The type of competition modulates the ecophysiological response of grassland species to elevated CO2 and drought

The effects of elevated CO₂ and drought on ecophysiological parameters in grassland species have been examined, but few studies have investigated the effect of competition on those parameters under climate change conditions. The objective of this study was to determine the effect of elevated CO₂ and drought on the response of plant water relations, gas exchange, chlorophyll a fluorescence and aboveground biomass in four grassland species, as well as to assess whether the type of competition modulates that response. Elevated CO₂ in well‐watered conditions increased aboveground biomass by augmenting CO₂ assimilation. Drought reduced biomass by reducing CO₂ assimilation rate via stomatal limitation and, when drought was more severe, also non‐stomatal limitation. When plants were grown under the combined conditions of elevated CO₂ and drought, drought limitation observed under ambient CO₂ was reduced, permitting higher CO₂ assimilation and consequently reducing the observed decrease in aboveground biomass. The response to climate change was species‐specific and dependent on the type of competition. Thus, the response to elevated CO₂ in well‐watered grasses was higher in monoculture than in mixture, while it was higher in mixture compared to monoculture for forbs. On the other hand, forbs were more affected than grasses by drought in monoculture, while in mixture the negative effect of drought was higher in grasses than in forbs, due to a lower capacity to acquire water and mineral nutrients. These differences in species‐level growth responses to CO₂ and drought may lead to changes in the composition and biodiversity of the grassland plant community in future climate conditions.     

Tree species diversity interacts with elevated CO2 to induce a greater root system response

As a consequence of land‐use change and the burning of fossil fuels, atmospheric concentrations of CO₂ are increasing and altering the dynamics of the carbon cycle in forest ecosystems. In a number of studies using single tree species, fine root biomass has been shown to be strongly increased by elevated CO₂. However, natural forests are often intimate mixtures of a number of co‐occurring species. To investigate the interaction between tree mixture and elevated CO₂, Alnus glutinosa, Betula pendula and Fagus sylvatica were planted in areas of single species and a three species polyculture in a free‐air CO₂ enrichment study (BangorFACE). The trees were exposed to ambient or elevated CO₂ (580 μmol mol^?1) for 4 years. Fine and coarse root biomass, together with fine root turnover and fine root morphological characteristics were measured. Fine root biomass and morphology responded differentially to the elevated CO₂ at different soil depths in the three species when grown in monocultures. In polyculture, a greater response to elevated CO₂ was observed in coarse roots to a depth of 20 cm, and fine root area index to a depth of 30 cm. Total fine root biomass was positively affected by elevated CO₂ at the end of the experiment, but not by species diversity. Our data suggest that existing biogeochemical cycling models parameterized with data from species grown in monoculture may be underestimating the belowground response to global change.     

Species-specific responses of plant communities to altered carbon and nutrient availability

In a field microcosm experiment, species‐specific responses of aboveground biomass of two California annual grassland communities to elevated CO₂ and nutrient availability were investigated. One community grows on shallow, nutrient‐poor serpentine‐derived soil whereas the other occurs on deeper, modestly fertile sandstone/greenstone‐derived substrate. In most species, CO₂ effects did not appear until late in the growing season, probably because the elevated CO₂ increased water‐use‐efficiency easing, the onset of the summer drought. Responses of aboveground biomass to elevated CO₂ differed depending on nutrient availability. Similarly, biomass responses to nutrient treatments differed depending on the CO₂ status. For the majority of the species, production increased most under elevated CO₂ with added nutrients (N,P,K, and micro nutrients). Some species were losers under conditions that increased overall community production, including Bromus hordeaceus in the serpentine community (negative biomass response under elevated CO₂) and Lotus wrangelianus in both communities (negative biomass response with added nitrogen). Treatment and competitive effects on species‐specific biomass varied in both magnitude and direction, especially in the serpentine community, significantly affecting community structure. Individual resource environments are likely to be affected by neighbouring plants, and these competitive interactions complicate predictions of species' responses to elevated CO₂.     

CO2‐caused change in plant species composition rivals the shift in vegetation between mid‐grass and tallgrass prairies

Atmospheric CO₂ enrichment usually changes the relative contributions of plant species to biomass production of grasslands, but the types of species favored and mechanisms by which change is mediated differ among ecosystems. We measured changes in the contributions of C₃ perennial forbs and C₄ grasses to aboveground biomass production of tallgrass prairie assemblages grown along a field CO₂ gradient (250–500 μmol mol^?1) in central Texas USA. Vegetation was grown on three soil types and irrigated each season with water equivalent to the growing season mean of precipitation for the area. We predicted that CO₂ enrichment would increase the forb contribution to community production, and favor tall‐grasses over mid‐grasses by increasing soil water content and reducing the frequency with which soil water fell below a limitation threshold. CO₂ enrichment favored forbs over grasses on only one of three soil types, a Mollisol. The grass fraction of production increased dramatically across the CO₂ gradient on all soils. Contribution of the tall‐grass Sorghastrum nutans to production increased at elevated CO₂ on the two most coarse‐textured of the soils studied, a clay Mollisol and sandy Alfisol. The CO₂‐caused increase in Sorghastrum was accompanied by an offsetting decline in production of the mid‐grass Bouteloua curtipendula. Increased CO₂ favored the tall‐grass over mid‐grass by increasing soil water content and apparently intensifying competition for light or other resources (Mollisol) or reducing the frequency with which soil water dipped below threshold levels (Alfisol). An increase in CO₂ of 250 μmol mol^?1 above the pre‐industrial level thus led to a shift in the relative production of established species that is similar in magnitude to differences observed between mid‐grass and tallgrass prairies along a precipitation gradient in the central USA. By reducing water limitation to plants, atmospheric CO₂ enrichment may alter the composition and even structure of grassland vegetation.     

Biomass and compositional changes occur in chalk grassland turves exposed to elevated CO2 for two seasons in FACE

Artificial turves composed of 7 chalk grassland species (Festuca ovina L.; Briza media L.; Bromopsis erecta (Hudson) Fourr.; Plantago media L.; Sanguisorba minor Scop.; Anthyllis vulneraria L. and Lotus corniculatus L.) were grown from seed and exposed to two seasons of elevated (600 μmol mol^–1) and ambient (340 μmol mol^–1) CO₂ concentrations in free air CO₂ enrichment (ETH-FACE, Zurich). The turves were clipped regularly to a height of 5 cm and assessed for above ground biomass production and relative abundance based on accumulated clipped dry biomass as well as by point quadrat recording. Below ground biomass production was assessed with root in-growth bags during the second season of growth. Increases in total biomass (> 30%) were noted in elevated CO₂, but the differences did not become significant until the second season of growth. Individual species’ biomass varied in response to elevated CO₂, with significant increases in biomass in elevated CO₂ turves for both legume species, and no significant CO₂ effect on S. minor or P. media. An initial positive CO₂ effect on biomass of combined grass species was reversed by the end of the experiment with less biomass and a significantly smaller proportion of total biomass present in elevated CO₂, which was attributed primarily to changes in proportion of F. ovina. Species relative abundance was significantly affected by elevated CO₂ in the final 4 of the 6 clip events, with the legume species increasing in proportion at the expense of the other species, particularly the grasses. Root length and dry weight were both significantly increased in elevated CO₂ (77% and 89%, respectively), and these increases were greater than increases in shoot biomass (36%) from the same period. Species responses to elevated CO₂, within the model community, were not consistent with predictions made from data on individual species, leading to the conclusion that responses to elevated CO₂, at the community level, and species within the community level, are the result of direct physiological effects and indirect competitive effects. These conclusions are discussed with respect to the ecological responses of natural communities, and the chalk grassland community in particular, to elevated CO₂.     

Transpiration of a 64-year-old maritime pine stand in Portugal

Alpine plant species have been shown to exhibit a more pronounced increase in leaf photosynthesis under elevated CO₂ than lowland plants. In order to test whether this higher carbon fixation efficiency will translate into increased biomass production under CO₂ enrichment we exposed plots of narrow alpine grassland (Swiss Central Alps, 2470 m) to ambient (355 l l^-1) and elevated (680 l l^-1) CO₂ concentration using open top chambers. Part of the plost received moderate mineral nutrient additions (40 kg ha^-1 year^-1 of nitrogen in a complete fertilizer mix). Under natural nutrient supply CO₂ enrichment had no effect on biomass production per unit land area during any of the three seasons studied so far. Correspondingly, the dominant species Carex curvula and Leontodon helveticus as well as Trifolium alpinum did not show a growth response either at the population level or at the shoot level. However, the subdominant generalistic species Poa alpina strongly increased shoot growth (+47%). Annual root production (in ingrowth cores) was significantly enhanced in C. curvula in the 2nd and 3rd year of investigation (+43%) but was not altered in the bulk samples for all species. Fertilizer addition generally stimulated above-ground (+48%) and below-ground (+26%) biomass production right from the beginning. Annual variations in weather conditions during summer also strongly influenced above-ground biomass production (19–27% more biomass in warm seasons compared to cool seasons). However, neither nutrient availability nor climate had a significant effect on the CO₂ response of the plants. Our results do not support the hypothesis that alpine plants, due to their higher carbon uptake efficiency, will increase biomass production under future atmospheric CO₂ enrichment, at least not in such late successional communities. However, as indicated by the response of P. alpina, species-specific responses occur which may lead to altered community structure and perhaps ecosystem functioning in the long-term. Our findings further suggest that possible climatic changes are likely to have a greater impact on plant growth in alpine environments than the direct stimulation of photosynthesis by CO₂. Counter-intuitively, our results suggest that even under moderate climate warming or enhanced atmospheric nitrogen deposition positive biomass responses to CO₂ enrichment of the currently dominating species are unlikely.     

Responses of C4 grasses to atmospheric CO2 enrichment

Summary The growth and photosynethetic responses to atmospheric CO₂ enrichment of 4 species of C₄ grasses grown at two levels of irradiance were studied. We sought to determine whether CO₂ enrichment would yield proportionally greater growth enhancement in the C₄ grasses when they were grown at low irradiance than when grown at high irradiance. The species studied were Echinochloa crusgalli, Digitaria sanguinalis, Eleusine indica, and Setaria faberi. Plants were grown in controlled environment chambers at 350, 675 and 1,000 l 1^-1 CO₂ and 1,000 or 150 mol m^-2 s^-1 photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD). An increase in CO₂ concentration and PPFD significantly affected net photosynthesis and total biomass production of all plants. Plants grown at low PPFD had significantly lower rates of photosynthesis, produced less biomass, and had reduced responses to increases in CO₂. Plants grown in CO₂-enriched atmosphere had lower photosynthetic capacity relative to the low CO₂ grown plants when exposed to lower CO₂ concentration at the time of measurement, but had greater rate of photosynthesis when exposed to increasing PPFD. The light level under which the plants were growing did not influence the CO₂ compensation point for photosynthesis.     

Plant species-specific changes in root-inhabiting fungi in a California annual grassland: responses to elevated CO2 and nutrients

Five co-occurring plant species from an annual mediterranean grassland were grown in monoculture for 4 months in pots inside open-top chambers at the Jasper Ridge Biological Preserve (San Mateo County, California). The plants were exposed to elevated atmospheric CO₂ and soil nutrient enrichment in a complete factorial experiment. The response of root-inhabiting non-mycorrhizal and arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi to the altered resource base depended strongly on the plant species. Elevated CO₂ and fertilization altered the ratio of non-mycorrhizal to mycorrhizal fungal colonization for some plant species, but not for others. Percent root infection by non-mycorrhizal fungi increased by over 500% for Linanthus parviflorus in elevated CO₂, but decreased by over 80% for Bromus hordeaceus. By contrast, the mean percent infection by mycorrhizal fungi increased in response to elevated CO₂ for all species, but significantly only for Avena barbata and B. hordeaceus. Percent infection by mycorrhizal fungi increased, decreased, or remained unchanged for different plant hosts in response to fertilization. There was evidence of a strong interaction between the two treatments for some plant species and non-mycorrhizal and mycorrhizal fungi. This study demonstrated plant species- and soil fertility-dependent shifts in below-ground plant resource allocation to different morpho-groups of fungal symbionts. This may have consequences for plant community responses to elevated CO₂ in this California grassland ecosystem. Received: 2 June 1997 / Accepted: 22 August 1997     

Elevated CO2 increases belowground respiration in California grasslands

This study was designed to identify potential effects of elevated CO₂ on belowground respiration (the sum of root and heterotrophic respiration) in field and microcosm ecosystems and on the annual carbon budget. We made three sets of respiration measurements in two CO₂ treatments, i.e., (1) monthly in the sandstone grassland and in microcosms from November 1993 to June 1994; (2) at the annual peak of live biomass (March and April) in the serpentine and sandstone grasslands in 1993 and 1994; and (3) at peak biomass in the microcosms with monocultures of seven species in 1993. To help understand ecosystem carbon cycling, we also made supplementary measurements of belowground respiration monthly in sandstone and serpentine grasslands located within 500 m of the CO₂ experiment site. The seasonal average respiration rate in the sandstone grassland was 2.12 mol m^-2 s^-1 in elevated CO₂, which was 42% higher than the 1.49 mol m^-2 s^-1 measured in ambient CO₂ (P=0.007). Studies of seven individual species in the microcosms indicated that respiration was positively correlated with plant biomass and increased, on average, by 70% with CO₂. Monthly measurements revealed a strong seasonality in belowground respiration, being low (0–0.5 mol CO₂ m^-2 s^-1 in the two grasslands adjacent to the CO₂ site) in the summer dry season and high (2–4 mol CO₂ m^-2 s^-1 in the sandstone grassland and 2–7 mol CO₂ m^-2 s^-1 in the microcosms) during the growing season from the onset of fall rains in November to early spring in April and May. Estimated annual carbon effluxes from the soil were 323 and 440 g C m^-2 year^-1 for the sandstone grasslands in ambient and elevated CO₂. That CO₂-stimulated increase in annual soil carbon efflux is more than twice as big as the increase in aboveground net primary productivity (NPP_a) and approximately 60% of NPP_a in this grassland in the current CO₂ environment. The results of this study suggest that below-ground respiration can dissipate most of the increase in photosynthesis stimulated by elevated CO₂.CIWDPB Publication # 1271     

Fungal root colonization responses in natural grasslands after long-term exposure to elevated atmospheric CO2

Arbuscular mycorrhizae, ubiquitous mutualistic symbioses between plant roots and fungi in the order Glomales, are believed to be important controllers of plant responses to global change, in particular to elevated atmospheric CO₂. In order to test if any effects on the symbiosis can persist after long-term treatment, we examined root colonization by arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) and other fungi of several plant species from two grassland communities after continuous exposure to elevated atmospheric CO₂ for six growing seasons in the field. For plant species from both a sandstone and a serpentine annual grassland there was evidence for changes in fungal root colonization, with changes occurring as a function of plant host species. We documented decreases in percentage nonmycorrhizal fungal root colonization in elevated CO₂ for several plant species. Total AM root colonization (%) only increased significantly for one out of the five plant species in each grassland. However, when dividing AM fungal hyphae into two groups of hyphae (fine endophyte and coarse endophyte), we could document significant responses of AM fungi that were hidden when only total percentage colonization was measured. We also documented changes in elevated CO₂ in the percentage of root colonized by both AM hyphal types simultaneously. Our results demonstrate that changes in fungal root colonization can occur after long-term CO₂ enrichment, and that the level of resolution of the study of AM fungal responses may have to be increased to uncover significant changes to the CO₂ treatment. This study is also one of the first to document compositional changes in the AM fungi colonizing roots of plants grown in elevated CO₂. Although it is difficult to relate the structural data directly to functional changes, possible implications of the observed changes for plant communities are discussed.     

Effects of elevated CO2 and phosphorus addition on productivity and community composition of intact monoliths from calcareous grassland

We investigated the effects of elevated CO₂ (600 μl l⁻¹ vs 350 μl l⁻¹) and phosphorus supply (1 g P m⁻² year⁻¹ vs unfertilized) on intact monoliths from species-rich calcareous grassland in a greenhouse. Aboveground community dry mass remained almost unaffected by elevated CO₂ in the first year (+6%, n.s.), but was significantly stimulated by CO₂ enrichment in year two (+26%, P<0.01). Among functional groups, only graminoids contributed significantly to this increase. The effect of phosphorus alone on community biomass was small in both years and marginally significant only when analyzed with MANOVA (+6% in year one, +9% in year two, 0.1 ≥P > 0.05). Belowground biomass and stubble after two seasons were not different in elevated CO₂ and when P was added. The small initial increase in aboveground community biomass under elevated CO₂ is explained by the fact that some species, in particular Carex flacca, responded very positively right from the beginning, while others, especially the dominant Bromus erectus, responded negatively to CO₂ enrichment. Shifts in community composition towards more responsive species explain the much larger CO₂ response in the second year. These shifts, i.e., a decline in xerophytic elements (B. erectus) and an increase in mesophytic grasses and legumes occurred independently of treatments in all monoliths but were accelerated significantly by elevated CO₂. The difference in average biomass production at elevated compared to ambient CO₂ was higher when P was supplied (at the community level the CO₂ response was enhanced from 20% to 33% when P was added, in graminoids from 17% to 27%, in legumes from 4% to 60%, and in C. flacca from 120% to 298% by year two). Based on observations in this and similar studies, we suggest that interactions between CO₂ concentration, species presence, and nutrient availability will govern community responses to elevated CO₂. Received: 12 July 1997 / Accepted: 28 March 1998     

Interspecific variations in responses of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Festuca rubra</Emphasis> and <Emphasis Type="Italic">Trifolium pratense</Emphasis> to a severe clipping under environmental changes

Understanding and predicting possible responses of grassland species to global change is of important meaning for adapting grassland management to a changed and changing environment. A laboratory clipping experiment was conducted to examine the interspecific responses in an ecological context of competition and environmental changes. Festuca rubra and Trifolium pratense, either in monoculture or two- and three-species mixtures, were grown in three environmental combinations (ambient and increased temperature, repetitive N supply, and simulated acid rain), respectively. After a growth time of three months, plants were clipped at the height of 1.0 cm above soil surface. Plant height and aboveground biomass prior clipping, and survival rate and regrowth (height and biomass) after clipping were analyzed. F. rubra and T. pratense responded differently in compensatory growth and competition intensity to environmental change and co-existing species. The differences in their physiological and ecological traits may account for species-dependent responses. The present study emphasizes that predicting the plant assemblage response in the face of global change requires in understanding the integrating effects of abiotic and biotic factors.     

[CO2]- and density-dependent competition between grassland species

The predicted ongoing increase of atmospheric carbon dioxide levels is considered to be one of the main threats to biodiversity due to potential changes in biotic interactions. We tested whether effects of intra‐ and interspecific planting density of the calcareous grassland perennials Bromus erectus and Carex flacca change in response to elevated [CO₂] (600 ppm) by using factorial combinations of seven densities (0, 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, 24 tillers per 8 × 8 cm² cell) of both species in plots with and without CO₂ enrichment. Although aboveground biomass of C. flacca was increased by 54% under elevated [CO₂], the combined aboveground biomass of the whole stand was not significantly increased. C. flacca tended to produce more tillers under elevated [CO₂] while B. erectus produced less tillers. The positive effect of [CO₂] on the number of tillers of C. flacca was strongest at high intraspecific densities. On the other hand, the negative effect of [CO₂] on the number of tillers of B. erectus was not present at intermediate intraspecific planting densities. Seed production of C. flacca was more than doubled under elevated [CO₂], while seed production of B. erectus was not affected. Moreover, the mass per seed of C. flacca was increased by elevated [CO₂] at intermediate interspecific planting densities while the mass per seed of B. erectus was decreased by elevated [CO₂] at high interspecific planting densities. Our results show that the responses of C. flacca and B. erectus to elevated [CO₂] depend in a complex way on initial planting densities of both species. In other words, competition between these two model species is both [CO₂]‐ and density dependent. On average, however, the effects of [CO₂] on the individual species indicate that the composition of calcareous grasslands is likely to change under elevated [CO₂] in favor of C. flacca.     

Plant Nitrogen Dynamics in Shortgrass Steppe under Elevated Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide

The direct and indirect effects of increasing levels of atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO₂) on plant nitrogen (N) content were studied in a shortgrass steppe ecosystem in northeastern Colorado, USA. Beginning in 1997 nine experimental plots were established: three open-top chambers with ambient CO₂ levels (approximately 365 mol mol^–1), three open-top chambers with twice-ambient CO₂ levels (approximately 720 mol mol^–1), and three unchambered control plots. After 3 years of growing-season CO₂ treatment, the aboveground N concentration of plants grown under elevated atmospheric CO₂ decreased, and the carbon–nitrogen (C:N) ratio increased. At the same time, increased aboveground biomass production under elevated atmospheric CO₂ conditions increased the net transfer of N out of the soil of elevated-CO₂ plots. Aboveground biomass production after simulated herbivory was also greater under elevated CO₂ compared to ambient CO₂. Surprisingly, no significant changes in belowground plant tissue N content were detected in response to elevated CO₂. Measurements of individual species at peak standing phytomass showed significant effects of CO₂ treatment on aboveground plant tissue N concentration and significant differences between species in N concentration, suggesting that changes in species composition under elevated CO₂ will contribute to overall changes in nutrient cycling. Changes in plant N content, driven by changes in aboveground plant N concentration, could have important consequences for biogeochemical cycling rates and the long-term productivity of the shortgrass steppe as atmospheric CO₂ concentrations increase.     

Water relations in grassland and desert ecosystems exposed to elevated atmospheric CO2

Atmospheric CO₂ enrichment may stimulate plant growth directly through (1) enhanced photosynthesis or indirectly, through (2) reduced plant water consumption and hence slower soil moisture depletion, or the combination of both. Herein we describe gas exchange, plant biomass and species responses of five native or semi-native temperate and Mediterranean grasslands and three semi-arid systems to CO₂ enrichment, with an emphasis on water relations. Increasing CO₂ led to decreased leaf conductance for water vapor, improved plant water status, altered seasonal evapotranspiration dynamics, and in most cases, periodic increases in soil water content. The extent, timing and duration of these responses varied among ecosystems, species and years. Across the grasslands of the Kansas tallgrass prairie, Colorado shortgrass steppe and Swiss calcareous grassland, increases in aboveground biomass from CO₂ enrichment were relatively greater in dry years. In contrast, CO₂-induced aboveground biomass increases in the Texas C₃/C₄ grassland and the New Zealand pasture seemed little or only marginally influenced by yearly variation in soil water, while plant growth in the Mojave Desert was stimulated by CO₂ in a relatively wet year. Mediterranean grasslands sometimes failed to respond to CO₂-related increased late-season water, whereas semiarid Negev grassland assemblages profited. Vegetative and reproductive responses to CO₂ were highly varied among species and ecosystems, and did not generally follow any predictable pattern in regard to functional groups. Results suggest that the indirect effects of CO₂ on plant and soil water relations may contribute substantially to experimentally induced CO₂-effects, and also reflect local humidity conditions. For landscape scale predictions, this analysis calls for a clear distinction between biomass responses due to direct CO₂ effects on photosynthesis and those indirect CO₂ effects via soil moisture as documented here.     

A field study of the effects of elevated CO2 on plant biomass and community structure in a calcareous grassland

The effects of elevated CO₂ on plant biomass and community structure have been studied for four seasons in a calcareous grassland in northwest Switzerland. This highly diverse, semi-natural plant community is dominated by the perennial grass Bromus erectus and is mown twice a year to maintain species composition. Plots of 1.3 m² were exposed to ambient or elevated CO₂ concentrations (n = 8) using a novel CO₂ exposure technique, screen-aided CO₂ control (SACC) starting in March 1994. In the 1st year of treatment, the annual harvested biomass (sum of aboveground biomass from mowings in June and October) was not significantly affected by elevated CO₂. However, biomass increased significantly at elevated CO₂ in the 2nd (+20%, P = 0.05), 3rd (+21%, P = 0.02) and 4th years (+29%, P = 0.02). There were no detectable differences in root biomass in the top 8 cm of soil between CO₂ treatments on eight out of nine sampling dates. There were significant differences in CO₂ responsiveness between functional groups (legumes, non-leguminous forbs, graminoids) in the 2nd (P = 0.07) and 3rd (P < 0.001) years of the study. The order of CO₂ responsiveness among functional groups changed substantially from the 2nd to the 3rd year; for example, non-leguminous forbs had the smallest relative response in the 2nd year and the largest in the 3rd year. By the 3rd year of CO₂ exposure, large species-specific differences in CO₂ response had developed. For five important species or genera the order of responsiveness was Lotus corniculatus (+271%), Carex flacca (+249%), Bromus erectus (+33%), Sanguisorba minor (no significant CO₂ effect), and six Trifolium species (a negative response that was not significant). The positive CO₂ responses in Bromus and Carex were most closely related to increases in tiller number. Species richness was not affected by CO₂ treatment, but species evenness increased under elevated CO₂ (modified Hill ratio; P = 0.03) in June of the 3rd year, resulting in a marginally significant increase in species diversity (Simpson's index; P = 0.09). This and other experiments with calcareous grassland plants show that elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentrations can substantially alter the structure of calcareous grassland communities and may increase plant community biomass. Received: 12 July 1997 / Accepted: 14 September 1998     

Genetic variation in Sanguisorba minor after 6 years in situ selection under elevated CO2

Genetic variation within plant species in their response to elevated CO₂ could be important for long‐term changes in plant community composition because it allows for selection of responsive genotypes. Six years of in situ CO₂ enrichment in a temperate grassland offered a unique opportunity to investigate such microevolutionary changes in a common herb of that plant community, Sanguisorba minor. Plants were grown from seeds collected at the end of a 6‐year treatment in either ambient or elevated CO₂. The resulting seedlings were grown under ambient or elevated CO₂ and with or without interspecific competition by Bromus erectus in the greenhouse for two seasons. The effect of competition was included because we expected selection under elevated CO₂ to favour increased competitive ability. Elevated CO₂ in the greenhouse and competition both caused a significant reduction of the total dry mass in S. minor, by 12% and 40%, respectively, with no interaction between CO₂ and competition. Genetic variation in all traits was substantial. Seed families responded differently to competition, but the family × greenhouse CO₂ interaction was rather weak. There was no main effect of the field CO₂ treatment on any parameter analysed in the greenhouse. However, the field CO₂ treatment did significantly interact with the greenhouse CO₂ treatment for the cumulative number of leaves, suggesting microevolutionary change in this plant trait. Families from ambient field CO₂ produced fewer leaves under elevated greenhouse CO₂, whereas families from elevated field CO₂ retained constant number of leaves in either greenhouse CO₂ treatment. Since this resulted in increased litter production of the families from elevated field CO₂ under elevated greenhouse CO₂, the microevolutionary response should, in turn, affect ecosystem functions through dry matter recycling.     

Flowering in grassland predicted by CO2 and resource effects on species aboveground biomass

Continuing enrichment of atmospheric CO₂ may change plant community composition, in part by altering the availability of other limiting resources including soil water, nutrients, or light. The combined effects of CO₂ enrichment and altered resource availability on species flowering remain poorly understood. We quantified flowering culm and ramet production and biomass allocation to flowering culms/ramets for 10 years in C₄‐dominated grassland communities on contrasting soils along a CO₂ concentration gradient spanning pre‐industrial to expected mid‐21st century levels (250–500 μl/L). CO₂ enrichment explained up to 77% of the variation in flowering culm count across soils for three of the five species, and was correlated with flowering culm count on at least one soil for four of five species. In contrast, allocation to flowering culms was only weakly correlated with CO₂ enrichment for two species. Flowering culm counts were strongly correlated with species aboveground biomass (AGB; R² = .34–.74), a measure of species abundance. CO₂ enrichment also increased soil moisture and decreased light levels within the canopy but did not affect soil inorganic nitrogen availability. Structural equation models fit across the soils suggested species‐specific controls on flowering in two general forms: (1) CO₂ effects on flowering culm count mediated by canopy light level and relative species AGB (species AGB/total AGB) or by soil moisture effects on flowering culm count; (2) effects of canopy light level or soil inorganic nitrogen on flowering and/or relative species AGB, but with no significant CO₂ effect. Understanding the heterogeneity in species responses to CO₂ enrichment in plant communities across soils in edaphically variable landscapes is critical to predict CO₂ effects on flowering and other plant fitness components, and species potential to adapt to future environmental changes.     

Effects of Warming, Summer Drought, and CO2 Enrichment on Aboveground Biomass Production, Flowering Phenology, and Community Structure in an Upland Grassland Ecosystem

Future climate scenarios predict simultaneous changes in environmental conditions, but the impacts of multiple climate change drivers on ecosystem structure and function remain unclear. We used a novel experimental approach to examine the responses of an upland grassland ecosystem to the 2080 climate scenario predicted for the study area (3.5°C temperature increase, 20% reduction in summer precipitation, atmospheric CO₂ levels of 600 ppm) over three growing seasons. We also assessed whether patterns of grassland response to a combination of climate change treatments could be forecast by ecosystem responses to single climate change drivers. Effects of climate change on aboveground production showed considerable seasonal and interannual variation; April biomass increased in response to both warming and the simultaneous application of warming, summer drought, and CO₂ enrichment, whereas October biomass responses were either non-significant or negative depending on the year. Negative impacts of summer drought on production were only observed in combination with a below-average rainfall regime, and showed lagged effects on spring biomass. Elevated CO₂ had no significant effect on aboveground biomass during this study. Both warming and the 2080 climate change scenario were associated with a significant advance in flowering time for the dominant grass species studied. However, flowering phenology showed no significant response to either summer drought or elevated CO₂. Species diversity and equitability showed no response to climate change treatments throughout this study. Overall, our data suggest that single-factor warming experiments may provide valuable information for projections of future ecosystem changes in cool temperate grasslands.     

Effects of CO2 enrichment on whole-plant carbon budget of seedlings of Fagus grandifolia and Acer saccharum in low irradiance

Carbon exchange rates (CER) and whole-plant carbon balances of beech (Fagus grandifolia) and sugar maple (Acer saccharum) were compared for seedlings grown under low irradiance to determine the effects of atmospheric CO₂ enrichment on shade-tolerant seedlings of co-dominant species. Under contemporary atmospheric CO₂, photosynthetic rate per unit mass of beech was lower than for sugar maple, and atmospheric CO₂ enrich ment enhanced photosynthesis for beech only. Aboveground respiration per unit mass decreased with CO₂ enrichment for both species while root respiration per unitmass decreased for sugar maple only. Under contemporary atmoapheric CO₂, beech had lower C uptake per plant than sugar maple, while C losses per plant to nocturnal aboveground and root respiration were similar for both species. Under elevated CO₂, C uptake per plant was similar for both species, indicating a significant relative increase in whole-seedling CER with CO₂ enrich ment for beech but not for sugar maple. Total C loss per plant to aboveground respiration was decreased for beech only because increase in sugar maple leaf mass counterbalanced a reduction in respiration rates. Carbon loss to root respiration per plant was not changed by CO₂ enrichment for either species. However, changes in maintenance respiration cost and nitrogen level suggest changes in tissue composition with elevated CO₂. Beech had a greater net daily C gain with CO₂ enrichment than did sugar maple in contrast to a lower one under contemporary CO₂. Elevated CO₂ preferentially enhances the net C balance of beech by increasing photosynthesis and reducing respiration cost. In all cases, the greatest C lost was by roots, indicating the importance of belowground biomass in net C gain. Relative growth rate estimated from biomass accumulation was not affected by CO₂ enrichment for either species possibly because of slow growth under low light. This study indicates the importance of direct effects of CO₂ enrichment when predicting potential change in species distribution with global climate change.