Differences in gene expression levels and in enzymatic qualities account for the uneven contribution of superoxide dismutases SodCI and SodCII to pathogenicity in Salmonella enterica

Most Salmonella enterica serovars produce two periplasmic [Cu,Zn] superoxide dismutases, SodCI, which is prophage encoded, and SodCII, encoded by a conserved chromosomal gene. Both enzymes were proposed to enhance Salmonella virulence by protecting bacteria against products of macrophage oxidative burst. However, we previously found SodCI, but not SodCII, to play a role during mouse infection by S. enterica serovar Typhimurium. Here we have extended these findings to another serovar of epidemiological relevance: sv Enteritidis. In both serovars, the dominant role of SodCI in virulence correlates with its higher levels in bacteria proliferating in mouse tissues, relative to SodCII. To analyze the basis of these differences, the coding sequences of sodCI and sodCII genes were exchanged with the reciprocal 5'-regions (in serovar Typhimurium). The accumulation patterns of the two proteins in vivo were reversed as a result, indicating that the regulatory determinants lie entirely within the regions upstream from the initiation codon. In the construct with the sodCI gene fused to the sodCII 5'-region, SodCI contribution to virulence was reduced but remained significant. Thus, both, high-level expression and some unidentified qualities of the enzyme participate in the phenotypic dominance of SodCI over SodCII in Salmonella pathogenicity.     

Differences in enzymatic properties allow SodCI but not SodCII to contribute to virulence in Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium strain 14028

Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium produces two Cu/Zn cofactored periplasmic superoxide dismutases, SodCI and SodCII. While mutations in sodCI attenuate virulence eightfold, loss of SodCII does not confer a virulence phenotype, nor does it enhance the defect observed in a sodCI background. Despite this in vivo phenotype, SodCI and SodCII are expressed at similar levels in vitro during the stationary phase of growth. By exchanging the open reading frames of sodCI and sodCII, we found that SodCI contributes to virulence when placed under the control of the sodCII promoter. In contrast, SodCII does not contribute to virulence even when expressed from the sodCI promoter. Thus, the disparity in virulence phenotypes is due primarily to some physical difference between the two enzymes. In an attempt to identify the unique property of SodCI, we have tested factors that might affect enzyme activity inside a phagosome. We found no significant difference between SodCI and SodCII in their resistance to acid, resistance to hydrogen peroxide, or ability to obtain copper in a copper-limiting environment. Both enzymes are synthesized as apoenzymes in the absence of copper and can be fully remetallated when copper is added. The one striking difference that we noted is that, whereas SodCII is released normally by an osmotic shock, SodCI is "tethered" within the periplasm by an apparently noncovalent interaction. We propose that this novel property of SodCI is crucial to its ability to contribute to virulence in serovar Typhimurium.     

Bacterial copper- and zinc-cofactored superoxide dismutase contributes to the pathogenesis of systemic salmonellosis

Copper/zinc-cofactored superoxide dismutase ([Cu,Zn]-SOD) has been found in the periplasm of many bacterial species but its biological function is unknown. Here we report the cloning and characterization of sodC , encoding [Cu,Zn]-SOD, from Salmonella typhimurium . The predicted protein sequence shows only 58% identity to Escherichia coli SodC, and from this its chromosomal location and its immediate proximity to a phage gene, sodC , in Salmonella is speculated to have been acquired by bacteriophage-mediated horizontal transfer from an unknown donor. A sodC mutant of S . typhimurium was unimpaired on aerobic growth in rich medium but showed enhanced sensitivity in vitro to the microbicidal action of superoxide. S . typhimurium , S . choleraesuis and S . dublin sodC mutants showed reduced lethality in a mouse model of oral infection and persisted in significantly lower numbers in livers and spleens after intraperitoneal infection, suggesting that [Cu,Zn]-SOD plays a role in pathogenicity, protecting Salmonella against oxygen radical-mediated host defences. There was, however, no observable difference compared with wild type in the interaction of sodC mutants with porcine pleural, mouse peritoneal or J774 macrophages in vitro , perhaps reflecting the hierarchical capacity of different macrophage lines to kill Salmonella , the most efficient overwhelming the proposed protective effect of periplasmic SOD.     

Structural properties of periplasmic SodCI that correlate with virulence in Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium

Salmonella enterica strains survive and propagate in macrophages by both circumventing and resisting the antibacterial effectors normally delivered to the phagosome. An important aspect of Salmonella resistance is the production of periplasmic superoxide dismutase to combat phagocytic superoxide. S. enterica serovar Typhimurium strain 14028 produces two periplasmic superoxide dismutases: SodCI and SodCII. Both enzymes are produced during infection, but only SodCI contributes to virulence in the animal. Although 60% identical to SodCII at the amino acid level with very similar enzymatic properties, SodCI is dimeric, protease resistant, and tethered within the periplasm via a noncovalent interaction. In contrast, SodCII is monomeric and protease sensitive and is released from the periplasm normally by osmotic shock. We have constructed an enzymatically active monomeric SodCI enzyme by site-directed mutagenesis. The resulting protein was released by osmotic shock and sensitive to protease and could not complement the loss of wild-type dimeric SodCI during infection. To distinguish which property is most critical during infection, we cloned and characterized related SodC proteins from a variety of bacteria. Brucella abortus SodC was monomeric and released by osmotic shock but was protease resistant and could complement SodCI in the animal. These data suggest that protease resistance is a critical property that allows SodCI to function in the harsh environment of the phagosome to combat phagocytic superoxide. We propose a model to account for the various properties of SodCI and how they contribute to bacterial survival in the phagosome.     

Periplasmic Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase and cytoplasmic Dps concur in protecting Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium from extracellular reactive oxygen species

Several bacteria possess periplasmic Cu,Zn superoxide dismutases which can confer protection from extracellular reactive oxygen species. Thus, deletion of the sodC1 gene reduces Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium ability to colonize the spleens of wild type mice, but enhances virulence in p47phox mutant mice. To look into the role of periplamic Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase and into possible additive effects of the ferritin-like Dps protein involved in hydrogen peroxide detoxification, we have analyzed bacterial survival in response to extracellular sources of superoxide and/or hydrogen peroxide. Exposure to extracellular superoxide of Salmonella Typhimurium mutant strains lacking the sodC1 and sodC2 genes and/or the dps gene does not cause direct killing of bacteria, indicating that extracellular superoxide is poorly bactericidal. In contrast, all mutant strains display a sharp hydrogen peroxide-dependent loss of viability, the dps,sodC1,sodC2 mutant being less resistant than the dps or the sodC1,sodC2 mutants. These findings suggest that the role of Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase in bacteria is to remove rapidly superoxide from the periplasm to prevent its reaction with other reactive molecules. Moreover, the nearly additive effect of the sodC and dps mutations suggests that localization of antioxidant enzymes in different cellular compartments is required for bacterial resistance to extracytoplasmic oxidative attack.     

Either periplasmic tethering or protease resistance is sufficient to allow a SodC to protect Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium from phagocytic superoxide

Salmonella Typhimurium combats phagocytic superoxide by producing the periplasmic superoxide dismutase, SodCI. The homologous protein, SodCII, is also produced during infection, but does not contribute to virulence. The proteins physically differ in that SodCI is dimeric, protease resistant and non-covalently tethered within the periplasm. Conversely, SodCII is a protease-sensitive monomer that is released normally from the periplasm by osmotic shock. To identify which properties correlate with virulence, we constructed over 20 enzymatically functional hybrid SodC proteins and assayed them for protease susceptibility, release by osmotic shock, multimerization and affinity for metal cofactors. Protease susceptibility maps to the C-terminus of SodCII, while SodCI residues 120-131 are required for tethering. A protease-resistant SodCII hybrid was able to substitute for SodCI during infection. Interestingly, a tethered but protease-sensitive SodCII hybrid was also able to confer protection. Thus, either tethering or protease resistance is sufficient for a SodC to function during infection. These results support our model that in the macrophage, the outer membrane of Salmonella is partially disrupted by antimicrobial peptides. Periplasmic proteins, including SodCII, are released and/or phagocytic proteases gain access. SodCI is both tethered within the periplasm and protease resistant, thereby surviving to detoxify superoxide.     

Differential contribution of sodC1 and sodC2 to intracellular survival and pathogenicity of Salmonella enterica serovar Choleraesuis

Several of the most virulent Salmonella enterica strains possess two genes encoding periplasmic Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase, sodC1 and sodC2, located on a lambdoid prophage and on the chromosome, respectively. These genes contribute to Salmonella virulence by protecting bacteria from superoxide generated by the host's phagocytes. To investigate the respective contributions of sodC1 and sodC2 to the virulence of a clinical isolate of Salmonella enterica serovar Choleraesuis (S. choleraesuis), we have analyzed both the intracellular survival of wild type and sodC mutant strains within J774 macrophages and Caco-2 cells, and their ability to proliferate in intraperitoneally-infected mice in competition assays. In agreement with previous studies, mutant strains lacking one or both sodC genes were equally impaired in their ability to survive within activated macrophages. However, when macrophage killing experiments were carried out with non-opsonized bacteria, sodC2 contributed to intracellular survival more than sodC1, indicating that changes in the pathways of bacterial uptake can modify the relative role of the two sodC genes. More unexpectedly, we have found that the ability of S. choleraesuis to survive within Caco-2 cells was severely affected by inactivation of sodC genes, sodC2 being more important than sodC1. As Caco-2 cells actively produce superoxide, this suggests that oxygen radical production by colonic cells has a role in controlling proliferation of facultative intracellular bacteria. Mouse infection studies confirmed that, in the S. choleraesuis strain under investigation, both sodC genes are required to confer full virulence, sodC2 contributing slightly more than sodC1 to Salmonella pathogenesis. Our findings contrast with the results of other studies carried out in S. enterica serovar Typhimurium and suggest that the relative contributions of sodC1 and sodC2 to host-pathogen interactive biology may vary depending on the Salmonella serovar or strain.     

Variable assortment of prophages provides a transferable repertoire of pathogenic determinants in Salmonella

Gene transfer between separate lineages of a bacterial pathogen can promote recombinational divergence and the emergence of new pathogenic variants. Temperate bacteriophages, by virtue of their ability to carry foreign DNA, are potential key players in this process. Our previous work has shown that representative strains of Salmonella typhimurium (LT2, ATCC14028 and SL1344) are lysogenic for two temperate bacteriophages: Gifsy-1 and Gifsy-2. Several lines of evidence suggested that both elements carry genes that contribute to Salmonella virulence. One such gene, on the Gifsy-2 prophage, codes for the [Cu, Zn] superoxide dismutase SodCI. Other putative pathogenicity determinants were uncovered more recently. These include genes for known or presumptive type III-translocated proteins and a locus, duplicated on both prophages, showing sequence similarity to a gene involved in Salmonella enteropathogenesis (pipA). In addition to Gifsy-1 and Gifsy-2, each of the above strains was found to harbour a specific set of prophages also carrying putative pathogenicity determinants. A phage released from strain LT2 and identified as phage Fels-1 carries the nanH gene and a novel sodC gene, which was named sodCIII. Strain ATCC14028 releases a lambdoid phage, named Gifsy-3, which contains the phoP/phoQ-activated pagJ gene and the gene for the secreted leucine-rich repeat protein SspH1. Finally, a phage specifically released from strain SL1344 was identified as SopEPhi. Most phage-associated loci transferred efficiently between Salmonella strains of the same or different serovars. Overall, these results suggest that lysogenic conversion is a major mechanism driving the evolution of Salmonella bacteria.     

Periplasmic Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase and cytoplasmic Dps concur in protecting Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium from extracellular reactive oxygen species

Several bacteria possess periplasmic Cu,Zn superoxide dismutases which can confer protection from extracellular reactive oxygen species. Thus, deletion of the sodC1 gene reduces Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium ability to colonize the spleens of wild type mice, but enhances virulence in p47phox mutant mice. To look into the role of periplamic Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase and into possible additive effects of the ferritin-like Dps protein involved in hydrogen peroxide detoxification, we have analyzed bacterial survival in response to extracellular sources of superoxide and/or hydrogen peroxide. Exposure to extracellular superoxide of Salmonella Typhimurium mutant strains lacking the sodC1 and sodC2 genes and/or the dps gene does not cause direct killing of bacteria, indicating that extracellular superoxide is poorly bactericidal. In contrast, all mutant strains display a sharp hydrogen peroxide-dependent loss of viability, the dps,sodC1,sodC2 mutant being less resistant than the dps or the sodC1,sodC2 mutants. These findings suggest that the role of Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase in bacteria is to remove rapidly superoxide from the periplasm to prevent its reaction with other reactive molecules. Moreover, the nearly additive effect of the sodC and dps mutations suggests that localization of antioxidant enzymes in different cellular compartments is required for bacterial resistance to extracytoplasmic oxidative attack.     

Periplasmic superoxide dismutase SodCI of Salmonella binds peptidoglycan to remain tethered within the periplasm

Salmonellae survive and propagate in macrophages to cause serious systemic disease. Periplasmic superoxide dismutase plays a critical role in this survival by combating phagocytic superoxide. Salmonella Typhimurium strain 14028 produces two periplasmic superoxide dismutases: SodCI and SodCII. Although both proteins are produced during infection, only SodCI is functional in the macrophage phagosome. We have previously shown that SodCI, relative to SodCII, is both protease resistant and tethered within the periplasm and that either of these properties is sufficient to allow a SodC to protect against phagocytic superoxide. Tethering is defined as remaining cell‐associated after osmotic shock or treatment with cationic antimicrobial peptides. Here we show that SodCI non‐covalently binds peptidoglycan. SodCI binds to Salmonella and Bacillus peptidoglycan, but not peptidoglycan from Staphylococcus. Moreover, binding can be inhibited by a diaminopimelic acid containing tripeptide, but not a lysine containing tripeptide, showing that the protein recognizes the peptide portion of the peptidoglycan. Replacing nine amino acids in SodCII with the corresponding residues from SodCI confers tethering, partially delineating an apparently novel peptidoglycan binding domain. These changes in sequence increase the affinity of SodCII for peptidoglycan fragments to match that of SodCI and allow the now tethered SodCII to function during infection.     

Inducible prophages contribute to Salmonella virulence in mice

We show that Salmonella typhimurium harbours two fully functional prophages, Gifsy-1 and Gifsy-2, that can be induced by standard treatments or, more effectively, by exposing bacteria to hydrogen peroxide. Curing bacteria for the Gifsy-2 prophage significantly reduces Salmonella's ability to establish a systemic infection in mice. Cured strains recover their virulence properties upon relysogenization. Phage Gifsy-2 carries the sodC gene for a periplasmic [Cu,Zn]-superoxide dismutase previously implicated in the bacterial defences against killing by macrophages. The contribution of the Gifsy-1 prophage to virulence - undetectable in the presence of Gifsy-2 as prophage - becomes significant in cells that lack Gifsy-2 but carry the sodC gene integrated in the chromosome. This confirms the involvement of Gifsy-2-encoded SodC protein in Salmonella pathogenicity and suggests that the Gifsy-1 prophage carries one or more additional virulence genes that have a functional equivalent on the Gifsy-2 genome.     

Identification of GtgE,a novel virulence factor encoded on the Gifsy-2 bacteriophage of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium

The Gifsy-2 temperate bacteriophage of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium contributes significantly to the pathogenicity of strains that carry it as a prophage. Previous studies have shown that Gifsy-2 encodes SodCI, a periplasmic Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase, and at least one additional virulence factor. Gifsy-2 encodes a Salmonella pathogenicity island 2 type III secreted effector protein. Sequence analysis of the Gifsy-2 genome also identifies several open reading frames with homology to those of known virulence genes. However, we found that null mutations in these genes did not individually have a significant effect on the ability of S. enterica serovar Typhimurium to establish a systemic infection in mice. Using deletion analysis, we have identified a gene, gtgE, which is necessary for the full virulence of S. enterica serovar Typhimurium Gifsy-2 lysogens. Together, GtgE and SodCI account for the contribution of Gifsy-2 to S. enterica serovar Typhimurium virulence in the murine model.     

Identification of sodC encoding periplasmic [Cu,Zn]-superoxide dismutase in Salmonella

Abstract sodC , encoding [Cu,Zn]-cofactored Superoxide dismutase, once thought to be virtually confined to eukaryotes, has now been described in many Gram-negative pathogens that have their primary niche of colonization in the upper respiratory tract. Their role in host-parasite interactive biology is unknown. We here show that members of the major human and animal enteric pathogenic species Salmonella harbour a version of sodC most closely resembling that found in Brucella abortus . The enzyme it encodes is a novel candidate determinant of virulence in Salmonella , an intracellular pathogen potentially exposed to toxic oxygen free radicals within its intracellular niche.     

A fresh view of the cell biology of copper in enterobacteria

Copper ions are essential but also very toxic. Copper resistance in bacteria is based on export of the toxic ion, oxidation from Cu(I) to Cu(II), and sequestration by copper‐binding metal chaperones, which deliver copper ions to efflux systems or metal‐binding sites of copper‐requiring proteins. In their publication in this issue, Osman et al. ( 2013 ) demonstrate how tightly copper resistance, homeostasis and delivery pathways are interwoven in Salmonella enterica sv. Typhimurium. Copper is transported from the cytoplasm by the two P‐type ATPases CopA and GolT to the periplasm and transferred to SodCII by CueP, a periplasmic copper chaperone. When copper levels are higher, SodCII is also able to bind copper without the help of CueP. This scheme raises the question as to why copper ions present in the growth medium have to make the detour through the cytoplasm. The data presented in the publication by Osman et al. ( 2013 ) change our view of the cell biology of copper in enterobacteria.     

Regulation of the synthesis of superoxide dismutases in rat lungs during oxidant and hyperthermic stresses

Heat shock proteins are induced at normal temperatures by oxidants and during reoxygenation following hypoxia. We now report cyanide-resistant O2 consumption increased 30-50% in rat lungs exposed to heat shock or reoxygenation following hypoxia. The synthesis of Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase, but not Mn superoxide dismutase, was increased in rat lung slices by in vivo hyperthermia (39 degrees C), by in vitro heat shock (41 degrees C), and during incubation of lung slices with the Cu chelator diethyldithiocarbamate, which decreased the activity of Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase. The heat shock-induced increase in Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase developed 2 h later than the induction of heat shock proteins and was not blocked by actinomycin D. The rates of synthesis of both superoxide dismutases were decreased 50% by hypoxia and failed to increase during reoxygenation. During hypoxia the activity of Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase decreased about 50%, but the activity of Mn superoxide dismutase remained unchanged. We conclude that hyperthermia increases the synthesis of Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase, the synthesis of Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase and Mn superoxide dismutase are not coordinately regulated by hyperthermia or by the oxidant stress produced by lowering the activity of Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase, and the synthesis of heat shock proteins and Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase are regulated at different levels of gene expression.