Evidence for separate translocation pathways in determining cadmium accumulation in grain and aerial plant parts in rice

Background  

Cadmium (Cd) translocation and accumulation in the grain and aerial plant parts of rice (Oryza sativa L.) is an important aspect of food safety and phytoextraction in areas with contaminated soil. Because control of Cd translocation and accumulation is likely to be determined by the plants genetics, the Cd contents of grain and the aerial parts of rice may be manipulated to improve food safety and for phytoextraction ability. This study studied Cd translocation and accumulation and their genetic control in aerial parts of rice to provide a starting point for improving food safety and phytoextraction in Cd-contaminated soils.     

Phytoextraction of cadmium with Thlaspi caerulescens

The in situ phytoextraction of cadmium from soils can only be achieved using plants that are both tolerant to high Cd concentrations and able to extract sufficient amounts of the metal. However, very few plant species are capable of remediating Cd polluted soils in a reasonable time frame. This paper aims to show that the population of the hyperaccumulator Thlaspi caerulescens J. & C. Presl. from Viviez (south of France), which has a high Cd-accumulating capability, is an efficient tool to remove Cd from contaminated soils. Roots of T. caerulescensViviez proliferate in hot spots of metals in soils which is particularly advantageous because of heterogeneity of the distribution of metal in polluted soils. Isotopic techniques showed that plants from this population acquire Cd from the same pools as non-accumulating species, but that it was much more efficient than non-hyperaccumulators at removing the metal from the soil labile pool. This is due: to (i) a specific rooting strategy, and (ii) a high uptake rate resulting from the existence in this population of Cd-specific transport channels or carriers in the root membrane. Growth and overall extraction can be improved with appropriate N fertilisation, supplied either as mineral fertilisers or uncontaminated sewage sludge. Selecting bigger plants is possible from within a suitable Cd-accumulating population to improve the phytoextraction process. Growing the Cd-accumulating populations results in a reduction in the availability of Cd and Zn as shown with field and lysimeter experiments conducted for several years. As a result, on a practical aspect, Cd hyperaccumulating populations of T. caerulescens may be used as a tool to efficiently reduce the availability of Cd in soils, providing appropriate populations are used.     

矿区绿化树木对镉和锌的吸收与分布

研究了南京某矿区11种树木的重金属吸收和分布特征.结果表明：树木对重金属的吸收和富集因树木种类、部位及重金属种类的不同而异.法国冬青对Cd的含量、富集和转运系数均高于其它树种,可以植物萃取方式修复土壤污染.Cd主要积累在树木根部,树木不同器官对Cd积累能力的总趋势为根＞叶及枝＞树皮＞树干;而Zn更多地积累在树木地上部（叶和枝）而非根部.11种树木对Cd和Zn的富集系数均<0.2.树木对Cd和Zn的转运系数差异显著,总体上是Zn>Cd.     

Effects of Soil Type and Genotype on Cadmium Accumulation by Rootstalk Crops: Implications for Phytomanagement

The variations of Cd accumulation in three rootstalk crop species (radish, carrot and potato) were investigated by using twelve cultivars grown in acidic Ferralsols and neutral Cambisols under two Cd treatments (0.3 and 0.6 mg kg^?1) in a pot experiment. The result showed that the total Cd uptake was significantly affected by genotype, soil type and interaction between them, suggesting the importance of selecting proper cultivars for phytoextraction in a given soil type. Among the cultivars tested, potato cultivar Luyin No.1 in Ferralsols and radish cultivar Zhedachang in Cambisols exhibited the highest Cd phytoextraction efficiency in aerial parts (4.45% and 0.59%, respectively) under 0.6 mg kg^?1Cd treatment. Furthermore, the Cd concentrations in their edible parts were below the National Food Hygiene Standard of China (0.1 mg kg^?1, fresh weight). Therefore, phytomanagement of slightly Cd-contaminated soils using rootstalk crops for safe food production combined with long-term phytoextraction was feasible, and potato cultivar Luyin No.1 for Ferralsols and radish cultivar Zhedachang for Cambisols were promising candidates for this approach.     

Foliar Spraying and Seed Soaking of Zinc Fertilizers Decreased Cadmium Accumulation in Cucumbers Grown in Cd-Contaminated Soils

It is important to use proper agronomic management to reduce cadmium (Cd) accumulation in plants, ensuring food safety. To find the most effective agronomic approach, the effect of foliar spraying and seed soaking of zinc (Zn) fertilizers on Cd accumulation in cucumbers (Cucumis sativus L.) grown in two soil Cd levels (2 and 5 mg kg^?1 Cd) with and without an immobilizing amendment (red mud, RM) was investigated in the present study. The results showed that the treatment of foliar Zn or seed Zn significantly decreased the Cd concentration in cucumber shoots by about 12–36% in Cd-contaminated soils without amendment. Combined with RM treatment, the foliar Zn treatment further decreased the Cd concentration in cucumber shoots by up to 48–66% in Cd-contaminated soils. There were significant negative correlations between Cd and Zn concentrations in shoots of cucumbers grown in soils treated with RM and foliar Zn. The results revealed that the cucumber seedlings treated with RM and foliar Zn had a higher capacity for limiting the transfer of Cd to aboveground tissues. The results also suggested that increasing seed Zn concentrations sufficiently might act as an efficient, economic, and practical method for decreasing Cd uptake in crops grown in mildly Cd-contaminated and Zn-deficient soils.     

Peanut as a potential crop for bioenergy production via Cd-phytoextraction: A life-cycle pot experiment

Aims

The current study aimed to assess the potential of peanut (Arachis hypogaea L.) for bioenergy production via phytoextraction in cadmium (Cd) -contaminated soils and screen appropriate cultivars for this approach.

Methods

A life-cycle pot experiment was conducted to determine the biomass, seed yield, oil content and Cd accumulation of seven peanut cultivars under Cd concentration gradients of 0, 2, and 4 mg kg^?1.

Results

Peanut exhibits genotypic variations in Cd tolerance, seed production, oil content, and Cd accumulation. Exposure of plants to 2 and 4 mg kg^?1 Cd did not inhibit shoot biomass, seed yield, and oil content for most of the cultivars tested. There are large amounts of Cd accumulated in the shoots. Although the seed Cd concentration of peanut was relatively high, the Cd concentration in seed oils was very low (0.04-0.08 mg kg^?1). Among the cultivars, Qishan 208 showed significant Cd tolerance, high shoot biomass, high pod and seed yield, high seed oil content, considerable shoot Cd concentration, and the largest translocation factor and total Cd in shoots.

Conclusions

The cultivation of peanut in Cd-contaminated farmland was confirmed to be feasible for bioenergy production via phytoextraction, and Qishan 208 is a good candidate for this approach.     

Predictability of the Zn and Cd phytoextraction efficiency of a Salix smithiana clone by DGT and conventional bioavailability assays

Aims

Phytomanagement of metal-polluted soils requires information on plant responses to metal availability in soil, but the predictability of metal accumulation in plant shoots and/or roots may be limited by metal toxicity and inherent shortfalls of the bioavailability assays.

Methods

We measured the uptake of Cd and Zn in a Salix smithiana clone grown in a pot experiment on soils with different characteristics and metal availabilities, determined by conventional soil single extractions (0.05 M Na₂-EDTA and 1 M NH₄NO₃), soil solution obtained by centrifugation, and diffusive gradients in thin films (DGT). The Cd and Zn phytoavailability after a 2-year phytoextraction by willow was assessed by metal accumulation in the straw of the following barley culture.

Results

The phytoextraction efficiency was largest on a moderately polluted acid soil. Biomass and shoot Zn concentrations of S. smithiana were better predicted by DGT-measured Zn concentrations in soil solution (C _DGT) than by Zn concentrations in the soil solution and extractable soil fractions. The weaker correlation for Cd in shoots may be related to relative Cd enrichment in the plant tissues. The metal accumulation in barley straw was unaffected or increased after a 2-year phytoextraction.

Conclusions

The shoot Zn and Cd removal of the tested Salix clone can be predicted by C _DGT concentrations and is highest on either calcareous or moderately polluted acid soils. Single extraction with NH₄NO₃ and the C _DGT value of Cd were not able to predict shoot Cd removal on the tested soils. Only shoot removal of Zn was predicted fairly well by the C _DGT value.     

Effects of nutrient solution zinc activity on net uptake,translocation, and root export of cadmium and zinc by separated sections of intact durum wheat (Triticum turgidum L. var durum) seedling roots

Cd accumulation in durum wheat presents a potential health risk to consumers. In an effort to understand the physiological mechanisms involved with Cd accumulation, this study examined the effects of Zn on Cd root uptake and phloem translocation in a split– root system. Durum wheat seedlings were grown in chelate-buffered nutrient solution with intact root systems divided into two sections. Each root section grew in a separate 1 l pot, one of which contained 0.2 μM CdSO₄. In addition, each two-pot system contained ZnSO₄ in the following combinations (in μm) (for -cd root system: +cd root system): 1:1, 1:10, 10:1,10:10, 1:19, and 19:1. Harvested plant material was analyzed for Cd and Zn. In addition, rates of Cd and Zn net uptake, translocation to the shoot, and root export (translocation from one root segment to the other) between days 8 and 22 were calculated. Results show that Zn was not translocated from one root section to its connected root section. Uptake rates of Cd increased as solution Zn concentrations increased. Cd translocation from one root section to the other decreased significantly when the Zn concentration in either pot was greater than 1 μM. These results show the potential of Zn to inhibit movement of Cd via the phloem, and suggests that providing adequate Zn levels may limit phloem loading of Cd into wheat grain. Increasing the rhizosphere activity of Zn²⁺ in Cd-containing soils may therefore result in reduced Cd accumulation in grain even while net Cd uptake is slightly enhanced. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Cadmium accumulation in Atriplex halimus subsp. schweinfurthii and its influence on growth,proline, root hydraulic conductivity and nutrient uptake

Atriplex halimus subsp. schweinfurthii is a newly found cadmium (Cd)-hyperaccumulator, but there have been no detailed studies on its physiological responses when Cd is hyperaccumulated. A. halimus was grown in hydroponic conditions to investigate the effect of cadmium chloride (CdCl₂) on growth, water status, leaf chlorophyll concentration, proline and Cd accumulation. Treatments were prepared by adding 0, 50, 100, 200 and 400 μM CdCl₂ to the nutrient medium. Plant growth was significantly affected at high-Cd treatments. Increased CdCl₂ decreased chlorophyll concentration, transpiration and root hydraulic conductivity (L₀). Hence water flux had only a little effect on the uptake of Cd in A. halimus seedlings. In contrast, proline content increased with increasing CdCl₂ concentration. Plants accumulated substantial amount of Cd in different plant parts (shoot and root). Most of the Cd taken up was retained in roots (606.51 μg g⁻¹DW after 15 d at 400 μM CdCl₂). The addition of Cd in the culture medium affected calcium (Ca) and potassium (K) nutrition in both shoot and root. A. halimus provides a new plant resource for exploring the mechanism of Cd hyperaccumulation and has potential for use in the phytostabilization of Cd-contaminated salt soils.     

Uptake of Cadmium by Hydroponically Grown,Mature Eucalyptus Camaldulensis Saplings and the Effect of Organic Ligands

The potential suitability of Eucalyptus camaldulensis for Cd phytoextraction was tested in a hydroponic study. Saplings were exposed to 4.5 and 89 μM Cd for one month, with and without EDTA and s,s-EDDS at 0.1, 1, and 5 mM. The saplings’ growth was not affected at the 4.5 μM Cd concentration, yet it decreased 3-fold at 89 μM, and almost all the Cd taken up was immobilized in the roots, reaching 360 and 5300 mg Cd kg^?1, respectively (approximately 75% of which was non-washable in acid). The respective Cd root-to-shoot translocation factors were 0.14 and ≈5*10^?4. At 0.1 mM concentration, EDTA and EDDS had no effect or even a positive effect on the saplings growth. This was reversed at 1 mM, and the chelants became lethal at the 5 mM concentration. At 89 μM Cd in the growth medium, 0.1 mM EDTA increased Cd translocation into the shoots by almost 10-fold, however it strongly reduced Cd content inside the roots. This hydroponic study indicates the feasibility of E. camaldulensis use for cleanup Cd-contaminated soils at environmental concentrations, both for site stabilization (phytostabilization) and gradual remediation (phytoextraction). EDTA was shown to be much more efficient in enhancing Cd translocation than s,s-EDDS.     

Soil Nitrogen Fertilization Effects on Phytoextraction of Cadmium and Lead by Tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.)

A greenhouse experiment using 24 plastic pots filled with 6 kg of Pb- and Cd-contaminated soil was carried out. In all 24 pots, soils were heavy metal–contaminated with 10 mg Cd kg^?1 soil and 500 mg of Pb kg^?1 soil by using CdCl and PbNO₃. Two-month-old tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) plants were used to extract these heavy metals. Results showed that tobacco is able to remove Cd and Pb from contaminated soils and concentrate them in its harvestable part, that is, it could be very useful in phytoextraction of these heavy metals. Increasing additions of ammonium nitrate to soil (50, 100, and 150 mg N kg^?1 soil) significantly (p ≤ .05) increased aboveground Cd and Pb accumulation during a 50-day experimental period, whereas increasing additions of urea to soil (50 and 100 mg N kg^?1 soil) did not show these effects at the same significance levels. Increasing additions of ammonium nitrate to soil shows as dry matter increases, both accumulated Cd and accumulated Pb also increase when tobacco plants are growing under Pb- and Cd-contaminated soil conditions. Higher Pb concentrations depress Cd/Pb ratios for concentrations and accumulations, suggesting that Pb negatively affects Cd concentration and/or accumulation.     

The Effect of Pollination on Cd Phytoextraction From Soil by Maize (Zea mays L.)

A pot experiment was conducted to investigate the effects of pollination on cadmium (Cd) phytoextraction from soil by mature maize plants. The results showed that the unpollinated maize plants accumulated 50% more Cd than that of the pollinated plants, even though the dry weight of the former plants was 15% less than that of the latter plants. The Cd accumulation in root and leaf of the unpollinated maize plant was 0.47 and 0.89 times higher than that of the pollinated plant, respectively. The Cd concentration in the cob was significantly decreased because of pollination. Preventing pollination is a promising approach for enhancing the effectiveness of phytoextraction in Cd-contaminated soils by maize. This study suggested that in low Cd-contaminated soil pollination should be encouraged because accumulation of Cd in maize grains is very little and maize seeds can bring farmers economic benefits, while in high Cd-contaminated soil, inhibition of pollination can be applied to enhance phytoextraction of Cd from soil by maize plant.     

Phytoextraction of cadmium and zinc by Salix from soil historically amended with sewage sludge

Short rotation coppice (SRC) such as Salix spp. can be grown as an energy crop and offers some potential for economic and practical phytoextraction of marginally contaminated arable soil. This study tested various soil amendments intended to increase soil metal availability to Salix, investigated the distribution of metal between different tree fractions and assessed the viability of phytoextraction using SRC on arable soils. Several Salix genotypes were grown in field trials over 4 years. Cd and Zn concentrations were generally ranked in the order leaves > bark > wood. Metal concentrations in wood increased towards the top of the willow stems, whereas concentrations in leaves showed the opposite trend. None of the amendments significantly increased uptake of Zn by willow. However, in response to a range of soil HCl treatments, mean Cd concentrations in stems and leaves were 112% and 130% of control values. Data from the current experiment, and previous studies, were combined to develop a predictive model of Cd and Zn stem uptake by Salix. The minimum biological concentration factor (BCF) required to achieve a prescribed soil metal target was also calculated based on typical proportions of bioavailable Cd in sludge-amended soils for a 25-year Salix rotation. The best Salix genotypes investigated achieved less than 20% of the uptake rate required to remove one third of the soil Cd content (equivalent to the average isotopically exchangeable Cd fraction in soils at the study site).     

The mobilisation and fate of soil and rock phosphate in the rhizosphere of ectomycorrhizal Pinus radiata seedlings in an Allophanic soil

A pot experiment was conducted to investigate the uptake of Zn from experimentally contaminated calcareous soil of low nutrient status by maize inoculated with the arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) fungus Glomus caledonium. EDTA was applied to the soil to mobilize Zn and thus maximize plant Zn uptake. The highest plant dry matter (DM) yields were obtained with a moderate Zn addition level of 300 mg kg^?1. Plant growth was enhanced by mycorrhizal colonization when no Zn was added and under the highest Zn addition level of 600 mg kg^?1, while application of EDTA to the soil generally inhibited plant growth. EDTA application also increased plant Zn concentration, and Zn accumulation in the roots increased with increasing EDTA addition level. The effects of inoculation with G. caledonium on plant Zn uptake varied with Zn addition level. When no Zn was added, Zn translocation from roots to shoots was enhanced by mycorrhizal colonization. In contrast, when Zn was added to the soil, mycorrhizal colonization resulted in lower shoot Zn concentrations in mycorrhizal plants. The P nutrition of the maize was greatly affected by AM inoculation, with mycorrhizal plants showing higher P concentrations and P uptake. The results indicate that application of EDTA mobilized soil Zn, leading to increased Zn accumulation by the roots and subsequent plant toxicity and growth inhibition. Mycorrhizal colonization alleviated both Zn deficiency and Zn contamination, and also increased host plant growth by influencing mineral nutrition. However, neither EDTA application nor arbuscular mycorrhiza stimulated Zn translocation from roots to shoots or metal phytoextraction under the experimental conditions. The results are discussed in relation to the environmental risk associated with chelate-enhanced phytoextraction and the potential role of arbuscular mycorrhiza in soil remediation.     

COLONIZATION AND MODULATION OF HOST GROWTH AND METAL UPTAKE BY ENDOPHYTIC BACTERIA OF SEDUM ALFREDII

Sedum alfredii Hance is a Zn and Cd co-hyperaccumulating plant species found in an old mining area in China. Four bacterial strains, Burkholderia sp. SaZR4, Burkholderia sp. SaMR10, Sphingomonas sp. SaMR12 and Variovorax sp. SaNR1, isolated from surface-sterilized S. alfredii plants were used to investigate their endophytic nature and root colonization patterns and effects on phytoextraction of Zn and Cd. Laser scanning confocal microscopy revealed that gfp-tagged SaZR4, SaMR12, and SaNR1 cells formed biofilms on roots and that SaZR4 and SaMR12 cells could invade root tissues. SaMR10 showed the lowest total population associated with S. alfredii and little effect on plant growth and phytoextraction. SaZR4 significantly promoted Zn-extraction but not Cd-extraction. SaMR12 and SaNR1 significantly promoted plant growth in substrates supplemented with Zn or Cd and phytoextraction of Zn and Cd. Together, this study have shown that the four native endophytic bacteria differently colonize the host plants and modulate metal uptake and growth of host plant, and that SaMR12 and SaNR1 strains are promising assistants of S. alfredii plants for phytoremediation of Zn/Cd-contaminated soil.     

Bioremediation of Cadmium-Contaminated Soil through Cultivation of Maize Inoculated with Plant Growth–Promoting Rhizobacteria

A pot experiment was conducted to study the effect of single and co-inoculation of Bacillus mycoides and Micrococcus roseus strains, indigenous to heavy metal (HM)–contaminated soils, on the growth and essential-nutrient and Cd uptake of maize in a soil polluted with 100 and 200 mg Cd kg^?1. Increasing Cd levels significantly decreased shoot and root dry weights, and shoot P, Fe, Zn, and Mn uptake. All bacterial treatments significantly increased biomass and shoot nutrient uptake of plant compared with control in the soil polluted with Cd. Inoculation of plants with B. mycoides and consortium of two bacteria significantly increased, whereas M. roseus significantly decreased, shoot and root Cd uptake, and Cd transfer and translocation factors compared with control in Cd-polluted conditions. The results showed that B. mycoides and consortium of two bacteria had an effective role in phytoextraction and M. roseus was the most effective treatment in phytostabilization of Cd.     

The long-term variation of Cd and Zn hyperaccumulation by Noccaea spp and Arabidopsis halleri plants in both pot and field conditions

Three Cd and Zn hyperaccumulating plant species Noccaea caerulescens Noccaea praecox and Arabidopsis halleri (Brassicacceae) were cultivated in seven subsequent vegetation seasons in both pot and field conditions in soil highly contaminated with Cd, Pb, and Zn. The results confirmed the hyperaccumulation ability of both plant species, although A. halleri showed lower Cd uptake compared to N. caerulescens. Conversely, Pb phytoextraction was negligible for both species in this case. Because of the high variability in plant yield and element contents in the aboveground biomass of plants, great variation in Cd and Zn accumulation was observed during the experiment. The extraction ability in field conditions varied in the case of Cd from 0.2 to 2.9 kg ha^?1 (N. caerulescens) and up to 0.15 kg ha^?1 (A. halleri), and in the case of Zn from 0.2 to 6.4 kg ha^?1 (N. caerulescens) and up to 13.8 kg.ha^?1 (A. halleri). Taking into account the 20 cm root zone of the soil, the plants were able to extract up to 4.1% Cd and 0.2% Zn in one season. However, cropping measures should be optimized to improve and stabilize the long-term phytoextraction potential of these plants.     

Magnesium and iron deficiencies alter Cd accumulation in Salix viminalis L.

Evidence exists that Cd and certain nutrient elements, such as Fe and Mg, could share similar mechanisms of plant uptake and accumulation. Here we report that Mg and Fe deficiency in mature plants of Salix viminalis, grown in hydroponic solutions containing 5 µg ml^?1 of Cd, caused a significant increase in Cd accumulation in roots, stems and leaves. Cd (µg g^?1 dry weight) was determined following three treatments: 1) Cd treatment in complete nutrient solution; 2) Cd treatment with Fe deficiency; and 3) Cd treatment with Mg deficiency, yielding, respectively: in young leaves (65.3, 76.1, and 92.2), mature leaves (51.5 to 76.3 and 87.1), upper stems (80.6, 116.8, and 130.6) lower stems (67.2, 119, and 102.3), roots (377.1, 744.8, and 442,5). Our results suggest that Cd utilizes the same uptake and transport pathways as Mg and Fe. Evidence exists that Mg and Fe uptake and translocation could be further facilitated by plants as an adaptive response to deficiency of these elements. Such physiological reaction could additionally stimulate Cd accumulation. Although Cd uptake was mostly confined in roots, high Cd content in aerial plant parts (51.5–130.6 µg g^?1) indicates that the analysed Salix viminalis genotype is suitable for phytoextraction.     

Dynamics of plant metal uptake and metal changes in whole soil and soil particle fractions during repeated phytoextraction

Aims

Phytoextration of metal polluted soils using hyperaccumulators is a promising technology but requires long term successive cropping. This study investigated the dynamics of plant metal uptake and changes in soil metals over a long remediation time.

Methods

A soil slightly polluted with metals (S1) was mixed with highly polluted soil (S4) to give two intermediate pollution levels (S2, S3). The four resulting soils were repeatedly phyto-extracted using nine successive crops of Cd/Zn-hyperaccumulator Sedum plumbizincicola over a period of 4 years.

Results

Shoot Cd concentration decreased with harvest time in all soils but shoot Zn declined in S1 only. Similar shoot Zn concentrations were found in S2, S3 and S4 although these soils differed markedly in metal availability, and their available metals decreased during phytoextraction. A possible explanation is that plant active acquisition ability served to maintain plant metal uptake. Plant uptake resulted in the largest decrease in the acid-soluble metal fraction followed by reducible metals. Oxidisable and residual fractions were less available to plants. The coarse soil particle fractions made the major contribution to metal decline overall than the fine fractions.

Conclusion

Sedum plumbizincicola maintained long term metal uptake and the coarse soil particles played the most important role in phytoextraction.     

Soil pH Effects on Uptake of Cd and Zn by Thlaspi caerulescens

For phytoextraction to be successful and viable in environmental remediation, strategies that can optimize plant uptake must be identified. Thlaspi caerulescens is an important hyperaccumulator of Cd and Zn, whether adjusting soil pH is an efficient way to enhance metal uptake by T. caerulescens must by clarified. This study used two soils differing in levels of Cd and Zn, which were adjusted to six different pH levels. Thlaspi caerulescens tissue metal concentrations and 0.1 M Sr(NO₃)₂ extractable soil metal concentrations were measured. The soluble metal form of both Cd and Zn was greatly increased with decreasing pH. Lowering pH significantly influenced plant metal uptake. For the high metal soil, highest plant biomass was at the lowest soil pH (4.74). The highest shoot metal concentration was at the second lowest pH (5.27). For low metal soil, due to low pH induced Al and Mn toxicity, both plant growth and metal uptake was greatest at intermediate pH levels. The extraordinary Cd phytoextraction ability of T. caerulescens was further demonstrated in this experiment. In the optimum pH treatments, Thlaspi caerulescens extracted 40% and 36% of total Cd in the low and high metal soils, respectively, with just one planting. Overall, decreasing pH is an effective strategy to enhance phytoextraction. But different soils had various responses to acidification treatment and a different optimum pH may exist. This pH should be identified to avoid unnecessarily extreme acidification of soils.