Dark chilling effects on soybean genotypes during vegetative development: parallel studies of CO2 assimilation,chlorophyll a fluorescence kinetics O-J-I-P and nitrogen fixation

The effects of dark chilling on CO2 assimilation, chlorophyll a fluorescence kinetics and nitrogen fixation were compared in two Glycine max (L.) Merr. genotypes. The aim was to elucidate the mechanisms by which photosynthesis was inhibited as well as identification of selection criteria for dark chilling tolerance. Seedlings were dark chilled (8 degrees C) for 9 consecutive nights but kept at normal day temperatures (28 degrees C). CO2 gas exchange analysis indicated that photosynthesis in Maple Arrow was inhibited largely as a result of stomatal limitation, while in Fiskeby V, it indicated inhibition of the mesophyll reactions. Increased intercellular CO2 concentration and decreased carboxylation efficiency suggested loss of Rubisco activity in Fiskeby V, although no effect on the KM (CO2) of Rubisco was observed. Quantification and deconvolution of the Chl a fluorescence transients into several phenomenological and biophysical parameters (JIP-test) revealed large genotypic differences in the response of PSII to dark chilling. These parameters differentially changed in the two genotypes during the progression of the chilling treatment. Among them, the performance index, reflecting several responses of the photochemical apparatus, provided the best preliminary overall assessment of the genotypes. In contrast, the quantum yield of primary photochemistry varphiPo (FV/FM) was quite insensitive. The recovery of most of the JIP-test parameters in Maple Arrow after 6 and 9 nights of dark chilling was a major genotypic difference. Genotypic differences were also observed with regard to the ureide response and N2 fixation appeared to be more sensitive to dark chilling than CO2 assimilation. The JIP-test provided information consistent with results derived from CO2 assimilation and N2 fixation studies suggesting that it can substitute the much more time-consuming methods for the detection of chilling stress and can well satisfy the requirements of a rapid and accurate screening method.     

Separately and simultaneously induced dark chilling and drought stress effects on photosynthesis, proline accumulation and antioxidant metabolism in soybean

The effects of separately or simultaneously induced dark chilling and drought stress were evaluated in two Glycine max (L.) Merrill cultivars. For the separately induced dark chilling treatment (C), plants were incubated at 8 °C during 9 consecutive dark periods. During the days, plants were kept at normal growth temperatures. For the separately induced drought treatment (D), plants were maintained at normal growth temperatures without irrigation. For the simultaneously induced dark chilling and drought stress treatment (CD), plants were dark chilled without irrigation. All treatments caused similar decreases in pre-dawn leaf water potential, but resulted in distinct physiological and biochemical effects on photosynthesis. In Maple Arrow, where C had the smallest effect on photosynthesis, prolonged CD caused less inhibition of photosynthesis compared to D. Compared to Fiskeby V, the photosynthetic apparatus of Maple Arrow appears to possess superior dark chilling tolerance, a property which probably also conveyed enhanced protection against CD. Proline accumulation was prevented by CD at the ψ_PD where D already resulted in considerable accumulation. The superior capacity for proline accumulation in Maple Arrow would seem to be an important factor in its stress tolerance. Antioxidant activity evoked by CD and D was higher than for C alone. In Fiskeby V, the small increase in ascorbate peroxidase (EC 1.11.1.7) activity, which was in most cases not accompanied by increased gluthatione reductase (EC 1.6.4.2) activity, could impact negatively on its stress tolerance. These results demonstrate large genotypic differences in response to chilling and drought stress, even between soybean cultivars regarded as chilling tolerant.     

The expression of photosynthetic traits during and following severe chilling stress of European and tropical maize genotypes

Four genotypes of maize ( Zea mays L.), one from North-West Europe, two from tropical highlands and one from tropical lowlands were grown at 24°C until full expansion of the second leaf. Seedlings were then subjected to 2 days at 5°C, with or without a previous conditioning phase at 10°C for 4 days. After stress plants were allowed to recover at 24°C for 5 days. Previous conditioning protected the tropical lowland variety to some extent against losses in chlorophyll content and ribulose I,5-bisphosphate carboxylase (EC 4.1.1.39) activity by severe chilling stress. Without conditioning heavy losses occurred during the recovery phase. In all other genotypes the values of these traits decreased more with than without conditioning. Phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (EC 4.1.1.31) activity was little affected during stress, but declined considerably during the recovery phase, with the exception of the North-West European genotype. Previous conditioning prevented or retarded losses of NADP⁺ malate dehydrogenase (EC 1.1.1.82) activity during the stress phase. However, at the end of the recovery phase losses were as high with as without conditioning, and activity was very low in one tropical highland genotype and in the tropical lowland genotype. In summary, the chilling stability of photosynthetic traits was better in the North-West European genotype than in the tropical ones.     

Regulation of photosynthesis and antioxidant metabolism in maize leaves at optimal and chilling temperatures: review

Maize (Zea mays L.) is a chilling (below 15 °C) sensitive plant that shows little capacity to acclimate to low growth temperatures. Maize leaves are extremely sensitive to chilling injury, which usually results in premature leaf senescence. Leaves exposed to temperatures below 10 °C in the light show substantial inhibition of CO₂ assimilation and down-regulation of photosynthetic electron transport. However, the intrinsic relationships between the quantum efficiencies of photosystems I and II are not modified by chilling. Moreover, the integral relationships between non-cyclic electron transport and CO₂ fixation are similar in chilled and unchilled leaves. In this review we examine the roles and importance of photosynthetic regulation, carbon metabolism and antioxidant metabolism in determining the sensitivity of maize leaf photosynthesis to chilling. The distinct cellular localisation patterns of antioxidant enzymes such as glutathione reductase (EC 1.6.4.2) and dehydroascorbate reductase (EC 1.8.5.1) can restrict the recycling of antioxidants associated with photosynthesis during chilling. Disruption of circadian regulation of metabolism and insufficient antioxidant defence are postulated to cause chilling sensitivity.     

The role of low soil temperature in the inhibition of growth and PSII function during dark chilling in soybean genotypes of contrasting tolerance

Dark chilling affects growth and yield of warm-climate crops such as soybean [ Glycine max (L.) Merr.]. Several studies have investigated chilling-stress effects on photosynthesis and other aspects of metabolism, but none have compared effects of whole-plant chilling (WPC; shoots and roots) with that of aboveground chilling in legumes. This is important because low root temperatures might induce additional constraints, such as inhibition of N₂ fixation, thereby aggravating chilling-stress symptoms. Effects of dark chilling on PSII, shoot growth, leaf ureide content and photosynthetic capacity were studied in two soybean genotypes, Highveld Top (chilling tolerant) and PAN809 (chilling sensitive), in experiments comparing effects of WPC with that of shoot chilling (SC). Both treatments inhibited shoot growth in PAN809 but not Highveld Top. Also, WPC in PAN809 caused a decrease in leaf ureide content followed by severe chlorosis and alterations in O-J-I-P fluorescence-rise kinetics, distinct from SC. A noteworthy difference was the appearance of a ΔK peak in the O-J-I-P fluorescence rise in response to WPC. These genotypic and treatment differences also reflected in the degree of inhibition of CO₂ assimilation rates. The appearance of a ΔK peak, coupled with growth inhibition, reduced ureide content, chlorosis and lower CO₂ assimilation rates, provides mechanistic information about how WPC might have aggravated chilling-stress symptoms in PAN809. We introduce a model explaining how chilling soil temperatures might trigger N-limitation in sensitive genotypes and how characteristic changes in O-J-I-P fluorescence-rise kinetics are linked to changes in carbon and nitrogen metabolism.     

The relationship between CO2 assimilation, photosynthetic electron transport and water–water cycle in chill-exposed cucumber leaves under low light and subsequent recovery

The effects of chilling under low light (9/7 °C, 100 µmol m^?2 s^?1) on the photosynthetic and antioxidant capacities and subsequent recovery were examined in two (one tolerant and one sensitive) cucumber genotypes. Chilling resulted in an irreversible inhibition of net CO₂ assimilation and growth for the sensitive genotype, which was accompanied by decreases in the maximum velocity of RuBP carboxylation by Rubisco (V_cmax), the capacity for ribulose‐1,5‐bisphosphate regeneration (J_max), Rubisco content and activity, and the quantum efficiency of photosystem II, in the absence of any stomatal limitation of CO₂ supply or inorganic phosphate limitation. In contrast, CO₂ assimilation for the tolerant genotype fully recovered after chill. The chill‐induced decrease in the proportion of electron flux for photosynthetic carbon reduction was mostly compensated by an O₂‐dependent alternative electron flux driven by the water–water cycle, especially in the sensitive genotype. Compared with the tolerant genotype, the sensitive genotype after chill showed reduced capacity for scavenging reactive oxygen species and increased accumulation of reactive oxygen species. The balance between O₂‐dependent alternative electron flux and the capacity for scavenging reactive oxygen species in response to chill plays a major role in determining the tolerance of cucumber leaves to this stress factor. It is concluded that the water–water cycle operates at high rates when CO₂ assimilation is restricted in cucumber leaves subjected to chill and low light conditions.     

Effect of Chilling on Carbon Assimilation,Enzyme Activation,and Photosynthetic Electron Transport in the Absence of Photoinhibition in Maize Leaves

The relationships between electron transport and photosynthetic carbon metabolism were measured in maize (Zea mays L.) leaves following exposure to suboptimal temperatures. The quantum efficiency for electron transport in unchilled leaves was similar to that previously observed in C3 plants, although maize has two types of chloroplasts, mesophyll and bundle sheath, with PSII being largely absent from the latter. The index of noncyclic electron transport was proportional to the CO2 assimilation rate. Chilled leaves showed decreased rates of CO2 assimilation relative to unchilled leaves, but the integral relationships between the quantum efficiency for electron transport or the index of noncyclic electron transport and CO2 fixation were unchanged and there was no photoinhibition. The maximum catalytic activities of the Benson-Calvin cycle enzymes, fructose-1,6-bisphosphatase and ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase, were decreased following chilling, but activation was unaffected. Measurements of thiol-regulated enzymes, particularly NADP-malate dehydrogenase, indicated that chilling induced changes in the stromal redox state so that reducing equivalents were more plentiful. We conclude that chilling produces a decrease in photosynthetic capacity without changing the internal operational, regulatory or stoichiometric relationships between photosynthetic electron transport and carbon assimilation. The enzymes of carbon assimilation are particularly sensitive to chilling, but enhanced activation may compensate for decreases in maximal catalytic activity.     

Can genotypes of soybean (Glycine max) selected for nitrate tolerance provide good “models” for studying the mechanism of nitrate inhibition of nitrogenase activity?

In soybeans ( Glycine max L. Merr.), high levels of soil nitrate inhibit N₂ fixation, and nitrate-tolerant symbioses have been identified within a chemically mutagenized line of cv. Bragg denoted nts382 and within the line K466, a genotype representative of a number of Korean soybean cultivars. The genotypes nts382 and K466 were examined to see if they could be used as a model system for studying the mechanism responsible for the short-term (i.e. 3-day) inhibition of specific nitrogenase activity, especially the mechanism behind the greater O₂ limitation of nodule metabolism that is characteristic of nitrate inhibition of N₂ fixation in soybean. In nts382, total nitrogenase activity (TNA = H₂ production in Ar:O₂) was inhibited to a lesser degree (48% of control) relative to Bragg (30% of control), and the nitrate-treated symbioses showed less of an O₂ limitation of nodule metabolism in nts382 than in Bragg. However, the relative proportion of O₂ limitation to the total nitrate inhibition was similar (40 and 41%) in nts382 and Bragg, respectively. Therefore, the nts382 symbioses may be useful in elucidating the general mechanism for down-regulation of nitrogenase activity in soybean, but would not be a useful model system for studying the control of O₂-limited metabolism following nitrate exposure. The effects of nitrate on TNA and on the degree of O₂ limitation of nodule metabolism were the same in K466 and a reference cultivar Maple Arrow. Consequently, the tolerance of K466 to nitrate reported previously was attributed to the ability of this symbiosis to maintain nodule biomass in the presence of nitrate, not to any ability to maintain specific nitrogenase activity in the presence of nitrate.     

Elevated CO2 differentially affects photosynthetic induction response in two Populus species with different stomatal behavior

To understand dynamic photosynthetic characteristics in response to fluctuating light under a high CO(2) environment, we examined photosynthetic induction in two poplar genotypes from two species, Populus koreana 9 trichocarpa cv. Peace and Populus euramericana cv. I-55, respectively. Stomata of cv. Peace barely respond to changes in photosynthetic photon flux density (PFD), whereas those of cv. I-55 show a normal response to variations in PFD at ambient CO(2). The plants were grown under three CO2 regimes (380, 700, and 1,020 μmol CO(2) mol(-1) in air) for approximately 2 months. CO2 gas exchange was measured in situ in the three CO2 regimes under a sudden PFD increase from 20 to 800 μmol m(-2) s(-1). In both genotypes, plants grown under higher CO(2) conditions had a higher photosynthetic induction state, shorter induction time, and reduced induction limitation to photosynthetic carbon gain. Plants of cv. I-55 showed a much larger increase in induction state and decrease in induction time under high CO(2) regimes than did plants of cv. Peace. These showed that, throughout the whole induction process, genotype cv. I-55 had a much smaller reduction of leaf carbon gain under the two high CO(2) regimes than under the ambient CO(2) regime, while the high CO(2) effect was smaller in genotype cv. Peace. The results suggest that a high CO(2) environment can reduce both biochemical and stomatal limitations of leaf carbon gain during the photosynthetic induction process, and that a rapid stomatal response can further enhance the high CO(2) effect.     

Can genotypes of soybean (Glycine max) selected for nitrate tolerance provide good "models" for studying the mechanism of nitrate inhibition of nitrogenase activity?

In soybeans ( Glycine max L. Merr.), high levels of soil nitrate inhibit N₂ fixation, and nitrate-tolerant symbioses have been identified within a chemically mutagenized line of cv. Bragg denoted nts382 and within the line K466, a genotype representative of a number of Korean soybean cultivars. The genotypes nts382 and K466 were examined to see if they could be used as a model system for studying the mechanism responsible for the short-term (i.e. 3-day) inhibition of specific nitrogenase activity, especially the mechanism behind the greater O₂ limitation of nodule metabolism that is characteristic of nitrate inhibition of N₂ fixation in soybean. In nts382, total nitrogenase activity (TNA = H₂ production in Ar:O₂) was inhibited to a lesser degree (48% of control) relative to Bragg (30% of control), and the nitrate-treated symbioses showed less of an O₂ limitation of nodule metabolism in nts382 than in Bragg. However, the relative proportion of O₂ limitation to the total nitrate inhibition was similar (40 and 41%) in nts382 and Bragg, respectively. Therefore, the nts382 symbioses may be useful in elucidating the general mechanism for down-regulation of nitrogenase activity in soybean, but would not be a useful model system for studying the control of O₂-limited metabolism following nitrate exposure. The effects of nitrate on TNA and on the degree of O₂ limitation of nodule metabolism were the same in K466 and a reference cultivar Maple Arrow. Consequently, the tolerance of K466 to nitrate reported previously was attributed to the ability of this symbiosis to maintain nodule biomass in the presence of nitrate, not to any ability to maintain specific nitrogenase activity in the presence of nitrate.     

The response of the high altitude C(4) grass Muhlenbergia montana (Nutt.) A.S. Hitchc. to long- and short-term chilling.

The acclimation of C(4) photosynthesis to low temperature was studied in the montane grass Muhlenbergia montana in order to evaluate inherent limitations in the C(4) photosynthetic pathway following chilling. Plants were grown in growth cabinets at 26 degrees C days, but at night temperatures of either 16 degrees C (the control treatment), 4 degrees C for at least 28 nights (the cold-acclimated treatment), or 1 night (the cold-stress treatment). Below a measurement temperature of 25 degrees C, little difference in the thermal response of the net CO(2) assimilation rate (A) was observed between the control and cold-acclimated treatment. By contrast, above 30 degrees C, A in the cold-acclimated treatment was 10% greater than in the control treatment. The temperature responses of Rubisco activity and net CO(2) assimilation rate were similar below 22 degrees C, indicating high metabolic control of Rubisco over the rate of photosynthesis at cool temperatures. Analysis of the response of A to intercellular CO(2) level further supported a major limiting role for Rubisco below 20 degrees C. As temperature declined, the CO(2) saturated plateau of A exhibited large reductions, while the initial slope of the CO(2) response was little affected. This type of response is consistent with a Rubisco limitation, rather than limitations in PEP carboxylase capacity. Stomatal limitations at low temperature were not apparent because photosynthesis was CO(2) saturated below 23 degrees C at air levels of CO(2). In contrast to the response of photosynthesis to temperature and CO(2) in plants acclimated for 4 weeks to low night temperature, plants exposed to 4 degrees C for one night showed substantial reduction in photosynthetic capacity at temperatures above 20 degrees C. Because these reductions were at both high and low CO(2), enzymes associated with the C(4) carbon cycle were implicated as the major mechanisms for the chilling inhibition. These results demonstrate that C(4) plants from climates with low temperature during the growing season can fully acclimate to cold stress given sufficient time. This acclimation appears to involve reversal of injury to the C(4) cycle following initial exposure to low temperature. By contrast, carbon gain at low temperatures generally appears to be constrained by the carboxylation capacity of Rubisco, regardless of acclimation time. The inability to overcome the Rubisco limitation at low temperature may be an inherent limitation restricting C(4) photosynthetic performance in cooler climates.     

Dark chilling increases glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase activity in soybean leaves

Available evidence suggests that the stress‐induced increase in the activity of glucose‐6‐phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PDH, EC 1.1.1.49), the key regulatory enzyme of the oxidative pentose phosphate pathway, might often be related to the presence of plant water deficit. The response of G6PDH to dark chilling in chilling sensitive plant species is still unknown. In this communication we report on this response and its dependence on the presence of chill‐induced drought stress. A chilling sensitive soybean (Glycine max L. Merr.) genotype was exposed to dark chilling of the entire plant (whole‐chilled) or only the shoots and leaves (shoot‐chilled). The development of chill‐induced drought stress upon illumination was quantified by measurement of proline and relative water content (RWC). Chill‐induced drought stress (decrease in RWC and increase in proline content) developed with time in whole‐chilled plants, but not in shoot‐chilled plants. The response of the above‐mentioned treatments on G6PDH activity in fully expanded leaves was assessed. In parallel, the effects on CO₂ assimilation, PSII activity and chloroplast fructose‐1,6‐bisphosphatase (FBPase EC 3.1.3.11) and ribulose‐1,5‐bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco EC 4.1.1.39) activity were quantified. A decrease in CO₂ assimilation rate, FBPase activity and ribulose‐1,5‐bisphosphate (RuBP) content was observed in whole‐chilled but not in shoot‐chilled plants. However, in shoot‐chilled plants regulation of diurnal PSII activity was altered. The increase in the activation state of NADP‐dependent malate dehydrogenase (NADP‐MDH EC 1.1.1.82) in shoot‐chilled plants suggests an increase in stromal redox state. Although the two different dark chilling treatments resulted in distinct physiological and biochemical effects, both induced an increase in foliar G6PDH activity, suggesting an important role of this enzyme during and following dark chilling stress, irrespective of the presence of chill‐induced drought stress.     

An overnight chill induces a delayed inhibition of photosynthesis at midday in mango (Mangifera indica L.)

The effect of a cold night on photosynthesis in herbaceous chilling-sensitive crops, like tomato, has been extensively studied and is well characterized. This investigation examined the behaviour of the sub-tropical fruit tree, mango, to enable comparison with these well-studied systems. Unlike tomato, chilling between 5 degrees C and 7 degrees C overnight produced no significant inhibition of light-saturated CO(2) assimilation (A:) during the first hours following rewarming, measured either under controlled environment conditions or in the field. By midday, however, there was a substantial decline in A:, which could not be attributed to photoinhibition of PSII, but rather was associated with an increase in stomatal limitation of A: and lower Rubisco activity. Overnight chilling of tomato can cause severe disruption in the circadian regulation of key photosynthetic enzymes and is considered to be a major factor underlying the dysfunction of photosynthesis in chilling-sensitive herbaceous plants. Examination of the gas exchange of mango leaves maintained under constant conditions for 2 d, demonstrated that large depressions in A: during the subjective night were primarily the result of stomatal closure. Chilling did not disrupt the ability of mango leaves to produce a circadian rhythm in stomatal conductance. Rather, the midday increase in stomatal limitation of A: appeared to be the result of altered guard cell sensitivity to CO(2) following the dark chill.     

Limitations to photosynthesis of lettuce grown under tropical conditions: alleviation by root-zone cooling.

Aerial parts of lettuce plants were grown under natural tropical fluctuating ambient temperatures, but with their roots exposed to two different root-zone temperatures (RZTs): a constant 20 degrees C-RZT and a fluctuating ambient (A-) RZT from 23-40 degrees C. Plants grown at A-RZT showed lower photosynthetic CO2 assimilation (A), stomatal conductance (gs), midday leaf relative water content (RWC), and chlorophyll fluorescence ratio Fv/Fm than 20 degrees C-RZT plants on both sunny and cloudy days. Substantial midday depression of A and g(s) occurred on both sunny and cloudy days in both RZT treatments, although Fv/Fm did not vary diurnally on cloudy days. Reciprocal temperature transfer experiments investigated the occurrence and possible causes of stomatal and non-stomatal limitations of photosynthesis. For both temperature transfers, light-saturated stomatal conductance (gs sat) and photosynthetic CO2 assimilation (A(sat)) were highly correlated with each other and with midday RWC, suggesting that A was limited by water stress-mediated stomatal closure. However, prolonged growth at A-RZT reduced light- and CO2-saturated photosynthetic O2 evolution (Pmax), indicating non-stomatal limitation of photosynthesis. Tight temporal coupling of leaf nitrogen content and P(max) during both temperature transfers suggested that decreased nutrient status caused this non-stomatal limitation of photosynthesis.     

Seedling Development of Adapted and Exotic Maize Genotypes at Severe Chilling Stress

Stamp, P. 1987. Seedling development of adapted and exotic maizegenotypes at severe chilling stress.—J. exp. Bot. 38:1336–1342. Four maize genotypes from North West Europe (NWE), tropicalhighlands (TH) and tropical lowlands (TL) were grown at 24°Cuntil full expansion of the second leaf. Seedlings were subjectedto 5°C during 2 d thereafter, with or without a previousconditioning phase at 10°C for 4 d. After stress, seedlingswere allowed to recover at 24°C for 5 d. All genotypes resumedhigh growth rates after stress, highest values were observedfor one TH genotype. Previous conditioning was most effectivein TL and least effective in TH genotypes. In spite of similaritiesbetween patterns of growth rates and rates of leaf expansionthe latter process was less promoted by previous conditioning.The green area of the second leaf was little impaired by 5°Cin most genotypes. But without conditioning the TL genotypelost about 40% green leaf area, mostly during the recovery phase.Conditioning did not prevent losses in relative turgidity ofsecond leaves during stress but it enabled sensitive genotypesto resume normal values during recovery. Losses in phosphofructokinaseactivity occurred in the TL genotype during stress and recovery,and in TH genotypes during recovery while the activity was stablein the NWE genotype. A close relationship between this enzymeactivity and growth rates was not observed. Although one THgenotype had the best chilling tolerance on the whole plantlevel the expression of some physiological and biochemical leaftraits was inferior to the adapted NWE genotype. Key words: Low temperature, exotic germplasm, phosphofructokinase activity     

Leaf ureide degradation and N(2) fixation tolerance to water deficit in soybean

Accumulation of ureides in leaves is associated with the sensitivity of N(2) fixation in soybean to soil water deficit. Consequently, ureide degradation in leaves may be a key to increasing soybean tolerance to dry soils. Previous research indicated that allantoic acid degradation is catalysed by different enzymes in cultivars Maple Arrow and Williams. The enzyme found in Williams requires manganese as a cofactor. The first objective of this study was to determine if the two degradation pathways were associated with differences in N(2) sensitivity to soil water deficits. N(2) fixation of Williams grown on low-Mn soil was sensitive to stress, but it was relatively tolerant when grown on soil amended with Mn. N(2) fixation in Maple Arrow was relatively tolerant of soil drying regardless of the Mn treatment. The second objective of this study was to expand the study of the degradation pathway to nine additional genotypes. Based on ureide degradation in the presence and absence of Mn, these genotypes also segregated for the two degradation pathways. Those genotypes with the Mn-dependent pathway tended to have drought-sensitive N(2) fixation, but there was one exception. The genotypes not requiring Mn for ureide degradation were drought-tolerant except for one genotype. These results demonstrated the possibility for increasing N(2) fixation tolerance to soil water deficits in soybean by selection of lines with high ureide degradation rates, which were commonly associated with the Mn-independent pathway.     

Drought-inhibition of photosynthesis in C3 plants: stomatal and non-stomatal limitations revisited

There is a long-standing controversy as to whether drought limits photosynthetic CO2 assimilation through stomatal closure or by metabolic impairment in C3 plants. Comparing results from different studies is difficult due to interspecific differences in the response of photosynthesis to leaf water potential and/or relative water content (RWC), the most commonly used parameters to assess the severity of drought. Therefore, we have used stomatal conductance (g) as a basis for comparison of metabolic processes in different studies. The logic is that, as there is a strong link between g and photosynthesis (perhaps co-regulation between them), so different relationships between RWC or water potential and photosynthetic rate and changes in metabolism in different species and studies may be 'normalized' by relating them to g. Re-analysing data from the literature using light-saturated g as a parameter indicative of water deficits in plants shows that there is good correspondence between the onset of drought-induced inhibition of different photosynthetic sub-processes and g. Contents of ribulose bisphosphate (RuBP) and adenosine triphosphate (ATP) decrease early in drought development, at still relatively high g (higher than 150 mmol H20 m(-2) s(-1)). This suggests that RuBP regeneration and ATP synthesis are impaired. Decreased photochemistry and Rubisco activity typically occur at lower g (<100 mmol H20 m(-2) s(-1)), whereas permanent photoinhibition is only occasional, occurring at very low g (<50 mmol H20 m(-2) s(-1)). Sub-stomatal CO2 concentration decreases as g becomes smaller, but increases again at small g. The analysis suggests that stomatal closure is the earliest response to drought and the dominant limitation to photosynthesis at mild to moderate drought. However, in parallel, progressive down-regulation or inhibition of metabolic processes leads to decreased RuBP content, which becomes the dominant limitation at severe drought, and thereby inhibits photosynthetic CO2 assimilation.