Comparison of Bioassays to Measure Virulence of Different Entomopathogenic Nematodes

Five bioassays were compared for their usefulness to determine the virulence of four nematode strains. The objective of this study was to develop standard assays for particular nematode species. In all assays, the nematodes Steinernema feltiae (strain UK), S. riobravis, S. scapterisci Argentina and Heterorhabditis bacteriophora HP88 were exposed to Galleria mellonella larvae. All bioassays except the sand column assay were conducted in multi-well plastic dishes. In the penetration rate assay, the number of individual nematodes invading the insect was determined after a 48-h exposure to 200 infective juveniles (IJs). In the one-on-one assay, each larva was exposed to an individual nematode for 72 h before insect mortality was recorded. In the exposure time assay, insect mortality was recorded after exposure to 200 IJs for variable time periods. The dose-response assay involved exposing larvae to different nematode concentrations over the range 1-200 IJs/insect and recording mortality every 24 h for a 96-h period. In the sand columns assay, insects were placed in the bottom of a plastic cylinder filled with sand. Nematodes were applied on top of the sand and insect mortality was determined after IJs had migrated through the cylinder. The highest mortality level in the sand column assay was obtained with IJs of S. feltiae followed by H. bacteriophora; treatments with S. riobravis and S. scapterisci produced low levels of insect mortality. In the other four assays, S riobravis was the most virulent, followed by S. feltiae, H. bacteriophora and S. scapterisci. In the exposure time assay, rapid mortality was achieved when the insects were exposed to S. feltiae and S. riobravis. For these nematode species, a gradual increase in the number of individuals which penetrated into cadavers was recorded. Conversely, the number of nematodes in the cadavers of insects infected by H. bacteriophora and S. scapterisci remained low during the entire exposure period. In this assay, exposing the insects to these nematodes resulted in a gradual increase in mortality. In the dose-response assay, complete separation among nematode species was obtained only after 48 h of incubation at a concentration of 15 IJs/insect. LD and LD values were calculated from 50 90 dose-response assay data. However, these values did not indicate differences among the different nematode species. The present study demonstrated the variation in entomopathogenic nematode performance in different bioassays and supports the notion that one common bioassay cannot be used as a universal measure of virulence for all species and strains because nematodes differ in their behavior. Furthermore, particular assays should be used for different purposes. To select a specific population for use against a particular insect, assays that are more laborious but which simulate natural environmental conditions (e.g. the sand column assay) or invasion by the nematode (e.g. the penetration rate assay) should be considered. In cases where commercial production batches of the same nematode strains are compared, simple and fast assays are needed (e.g. the one-on-one and exposure time assays). Further studies are needed to determine the relationships between data obtained in each assay and nematode efficacy in the field.     

Heterorhabditis spp., Neoaplectana spp., and Steinernema kraussei: Interspecific and intraspecific differences in infectivity for insects

The effectiveness of various dosages of different species/strains of nematodes was compared for Galleria mellonella and various pest insects that live in or pupate in soil. Neoaplectana feltiae (= carpocapsae), the only nematode species tested by most other workers, was never the most infective for any of the insect species tested and was least infective for two. All species/strains of nematode were able to kill insects of each species. The degree of infectivity of each of the nematode species/strains for different hosts varied considerably, and no one species/strain of nematode was the most infective for all insect species. This indicates the importance of testing a number of nematode species against any particular insect before commencing field evaluations for biological control.     

Evaluation of entomopathogenic nematodes for control of the beetle, Luperomorpha suturalis Chen (Col., Chrysomelidae)

Abstract: The strains Steinernema feltiae Otio and A54, Steinernema ceratophorum D43 and Steinernema carpocapsae BJ were tested for their infectivity to the larvae and pupae of beetle ( Luperomorpha suturalis Chen) at 25 ± 0.5°C and 15 ± 0.5°C in laboratory conditions. The results, based on comparison of the insect mortalities and nematode penetration rates among four nematode strains, showed that S. feltiae Otio was a potential biocontrol agent of the larvae and pupae of L. suturalis . The mortalities of the larvae and pupae exposed to S. feltiae Otio strain were 95.8 and 97.1% at 25 ± 0.5°C and 78.0 and 83.0% at 15 ± 0.5°C, respectively. The nematode penetration rates of S. feltiae Otio of the larvae and pupae were 15.6 and 19.0% at 25 ± 0.5°C, 2.6 and 6.3% at 15 ± 0.5°C, respectively. Field efficacy of S. feltiae Otio strain was examined against beetle larvae in Hebei province, northern China. The population reduction of insect larvae was 77.8 and 13.9% at doses of 30 and 15 infective juveniles (IJs)/cm² of S. feltiae Otio after 38 days of treatment and 90.2 and 92.4% after 100 days of treatment. However, the population of the insect larvae was reduced only to 15.5 and 15.7% when treated with pesticide after 38 and 100 days, respectively. The efficiency between the two nematode doses was not significantly different but it was remarkably higher than that of the pesticide after 100 days of application. The results suggest that S. feltiae Otio strain could be an alternative to pesticide for beetle control.     

Dynamics of carbon dioxide release from insects infected with entomopathogenic nematodes

The quality of an insect as a host to an entomopathogenic nematode infective juvenile depends in part on whether or not the insect is already infected and on the stage of that infection. Previous research has shown that nematode response to hosts can change after infection and that, for uninfected hosts, CO(2) can be an important cue used by infective stage juveniles during attraction. We hypothesized that CO(2) production from an insect changes after it is infected, and that these changes could influence nematode infection decisions. Changes in CO(2) released by two insect species (Galleria mellonella and Tenebrio molitor) after infection by one of four nematode species (Steinernema carpocapsae, Steinernema feltiae, Steinernema glaseri, or Steinernema riobrave) were measured. Measurements were taken every 2h from time of initial exposure to nematodes up to 224 h after infection. Dead (freeze-killed) and live uninfected insects were used as controls. Infected G. mellonella showed two distinct peaks of CO(2) production: one between 20 and 30 h and the other between 70 and 115 h after exposure to the nematodes. Peaks were up to two times higher than levels produced by uninfected insects. Infected T. molitor showed only one peak between 25 and 50h. We found differences in peak height and timing among nematode and insect species combinations. The influence of these changes in CO(2) production on IJ attraction and infection behavior remains to be determined.     

Infectivity of Steinernema spp. (Nematoda: Steinernematidae) to Adult Litter Beetles, Alphitobius diaperinus (Coleoptera: Tenebrionidae) in the Laboratory

Three species of Steinernema, S. carpocapsae, S. feltiae, and S. scapterisci consisting of 12 different strains, were tested for their infectivity towards adults of the litter beetle Alphitobius diaperinus. Of the five most promising nematode strains, LC₅₀ values ranged from 1.5 to 77.0 nematodes per host in the filter paper assays. Assays in poultry litter material revealed LC₅₀ values to be 5.8 and 14.6 nematodes per host for the Mexican S. carpocapsae strain and Pye S. feltiae strain.     

Evaluation of Entomopathogenic Nematodes for the Control of Mediterranean Fruit Fly (Diptera: Tephritidae)

The virulence of various entomopathogenic nematode (EPN) strains was evaluated against the Mediterranean fruit fly, C. capitata . The selected nematodes were assessed for their infectivity for the final larval stage of the insect host and under varying environmental conditions. Among 12 EPN strains tested, Steinernema riobrave Texas ( Sr TX) and Heterorhabditis sp. IS-5 (H IS-5), showed high activity and induced >80% mortality. Six EPN strains showed limited activity (>30% mortality), and four strains had no effect (<20% mortality). Sr TX was more effective than H IS-5. Mature C. capitata larvae were most susceptible to nematode infection during the first 4h after they began to emerge from their diet to pupate. Activity of the two nematode strains at a constant inoculation rate was dependent on insect larval density. The highest activity was recorded at 1.88 larvae cm -2 and decreased at higher larval densities. EPN activity was also directly related to nematode density. Maximal activity was shown at a density of 150 infective juveniles cm -2 . A similar activity pattern was also recorded with Sr TX in four different soil types. The persistence of this EPN in the soil extended over 5 days but there was no activity after 14 days. Except for a lower activity under cool conditions (17°C), temperatures ranging between 22 and 41°C, or moisture levels in the treated soil ranging between 3 and 20%, had no significant effect on nematode activity. Our results suggest that application of Sr TX against C. capitata may have potential for controlling C. capitata .     

昆虫病原线虫Steinernema longicaudum X-7增效药剂的筛选

测试了19种昆虫生长调节剂、植物源或病毒类药剂对昆虫病原线虫Steinernema longicaudumX-7的存活和侵染率的影响。筛选9种对线虫存活和侵染率均无影响的药剂,测定其与线虫混用对黄粉虫Tenebrio molitorL.9~11龄幼虫的交互作用。结果显示,各种参试药剂和线虫组合均表现为相加作用。为了进一步确定参试药剂与线虫混用对目标昆虫卵圆齿爪鳃金龟Holotrichia ovataChang 3龄幼虫的交互作用,本研究选择氟虫脲、除虫脲、灭幼脲、苦参碱、氟啶脲和虫酰肼在低浓度下与线虫混用,除虫脲与线虫混用对测定昆虫处理7 d后表现为增效作用,其它药剂与线虫则表现为相加作用;各种参试药剂与线虫组合处理14 d后均表现为相加作用。     

Efficacy of entomopathogenic nematodes against neonate larvae of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Capnodis tenebrionis</Emphasis> (L.) (Coleoptera: Buprestidae) in laboratory trials

The efficacy of five entomopathogenic nematode strains of the families Steinernematidae and Heterorhabditidae was tested against the neonate larvae of Capnodis tenebrionis. The nematode strains screened included two of Steinernema carpocapsae (Exhibit and M137), and one each of S. feltiae (S6), S. arenarium (S2), and Heterorhanditis bacteriophora (P4). Exposure of neonate larvae of Capnodis to 10 and 150 infective juveniles (IJs) per larva (equivalent to 3 and 48 IJs/cm² respectively) in test tubes with sterile sand, resulted in mortality between 60–91% and 96–100%, respectively. At a concentration of 150 IJs/larva, all of the nematode strains were highly virulent. Both S. carpocapsae strains (Exhibit and M137) caused infection and mortality to larvae more quickly than the other strains. However, at a lower concentration assay (10 IJs/larva), S. arenarium was the most virulent strain. The penetration rate as an indicator of entomopathogenic nematode infection was also evaluated. The highest value was recorded for S. arenarium (36%), followed by H. bacteriophora (30.6%), S. feltiae (23.1%), and S. carpocapsae (20.7%).     

Differences between the pathogenic processes induced by Steinernema and Heterorhabditis (Nemata: Rhabditida) in Pseudaletia unipuncta (Insecta: Lepidoptera)

Larvae of Pseudaletia unipuncta are moderately susceptible to infections caused by entomopathogenic nematodes, being a desirable host to study pathogenic processes caused by Heterorhabditis bacteriophora, Steinernema carpocapsae, and Steinernema glaseri and their associated bacteria. The ability of the infective stage of these nematodes to invade hosts is quite different. S. carpocapsae invades the highest number of insects and presents the highest penetration rate, followed by H. bacteriophora. Regression analysis between the number of insects parasitized and the number of IJs counted per insect, over time, showed a high correlation for S. carpocapsae whereas for H. bacteriophora it was low. Dose-response was most evident at a concentration below 100 IJs per insect on H. bacteriophora, whereas on S. carpocapsae it was found for doses ranging from 100 to 2,000 IJs. Student's t test analysis of dose-response showed parallel, yet unequal, slopes for both strains of H. bacteriophora, whereas distinct regressions were obtained for S. carpocapsae and S. glaseri, thus, evidencing each species develop a distinct pathogenic process. Insects injected with Photorhabdus luminescens died within 50 h after injection, whereas those treated with X. nematophila died much later. Moreover, the mortality in insects exposed to H. bacteriophora complex and injected with P. luminescens was close, but insects injected with bacteria died faster. Insect mortality in treatments with complexes S. carpocapsae and S. glaseri was significantly higher than that which was observed in insects injected with symbiotic bacteria.     

Natural population dynamics of entomopathogenic nematode Steinernema affine (Steinernematidae) under dry conditions: Possible nematode persistence within host cadavers?

The effect of dry conditions on the population dynamics of the entomopathogenic nematode (EPN) Steinernema affine was studied for one month in the exceptionally dry period in the summer of 2003 in the oak wood in the vicinity of Ceské Budejovice, Czech Republic. Soil moisture, soil temperature, and the abundance of suitable insect hosts were monitored. The abundance of infective juveniles (IJs) was correlated with soil moisture and both these values were gradually decreasing during the study period and finally rapidly increased at the end of the investigation. During this period there was a decline in the number of insects suitable as hosts for S. affine, but not in numbers of unsuitable insects. We hypothesise that the observed decrease in IJ numbers was probably caused by the persistence of IJs in host cadavers due to low ambient moisture.     

Selective breeding of Steinernema feltiae (Filipjev) (Nematoda: Steinernematidae) for improved efficacy in control of a mushroom fly,Lycoriella solani Winnertz (Diptera: Sciaridae)

A method of selecting a Steinernema feltiae strain that is effective against a mushroom fly, Lycoriella solani, is described in detail. The pest control efficacy of the selected nematode strain was evaluated and compared with the efficacy of two unselected strains. The selection procedure was designed to give preference to nematode individuals with the greatest ability (1) to search effectively for the target insect larvae in their natural habitat, (2) to infect them shortly after application and (3) to reproduce in their haemocoel. Thirty‐four rounds of selection achieved a 4‐fold improvement in nematode ability to find and parasitize third‐ and fourth‐instar larvae of the pest in the mushroom substrate. In 24‐h laboratory experiments, mortality of the insect caused by nematode juveniles rose from 22.5%, recorded for the original unselected isolate, to 92.5% for the selected strain. In a 51‐day experiment conducted on a mixed age mushroom house population of L. solani, the enhanced pest control ability of the selected strain was detected shortly after nematode application and remained high throughout the experimental period. During the first 4 weeks of the trial the selected nematode strain was significantly better than both unselected strains and caused 91.1–92.7% reduction of the fly emergence from the mushroom substrate. No difference was observed between the efficacy of the selected nematodes applied at 1 × 10⁶ and 3 ×10⁶ infective juveniles per m², while the unselected strains performed significantly better at the higher concentration. All the nematodes examined showed good persistence in the mushroom casing apparently due to recycling in the insect host.     

Ecological aspects of an isolate of Steinernema diaprepesi (Rhabditida: Steinernematidae) from Argentina

Ecological aspects of Steinernema diaprepesi isolate SRC were studied to evaluate the species potential as biological control agent of insect pests. Under laboratory conditions, the following aspects were determined: the nematode life cycle, pathogenicity to several arthropods, reproductive capacity, tolerance to desiccation, effect of temperature on survival and infectivity of infective juveniles (IJs), and influence of soil texture and soil water potential on the isolate. The parasitic cycle on last-instar larvae of Galleria mellonella at 25°C was completed 8 days after infection. The nematode showed high virulence to lepidopteran larvae, being limited or nil in the remaining orders of arthropods evaluated. An acceptable offspring production of S. diaprepesi was confirmed in the species G. mellonella and S. frugiperda, suggesting that the isolate would have potential for control of lepidopteran larvae. Optimum temperature for reproduction was 20–25°C. IJs survived exposure to a range of temperatures between 10 and 40°C, with a significant reduction in the number of live IJs at 40°C. The nematodes remained infective at 20–40°C. IJ mortality was 100% on day 6 of exposure to 85% RH. The movement of IJs observed in the soil column experiments revealed that the isolate uses a cruiser-type search strategy. Soil texture and water potential significantly influenced IJ movement, search and penetration of G. mellonella larvae. The efficacy of this isolate was found to be favoured in sandy soils, regardless of the soil water potential.     

Effects of Insecticides on Movement,Nictation, and Infectivity of Steinernema carpocapsae

Movement, nictation, and infectivity of Steinernema carpocapsae strain All were compared for ensheathed (EnJ) and desheathed (DeJ) infective juveniles exposed to the insecticides acephate, dichlorvos, methomyl, oxamyl, or permethrin. Nematode response to various solutions included normal sinusoidal movement, uncoordinated motion, twitching, convulsion or formation of a pretzel shape, an inactive "S" posture with fine twitching, or a quiescent straight posture. The DeJ displayed these movements at lower concentrations of each insecticide than did EnJ. In petri dish bioassays, insecticide-treated EnJ caused generally lower mortality in the common cutworm, Spodoptera litura, than did EnJ alone but caused greater insect mortality than did insecticides alone. Nematode response to chemicals was more clearly demonstrated by nictating behavior than by the movement bioassay. Nictation of DeJ was suppressed by the test chemicals at low concentrations, except for acephate and permethrin. Nictating EnJ or DeJ, regardless of chemical treatment, killed host insects faster than did non-nictating juveniles. Insecticides that enhance nictating behavior at certain concentrations may be used for mixed applications with nematodes.     

Distribution of the entomopathogenic nematodes from La Rioja (Northern Spain)

Entomopathogenic nematodes (EPNs) distribution in natural areas and crop field edges in La Rioja (Northern Spain) has been studied taking into account environmental and physical-chemical soil factors. Five hundred soil samples from 100 sites of the most representative habitats were assayed for the presence of EPNs. The occurrence of EPNs statistically fitted to a negative binomial distribution, which pointed out that the natural distribution of these nematodes in La Rioja was in aggregates. There were no statistical differences (p < or = 0.05) in the abundance of EPNs to environmental and physical-chemical variables, although, there were statistical differences in the altitude, annual mean air temperature and rainfall, potential vegetation series and moisture percentage recovery frequency. Twenty-seven samples from 14 sites were positive for EPNs. From these samples, twenty isolates were identified to a species level and fifteen strains were selected: 11 Steinernema feltiae, two S. carpocapsae and two S. kraussei strains. S. kraussei was isolated from humid soils of cool and high altitude habitats and S. carpocapsae was found to occur in heavy soils of dry and temperate habitats. S. feltiae was the most common species with a wide range of altitude, temperature, rainfall, pH and soil moisture, although this species preferred sandy soils. The virulence of nematode strains were assessed using G. mellonella as insect host, recording the larval mortality percentage and the time to insect die, as well as the number of infective juveniles produced to evaluate the reproductive potential and the time tooks to leave the insect cadaver to determinate the infection cycle length. The ecological trends and biological results are discussed in relationship with their future use as biological control.     

Selection responses and quantitative-genetic analysis of preadult performance on two host plants in the bean weevil, Acanthoscelides obtectus

The infectivity and biocontrol potential of entomopathogenic nematodes against two common urban tree leaf beetles (Altica quercetorum and Agelastica alni) pupating in the soil were examined under laboratory and semi‐field conditions. In the laboratory experiments, pre‐pupae and pupae of both insect species were shown to be highly susceptible to nematode infection when challenged in soil pre‐treated with the parasites’ infective juveniles. In general, Heterorhabditis megidis was more effective than Steinernema feltiae. However, significant differences were observed between individual isolates within the latter species. Nematodes developed and reproduced in cadavers of both insect species. A semi‐field experiment studying the biocontrol potential of selected nematode strains, conducted under the canopy of urban trees, confirmed the preliminary laboratory findings and revealed that H. megidis could eliminate most of the insects pupating in the soil, when applied at a relatively low dose of 10⁵ IJs m^?2. The potential of entomopathogenic nematodes as environmentally safe, effective, and economically viable agents for the biological control of tree leaf beetles in urban green areas is discussed.     

Pathogenic potential of six isolates of entomopathogenic nematodes (Rhabditida: Steinernematidae) from Vietnam

The potential of six Steinernema isolates, isolated from different provinces in Vietnam, was evaluated in the laboratory against Galleria mellonella and Spodoptera littoralis. Steinernema sangi and S. robustispiculum TN24 had the highest penetration rate in both hosts according to a penetration rate assay. The virulence assay showed that S. sangi had a high virulence to both hosts and along with isolate TN38 it was the most mobile among the isolates tested. The migration of S. sangi in sand columns with an insect host at the bottom was significantly higher than in sand columns without insect host. This Steinernema species was the only one that penetrated a host in 24h after migrating 10cm in sand columns at 25°C. Moreover, a multiplication assay showed that S. sangi produced a high number of infective juveniles in G. mellonella. However, all Steinernema isolates tested had low multiplication rates in S. littoralis.     

Assessing the Potential of Entomopathogenic Nematodes to Control the Grape Root Borer Vitacea polistiformis (Lepidoptera: Sesiidae) Through Laboratory and Greenhouse Bioassays

Seventeen entomopathogenic nematode species and strains were evaluated for virulence to the grape root borer, Vitacea polistiformis (Harris) in laboratory and greenhouse bioassays. Heterohabditis bacteriophora strain GPS11 and H. zealandica strain X1 produced a larval mortality rate of over 85% of larvae embedded in the root cambium in laboratory bioassays. The nematode species H. marelata and H. bacteriophora strain Oswego produced mortality rates of over 75%. Of the Steinernema species tested, S. carpocapsae strain 'All' performed the best with a mortality rate of 69%. All other nematode species and strains tested, with the exception of S. bicornutum , produced some degree of larval mortality. In the greenhouse bioassays, 93% control was achieved with H. zealandica strain X1 applied at 4 ×109 infective juveniles (IJs) acre1 -1 (9.88 ×10 9 IJs ha -1 ). H. bacteriophora strain GPS11 successfully reproduced in grape root borer larvae. The numbers of IJs produced within infected larvae were related to larval size. The survival rate of neonate larvae on grape root sections was 61%, which thus provides a means to rear the neonate larvae for bioassays.     

Attraction of four entomopathogenic nematodes to four white grub species

To better understand the differences in the efficacy of entomopathogenic nematode species against white grub species, we are studying the various steps of the infection process of entomopathogenic nematodes into different white grub species using nematode species/strains with particular promise as white grub control agents. In this study we compared the attraction of the entomopathogenic nematodes Steinernema scarabaei (AMK001 strain), Steinernema glaseri (NC1 strain), Heterorhabditis zealandica (X1 strain), and Heterorhabditis bacteriophora (GPS11 strain) to third-instars of the scarabs Popillia japonica, Anomala orientalis, Cyclocephala borealis, and Rhizotrogus majalis, and late-instar greater wax moth, Galleria mellonella, larvae. Individual larvae were confined at the bottom of 5.5 cm vertical sand columns, nematodes added to the sand surface after 24 h, and nematodes extracted after another 24 h. Nematode attraction to hosts was strongly affected by nematode species but the effect of insect species varied with nematode species. S. glaseri had a high innate dispersal rate (i.e., in absence of insects) and was strongly attracted to insects without significant differences among insect species. S. scarabaei had a very low innate dispersal rate so that even a strong relative response to insects resulted in low absolute dispersal rates toward insects. S. scarabaei tended to be most attracted to G. mellonella and least attracted to C. borealis. H. zealandica had a high innate dispersal rate but only responded weakly to insects without significant differences among species. H. bacteriophora had limited innate dispersal and only weakly responded to insects with G. mellonella tending to be the most attractive and C. borealis the least attractive insect. It has to be noted that we cannot exclude that the use of different rearing hosts (A. orientalis and P. japonica larvae for S. scarabaei, G. mellonella larvae for the other nematodes) might have had an impact on the nematodes dispersal and relative attraction behavior. This study indicates that host attractiveness and nematode dispersal rates may contribute but do not play a major role in the variability in white grub susceptibility and/or nematode virulence.     

Synergistic effect of the herbicides glyphosate and MCPA on survival of entomopathogenic nematodes

The survival and infectivity of the infective juveniles of two species of entomopathogenic nematodes, Steinernema feltiae (Rhabditida: Steinernematidae) Heterorhabditis bacteriophora (Rhabditida: Heterorhabditidae), were determined after exposure for 72 h to two concentrations of the herbicides glyphosate and MCPA, as well as to the combination of the two herbicides (glyphosate + MCPA). For all herbicide treatments, concentrations and exposure times, S. feltiae was more tolerant to the herbicides than H. bacteriophora. The exposure of entomopathogenic nematodes to glyphosate + MCPA caused significantly higher mortality (26.33–57.33%) than glyphosate (0.67–15%) or MCPA (2.33–19%) alone. These results confirm the synergistic effect of the glyphosate + MCPA combination on the mortality in these nematodes. Nematode infectivity of Galleria mellonella larvae in response to the herbicides presence was evaluated in Petri dish assays containing sterile sand. Nematode infectivity was not significantly reduced by exposure to herbicides in S. feltiae but H. bacteriophora was less tolerant. Synergistic effect was obtained in the nematode mortality test but no synergistic effect was observed in the nematode infectivity assay. Our results suggest that possible synergistic effects of agrochemicals on survival of nematodes should be tested before mixing with entomopathogenic nematodes.