Apoptosis in Etiolated Wheat Seedlings: 2. Effects of the Antioxidant Butylated Hydroxytoluene and Peroxides

The antioxidant butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT, 50 mg/l, 2.27 × 10^–4 M) was found to prevent the development of characteristic signs of senescence and apoptosis in the cells of etiolated wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) seedlings. In particular, BHT blocked the apoptotic and age-induced formation of specific cytoplasmic mitochondria-containing vesicles in the coleoptiles. In contrast, the oxidants (H₂O₂ and cumene hydroxyperoxide) accelerated apoptosis (DNA fragmentation) in the coleoptiles and induced it in the first leaves, while in the control leaves, there were no signs of apoptosis. Thus, the programmed developmental apoptosis is controlled by the reactive oxygen species (ROS), and anti- and prooxidants can actively affect this process. In the coleoptile, BHT induced substantial changes in the ultrastructure of all cell organelles (nucleus, mitochondria, plastids, Golgi apparatus, and endoplasmic reticulum). It also induced the formation of unusual membrane structures in the cytoplasm and impaired nucleus and cell divisions. As a result, giant multilobed nuclei and multinuclear cells appeared. The effects of the antioxidant were tissue-specific: BHT did not noticeably affect cell ultrastructure in the first leaf. In roots of etiolated seedlings, BHT stimulated unusual plastid differentiation that resulted in the formation of chloroplasts, which is a phenomenon abnormal for roots. The BHT effects on the plant are evidently related to its antioxidant properties. Indeed, its structural analog, 3,5-di-tert-butyltoluene, which does not exhibit antioxidant properties, was physiologically inert. The BHT-controlled ROS evidently triggered apoptosis and produced age-dependent structural rearrangements of the cytoplasm and the formation of specific mitochondria-containing vesicles, which actively synthesize mtDNA. ROS inactivation by BHT is evidently responsible for BHT-induced changes in the structure of all cell organelles. Therefore, we believe that ROS control cell division (including nucleus division and cell-wall formation) and affect the differentiation of plastids and Golgi apparatus. In such a way, ROS effectively control plant growth and development.     

Apoptosis in the Initial Leaf of Etiolated Wheat Seedlings: Influence of the Antioxidant Ionol (BHT) and Peroxides

Apoptosis was observed in the initial leaf of 5-8-day-old etiolated wheat seedlings. A condensation of cytoplasm in apoptotic cells, formation of myelin-like structures, specific fragmentation of cytoplasm, appearance in vacuoles of specific vesicles containing subcellular organelles, condensation and margination of chromatin in the nucleus, and internucleosomal fragmentation of nuclear DNA are ultrastructural features of apoptosis in the initial wheat leaf. Single-membrane vesicles detected in vacuoles of the leaf cells resemble in appearance the vacuolar vesicles in the coleoptile apoptotic cells described earlier (Bakeeva, L. E., et al. (1999) FEBS Lett., 457, 122-125); they contain preferentially plastids but not mitochondria as was observed in coleoptile. The vacuolar vesicles are specific for the apoptotic plant cells. Thus, apoptosis in various tissues is an obligatory element of plant (wheat) growth and development even in the early stages of ontogenesis. Contrary to strong geroprotecting action in coleoptile, the known antioxidant BHT (ionol, 2.27·10^–4 M) does not prevent in the leaf cells the apoptotic internucleosomal DNA fragmentation and appearance of specific vacuolar vesicles containing subcellular organelles. Therefore, the antioxidant action on apoptosis in plants is tissue specific. Peroxides (H₂O₂, cumene hydroperoxide) stimulated apoptosis (internucleosomal DNA fragmentation) in coleoptile and induced it in an initial leaf when apoptosis in a control seedling leaf was not yet detected. Thus, apoptosis that is programmed in plant ontogenesis and controlled by reactive oxygen species (ROS) can be modulated by anti- and prooxidants.     

Apoptosis in Wheat Seedlings Grown under Normal Daylight

Apoptosis was observed in the coleoptile and initial leaf in 5-8-day-old wheat seedlings grown under normal daylight. Apoptosis is an obligatory event in early wheat plant ontogenesis, and it is characterized by cytoplasmic structural reorganization and fragmentation, in particular, with the appearance in vacuoles of specific vesicles containing intact organelles, chromatin condensation and margination in the nucleus, and internucleosomal fragmentation of nuclear DNA. The earliest signs of programmed cell death (PCD) were observed in the cytoplasm, but the elements of apoptotic degradation in the nucleus appeared later. Nuclear DNA fragmentation was detected after chromatin condensation and the appearance in vacuoles of specific vesicles containing mitochondria. Two PCD varieties were observed in the initial leaf of 5-day-old seedlings grown under normal daylight: a proper apoptosis and vacuolar collapse. On the contrary, PCD in coleoptiles under various growing (light) conditions and in the initial leaf of etiolated seedlings is only a classical plant apoptosis. Therefore, various tissue-specific and light-dependent PCD forms do exist in plants. Amounts of O2*- and H2O2 evolved by seedlings grown under normal daylight are less than that evolved by etiolated seedlings. The amount of H2O2 formed in the presence of sodium salicylate or azide by seedlings grown under normal daylight was increased. Contrary to etiolated seedlings, the antioxidant BHT (ionol) did not inhibit O2*- formation and apoptosis and it had no influence on ontogenesis in the seedlings grown under normal daylight. Thus, in plants grown under the normal light regime the powerful system controlling the balance between formation and inactivation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) does exist and it effectively functions. This system is responsible for maintenance of cell homeostasis, and it regulates the crucial ROS level controlling plant growth and development. In etiolated plants, this system seems to be absent, or it is much less effective.     

Apoptosis in Etiolated Wheat Seedlings: 1. Ultrastructure of the Apoptotic Cell

We studied the process of apoptosis in etiolated wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) seedlings. As a result, an integral pattern of the apoptotic plant cell ultrastructure was established. In the apoptotic cells of the coleoptile, we observed chromatin condensation and margination, an increased density and specific cytoplasm fragmentation accompanied by the appearance of unusual cytoplasmic vesicles containing subcellular organelles, mitochondria in particular, in the vacuoles.     

Necessity of Superoxide Production for Development of Etiolated Wheat Seedlings

It was found that production of superoxide (O₂ ^{– ·}) is crucial for normal morphogenesis of etiolated wheat seedlings in the early stages of plant development. The development of etiolated wheat seedlings was shown to be accompanied with cyclic changes in the rate of O₂ ^{– ·} production both in the entire intact seedling and in its separated organs (leaf, coleoptile). First increase in the rate of O₂ ^{– ·} production was clearly observed in the period from two to four days of seedling development, then the rate of O₂ ^{– ·} production decreased to the initial level, and then it increased again for two days to a new maximum. An increase in O₂ ^{– ·} production in the period of the first four days of seedling development correlates with an increase in DNA and protein contents in the coleoptile. The second peak of increased rate of O₂ ^{– ·} production observed on the sixth or seventh day of seedling development coincides with a decrease in DNA and protein contents and apoptotic internucleosomal nuclear DNA fragmentation in the coleoptile. Incubation of seedlings in the presence of the antioxidant BHT (ionol) strongly affects their development but it does not influence the increase in DNA and protein contents for the initial four days of seedling life, and it slows down the subsequent age-dependent decrease in protein content and fully prevents the age-dependent decrease in DNA content in the coleoptile. A decrease in the O₂ ^{– ·} amount induced by BHT distorts the seedling development. BHT retards seedling growth, presumably by suppression of cell elongation, and it increases the life span of the coleoptile. It seems that O₂ ^{– ·} controls plant growth by cell elongation at the early stages of seedling development but later O₂ ^{– ·} controls (induces) apoptotic DNA fragmentation and protein disintegration.     

外源氯化胆碱可提高小麦线粒体膜的流动性

分别用ANS、DPH及16 -NS三种不同的标记物标记小麦黄化苗的线粒体 ,研究氯化胆碱 (cholinechloride,CC)对线粒体膜的荧光光谱、平均微粘度 (η )及ESR图谱的影响。结果表明 ,0.21 -1.79mmol·L-1 的CC均能显著降低线粒体膜的荧光强度、η 值及ESR图谱的序参数 (S)和旋转相关时间 (τc) ,表明CC可增加线粒体膜的流动性。为揭示CC的提高植物抗冷机制提供依据     

The Effects of Phytohormones and 5-Azacytidine on Apoptosis in Etiolated Wheat Seedlings

The development of etiolated wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) seedlings is necessarily accompanied by apoptosis in their coleoptiles and first leaves. Internucleosome DNA fragmentation, which is characteristic of apoptosis, was detected in the coleoptile as soon as six days after germination. After eight days of germination, DNA fragmentation was clearly expressed in the coleoptile and was noticeable in the apical part of the first-leaf blade. Growing of intact seedlings or incubation of their shoots in the presence of such phytohormones as benzyladenine, gibberellin A₃, fusicoccin C, and 2,4-D at the concentration of 10^–5 M did not essentially affect DNA fragmentation in the coleoptile. As distinct from antioxidants, none of the phytohormones used prevented apoptosis in wheat seedlings. In contrast, ABA (10^–5 M) and an ethylene producer, ethrel (2-chloroethylphosphonic acid, 10^–2–10^–3 M), stimulated sharply DNA fragmentation in the coleoptile. An inhibitor of DNA methylation, 5-azacytidine, was very efficient in the stimulation of DNA fragmentation in the coleoptiles of eight-day-old seedlings at its concentration of 100 g/ml. Thus, some phytohormones can regulate apoptosis, and DNA methylation is involved in this process. Our results indicate that apoptosis activation by some phytohormones may be mediated by their regulation of DNA methylation/demethylation, which is responsible for the induction of genes encoding apoptogenic proteins and/or the repression of antiapoptotic genes.     

Quantitative cytology of the egg and central cell of Plumbago zeylanica and its impact on cytoplasmic inheritance patterns

Summary The egg and central cells of Plumbago zeylanica have an average volume of 543,000 m³ and 2,560,000 m³ respectively, with surface areas of 38,600 m² and 154,000 m². The egg contains an average of 39,900 mitochondria and 730 plastids. The majority of the plastids are perinuclear (> 60%) with less than 40% in lateral areas or near the filiform apparatus. After fertilization, the number of maternal organelles exceeds paternal organelles by a ratio of 11,000 for mitochondria and 154 for plastids. The central cell contains an average of 178,700 mitochondria and 1,840 plastids. After fertilization, these organelles far exceed the number of sperm organelles transmitted, by a ratio of approx. 14,000 for plastids and 1820 for mitochondria. Biparental inheritance of plastids in the embryo is possible, but not favored; the only comparable data in Oenothera and Impatiens reveals that biparental inheritance is possible in up to 124 ratios. Plants lacking biparental plastid inheritance do not contain plastids in the sperm, and thus the presence of even few sperm plastids may result in expression. The number of paternal mitochondria transmitted into the central cell is greater than that transmitted into the egg as the result of preferential fertilization with the mitochondrion-rich dimorphic sperm cell, although the ratio of paternal to maternal mitochondria is 11,000 in the egg and 1820 in the central cell. The similarity in these ratios suggests that there is a critical dosage of mitochondria that is permissible within the zygotic and endospermatic lineages. This may represent either: (1) a maximum permissible value to prevent expression of paternal mitochondrial genome, (2) a minimum ratio required in order to permit recombination of maternal and paternal mitochondrial genomes, or (3) a cytoplasmic genome balance number.Abbreviations mtDNA mitochondrial DNA - S_ua sperm cell unassociated with the vegetative nucleus - S_vn sperm cell physically associated with the vegetative nucleus     

Ionol (BHT) produces superoxide anion

In aqueous medium etiolated wheat seedlings release superoxide anion ( ). Interaction of a synthetic antioxidant, butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT, ionol), with oxygen in the aqueous medium is accompanied by formation. This suggests that under certain conditions BHT behaves as a prooxidant. A natural antioxidant, superoxide dismutase (SOD), and also a wound healing preparation, emulsified denatured placenta (EDP), do not exhibit the prooxidant properties. In contrast to BHT, they reduce production by the etiolated wheat seedling system.     

Exceptional inheritance of plastids via pollen in Nicotiana sylvestris with no detectable paternal mitochondrial DNA in the progeny

Plastids and mitochondria, the DNA‐containing cytoplasmic organelles, are maternally inherited in the majority of angiosperm species. Even in plants with strict maternal inheritance, exceptional paternal transmission of plastids has been observed. Our objective was to detect rare leakage of plastids via pollen in Nicotiana sylvestris and to determine if pollen transmission of plastids results in co‐transmission of paternal mitochondria. As father plants, we used N. sylvestris plants with transgenic, selectable plastids and wild‐type mitochondria. As mother plants, we used N. sylvestris plants with Nicotiana undulata cytoplasm, including the CMS‐92 mitochondria that cause cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) by homeotic transformation of the stamens. We report here exceptional paternal plastid DNA in approximately 0.002% of N. sylvestris seedlings. However, we did not detect paternal mitochondrial DNA in any of the six plastid‐transmission lines, suggesting independent transmission of the cytoplasmic organelles via pollen. When we used fertile N. sylvestris as mothers, we obtained eight fertile plastid transmission lines, which did not transmit their plastids via pollen at higher frequencies than their fathers. We discuss the implications for transgene containment and plant evolutionary histories inferred from cytoplasmic phylogenies.