Fluorescence correlation spectroscopic study of serpin depolymerization by computationally designed peptides

Members of the serine proteinase inhibitor (serpin) family play important roles in the inflammatory and coagulation cascades. Interaction of a serpin with its target proteinase induces a large conformational change, resulting in insertion of its reactive center loop (RCL) into the main body of the protein as a new strand within beta-sheet A. Intermolecular insertion of the RCL of one serpin molecule into the beta-sheet A of another leads to polymerization, a widespread phenomenon associated with a general class of diseases known as serpinopathies. Small peptides are known to modulate the polymerization process by binding within beta-sheet A. Here, we use fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) to probe the mechanism of peptide modulation of alpha(1)-antitrypsin (alpha(1)-AT) polymerization and depolymerization, and employ a statistical computationally-assisted design strategy (SCADS) to identify new tetrapeptides that modulate polymerization. Our results demonstrate that peptide-induced depolymerization takes place via a heterogeneous, multi-step process that begins with internal fragmentation of the polymer chain. One of the designed tetrapeptides is the most potent antitrypsin depolymerizer yet found.     

Structural differences between active forms of plasminogen activator inhibitor type 1 revealed by conformationally sensitive ligands

Plasminogen activator inhibitor type 1 (PAI-1) is a serine protease inhibitor (serpin) in which the reactive center loop (RCL) spontaneously inserts into a central beta-sheet, beta-sheet A, resulting in inactive inhibitor. Available x-ray crystallographic studies of PAI-1 in an active conformation relied on the use of stabilizing mutations. Recently it has become evident that these structural models do not adequately explain the behavior of wild-type PAI-1 (wtPAI-1) in solution. To probe the structure of native wtPAI-1, we used three conformationally sensitive ligands: the physiologic cofactor, vitronectin; a monoclonal antibody, 33B8, that binds preferentially to RCL-inserted forms of PAI-1; and RCL-mimicking peptides that insert into beta-sheet A. From patterns of interaction with wtPAI-1 and the stable mutant, 14-1B, we propose a model of the native conformation of wtPAI-1 in which the bottom of the central sheet is closed, whereas the top of the beta-sheet A is open to allow partial insertion of the RCL. Because the incorporation of RCL-mimicking peptides into wtPAI-1 is accelerated by vitronectin, we further propose that vitronectin alters the conformation of the RCL to allow increased accessibility to beta-sheet A, yielding a structural hypothesis that is contradictory to the current structural model of PAI-1 in solution and its interaction with vitronectin.     

Full or partial substitution of the reactive center loop of alpha-1-proteinase inhibitor by that of heparin cofactor II: P1 Arg is required for maximal thrombin inhibition

The abundant plasma protein alpha(1)-proteinase inhibitor (alpha(1)-PI) physiologically inhibits neutrophil elastase (NE) and factor XIa and belongs to the serine protease inhibitor (serpin) protein superfamily. Inhibitory serpins possess a surface peptide domain called the reactive center loop (RCL), which contains the P1-P1' scissile peptide bond. Conversion of this bond in alpha(1)-PI from Met-Ser to Arg-Ser in alpha(1)-PI Pittsburgh (M358R) redirects alpha(1)-PI from inhibiting NE to inhibiting thrombin (IIa), activated protein C (APC), and other proteases. In contrast to either the wild-type or M358R alpha(1)-PI, heparin cofactor II (HCII) is a IIa-specific inhibitor with an atypical Leu-Ser reactive center. We examined the effects of replacement of all or part of the RCL of alpha(1)-PI with the corresponding parts of the HCII RCL on the activity and specificity of the resulting chimeric inhibitors. A series of 12 N-terminally His-tagged alpha(1)-PI proteins differing only in their RCL residues were expressed as soluble proteins in Escherichia coli. Substitution of the P16-P3' loop of alpha(1)-PI with that of HCII increased the low intrinsic antithrombin activity of alpha(1)-PI to near that of heparin-free HCII, while analogous substitution of the P2'-P3' dipeptide surpassed this level. However, gel-based complexing and quantitative kinetic assays showed that all mutant proteins inhibited thrombin at less than 2% of the rate of alpha(1)-PI (M358R) unless the P1 residue was also mutated to Arg. An alpha(1)-PI (P16-P3' HCII/M358R) variant was only 3-fold less active than M358R against IIa but 70-fold less active against APC. The reduction in anti-APC activity is desired in an antithrombotic agent, but the improvement in inhibitory profile came at the cost of a 3.5-fold increase in the stoichiometry of inhibition. Our results suggest that, while P1 Arg is essential for maximal antithrombin activity in engineered alpha(1)-PI proteins, substitution of the corresponding HCII residues can enhance thrombin specificity.     

The structural basis of serpin polymerization studied by hydrogen/deuterium exchange and mass spectrometry

The serpinopathies are a group of inherited disorders that share as their molecular basis the misfolding and polymerization of serpins, an important class of protease inhibitors. Depending on the identity of the serpin, conditions arising from polymerization include emphysema, thrombosis, and dementia. The structure of serpin polymers is thus of considerable medical interest. Wild-type alpha(1)-antitrypsin will form polymers upon incubation at moderate temperatures and has been widely used as a model system for studying serpin polymerization. Using hydrogen/deuterium exchange and mass spectrometry, we have obtained molecular level structural information on the alpha(1)-antitrypsin polymer. We found that the flexible reactive center loop becomes strongly protected upon polymerization. We also found significant increases in protection in the center of beta-sheet A and in helix F. These results support a model in which linkage between serpins is achieved through insertion of the reactive center loop of one serpin into beta-sheet A of another. We have also examined the heat-induced conformational changes preceding polymerization. We found that polymerization is preceded by significant destabilization of beta-sheet C. On the basis of our results, we propose a mechanism for polymerization in which beta-strand 1C is displaced from the rest of beta-sheet C through a binary serpin/serpin interaction. Displacement of strand 1C triggers further conformational changes, including the opening of beta-sheet A, and allows for subsequent polymerization.     

Nucleation of alpha 1-antichymotrypsin polymerization

Alpha(1)-antichymotrypsin is an acute phase plasma protein and a member of the serpin superfamily. We show here that wildtype alpha(1)-antichymotrypsin forms polymers between the reactive center loop of one molecule and the beta-sheet A of a second at a rate that is dependent on protein concentration and the temperature of the reaction. The rate of polymerization was accelerated by seeding with polymers of alpha(1)-antichymotrypsin and a complex of alpha(1)-antichymotrypsin with an exogenous reactive loop peptide but not with reactive loop cleaved alpha(1)-antichymotrypsin or with polymers of other members of the serpin superfamily. Sonication of alpha(1)-antichymotrypsin polymers markedly increased the efficacy of seeding such that polymers were able to form under physiological conditions. Taken together, these data provide the first demonstration that serpin polymerization can result from seeding. This mechanism is analogous to the fibrillization of the Abeta(1-42) peptide and may be important in the deposition of alpha(1)-antichymotrypsin in the plaques of Alzheimer's disease.     

Cleaved antitrypsin polymers at atomic resolution

Alpha1-antitrypsin deficiency, which can lead to both emphysema and liver disease, is a result of the accumulation of alpha1-antitrypsin polymers within the hepatocyte. A wealth of biochemical and biophysical data suggests that alpha1-antitrypsin polymers form via insertion of residues from the reactive center loop of one molecule into the beta-sheet of another. However, this long-standing hypothesis has not been confirmed by direct structural evidence. Here, we describe the first crystallographic evidence of a beta-strand linked polymer form of alpha1-antitrypsin: the crystal structure of a cleaved alpha1-antitrypsin polymer.     

A 2.6 A structure of a serpin polymer and implications for conformational disease.

The function of the serpins as proteinase inhibitors depends on their ability to insert the cleaved reactive centre loop as the fourth strand in the main A beta-sheet of the molecule upon proteolytic attack at the reactive centre, P1-P1'. This mechanism is vulnerable to mutations which result in inappropriate intra- or intermolecular loop insertion in the absence of cleavage. Intermolecular loop insertion is known as serpin polymerisation and results in a variety of diseases, most notably liver cirrhosis resulting from mutations of the prototypical serpin alpha1-antitrypsin. We present here the 2.6 A structure of a polymer of alpha1-antitrypsin cleaved six residues N-terminal to the reactive centre, P7-P6 (Phe352-Leu353). After self insertion of P14 to P7, intermolecular linkage is affected by insertion of the P6-P3 residues of one molecule into the partially occupied beta-sheet A of another. This results in an infinite, linear polymer which propagates in the crystal along a 2-fold screw axis. These findings provide a framework for understanding the uncleaved alpha1-antitrypsin polymer and fibrillar and amyloid deposition of proteins seen in other conformational diseases, with the ordered array of polymers in the crystal resulting from slow accretion of the cleaved serpin over the period of a year.     

Sugar and alcohol molecules provide a therapeutic strategy for the serpinopathies that cause dementia and cirrhosis

Mutations in neuroserpin and alpha1-antitrypsin cause these proteins to form ordered polymers that are retained within the endoplasmic reticulum of neurones and hepatocytes, respectively. The resulting inclusions underlie the dementia familial encephalopathy with neuroserpin inclusion bodies (FENIB) and Z alpha1-antitrypsin-associated cirrhosis. Polymers form by a sequential linkage between the reactive centre loop of one molecule and beta-sheet A of another, and strategies that block polymer formation are likely to be successful in treating the associated disease. We show here that glycerol, the sugar alcohol erythritol, the disaccharide trehalose and its breakdown product glucose reduce the rate of polymerization of wild-type neuroserpin and the Ser49Pro mutant that causes dementia. They also attenuate the polymerization of the Z variant of alpha1-antitrypsin. The effect on polymerization was apparent even when these agents had been removed from the buffer. None of these agents had any detectable effect on the structure or inhibitory activity of neuroserpin or alpha1-antitrypsin. These data demonstrate that sugar and alcohol molecules can reduce the polymerization of serpin mutants that cause disease, possibly by binding to and stabilizing beta-sheet A.     

Structure of the PIN/LC8 dimer with a bound peptide.

The structure of the protein known both as neuronal nitric oxide synthase inhibitory protein, PIN (protein inhibitor of nNOS), and also as the 8 kDa dynein light chain (LC8) has been solved by X-ray diffraction. Two PIN/LC8 monomers related by a two-fold axis form a rectangular dimer. Two pairs of alpha-helices cover opposite faces, and each pair of helices packs against a beta-sheet with five antiparallel beta-strands. Each five-stranded beta-sheet contains four strands from one monomer and a fifth strand from the other monomer. A 13-residue peptide from nNOS is bound to the dimer in a deep hydrophobic groove as a sixth antiparallel beta-strand. The structure provides key insights into dimerization of and peptide binding by the multifunctional PIN/LC8 protein.     

Engineering of conformations of plasminogen activator inhibitor-1. A crucial role of beta-strand 5A residues in the transition of active form to latent and substrate forms.

The serpin (serine proteinase inhibitor) family is of general protein chemical interest because of its ability to undergo large conformational changes, in which the surface-exposed reactive centre loop (RCL) is inserted as strand 4 in the large central beta-sheet A. Loop insertion is an integral part of the inhibitory mechanism and also takes place at conversion of serpins to the latent state, occurring spontaneously only in plasminogen activator inhibitor-1 (PAI-1). We have investigated the importance of beta-strand 5A residues for the activity and latency transition of PAI-1. An approximately fourfold increase in the rate of latency transition resulted from His-substitution of Gln324 (position 334 in the alpha(1)-proteinase inhibitor template numbering), which interacts with the underlying alpha-helix B. The side chains of Gln321 and Lys325 (template residues 331 and 335, respectively) form hydrogen bonds to the peptide backbone of a loop connecting alpha-helix F and beta-strand 3A. While substitution with Ala of Glu321 had only minor effects on the properties of PAI-1, substitution with Ala of Lys325 led to stabilization of the inhibitory activity at incubation conditions leading to conversion of wild-type PAI-1 to a substrate form, and to an anomalous reaction towards a monoclonal antibody, which induced a delay in the latency transition of the mutant, but not wild-type PAI-1. We conclude that the anchoring of beta-strand 5A plays a crucial role in loop insertion. These findings provide new information about the mechanism of an important example of protein conformational changes.     

The reactive-center loop of active PAI-1 is folded close to the protein core and can be partially inserted

Plasminogen activator inhibitor 1 (PAI-1) is the main inhibitor of plasminogen activators and plays an important role in many pathophysiological processes. Like other members of the serpin family, PAI-1 has a reactive center consisting of a mobile loop (RCL) with P1 and P1' residues acting as a "bait" for cognate protease. In contrast to the other serpins, PAI-1 loses activity by spontaneous conversion to an inactive latent form. This involves full insertion of the RCL into beta-sheet A. To search for molecular determinants that could be responsible for conversion of PAI-1 to the latent form, we studied the conformation of the RCL in active PAI-1 in solution. Intramolecular distance measurements by donor-donor energy migration and probe quenching methods reveal that the RCL is located much closer to the core of PAI-1 than has been suggested by the recently resolved X-ray structures of stable PAI-1 mutants. Disulfide bonds can be formed in double-cysteine mutants with substitutions at positions P11 or P13 of the RCL and neighboring residues in beta-sheet A. This suggests that the RCL may be preinserted up to residue P13 in active PAI-1, and possibly even to residue P11. We propose that the close proximity of the RCL to the protein core, and the ability of the loop to preinsert into beta-sheet A is a possible reason for PAI-1 being able to convert spontaneously to its latent form.     

Universal sequence replication, reversible polymerization and early functional biopolymers: a model for the initiation of prebiotic sequence evolution

Many models for the origin of life have focused on understanding how evolution can drive the refinement of a preexisting enzyme, such as the evolution of efficient replicase activity. Here we present a model for what was, arguably, an even earlier stage of chemical evolution, when polymer sequence diversity was generated and sustained before, and during, the onset of functional selection. The model includes regular environmental cycles (e.g. hydration-dehydration cycles) that drive polymers between times of replication and functional activity, which coincide with times of different monomer and polymer diffusivity. Template-directed replication of informational polymers, which takes place during the dehydration stage of each cycle, is considered to be sequence-independent. New sequences are generated by spontaneous polymer formation, and all sequences compete for a finite monomer resource that is recycled via reversible polymerization. Kinetic Monte Carlo simulations demonstrate that this proposed prebiotic scenario provides a robust mechanism for the exploration of sequence space. Introduction of a polymer sequence with monomer synthetase activity illustrates that functional sequences can become established in a preexisting pool of otherwise non-functional sequences. Functional selection does not dominate system dynamics and sequence diversity remains high, permitting the emergence and spread of more than one functional sequence. It is also observed that polymers spontaneously form clusters in simulations where polymers diffuse more slowly than monomers, a feature that is reminiscent of a previous proposal that the earliest stages of life could have been defined by the collective evolution of a system-wide cooperation of polymer aggregates. Overall, the results presented demonstrate the merits of considering plausible prebiotic polymer chemistries and environments that would have allowed for the rapid turnover of monomer resources and for regularly varying monomer/polymer diffusivities.     

Enthalpy measurement using calorimetry shows a significant difference in potential energy between the active and latent conformations of PAI-1

A central feature of the serpin inhibition mechanism is insertion of the reactive center loop into the central beta-sheet (beta-sheet A). This insertion also occurs when the reactive center loop is cleaved without protease inhibition. Using this effect, we have measured the enthalpy (DeltaH) of loop cleavage and insertion for plasminogen activator inhibitor 1 (PAI-1) as -38 kcal/mol. Because loop insertion can be blocked by incorporating a peptide into the central beta-sheet, it was possible to assign -7 kcal/mol to loop cleavage and -31 kcal/mol to loop insertion. These values are lower than values reported for the serpins alpha 1 -proteinase inhibitor and antithrombin of -53 to -63 kcal/mol, respectively, for loop insertion with negligible enthalpy for loop cleavage. A free energy difference of -9 kcal/mol has been reported between the active and spontaneously loop inserted "latent forms" of PAI-1, which is significantly smaller in magnitude than the -31 kcal/mol of enthalpy we measured for loop insertion. Because the enthalpy should relate closely to those regions of PAI-1 that have moved to lower potential energy, a difference distance matrix is presented that identifies regions of PAI-1 that move during loop insertion.     

An indel within the C8 alpha subunit of human complement C8 mediates intracellular binding of C8 gamma and formation of C8 alpha-gamma

Human C8 is one of five complement components (C5b, C6, C7, C8, and C9) that interact to form the cytolytic membrane attack complex, or MAC. It is an oligomeric protein composed of three subunits (C8alpha, C8beta, C8gamma) that are products of different genes. In C8 from serum, these are arranged as a disulfide-linked C8alpha-gamma dimer that is noncovalently associated with C8beta. In this study, the site on C8alpha that mediates intracellular binding of C8gamma to form C8alpha-gamma was identified. From a comparative analysis of indels (insertions/deletions) in C8alpha and its structural homologues C8beta, C6, C7, and C9, it was determined that C8alpha contains a unique insertion (residues 159-175), which includes Cys(164) that forms the disulfide bond to C8gamma. Incorporation of this sequence into C8beta and coexpression of the resulting construct (iC8beta) with C8gamma produced iC8beta-gamma, an atypical disulfide-linked dimer. In related experiments, C8gamma was shown to bind noncovalently to mutant forms of C8alpha and iC8beta in which Cys(164)-->Gly(164) substitutions were made. In addition, C8gamma bound specifically to an immobilized synthetic peptide containing the mutant indel sequence. Together, these results indicate (a) intracellular binding of C8gamma to C8alpha is mediated principally by residues contained within the C8alpha indel, (b) binding is not strictly dependent on Cys(164), and (c) C8gamma must contain a complementary binding site for the C8alpha indel.     

Functional diversification during evolution of the murine alpha(1)-proteinase inhibitor family: role of the hypervariable reactive center loop

Alpha(1)-proteinase inhibitor (alpha(1)-PI) is a member of the serpin superfamily of serine proteinase inhibitors that are involved in the regulation of a number of proteolytic processes. Alpha(1)-PI, like most serpins, functions by covalent binding to, and inhibition of, target proteinases. The interaction between alpha(1)-PI and its target is directed by the so-called reactive center loop (RCL), an approximately 20 residue domain that extends out from the body of the alpha(1)-PI polypeptide and determines the inhibitor's specificity. Mice express at least seven closely related alpha(1)-PI isoforms, encoded by a family of genes clustered at the Spi1 locus on chromosome 12. The amino acid sequence of the RCL region is hypervariable among alpha(1)-PIs, a phenomenon that has been attributed to high rates of evolution driven by positive Darwinian selection. This suggests that the various isoforms are functionally diverse. To test this notion, we have compared the proteinase specificities of individual alpha(1)-PIs from each of the two mouse species. As predicted from the positive Darwinian selection hypothesis, the various alpha(1)-PIs differ in their ability to form covalent complexes with serine proteinases, such as elastase, trypsin, chymotrypsin, and cathepsin G. In addition, they differ in their binding ability to proteinases in crude snake venoms. Importantly, the RCL region of the alpha(1)-PI polypeptide is the primary determinant of isoform-specific differences in proteinase recognition, indicating that hypervariability within this region drives the functional diversification of alpha(1)-PIs during evolution. The possible physiological benefits of alpha(1)-PI diversity are discussed.     

The conformational dynamics of a metastable serpin studied by hydrogen exchange and mass spectrometry

Serpins are a class of protease inhibitors that initially fold to a metastable structure and subsequently undergo a large conformational change to a stable structure when they inhibit their target proteases. How serpins are able to achieve this remarkable conformational rearrangement is still not understood. To address the question of how the dynamic properties of the metastable form may facilitate the conformational change, hydrogen/deuterium exchange and mass spectrometry were employed to probe the conformational dynamics of the serpin human alpha(1)-antitrypsin (alpha(1)AT). It was found that the F helix, which in the crystal structure appears to physically block the conformational change, is highly dynamic in the metastable form. In particular, the C-terminal half of the F helix appears to spend a substantial fraction of time in a partially unfolded state. In contrast, beta-strands 3A and 5A, which must separate to accommodate insertion of the reactive center loop (RCL), are not conformationally flexible in the metastable state but are rigid and stable. The conformational lability required for loop insertion must therefore be triggered during the inhibition reaction. Beta-strand 1C, which anchors the distal end of the RCL and thus prevents transition to the so-called latent form, is also stable, consistent with the observation that alpha(1)AT does not spontaneously adopt the latent form. A surprising degree of flexibility is seen in beta-strand 6A, and it is speculated that this flexibility may deter the formation of edge-edge polymers.     

Interaction between the P14 residue and strand 2 of beta-sheet B is critical for reactive center loop insertion in plasminogen activator inhibitor-2

The molecular interactions driving reactive center loop (RCL) insertion are of considerable interest in gaining a better understanding of the serpin inhibitory mechanism. Previous studies have suggested that interactions in the proximal hinge/breach region may be critical determinants of RCL insertion in serpins. In this study, conformational and functional changes in plasminogen activator inhibitor-2 (PAI-2) following incubation with a panel of synthetic RCL peptides indicated that the P14 residue is critical for RCL insertion, and hence inhibitory activity, in PAI-2. Only RCL peptides with a P14 threonine were able to induce the stressed to relaxed transition and abolish inhibitory activity in PAI-2, indicating that RCL insertion into beta-sheet A of PAI-2 is dependent upon this residue. The recently solved crystal structure of relaxed PAI-2 (PAI-2.RCL peptide complex) allowed detailed analysis of molecular interactions involving P14 related to RCL insertion. Of most interest is the rearrangement of hydrogen bonding around the breach region that accompanies the stressed to relaxed transition, in particular the formation of a side chain hydrogen bond between the threonine at P14 and an adjacent tyrosine on strand 2 of beta-sheet B in relaxed PAI-2. Structural alignment of known serpin sequences showed that this pairing (or the equivalent serine/threonine pairing) is highly conserved ( approximately 87%) in inhibitory serpins and may represent a general structural basis for serpin inhibitory activity.     

Three-dimensional structure of Schistosoma japonicum glutathione S-transferase fused with a six-amino acid conserved neutralizing epitope of gp41 from HIV.

The 3-dimensional crystal structure of glutathione S-transferase (GST) of Schistosoma japonicum (Sj) fused with a conserved neutralizing epitope on gp41 (glycoprotein, 41 kDa) of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) (Muster T et al., 1993, J Virol 67:6642-6647) was determined at 2.5 A resolution. The structure of the 3-3 isozyme rat GST of the mu gene class (Ji X, Zhang P, Armstrong RN, Gilliland GL, 1992, Biochemistry 31:10169-10184) was used as a molecular replacement model. The structure consists of a 4-stranded beta-sheet and 3 alpha-helices in domain 1 and 5 alpha-helices in domain 2. The space group of the Sj GST crystal is P4(3)2(1)2, with unit cell dimensions of a = b = 94.7 A, and c = 58.1 A. The crystal has 1 GST monomer per asymmetric unit, and 2 monomers that form an active dimer are related by crystallographic 2-fold symmetry. In the binding site, the ordered structure of reduced glutathione is observed. The gp41 peptide (Glu-Leu-Asp-Lys-Trp-Ala) fused to the C-terminus of Sj GST forms a loop stabilized by symmetry-related GSTs. The Sj GST structure is compared with previously determined GST structures of mammalian gene classes mu, alpha, and pi. Conserved amino acid residues among the 4 GSTs that are important for hydrophobic and hydrophilic interactions for dimer association and glutathione binding are discussed.     

Pathogenic alpha 1-antitrypsin polymers are formed by reactive loop-beta-sheet A linkage

alpha(1)-Antitrypsin is the most abundant circulating protease inhibitor and the archetype of the serine protease inhibitor or serpin superfamily. Members of this family may be inactivated by point mutations that favor transition to a polymeric conformation. This polymeric conformation underlies diseases as diverse as alpha(1)-antitrypsin deficiency-related cirrhosis, thrombosis, angio-edema, and dementia. The precise structural linkage within a polymer has been the subject of much debate with evidence for reactive loop insertion into beta-sheet A or C or as strand 7A. We have used site directed cysteine mutants and fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) to measure a number of distances between monomeric units in polymeric alpha(1)-antitrypsin. We have then used a combinatorial approach to compare distances determined from FRET with distances obtained from 2.9 x 10(6) different possible orientations of the alpha(1)-antitrypsin polymer. The closest matches between experimental FRET measurements and theoretical structures show conclusively that polymers of alpha(1)-antitrypsin form by insertion of the reactive loop into beta-sheet A.     

Formation of the covalent chymotrypsin.antichymotrypsin complex involves no large-scale movement of the enzyme

alpha(1)-Antichymotrypsin is a member of the serine proteinase inhibitor, or serpin, family that typically forms very long-lived, enzymatically inactive 1:1 complexes (denoted E*I*) with its target proteinases. Serpins share a conserved tertiary structure, in which an exposed region of amino acid residues (called the reactive center loop or RCL) acts as bait for a target proteinase. Within E*I*, the two proteins are linked covalently as a result of nucleophilic attack by Ser(195) of the serine proteinase on the P1 residue within the RCL of the serpin. This species is formally similar to the acyl enzyme species normally seen as an intermediate in serpin proteinase catalysis. However, its subsequent hydrolysis is extremely slow as a result of structural changes within the enzyme leading to distortion of the active site. There is at present an ongoing debate concerning the structure of the E*I* complex; in particular, as to whether the enzyme, bound to P1, maintains its original position at the top of the serpin molecule or instead translocates across the entire length of the serpin, with concomitant insertion of RCL residues P1-P14 within beta-sheet A and a large separation of the enzyme and RCL residue P1'. We report time-resolved fluorescence energy transfer and rapid mixing/quench studies that support the former model. Our results indicate that the distance between residue P1' in alpha(1)-antichymotrypsin and the amino terminus of chymotrypsin actually decreases on conversion of the encounter complex E.I to E*I*. These results led us to formulate a comprehensive mechanism that accounted both for our results and for those of others supporting the two different E*I* structures. In this mechanism, partial insertion of the RCL, with no large perturbation of the P1' enzyme distance, is followed by covalent acyl enzyme formation. Full insertion can subsequently take place, in a reversible fashion, with the position of equilibrium between the partially and fully inserted complexes depending on the particular serpin-proteinase pair under consideration.