A history of theories of acquired immunity

Alloimmune mouse spleen cells are capable of carrying out nonspecific cell-mediated cytolysis of syngeneic target cells when incubated in the presence of lectins such as Con A or PHA (lectin-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity). In the present study plant lectins from a variety of sources were examined for their ability to participate in alloimmune-LDCC. Reactivity was then compared to mitogenic activity and the ability to activate cytotoxic effector cells in vitro. Of the lectins tested only those reported to be T-cell mitogens were capable of participating in alloimmune-LDCC. Agglutinating but nonmitogenic lectins (e.g., WGA) or mitogens such as LPS or PWM failed to yield positive LDCC. Of the T-cell mitogens demonstrating positive reactivity in the alloimmune-LDCC assay, only a portion were able to generate cytolytic activity when incubated with normal spleen cells in vitro (Con A, GPA, lentil). Crude PHA, purified erythroagglutinin, or leukagglutinin failed to generate cytotoxic effector cells in this system even though these were mitogenic and demonstrated positive alloimmune-LDCC. The results suggest that T-cell mitogens interact with cytotoxic effector cells in a manner which specifically triggers cytolysis. The relationship of this interaction to other lymphocyte-lectin interactions is discussed.     

The pathway of lectin-mediated lymphocytotoxicity by Con A-coupled Sepharose beads

Soluble concanavalin A (Con A) can effectively mediate nonspecific target cell lysis by cytolytic T lymphocytes (LDCC). Because Con A bound to Sepharose beads (Con A-Seph) is also effective, it has been concluded by Z. K. Ballas, W. R. Green, and C. S. Henney. (Cell. Immunol.59, 411, 1981) that Con A-mediated “activation” of the cytolytic cell to kill in LDCC can occur without intracellular penetration of the lectin. No preincubation of either effector or target cells with Con A-Seph has been performed. Exploiting the previous finding of G. Berke (Immunol. Rev. 72, 5, 1983) that in LDCC Con A exerts its effect(s) strictly by affecting the target rather than by bridging effector and target cells and activating the effector, identical results with Con A-Seph are shown. Preincubation of Con A-Seph with the target but not with the effector cells results in substantial killing. Moreover it is shown that the ability of Con A-Seph to mediate LDCC can be attributed to free Con A dissociating from the beads (about 1%) during the assay. Evidence is presented to indicate that the dissociated Con A, not unlike free Con A, reacts with the target cells, thereby rendering them recognizable by the effector cells. It is concluded that the activity of Con A-Seph may not be taken as evidence for Con A-mediated activation of the cytolytic cell, as suggested by Ballas et al., and that the putative Con A-mediated lymphocyte activation relevant to killing still remains to be demonstrated. Evidence contradicting Con A-mediated activation of the effector and supporting the target cell modification theory has been discussed by G. Berke, V. Hu, E. McVey, and W. R. Clark (J. Immunol.127, 776, 1981).     

Effect of T- and B-lymphocyte mitogens on interactions between lymphocytes and macrophages.

The mitogenic response of murine T cells ² to Con A, S-Con A and PHA was found to be macrophage-dependent. Optimal mitogenic responses were obtained when macrophage-depleted T-cell populations were reconstituted with 5% normal peritoneal macro-phages. Studies were carried out to investigate the effect of T- and B-cell mitogens on in vitro physical interactions between murine lymphocytes and macrophages. This was done by determining the number of T- or B cells binding to macrophages in the absence and in the presence of T- and B cell mitogens, and comparing the results of these experiments with the induction of lymphocyte proliferation. Con A increased the binding of T cells to macrophages when used in mitogenic doses (1–5 μg/ml). Dose response experiments showed that the same dose of Con A which produced maximal mitogenic stimulation also induced the greatest number of T cells to bind to macrophages. Nonmitogenic doses of Con A (20–50 μg/ml) did not enhance the binding of T cells, while identical doses of S-Con A both induced T cell mitogenesis and increased the number of T cells bound to macrophages. Similar results were obtained with PHA. None of the B-cell mitogens tested (LPS, EPO 127 and LAgl) increased the binding of either T or B cells to macrophages. PWM, which is mitogenic for both T and B cells, increased the binding of T cells to macrophages, but not that of B cells. In brief, the four T-cell mitogens tested (Con A, S-Con A, PHA, and PWM) induced specific physical interactions between T cells and macrophages, while none of the B-cell mitogens had any effect on the physical interactions between either B or T cells and macrophages when used in mitogenic doses.     

Ontogeny of T-cell mitogen response in Lewis rats. III. Juvenile adherent suppressor cells block adult mitogen responses

Spleen cells from suckling female Lewis rats (4 to 20 days old) were able to suppress mitogenic responses to concanavalin A (Con A) and phytohemagglutinin (PHA) of spleen or thymus cells from adult female Lewis rats and thymus cells from suckling Lewis rats. Thymus cells from suckling rats were unable to suppress adult spleen cell mitogenic responses to Con A. Removal of carbonyl iron (cFe)-, plastic-, or nylon-wool-adherent cells removed the suppressive action of juvenile spleen cells, but irradiation did not. Separated plastic-adherent spleen cells from suckling animals suppressed adult mitogenic responses to Con A. at optimal Con A doses 2-mercaptoethanol (2-ME, 2 X 10(-5) M) abolished the suppressive effect of juvenile cells, however, at the hyperoptimal dose of Con A (125 micrograms/ml) even higher doses of 2-ME did not relieve suppression by juvenile cells. These suppressor cells in suckling pups were affected by early weaning which decreased suppression, resulting in enhanced mitogenic responses of juvenile cells and removal of the ability to suppress adult mitogenic response.     

Lymphokine-mediated induction of cytolytic activity in a T cell hybridoma

Functionally inducible CTL hybridomas were constructed by fusing alloantigen-specific T cells (C57BL/6 alpha-DBA/2) with cells from the rat thymoma line W/FU (C58NT)D. A cloned hybridoma line (KSH.4.13.6) that was specifically cytolytic in the presence of activated rat spleen cell supernatant fluid (rat Con A SN) lost activity when transferred to normal medium. However, a cytolytic activity could be reinduced by culturing KSH.4.13.6 cells in medium containing rat Con A SN or secondary mixed leukocyte culture SN. By using various sources of SN, it was found that cytolytic induction required two different factors. PMA-induced EL-4 SN and SN from antigen-activated cloned T cells, neither of which were capable of inducing cytolytic activity alone, were able to synergize in the cytolytic induction of KSH.4.13.6 IFN-gamma and IL 1 failed to induce cytolytic activity even in the presence of EL-4 SN. Furthermore, this hybridoma produced macrophage activating factor (MAF) upon culture in rat Con A SN, although MAF production could not be induced by either specific antigen or lectins. The kinetics of induction and loss of cytolytic activity mediated by rat Con A SN were similar to those of the induction of MAF production. However, EL-4 SN, which by itself was incapable of inducing cytolytic activity, was able to induce MAF production in the KSH.4.13.6 hybrid to an extent similar to that induced by rat Con A SN. These results suggest that the induction of cytolytic activity and of MAF production in this cloned hybridoma cell line are regulated by different mechanisms. Such a functionally inducible T cell hybrid may provide a tool for biochemical and molecular analysis of T cell function and regulation, and of the characterization of cytokines required for CTL differentiation.     

Synergistic cytolytic activity by combined populations of peritoneal T lymphocytes and macrophages during the L5178Y cell tumor-dormant state in DBA/2 mice

It was previously reported that the establishment of the L5178Y cell tumor-dormant state in DBA/2 mice is mediated principally by a peritoneal cytolytic T-cell response that reaches peak levels 4 days after L5178Y cell challenge, lyses more than 99% but less than 100% of peritoneal L5178Y cells, and gradually wanes to background levels by 40–70 days postchallenge (DPC). At this time the majority of mice are clinically normal, and contain a relatively small number of L5178Y cells in the peritoneal cavity. During the tumor-dormant state, mice that harbor more than 10⁴ L5178Y cells contain peritoneal macrophage-mediated cytolytic activity. We report here that tumor-dormant mice that contain fewer than 10⁴ peritoneal L5178Y cells also produce cytolytic activity in vitro, but that it is synergistic, in that the cytolytic activity of adherent (AD) peritoneal cells (PEC) and nonadherent (NAD) PEC cultured together is greater than the additive lysis produced by these cell populations when cultured separately. This synergistic cytolytic activity is: (1) effector cell density dependent, (2) dependent on the tumor-dormant status of the NAD and AD PEC donor mice, (3) protracted in its kinetics during a 48-hr in vitro assay, and (4) dependent on an interaction between NAD T cells and AD phagocytic macrophages. The consistent detection of this in vitro-assayed cytolytic activity in PEC of tumor-dormant mice which harbor small endogenous tumor burdens suggests that it reflects an in vivo cytotoxic effector mechanism involved in the long-term maintenance of the tumor-dormant state.     

Immunobiological properties of a concanavalin A derivative

A monovalent subunit of concanavalin A (Con A) was tested for mitogenic effects on murine splenic lymphocytes in vitro. In contrast to the effects of intact Con A, the monovalent derivative was not mitogenic at any concentration tested. Furthermore, prior exposure of splenic lymphocytes to monovalent Con A rendered the cells refractory to stimulation by the unmodified lectin.     

Modulation of T-cell functions: I. Effect of 2-mercaptoethanol and macrophages on T-cell proliferation

The in vitro effects of 2-mercaptoethanol (2-ME), macrophages (MØ), and concanavalin A (Con A) on the proliferation of normal spleen cells (NSC), MØ-depleted spleen cells (DSC), T cells, T-cell subpopulations, and B cells were assessed by [³H]thymidine incorporation. 2-ME alone was consistently shown not to be mitogenic for purified T cells; however, 2-ME enhanced the early (Days 1 and 2) Con A (2 μg/ml)-induced response of NSC, DSC, and T-cell preparations, but depressed the late response (Days 4 and 5). 2-ME alone was mitogenic for purified B-cells, as reported previously; and the 2-ME-induced B-cell response was inhibited by Con A. Preincubation of T cells with 2-ME was sufficient for enhanced Con A responsiveness; however, if 2-ME was added 24 hr after the initiation of culture, no alteration of the Con A-induced response was observed. Ly-2,3⁺ T cells were unresponsive to Con A (0.3–20 μg/ml), but the addition of 2-ME or peritoneal cells enhanced the Con A responsiveness of Ly-2,3⁺ T cells over 200-fold. Ly-1⁺ T cells responded with a similar doseresponse and kinetic profile as unselected T cells. Although Ly-1⁺ T cells responded to Con A, unlike Ly-2, 3⁺ T cells, extensive removal of MØ significantly reduced the Con A-induced responsiveness of the Ly-1⁺ T cells. The reactivities of Ly-1⁺ and Ly-2,3⁺ DSC could be reconstituted by the addition of MØ or 2-ME; however, the kinetic response of Ly-1⁺ T cells peaked on Day 2–3, and Ly-2,3⁺ T cells had a delayed response which peaked on Day 4–5. The results indicated that (i) 2-ME and/or MØ accelerate the response kinetics of T-cells to Con A; (ii) T-cell subpopulations have differential requirements for MØ and/or 2-ME in the response to Con A; (iii) T-cell subpopulations exhibit differential dose responsiveness to Con A; and (iiii) 2-ME alters Con A responsiveness by a direct effect on T cells.     

Increased ornithine decarboxylase activity and polyamine biosynthesis are required for optimal cytolytic T lymphocyte induction

The objective of the present investigation was to evaluate the requirement for increased ornithine decarboxylase (ODC) activity and polyamine biosynthesis in the induction of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL). In this regard, we have utilized alpha-difluoromethylornithine (DFMO), an irreversible inhibitor of ODC. DFMO treatment completely abrogated Con A-induced NW T-cell ODC activity. Similarly, DFMO treatment reduced putrescine and spermidine biosynthesis 100 and 87% respectively by the end of a 48-hr incubation period. Polyamine depletion reduced the Con A-mediated polyclonal induction of CTL by 52 and 81% at 24 and 48 hr of culture, respectively. The effect of DFMO on CTL induction could be reversed by the addition of exogenous putrescine. These data indicate that the observed effects of DFMO on CTL induction were mediated through inhibition of polyamine biosynthesis. Therefore, increased ODC activity and polyamine biosynthesis are required for optimal CTL induction. Furthermore, polyamine depletion did not impair IL-2 production; however, IL-2-dependent proliferation was reduced. These data are the first to discriminate between the requirement for polyamines with regard to IL-2 responsiveness, rather than IL-2 production, during a primary T-cell mitogenic response.     

Requirement for three distinct lymphokines for the induction of cytotoxic T lymphocytes from thymocytes

The induction of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) from CTL precursors requires a combination of antigen and lymphokine signals. To investigate lymphokine requirements for CTL generation, we used an assay in which helper T cell and accessory cell-depleted spleen cells or whole thymocytes were cultured with lectin (Con A) and lymphokines. This culture was followed by assessment of lectin-dependent cytolysis. High concentrations of recombinant interleukin 2 (R-IL 2) (100 U/ml) alone were not sufficient for lectin-mediated CTL induction from thymocytes, whereas 20 to 100 U/ml of R-IL 2 alone could induce a significant lectin-mediated CTL response from accessory cell-depleted spleen cells. Using thymocytes as responders, we found purified or recombinant interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) did not cause cytolytic activity either in the absence of or in the presence of R-IL 2. However, supernatant from Con A-stimulated rat spleen cells (rat Con A SN) in combination with R-IL 2 could induce cytolytic activity, suggesting that several factors are required for CTL induction. Con A SN was fractionated by gel filtration and the fractions were tested for ability to induce CTL. In the presence of a low level of R-IL 2 (5 U/ml), fractions with a Mr of approximately 31,000 could induce CTL, and this activity was referred to as CTL differentiation factor (CDF). The peak fractions containing CDF activity did not have detectable IL 1, IL 2, IFN-gamma, or CSF activity. However, by add-back experiments and the use of blocking antibodies, a monoclonal antibody against the IL 2 receptor or antibodies against murine IFN-gamma, we demonstrated that CTL induction from mature thymocytes (L3T4-, Lyt-2+) requires CDF activity in addition to IL 2 and IFN-gamma.     

The regulatory role of adenosine-activated T-lymphocyte subset on the immune response in humans: I. Mitogenic response and production of mediators

Human T lymphocytes, rerosetted with sheep erythrocytes in the presence of adenosine, yield two subpopulations: a major one (E_R), still capable of forming E rosettes; and a minor nonrosetting (E_S) one. The two subpopulations differed in their proliferative responses to various mitogens. E_R cells responded well to galactose oxidase (GO), soybean agglutinin (SBA), and phytohemagglutinin (PHA) but responded poorly to concanavalin A (Con A). The response of E_S cells was poor to GO and SBA, intermediate to PHA, and significantly high to Con A. The different response of E_R and E_S subsets to Con A was not greatly affected by adherent cells, but an enhancing effect on the proliferation of E_S cells to Con A was observed when prostaglandin synthesis was inhibited by indomethacin. Addition of E_S cells to E_R cells in a ratio of 1:5 resulted in an enhanced synergistic effect of Con A-induced proliferation. A soluble mitogenic factor released from Con A-activated T cells appeared involved in this enhanced proliferation. This factor (E_SF) was produced only by the minor T-cell subpopulation which is sensitive to adenosine (E_S). The induction of E_SF was not dependent on the addition of adherent cells and required 72 hr of incubation for its production. E_SF was mitogenic to nonactivated and Con A-activated PBL as well as to T, E_R, and E_S subpopulations. Following incubation of E_R cells with E_SF, a suppressor factor (E_RSF) was produced which abolished the mitogenic activity of E_SF. Differences between these factors and a known mediator like Interleukin-2 (IL-2) and suppressor factors are discussed.     

The mitogenic activity of staphylococcal enterotoxin B (SEB): a monovalent T cell mitogen that stimulates cytolytic T lymphocytes but cannot mediate their lytic interaction

Staphylococcal enterotoxin B (SEB), a monovalent T cell mitogen and inducer of T suppressor cells, was found to be a potent polyclonal activator of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) effective against concanavalin A (Con A)-treated target cells. In addition to polyclonal stimulation of CTL, SEB could reactivate "memory" CTL, alloimmunized 60 to 90 days earlier, into "secondary" CTL detectable as early as 24 hr after onset of stimulation and specific for the original priming target cells. Optimal cytolytic activity was induced at 0.5 to 10 micrograms/ml SEB; optimal priming time was 3 days, correlating well with the proliferative activity and morphologic transformation of small lymphocytes into large T lymphoblasts. Long-term cultures of splenocytes, stimulated by SEB, continued to express high cytolytic activity. It is noteworthy that although SEB and Con A are comparable CTL inducers, SEB, unlike Con A, is an ineffective mediator of nonspecific, CTL/target cell interactions. To the best of our knowledge this is the first example of a CTL inducer unable to mediate CTL-target interaction and lysis. The latter observations suggests that different receptors are involved in CTL activation and in CTL-target interaction resulting in lysis.     

Separation of mitogen-induced suppressor cells of human antibody-producing cells

Human antibody-forming cells were demonstrated by a plaque in agar technique following in vitro stimulation with either pokeweed mitogen or Cowan I strain of protein A-positive Staphylococcus aureus bacteria. We evaluated the effects on this antibody formation caused by the addition of cells which had been stimulated with PH A or Con A. Both Con A and PHA cells harvested after 3 days showed strong inhibition of pokeweed-induced plaque formation. The majority of the suppression could be accounted for by a blast fraction separated on 1g sedimentation gradients from the Con A or PHA cultures. Small cells from such cultures showed inhibition of PFC when added at high ratios (1:2), but this suppressive activity diluted out much more rapidly than that of the blast cells. No helper activity was noted with either small cells or blasts. Our studies indicate a T-cell blast as the suppressive fraction in Con A- or PHA-stimulated human lymphoid cells. While this T-cell suppression applies to T-dependent responses such as antibody stimulation with pokeweed mitogen, it does not have a substantial effect on Cowan I-induced plaque-forming responses. The finding that Cowan I-induced plaques could not be inhibited by Con A or PHA blasts indicates the T independence of this response.     

Lens culinaris lectin is a T-cell mitogen: binding inhibition by concanavalin A and phytohemagglutinin-P.

Binding and mitogenicity of a lectin from Lens culinaris (LcH) were studied in mouse lymphocytes. Both continuous and pulse treatment of lymphocytes with LcH induced a mitogenic response selectively in T cells. LcH and Con A, which have similar binding specificities, exhibited binding inhibition both in unfixed cells and glutaraldehype-fixed cells, with native Con A and succinyl Con A and at 37 °C as well as 0 °C. On the other hand, reciprocal binding inhibition by a third T-cell mitogen, phytohemagglutinin-P (PHA-P), was found only in unfixed cells at 37 °C and with native Con A, indicating that the inhibition is a secondary effect as opposed to direct competition for receptors. The inhibition of mitogenic responses to LcH and PHA-P by pretreatment of cells with Con A was studied in relation to the two different types of binding inhibition. Only the type of binding inhibition caused by a secondary effect correlated with interference with the mitogenic response.     

Cellular cooperation in mitogen-induced human leukocyte inhibitory factor (LIF) synthesis.

Interactions between human T and B lymphocytes and between lymphocyte subpopulations and accessory cells in lymphokine synthesis were investigated. The cells were stimulated with leukoagglutinin (LA), concanavalin A (Con A), protein A (prot A) and anti-β₂-microglobulin (anti-β₂m). The presence of leukocyte inhibitory factor (LIF) in the culture supernatants was tested by the agarose-migration method. The results indicated that monocytes augmented LIF synthesis of T cells but suppressed that of B cells. Monocyte-helper effect was mediated by both cell-cell contact and soluble factors. In addition, T lymphocytes were found to augment B-cell LIF production. B lymphocytes enhanced Con A- but suppressed LA-induced LIF production by T cells. T-cell/B-cell collaboration was based on a direct cell-cell contact and no soluble factors were found.     

Simultaneous Preparation of a DNA Ligase and Restriction Endonucleases from Bacillus amyloliquefaciens N

An N-acetylgalactosamine (GalNAc)-specific Ca²⁺-dependent lectin (C-type lectin), isolated from the marine invertebrate Holothuroidea (Cucumaria echinata), CEL-I, showed potent mitogenic activity toward normal mouse spleen cells. The mitogenic activity of CEL-I, which reached a maximum at 100 μg/ml, was inhibited by GalNAc in a concentration-dependent manner. The mitogenic effect of CEL-I at 10 μg/ml on T cell- enriched splenocytes was at a similar level due to a well-known T cell mitogen, concanavalin A (Con A), at 10 μg/ml. Furthermore, CEL-I evoked a mitogenic response from nude mouse spleen cells, while no significant effects of Con A on this cell population were observed over a wide range of concentrations. These results suggest that CEL-I is a potent mitogenic lectin with the ability to stimulate both T and B cells.     

Production of an antiviral factor by murine spleen cells after treatment with Corynebacterium parvum.

We have previously shown that injection of Corynebacterium parvum (CP) in mice protected them against lethal encephalitis induced by herpes simplex virus, (HSV). It is shown here that spleen cells of CP-injected mice in vitro produce a factor capable of inhibiting the replication of HSV in mouse embryo fibroblasts (MEF). A similar activity was produced after in vitro exposure of spleen cells from untreated mice to CP. CP was only slightly mitogenic in contrast to phytohemagglutinin (PHA), concanavalin A (Con A), and bacterial lipopolysaccharide (LPS) which were strongly mitogenic but did not induce antiviral activity high enough to be detected in the HSV-MEF system. The activity produced by CP-treated spleen cells appeared to be interferon since it was trypsin sensitive and species specific and not virus specific, and since preincubation of the cells was required to demonstrate an antiviral effect. However, the identity of CP-induced interferon with any of the previously described subclasses of interferon remains to be determined.     

Lectin-induced modulation of the antibody response to type III pneumococcal polysaccharide

Several lectins were tested for their capacity to alter the antibody response to type III pneumococcal polysaccharide (SSS-III). The antibody response was enhanced by concanavalin A (Con A), phytohemagglutinin (PHA), as well as lectins from Phytolacca americana (Pa-2), Pisum sativum (PSA), and Lens culinaris (LCH), when these lectins were given 2 days after immunization with SSS-III; however, suppression was obtained when Con A and Pa-2 were given at the time of immunization. By contrast the lectins from Vicia villosa (VVL) and Bauhinia purpurea (BPA) did not alter the antibody response. Since the lectins PSA and LCH bind to the same monosaccharide as Con A, whereas the other lectins bind to different monosaccharides, these findings indicate that there is no relationship between nominal monosaccharide specificity and the capacity to modulate the antibody response. Substantial increases in the magnitude of the IgG₁ antibody response was noted after the administration of Con A whereas profound enhancement of IgG_2a antibody response was noted after PHA was given.     

Colony-forming B cells in F1 hybrid and transplanted CBA/N mice.

The conditions for evaluation of suppressor cell regulation of the pokeweed mitogen (PWM)-induced plaque-forming cell (PFC) responses of peripheral blood (PB) B cells in normal individuals using allogeneic cocultures is described. In 14 separate experiments, after preincubation with concanavalin A (Con A) for 2 days, PB cells suppressed the PWM-induced anti-sheep erythrocyte (SRBC) PFC response of fresh allogeneic PB cells to 17% of the expected PFC response (P < 0.05). In addition, control cells incubated for 2 days in the absence of Con A suppressed the PWM- induced PFC response of allogeneic cells in 6 of 14 experiments to the same extent as did the Con A-generated cells (P < 0.01). It was found that unstimulated control cells (without Con A activation) from normal subjects who themselves were nonresponders to PWM stimulation (< 50 PFC/10⁶ cells) usually suppressed the PFC response of allogeneic cells (P < 0.05), while control cells from normal subjects who consistently had a good PFC response to PWM stimulation (> 75 PFC/10⁶ cells) did not suppress the PFC response of allogeneic cells. The spontaneously occurring suppressor cell in nonresponder PB cell suspensions was sensitive to 3000-R irradiation, and the nonresponder state was not associated with a decreased blastogenic response to PWM. Thus, some normal subjects who themselves had a poor PWM-induced PFC response had irradiation-sensitive, spontaneously occurring suppressor cells which were capable of suppressing the PWM-induced PFC response of normal responders. The majority of normal subjects (90%) were good PFC responders to PWM stimulation and did not spontaneously suppress the PFC response of allogeneic cells to PWM, but did have PB cells which were capable of being activated by Con A to suppress.