurasia, North America and Australasia. Subsequently, free-living invasive populations have become established in several countries, including the Czech Republic, where the expanding sika population causes serious problems through overgrazing, damage through browsing and through competition and hybridisation with native red deer. 122 Japanese and 221 Czech samples were used to examine the genetic diversity, genetic structure, and the level of genetic differentiation between native populations and those introduced to the Czech Republic. Analyses of 22 microsatellite loci revealed, for both countries, evidence of isolation by distance and clear sub-structuring of populations, different from patterns previously revealed by mtDNA markers. The high number of private alleles (58 within the Czech Republic and 84 within Japan), the Fst values, factorial correspondence analysis and Bayesian clustering support a high level of divergence between the source and introduced populations. Genetic variability was generally low due to recent demographic events (founder effect in the Czech population, bottlenecks in Japanese populations); however, the values of expected heterozygosity differed greatly between subpopulations and were not the lowest in the introduced Czech populations. Multiple introductions, rapid population growth, and possible hybridisation with red deer seem to have helped the successful expansion of sika within the Czech Republic. The results also indicate that male-mediated gene flow and human-mediated translocations have significantly influenced the current genetic structure of native sika populations in Japan.     

内蒙古赛罕乌拉自然保护区东北马鹿种群遗传多样性与性别结构分析

东北马鹿（Cervus canadensis）种群面临着地理隔绝和生境破碎化等问题,对其种群遗传多样性和性别结构的研究,有助于了解其隔离种群的生存现状,为保护与管理工作提供科学依据。本研究利用8对微卫星分子标记,对内蒙古赛罕乌拉国家级自然保护区的456份马鹿粪便样品进行遗传多样性分析。结果识别出2015年冬季56只个体,2016年秋季41只个体;微卫星位点平均期望杂合度为0.650 1,平均多态信息含量为0.603 5,表明该地区马鹿种群的遗传多样性处于中等偏上水平。种群遗传分化系数为-0.053 99、近交系数为0.086 67、基因流为2.942 11,说明该马鹿种群基因交流普遍,近交水平低。基于SRY基因的方法进行性别鉴定,种群雌雄性比在冬季为1.8：1,秋季为0.71：1。本研究显示,该区域马鹿种群目前遗传多样性较为丰富,但现有种群集中分布于保护区内,处于相对隔离状态,长期发展则存在种群内部近交的风险。因此,加强对种群遗传结构和生存状态的监测,并促进与附近区域马鹿个体的交流,将有助于保持区域性东北马鹿种群长期繁盛。     

Genetic consequences of human management in an introduced island population of red deer (Cervus elaphus)

We investigated phylogeography and spatial genetic structure in an introduced island population of red deer (Cervus elaphus) on the Isle of Rum, Scotland, experiencing spatial variation in management regime. Five different mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) haplotypes were present among female red deer on Rum. These comprised two phylogenetically divergent groups, one of which clustered with red deer from Sardinia and North Africa, while the other four grouped with other Western European red deer. Recent and historical red deer management practices explain this result. The Rum population is descended from recent introductions from at least four different UK mainland populations, and translocation of red deer within the UK and across Europe is well documented. We found significant spatial genetic structure across Rum in both mtDNA haplotypes and microsatellite markers. Mitochondrial spatial structure was over an order of magnitude greater than structure in nuclear markers. This extreme difference is explained by the fact that the Rum population was introduced from different source populations, the highly male-biased dispersal patterns of red deer and the much smaller effective population size of mitochondrial compared to nuclear markers. Spatial structure in mtDNA conformed to a pattern of isolation by distance, while nuclear DNA did not. Apparent structure in the nuclear markers was driven by differences between the North Block and the rest of the island. We suggest that recent differences in the management regimes in different parts of the island have led to differences in effective male migration that would account for this observation.     

Crossing the border? Structure of the red deer (Cervus elaphus) population from the Bavarian–Bohemian forest ecosystem

Anthropogenic impact such as overhunting and habitat fragmentation has reduced the total red deer population (Cervus elaphus) across Europe. In Germany remaining subpopulations are even confined to designated areas with limited or no gene flow among them. Red deer populations inhabiting the Bavarian–Bohemian forest ecosystem had been divided by a fortified State border between Germany and former Czechoslovakia. To assess red deer genetic diversity more than two decades after the removal of the fortifications, we analysed a population from the Bavarian Forest National Park, Germany, and one from the National Park ?umava, Czech Republic, using 11 microsatellite loci and a 910 bp long section of the mitochondrial control region (mtDNA). Bayesian analyses of microsatellite allele frequencies favoured the presence of a single population in the Bavarian-Bohemian forest ecosystem over other population genetic structures. This admixture was supported by a lack of population pairwise differentiation between German and Czech red deer microsatellite genotypes in the analysis of molecular variance (AMOVA, F_ST = 0.009, p = 0.383). Contrastingly, AMOVA revealed a highly significant matrilinear differentiation of mtDNA between the two samples (Φ_ST = 0.285, p = 0.002), whereby German red deer belonged predominantly to haplogroup A (western Europe) and Czech red deer predominantly to haplogroup C (eastern Europe). In combination, these findings indicated a high degree of philopatry by does and extensive gene flow across the former border mediated by stags. They also identified the Bavarian–Bohemian forest ecosystem as part of a suture zone between western and eastern European red deer matrilines.     

Microsatellite variation in China’s Hainan Eld’s deer (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Cervus eldi hainanus</Emphasis>) and implications for their conservation

Hainan Eld’s deer (Cervus eldi hainanus) experienced a dramatic decline in the late 1960s through early 1970s and by 1976 only 26 deer remained in Datian of Hainan Island, China. Since then, conservation efforts have successfully rescued this deer from extinction. We employed 10 microsatellite DNA loci to index genetic variation in the one source (Datian) and two introduced populations (Bangxi and Ganshiling) and suggest implications for the conservation of the species. A total of 40 alleles at 10 loci were examined from 198 deer blood samples. The source population harbored all 40 alleles, while the Bangxi and Ganshiling translocated populations contained 24 and 26 alleles, respectively. The genetic variability was low (H _e ≈ 0.33) for each of the three populations. No significant difference in genetic variability between the three populations was detected (P > 0.05); yet significant differentiation was found among the three populations. Our results suggest that founder effects and genetic drift have affected the two translocated populations. For conservation we recommend the three populations be managed as a meta-population. When establishing future reintroductions, the founder population should have a size larger than the original 26 founders in Datian population or be composed of a cohort of over 20 same-age individuals with 1:1 sex ratio. Genetic monitoring for both the source and translocated populations should be continuously conducted in order to assess the effectiveness of deer conservation in the future.     

Population structure, habitat features and genetic structure of managed red deer populations

Management of game ungulates alters population structure and habitat features, with potential effects on genetic structure. Here, we study 26 red deer (Cervus elaphus) populations in Spain. We used census data and habitat features as well as genetic information at 11 microsatellite markers from 717 individuals. We found that metapopulations presented a distribution associated with forest interruptions. Within metapopulations, fences did not have a significant effect on red deer genetic structure. The metapopulations we studied presented similar population structure, but they differed in habitat features and genetic structure. The metapopulation with higher resource availability showed a genetic structure pattern in which genetic relatedness between geographically close individuals was high while relatedness between geographically distant individuals was low. Contrarily, the metapopulation with lower resource availability presented a genetic structure pattern in which the genetic relatedness between individuals of different populations was independent of the geographic distance. We discuss the possible connection between resource availability and genetic structure. Finally, we did not find any population or environmental variable related to genetic differentiation within metapopulations.     

Non-indigenous introgression into the Norwegian red deer population

Rates of introgression from non-indigenous into native populations are increasing worldwide, often as a result of anthropogenic translocation events. In ungulates translocations have been common, especially among deer. European red deer consists of two distinct lineages, one western and one eastern. These probably originate from different glacial refuges, but it is unknown to what extent they hold different adaptations. Here we address dispersal and introgression into the Norwegian mainland population from an introduced island stock consisting of an admixture of both European lineages. The last decade this stock has grown considerably in number and dispersal could be expected to have increased. We therefore used samples separated by a 5 year interval from Otterøya, adjacent mainland areas and a more distant sub-population. Bayesian assignment analysis verified the genetic structure and identified dispersal between the Otterøya stock and the adjacent mainland coastal areas. Three individuals (two newly sampled) with second or third generation non-indigenous origin were found among the adjacent mainland samples (5 and 3 %, respectively). Two individuals with first and second generation mainland-origin were found on Otterøya (old samples). This suggests some non-indigenous introgression from Otterøya into the mainland Norwegian population.     

Bovine virus diarrhea and the vector-borne diseases Anaplasmosis and Bluetongue: a sero-surveillance in free-ranging red deer (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Cervus elaphus</Emphasis>) in selected areas of Switzerland

Due to climate changes, diseases emerging from southerly adjacent areas (Mediterranean countries) are likely to spread northward. Expanded migration of red deer harbors the risk of introducing new pathogens into a naive population of either wild or domestic animals. Little is known about the importance of red deer as a potential reservoir for diseases of domestic ruminants in Switzerland. Deer is susceptible for all three agents that were selected in this study: bovine virus diarrhea virus (BVDV), Anaplasma marginale (AM), and Bluetongue virus (BTV). The goal of this project was to establish the serological status of red deer in Switzerland concerning BVDV, AM, and BTV, and to assess the possible impact of disease dynamics with a focus on potential transmission of these diseases from red deer to cattle or vice versa. Sampling areas were selected according the following criteria: abundance of red deer, potential insect vector distribution due to climatic conditions, and traditional alpine pasture husbandry along with known migration routes of red deer. Blood samples were collected during the regular hunting season 2004 and 2005 by hunters and gamekeepers. There was no serological evidence for the presence of the vector-borne diseases AM and BT in red deer in Switzerland. Four out of 234 sera showed a positive result for BVD, corresponding to a sero-prevalence of 1.7% (95% CI 0.46–4.38). Facing the fact of the high sero-prevalence for BVD in Swiss cattle (60–80%) disease transmission from red deer to cattle in these areas under investigation is rather unlikely.     

Genetic effect of transportation infrastructure on roe deer populations (Capreolus capreolus)

Anthropogenic transportation infrastructure is a major factor of habitat fragmentation leading to genetic population fragmentation in wildlife. Assessing and understanding the impact of this deterministic factor on genetic diversity and divergence of populations is crucial to appraise the viability of wildlife populations in fragmented landscapes. In this study, the roe deer is used as an example species for the assessment of genetic differentiation of populations separated by an anthropogenic barrier. In order to detect genetic discontinuities, we screened 12 polymorphic microsatellites on 222 individuals out of 11 roe deer populations that were sampled on the east and the westside of a fenced motorway in Central Switzerland. The interaction between landscape structure and microevolutionary processes such as gene flow and drift were assessed and evaluated by different population genetic methods like F-statistics, Mantel test, spatial autocorrelation analyses, Monmonier algorithm, and principal component analysis in conjunction with geographic information system data (synthesis map). We revealed an influence of the transportation infrastructure on genetic divergence of the roe deer population examined, but no impact on genetic diversity was detected. Based on the achieved genetic findings, recommendations for management implementation were made.     

Mitochondrial DNA and microsatellite analyses of the genetic status of the presumed subspecies Cervus elaphus montanus (Carpathian red deer)

The possibly distinct Carpathian red deer was compared genetically to other European populations. We screened 120 red deer specimens from Serbia, the Romanian lowland and the Romanian Carpathians for genetic variability using 582 bp of the mitochondrial control region and nine polymorphic nuclear microsatellite loci. The study aimed at a population genetic characterization of the Carpathian red deer, which are often treated as a distinct subspecies (Cervus elaphus montanus). The genetic integrity of the Carpathian populations was confirmed through the haplotype distribution, private alleles and genetic distances. The Carpathian red deer are thus identified as one of the few remaining natural populations of this species, deserving special attention among game and conservation biologists. The history of the populations studied, in particular the introduction of Carpathian red deer into Romanian lowland areas in the 20th century, was reflected by the genetic data.     

Landscape features affect gene flow of Scottish Highland red deer (Cervus elaphus)

Landscape features have been shown to strongly influence dispersal and, consequently, the genetic population structure of organisms. Studies quantifying the effect of landscape features on gene flow of large mammals with high dispersal capabilities are rare and have mainly been focused at large geographical scales. In this study, we assessed the influence of several natural and human-made landscape features on red deer gene flow in the Scottish Highlands by analysing 695 individuals for 21 microsatellite markers. Despite the relatively small scale of the study area (115 × 87 km), significant population structure was found using F -statistics ( F _ST = 0.019) and the program structure , with major differentiation found between populations sampled on either side of the main geographical barrier (the Great Glen). To assess the effect of landscape features on red deer population structure, the ArcMap GIS was used to create cost-distance matrices for moving between populations, using a range of cost values for each of the landscape features under consideration. Landscape features were shown to significantly affect red deer gene flow as they explained a greater proportion of the genetic variation than the geographical distance between populations. Sea lochs were found to be the most important red deer gene flow barriers in our study area, followed by mountain slopes, roads and forests. Inland lochs and rivers were identified as landscape features that might facilitate gene flow of red deer. Additionally, we explored the effect of choosing arbitrary cell cost values to construct least cost-distance matrices and described a method for improving the selection of cell cost values for a particular landscape feature.     

Bottlenecks, drift and differentiation: the population structure and demographic history of sika deer (Cervus nippon) in the Japanese archipelago

We assessed genetic differentiation and diversity in 14 populations of sika deer (Cervus nippon) from Japan and four populations of sika deer introduced to the UK, using nine microsatellite loci. We observed extreme levels of differentiation and significant differences in diversity between populations. Our results do not support morphological subspecies designations, but are consistent with previous mitochondrial DNA analyses which suggest the existence of two genetically distinct lineages of sika deer in Japan. The source of sika introduced to the UK was identified as Kyushu. The underlying structure of Japanese populations probably derives from drift in separate glacial refugia and male dispersal limited by distance. This structure has been perturbed by bottlenecks and habitat fragmentation, resulting from human activity from the mid-nineteenth century. Most current genetic differentiation and differences in diversity among populations probably result from recent drift. Coalescent model analysis suggests sika on each of the main Japanese islands have experienced different recent population histories. Hokkaido, which has large areas of continuous habitat, has maintained high levels of gene flow. In Honshu the population is highly fragmented and is likely to have been evolving by drift alone. In Kyushu there has been a balance between gene flow and drift but all the populations have experienced high levels of drift. Habitat fragment size was not significantly associated with genetic diversity in populations but there was a significant correlation between habitat fragment size and effective population size.     

The impact of management practices and past demographic history on the genetic diversity of red deer (Cervus elaphus): an assessment of population and individual fitness

The influences of management practices and past demographic history on genetic diversity are of critical relevance to sustainable practices and the conservation of wildlife populations. The red deer (Cervus elaphus) is an interesting model species to address these questions because it has a wide geographical distribution and it has been intensively managed for humans in the last decades. In the present study, we have analyzed the impact of recent management practices on the genetic diversity of Iberian red deer populations and assessed the genetic variation effects on population and individual fitness‐related traits. Four populations subjected to distinct management systems were selected: Cabañeros (CB) and Doñana (DN), not hunted populations; Fraga/Caspe (FG/CP), open hunting area with very low or absent management; and PE, fenced private hunting estate founded 31 years ago through the introduction of deer of different origins. Ten microsatellites were amplified in a total of 172 individuals. Additionally, several fitness‐related traits such as the presence of tuberculosis compatible lesions (TBCL), spleen weight (SW), and body length (BL) were estimated. We found a marked genetic variation and differentiation among populations, suggesting a strong population structure. In the fenced population, the introduction of genetically distinct animals has led to high genetic variability (no evidence of inbreeding) despite intensive management. Lower levels of genetic diversity were observed in two historically isolated natural populations (DN and FG/CP). The past demographic history of Iberian populations appears to be more relevant than the current management policy in shaping the genetic variability of natural populations. Population genetic diversity may correlate with life‐history traits and disease susceptibility, which could compromise the conservation and management of these wildlife populations. Although no significant effects of individual genetic diversity (general and local effect hypotheses) were observed on TBCL, SW and BL, some single‐locus effects had almost significant trends for the TBCL and SW traits. © 2013 The Linnean Society of London, Biological Journal of the Linnean Society, 2014, 111 , 209–223.     

Positioning the Red Deer (Cervus elaphus) Hunted by the Tyrolean Iceman into a Mitochondrial DNA Phylogeny

In the last years several phylogeographic studies of both extant and extinct red deer populations have been conducted. Three distinct mitochondrial lineages (western, eastern and North-African/Sardinian) have been identified reflecting different glacial refugia and postglacial recolonisation processes. However, little is known about the genetics of the Alpine populations and no mitochondrial DNA sequences from Alpine archaeological specimens are available. Here we provide the first mitochondrial sequences of an Alpine Copper Age Cervus elaphus. DNA was extracted from hair shafts which were part of the remains of the clothes of the glacier mummy known as the Tyrolean Iceman or Ötzi (5,350–5,100 years before present). A 2,297 base pairs long fragment was sequenced using a mixed sequencing procedure based on PCR amplifications and 454 sequencing of pooled amplification products. We analyzed the phylogenetic relationships of the Alpine Copper Age red deer''s haplotype with haplotypes of modern and ancient European red deer. The phylogenetic analyses showed that the haplotype of the Alpine Copper Age red deer falls within the western European mitochondrial lineage in contrast with the current populations from the Italian Alps belonging to the eastern lineage. We also discussed the phylogenetic relationships of the Alpine Copper Age red deer with the populations from Mesola Wood (northern Italy) and Sardinia.     

Consequences for genetic diversity and population performance of introducing continental red deer into the northern distribution range

For several centuries, game management has involved translocations of non-native individuals of many species to reinforce local native populations. However, there are few quantitative studies of potentially negative effects on population viability as expected when taxa with different local adaptations hybridise. The European red deer has been subject to particularly many translocations. Around 1900, a total of 17 red deer of Hungarian (Cervus elaphus hippelaphus) and German (C. e. germanicus) origin were introduced onto the island of Otterøya in Norway where few native red deer (C. e. atlanticus) remained (n ~ 13). To assess interbreeding, the present stock on Otterøya and the indigenous Norwegian and Hungarian populations were characterised in 14 microsatellite loci and in the control region of mtDNA. An intermediate level of genetic variation in the Otterøya population and the presence of population specific alleles from both the indigenous Norwegian and the Hungarian population demonstrate that the introduced red deer interbred with the native. Even distributions of one indigenous and one non-indigenous mtDNA haplotype in the Otterøya population and two point estimates of admixture indicate similar genetic contributions from the two parental populations into the hybrid stock. Low numbers of migrants identified with Bayesian assignment tests demonstrate low recent gene flow from Otterøya into the Norwegian mainland population. The Otterøya hybrid stock has grown vastly in numbers during recent decades, suggesting a high population viability. We observed that the body mass of red deer on Otterøya was similar or greater than in adjacent indigenous Norwegian stocks, indicating that population performance has not been reduced in the hybrid stock and that gene flow probably has not had any negative effects.     

Genetic diversity, gene flow and drift in Bavarian red deer populations (Cervus elaphus)

The red deer (Cervus elaphus) populationof Bavaria in Southern Germany was severelyreduced during the 19th century due toover-hunting. The species has since recoveredwithin designated areas. Subsequent habitatfragmentation presumably has changed thegenetic structure of Bavarian red deer.In order to assess the genetic diversity, weanalysed samples obtained from nine differentBavarian and two adjacent (Thueringen andCzech-Republic) red deer populations,genotyping 19 microsatellite loci. Our analysesrevealed moderate and significant differencesin diversity. Referring to assignment tests,the genetic differentiation of Bavarian reddeer was sufficient to assign an individual'sorigin to the correct population at an averageof 91.6%. The correlation of genetic andgeographic distance matrices revealed noevidence for isolation by distance. Thecoalescent model analysis suggests that thegenetic structure used to be characterized by adrift–gene flow equilibrium and is nowinfluenced by drift and disruption of the geneflow. Only three of the examined populationsshowed a probability of less than 10% that twogenes within these populations share a commonancestor (F _IS-value). Twopopulations had high F _IS values,indicating the influence of drift.Additionally, the intrapopulation indicesrevealed a low variability in thesepopulations. The estimated effective populationsizes (N _e) were generally in thesame range as the actual population sizes. Theinbreeding rates, based on the estimated N _e, and the inbreeding coefficientssuggested that the Bavarian red deerpopulations are in a stable state.     

Differentiation of Alpine marmot populations traced by DNA fingerprinting.

As revealed by allozyme studies, the genetic variation of the Alpine marmot (Marmota m. marmota) has been reduced by a species-wide bottleneck at the end of the last glaciation. Therefore the more variable microsatellite loci were used as a genetic marker system to investigate variablility and differentiation of four autochthonous and four allochthonous populations founded by the release of small numbers of individuals during the last 150 years. The microsatellite loci detected by the DNA-probe (ATCC)₄ were found to be polymorphic in all populations, but the amount of variation was lower than in comparable mammalian species. In spite of founder effects the variation in the allochthonous populations was not significanlty reduced compared to the autochthonous populations. The autochthonous populations from Austria and from the eastern part of Switzerland were genetically similar, only the population from western Switzerland was clearly differentiated from the others. In the allochthonous populations similarities in the microsatellite patterns reveal genetic affinities to putative autochthonous source populations of the founder individuals.     

A genetic study of sika (Cervus nippon) in the New Forest and in the Purbeck region, southern England: is there evidence of recent or past hybridization with red deer (Cervus elaphus)?

Sika Cervus nippon are native to Japan and East Asia but are now naturalized in many parks of the world, including Britain. In contrast to the substantial body of research on the extent of hybridization between sika and red deer Cervus elaphus in Scottish populations, there has been little genetic analysis of the English populations of sika. Sika in England still have a patchy and discontinuous distribution; populations are thus still genetically isolated and may be expected to show higher variability in genetic type. The current paper uses DNA-based techniques to explore the genetic composition of sika in the New Forest (Hampshire) and that of sika from the largest population in England, in the Purbeck region (Dorset). The study aims were to determine whether New Forest sika show signs of recent interbreeding with New Forest red deer populations, whether New Forest sika are genetically distinct from Purbeck sika, and whether New Forest and Purbeck sika show evidence of past hybridization or whether they are pure (non-hybrid) strains. Microsatellite analysis was used to compare the genetic profiles of individual deer. Results showed that sika and red deer in the New Forest were genetically distinct, indicating that there is no large-scale in situ hybridization occurring between these feral populations. In terms of overall genetic composition, there was no significant difference between the sika in the New Forest and Purbeck. However, a more detailed analysis found that New Forest sika showed a lower level of introgression with red deer compared with the Purbeck sika. We conclude that, overall, the New Forest sika deer do appear to be more genetically pure bred than the Purbeck sika.     

梅花鹿的微卫星多态性及种群的遗传结构

梅花鹿是我国极度濒危的鹿科动物,其野生种群已濒临灭绝。为了探讨我国野生梅花鹿的保护和管理对策,我们选用了16 个微卫星位点检测来自东北、四川、江西和浙江种群的122 份样品,以此分析我国野生梅花鹿种群的遗传多样性和遗传结构。费希尔确切性检验表明,四个种群中均存在偏离哈迪- 温伯格平衡的现象。与其它的濒危动物相比,中国梅花鹿有着相对较高的遗传多样性:每个位点的平均等位基因数为4 个,平均期望杂合度为0. 559。四个种群中,东北种群拥有最高的平均等位基因数(n = 3. 688),东北种群、四川种群、江西种群以及浙江种群的平均期望杂合度分别为0. 584,0. 477,0. 585 和0.589,它们之间不存在显著的差异。同时,利用逐步突变模型、双相突变模型和无限等位基因突变模型检测了种群的瓶颈效应,结果表明:除四川种群外,其他种群在近期内都经历过遗传瓶颈。费希尔确切性检验及配对样品F ST 的结果均表明:四个梅花鹿种群间存在显著的遗传分化(P < 0. 001)。因此,我们建议将我国梅花鹿的野生种群划分为4 个管理单元进行保护和
管理。