Identification of new protein substrates for the chloroplast ATP-dependent Clp protease supports its constitutive role in Arabidopsis

The ATP-dependent Clp protease in plant chloroplasts consists of a heterogeneous proteolytic core containing multiple ClpP and ClpR paralogues. In this study, we have examined in detail the only viable knockout mutant to date of one of these subunits in Arabidopsis thaliana, ClpR1. Loss of ClpR1 caused a slow-growth phenotype, with chlorotic leaves during early development that later partially recovered upon maturity. Analysis of the Clp proteolytic core in the clpR1 mutant (clpR1-1) revealed approx. 10% of the wild-type levels remaining, probably due to a relative increase in the closely related ClpR3 protein and its partial substitution of ClpR1 in the core complex. A proteomic approach using an in organello proteolytic assay revealed 19 new potential substrates for the chloroplast Clp protease. Many of these substrates were constitutive enzymes involved in different metabolic pathways, including photosynthetic carbon fixation, nitrogen metabolism and chlorophyll/haem biosynthesis, whereas others function in housekeeping roles such as RNA maturation, protein synthesis and maturation, and recycling processes. In contrast, degradation of the stress-related chloroplast proteins Hsp21 (heat-shock protein 21) and lipoxygenase 2 was unaffected in the clpR1-1 line and thus not facilitated by the Clp protease. Overall, we show that the chloroplast Clp protease is principally a constitutive enzyme that degrades numerous stromal proteins, a feature that almost certainly underlies its vital importance for chloroplast function and plant viability.     

Assembly of the chloroplast ATP-dependent Clp protease in Arabidopsis is regulated by the ClpT accessory proteins

The ATP-dependent caseinolytic protease (Clp) is an essential housekeeping enzyme in plant chloroplasts. It is by far the most complex of all known Clp proteases, with a proteolytic core consisting of multiple catalytic ClpP and noncatalytic ClpR subunits. It also includes a unique form of Clp protein of unknown function designated ClpT, two of which exist in the model species Arabidopsis thaliana. Inactivation of ClpT1 or ClpT2 significantly reduces the amount of Clp proteolytic core, whereas loss of both proves seedling lethal under autotrophic conditions. During assembly of the Clp proteolytic core, ClpT1 first binds to the P-ring (consisting of ClpP3-6 subunits) followed by ClpT2, and only then does the P-ring combine with the R-ring (ClpP1, ClpR1-4 subunits). Most of the ClpT proteins in chloroplasts exist in vivo as homodimers, which then apparently monomerize prior to association with the P-ring. Despite their relative abundance, however, the availability of both ClpT proteins is rate limiting for the core assembly, with the addition of recombinant ClpT1 and ClpT2 increasing core content up to fourfold. Overall, ClpT appears to regulate the assembly of the chloroplast Clp protease, revealing a new and sophisticated control mechanism on the activity of this vital protease in plants.     

Clp protease complexes from photosynthetic and non-photosynthetic plastids and mitochondria of plants, their predicted three-dimensional structures, and functional implications

Tetradecameric Clp protease core complexes in non-photosynthetic plastids of roots, flower petals, and in chloroplasts of leaves of Arabidopsis thaliana were purified based on native mass and isoelectric point and identified by mass spectrometry. The stoichiometry between the subunits was determined. The protease complex consisted of one to three copies of five different serine-type protease Clp proteins (ClpP1,3-6) and four non-proteolytic ClpR proteins (ClpR1-4). Three-dimensional homology modeling showed that the ClpP/R proteins fit well together in a tetradecameric complex and also indicated unique contributions for each protein. Lateral exit gates for proteolysis products are proposed. In addition, ClpS1,2, unique to land plants, tightly interacted with this core complex, with one copy of each per complex. The three-dimensional modeling show that they do fit well on the axial sites of the ClpPR cores. In contrast to plastids, plant mitochondria contained a single approximately 320-kDa homo-tetradecameric ClpP2 complex, without association of ClpR or ClpS proteins. It is surprising that the Clp core composition appears identical in all three plastid types, despite the remarkable differences in plastid proteome composition. This suggests that regulation of plastid proteolysis by the Clp machinery is not through differential regulation of ClpP/R/S gene expression, but rather through substrate recognition mechanisms and regulated interaction of chaperone-like molecules (ClpS1,2 and others) to the ClpP/R core.     

Distinctive types of ATP-dependent Clp proteases in cyanobacteria

Cyanobacteria are the only prokaryotes that perform oxygenic photosynthesis and are thought to be ancestors to plant chloroplasts. Like chloroplasts, cyanobacteria possess a diverse array of proteolytic enzymes, with one of the most prominent being the ATP-dependent Ser-type Clp protease. The model Clp protease in Escherichia coli consists of a single ClpP proteolytic core flanked on one or both ends by a HSP100 chaperone partner. In comparison, cyanobacteria have multiple ClpP paralogs plus a ClpP variant (ClpR), which lacks the catalytic triad typical of Ser-type proteases. In this study, we reveal that two distinct soluble Clp proteases exist in the unicellular cyanobacterium Synechococcus elongatus. Each protease consists of a unique proteolytic core comprised of two separate Clp subunits, one with ClpP1 and ClpP2, the other with ClpP3 and ClpR. Each core also associates with a particular HSP100 chaperone partner, ClpC in the case of the ClpP3/R core, and ClpX for the ClpP1/P2 core. The two adaptor proteins, ClpS1 and ClpS2 also interact with the ClpC chaperone protein, likely increasing the range of protein substrates targeted by the Clp protease in cyanobacteria. We also reveal the possible existence of a third Clp protease in Synechococcus, one which associates with the internal membrane network. Altogether, we show that presence of several distinctive Clp proteases in cyanobacteria, a feature which contrasts from that in most other organisms.     

Subunit stoichiometry, evolution, and functional implications of an asymmetric plant plastid ClpP/R protease complex in Arabidopsis

The caseinolytic protease (Clp) protease system has been expanded in plant plastids compared with its prokaryotic progenitors. The plastid Clp core protease consists of five different proteolytic ClpP proteins and four different noncatalytic ClpR proteins, with each present in one or more copies and organized in two heptameric rings. We determined the exact subunit composition and stoichiometry for the intact core and each ring. The chloroplast ClpP/R protease was affinity purified from clpr4 and clpp3 Arabidopsis thaliana null mutants complemented with C-terminal StrepII-tagged versions of CLPR4 and CLPP3, respectively. The subunit stoichiometry was determined by mass spectrometry-based absolute quantification using stable isotope-labeled proteotypic peptides generated from a synthetic gene. One heptameric ring contained ClpP3,4,5,6 in a 1:2:3:1 ratio. The other ring contained ClpP1 and ClpR1,2,3,4 in a 3:1:1:1:1 ratio, resulting in only three catalytic sites. These ClpP1/R1-4 proteins are most closely related to the two subunits of the cyanobacterial P3/R complex and the identical P:R ratio suggests conserved adaptation. Furthermore, the plant-specific C-terminal extensions of the ClpP/R subunits were not proteolytically removed upon assembly, suggesting a regulatory role in Clp chaperone interaction. These results will now allow testing ClpP/R structure-function relationships using rationale design. The quantification workflow we have designed is applicable to other protein complexes.     

Structure and Function of a Novel Type of ATP-dependent Clp Protease

The Clp protease is conserved among eubacteria and most eukaryotes, and uses ATP to drive protein substrate unfolding and translocation into a chamber of sequestered proteolytic active sites. The main constitutive Clp protease in photosynthetic organisms has evolved into a functionally essential and structurally intricate enzyme. The model Clp protease from the cyanobacterium Synechococcus consists of the HSP100 molecular chaperone ClpC and a mixed proteolytic core comprised of two distinct subunits, ClpP3 and ClpR. We have purified the ClpP3/R complex, the first for a Clp proteolytic core comprised of heterologous subunits. The ClpP3/R complex has unique functional and structural features, consisting of twin heptameric rings each with an identical ClpP3₃ClpR₄ configuration. As predicted by its lack of an obvious catalytic triad, the ClpR subunit is shown to be proteolytically inactive. Interestingly, extensive modification to ClpR to restore proteolytic activity to this subunit showed that its presence in the core complex is not rate-limiting for the overall proteolytic activity of the ClpCP3/R protease. Altogether, the ClpP3/R complex shows remarkable similarities to the 20 S core of the proteasome, revealing a far greater degree of convergent evolution than previously thought between the development of the Clp protease in photosynthetic organisms and that of the eukaryotic 26 S proteasome.Proteases perform numerous tasks vital for cellular homeostasis in all organisms. Much of the selective proteolysis within living cells is performed by multisubunit chaperone-protease complexes. These proteases all share a common two-component architecture and mode of action, with one of the best known examples being the proteasome in archaebacteria, certain eubacteria, and eukaryotes (1).The 20 S proteasome is a highly conserved cylindrical structure composed of two distinct types of subunits, α and β. These are organized in four stacked heptameric rings, with two central β-rings sandwiched between two outer α-rings. Although the α- and β-protein sequences are similar, it is only the latter that is proteolytic active, with a single Thr active site at the N terminus. The barrel-shaped complex is traversed by a central channel that widens up into three cavities. The catalytic sites are positioned in the central chamber formed by the β-rings, adjacent to which are two antechambers conjointly built up by β- and α-subunits. In general, substrate entry into the core complex is essentially blocked by the α-rings, and thus relies on the associating regulatory partner, PAN and 19 S complexes in archaea and eukaryotes, respectively (1). Typically, the archaeal core structure is assembled from only one type of α- and β-subunit, so that the central proteolytic chamber contains 14 catalytic active sites (2). In contrast, each ring of the eukaryotic 20 S complex has seven distinct α- and β-subunits. Moreover, only three of the seven β-subunits in each ring are proteolytically active (3). Having a strictly conserved architecture, the main difference between the 20 S proteasomes is one of complexity. In mammalian cells, the three constitutive active subunits can even be replaced with related subunits upon induction by γ-interferon to generate antigenic peptides presented by the class 1 major histocompatibility complex (4).Two chambered proteases architecturally similar to the proteasome also exist in eubacteria, HslV and ClpP. HslV is commonly thought to be the prokaryotic counterpart to the 20 S proteasome mainly because both are Thr proteases. A single type of HslV protein, however, forms a proteolytic chamber consisting of twin hexameric rather than heptameric rings (5). Also displaying structural similarities to the proteasome is the unrelated ClpP protease. The model Clp protease from Escherichia coli consists of a proteolytic ClpP core flanked on one or both sides by the ATP-dependent chaperones ClpA or ClpX (6). The ClpP proteolytic chamber is comprised of two opposing homo-heptameric rings with the catalytic sites harbored within (7). ClpP alone displays only limited peptidase activity toward short unstructured peptides (8). Larger native protein substrates need to be recognized by ClpA or ClpX and then translocated in an unfolded state into the ClpP proteolytic chamber (9, 10). Inside, the unfolded substrate is bound in an extended manner to the catalytic triads (Ser-97, His-122, and Asp-171) and degraded into small peptide fragments that can readily diffuse out (11). Several adaptor proteins broaden the array of substrates degraded by a Clp protease by binding to the associated HSP100 partner and modifying its protein substrate specificity (12, 13). One example is the adaptor ClpS that interacts with ClpA (EcClpA) and targets N-end rule substrates for degradation by the ClpAP protease (14).Like the proteasome, the Clp protease is found in a wide variety of organisms. Besides in all eubacteria, the Clp protease also exist in mammalian and plant mitochondria, as well as in various plastids of algae and plants. It also occurs in the unusual plastid in Apicomplexan protozoan (15), a family of parasites responsible for many important medical and veterinary diseases such as malaria. Of all these organisms, photobionts have by far the most diverse array of Clp proteins. This was first apparent in cyanobacteria, with the model species Synechococcus elongatus having 10 distinct Clp proteins, four HSP100 chaperones (ClpB1–2, ClpC, and ClpX), three ClpP proteins (ClpP1–3), a ClpP-like protein termed ClpR, and two adaptor proteins (ClpS1–2) (16). Of particular interest is the ClpR variant, which has protein sequence similarity to ClpP but appears to lack the catalytic triad of Ser-type proteases (17). This diversity of Clp proteins is even more extreme in photosynthetic eukaryotes, with at least 23 different Clp proteins in the higher plant Arabidopsis thaliana, most of which are plastid-localized (18).We have recently shown that two distinct Clp proteases exist in Synechococcus, both of which contain mixed proteolytic cores. The first consists of ClpP1 and ClpP2 subunits, and associates with ClpX, whereas the other has a proteolytic core consisting of ClpP3 and ClpR that binds to ClpC, as do the two ClpS adaptors (19). Of these proteases, it is the more constitutively abundant ClpCP3/R that is essential for cell viability and growth (20, 21). It is also the ClpP3/R complex that is homologous to the single type in eukaryotic plastids, all of which also have ClpC as the chaperone partner (16). In algae and plants, however, the complexity of the plastidic Clp proteolytic core has evolved dramatically. In Arabidopsis, the core complex consists of five ClpP and four ClpR paralogs, along with two unrelated Clp proteins unique to higher plants (22). Like ClpP3/R, the plastid Clp protease in Arabidopsis is essential for normal growth and development, and appears to function primarily as a housekeeping protease (23, 24).One of the most striking developments in the Clp protease in photosynthetic organisms and Apicomplexan parasites is the inclusion of ClpR within the central proteolytic core. Although this type of Clp protease has evolved into a vital enzyme, little is known about its activity or the exact role of ClpR within the core complex. To address these points we have purified the intact Synechococcus ClpP3/R proteolytic core by co-expression in E. coli. The recombinant ClpP3/R forms a double heptameric ring complex, with each ring having a specific ClpP3/R stoichiometry and arrangement. Together with ClpC, the ClpP3/R complex degrades several polypeptide substrates, but at a rate considerably slower than that by the E. coli ClpAP protease. Interestingly, although ClpR is shown to be proteolytically inactive, its inclusion in the core complex is not rate-limiting to the overall activity of the ClpCP3/R protease. In general, the results reveal remarkable similarities between the evolutionary development of the Clp protease in photosynthetic organisms and the eukaryotic proteasome relative to their simpler prokaryotic counterparts.     

Identification of a 350-kDa ClpP protease complex with 10 different Clp isoforms in chloroplasts of Arabidopsis thaliana

A 350-kDa ClpP protease complex with 10 different subunits was identified in chloroplast of Arabidopsis thaliana, using Blue-Native gel electrophoresis, followed by matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization time-of-flight and nano-electrospray tandem mass spectrometry. The complex was copurified with the thylakoid membranes, and all identified Clp subunits show chloroplast targeting signals, supporting that this complex is indeed localized in the chloroplast. The complex contains chloroplast-encoded pClpP and six nuclear-encoded proteins nCpP1-6, as well as two unassigned Clp homologues (nClpP7, nClpP8). An additional Clp protein was identified in this complex; it does not belong to any of the known Clp genes families and is here assigned ClpS1. Expression and accumulation of several of these Clp proteins have never been shown earlier. Sequence and phylogenetic tree analysis suggests that nClpP5, nClpP2, and nClpP8 are not catalytically active and form a new group of Clp higher plant proteins, orthologous to the cyanobacterial ClpR protein, and are renamed ClpR1, -2, and -3, respectively. We speculate that ClpR1, -2, and -3 are part of the heptameric rings, whereas ClpS1 is a regulatory subunit positioned at the axial opening of the ClpP/R core. Several truncations and errors in intron and exon prediction of the annotated Clp genes were corrected using mass spectrometry data and by matching genomic sequences with cDNA sequences. This strategy will be widely applicable for the much needed verification of protein prediction from genomic sequence. The extreme complexity of the chloroplast Clp complex is discussed.     

Interaction specificity between the chaperone and proteolytic components of the cyanobacterial Clp protease

The Clp protease is conserved among eubacteria and most eukaryotes, and uses ATP to drive protein substrate unfolding and translocation into a chamber of sequestered proteolytic active sites. In plant chloroplasts and cyanobacteria, the essential constitutive Clp protease consists of the Hsp100/ClpC chaperone partnering a proteolytic core of catalytic ClpP and noncatalytic ClpR subunits. In the present study, we have examined putative determinants conferring the highly specific association between ClpC and the ClpP3/R core from the model cyanobacterium Synechococcus elongatus. Two conserved sequences in the N-terminus of ClpR (tyrosine and proline motifs) and one in the N-terminus of ClpP3 (MPIG motif) were identified as being crucial for the ClpC-ClpP3/R association. These N-terminal domains also influence the stability of the ClpP3/R core complex itself. A unique C-terminal sequence was also found in plant and cyanobacterial ClpC orthologues just downstream of the P-loop region previously shown in Escherichia coli to be important for Hsp100 association to ClpP. This R motif in Synechococcus ClpC confers specificity for the ClpP3/R core and prevents association with E. coli ClpP; its removal from ClpC reverses this core specificity.     

The chloroplast protease subunit ClpP4 is a substrate of the E3 ligase AtCHIP and plays an important role in chloroplast function

Animal CHIP proteins are chaperone-dependent E3 ubiquitin ligases that physically interact with Hsp70, Hsp90 and proteasome, promoting degradation of a selective group of non-native or damaged proteins in animal cells. The plant CHIP-like protein, AtCHIP, also plays important roles in protein turnover metabolism. AtCHIP interacts with a proteolytic subunit, ClpP4, of the chloroplast Clp protease in vivo, and ubiquitylates ClpP4 in vitro. The steady-state level of ClpP4 is reduced in AtCHIP-overexpressing plants under high-intensity light conditions, suggesting that AtCHIP targets ClpP4 for degradation and thereby regulates the Clp proteolytic activity in chloroplasts under certain stress conditions. Overexpression of ClpP4 in Arabidopsis leads to chlorotic phenotypes in transgenic plants, and chloroplast structures in the chlorotic tissues of ClpP4-overexpressing plants are abnormal and largely devoid of thylakoid membranes, suggesting that ClpP4 plays a critical role in chloroplast structure and function. As AtCHIP is a cytosolic protein that has been shown to play an important role in regulating an essential chloroplast protease, this research provides new insights into the regulatory networks controlling protein turnover catabolism in chloroplasts.     

Downregulation of ClpR2 leads to reduced accumulation of the ClpPRS protease complex and defects in chloroplast biogenesis in Arabidopsis

Plastids contain tetradecameric Clp protease core complexes, with five ClpP Ser-type proteases, four nonproteolytic ClpR, and two associated ClpS proteins. Accumulation of total ClpPRS complex decreased twofold to threefold in an Arabidopsis thaliana T-DNA insertion mutant in CLPR2 designated clpr2-1. Differential stable isotope labeling of the ClpPRS complex with iTRAQ revealed a fivefold reduction in assembled ClpR2 accumulation and twofold to fivefold reductions in the other subunits. A ClpR2:(his)(6) fusion protein that incorporated into the chloroplast ClpPRS complex fully complemented clpr2-1. The reduced accumulation of the ClpPRS protease complex led to a pale-green phenotype with delayed shoot development, smaller chloroplasts, decreased thylakoid accumulation, and increased plastoglobule accumulation. Stromal ClpC1 and 2 were both recruited to the thylakoid surface in clpr2-1. The thylakoid membrane of clpr2-1 showed increased carotenoid content, partial inactivation of photosystem II, and upregulated thylakoid proteases and stromal chaperones, suggesting an imbalance in chloroplast protein homeostasis and a well-coordinated network of proteolysis and chaperone activities. Interestingly, a subpopulation of PsaF and several light-harvesting complex II proteins accumulated in the thylakoid with unprocessed chloroplast transit peptides. We conclude that ClpR2 cannot be functionally replaced by other ClpP/R homologues and that the ClpPRS complex is central to chloroplast biogenesis, thylakoid protein homeostasis, and plant development.     

The chloroplast clpP gene, encoding a proteolytic subunit of ATP-dependent protease, is indispensable for chloroplast development in tobacco

ClpP is a proteolytic subunit of the ATP-dependent Clp protease, which is found in chloroplasts in higher plants. Proteolytic subunits are encoded both by the chloroplast gene, clpP, and a nuclear multi gene family. We insertionally disrupted clpP by chloroplast transformation in tobacco. However, complete segregation was impossible, indicating that the chloroplast-encoded clpP gene has an indispensable function for cell survival. In the heteroplasmic clpP disruptant, the leaf surface was rough by clumping, and the lateral leaf expansion was irregularly arrested, which led to an asymmetric, slender leaf shape. Chloroplasts consisted of two populations: chloroplasts that were similar to the wild type, and small chloroplasts that emitted high chl fluorescence. Ultrastructural analysis of chloroplast development suggested that clpP disruption also induced swelling of the thylakoid lumen in the meristem plastids and inhibition of etioplast development in the dark. In mature leaves, thylakoid membranes of the smaller chloroplast population consisted exclusively of large stacks of tightly appressed membranes. These results indicate that chloroplast-encoded ClpP is involved in multiple processes of chloroplast development, including a housekeeping function that is indispensable for cell survival.     

Identification of clp genes expressed in senescing Arabidopsis leaves.

Clp protease is a highly selective protease in E. coli, which consists of two types of subunits, the regulatory subunit with ATPase activity, ClpA, and the catalytic subunit, ClpP. In order to examine the possible association of plant Clp protease with the degradation of protein in senescing chloroplasts, we isolated a cDNA clone for ClpC which is a plant homologue of ClpA from Arabidopsis thaliana in addition to ERD1 which we had isolated earlier [Kiyosue et al. (1993) Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 196: 1214]. We also isolated a clone for the plastidic gene, clpP (pclpP) and cDNA clones for putative nuclear clpP genes (nclpP1-6). We analyzed the expression of these clp genes in Arabidopsis leaves after various dark periods and during natural senescence. The expression of erd1 was increased by dark-induced and by natural senescence, as reported earlier [Nakashima et al. (1997) Plant J. 12: 851], while that of AtclpC was decreased. Two catalytic subunits nclpPs (nclpP3 and nclpP5) showed high expression in naturally senescing leaves, but the expression of pclpP and the other nclpPs was not changed. Immunoblot analysis of chloroplast protein and in vitro import analysis demonstrated that both nucleus-encoded regulatory subunits as well as nClpP5 were localized in the chloroplast stroma. These observations suggest that chloroplast Clp protease is composed of very complicated combinations of subunits, and that ERD1, nClpP5 and pClpP have a role in the concerted degradation of protein in senescing chloroplasts.     

Validation of the essential ClpP protease in Mycobacterium tuberculosis as a novel drug target

Mycobacterium tuberculosis is a pathogen of major global importance. Validated drug targets are required in order to develop novel therapeutics for drug-resistant strains and to shorten therapy. The Clp protease complexes provide a means for quality control of cellular proteins; the proteolytic activity of ClpP in concert with the ATPase activity of the ClpX/ClpC subunits results in degradation of misfolded or damaged proteins. Thus, the Clp system plays a major role in basic metabolism, as well as in stress responses and pathogenic mechanisms. M. tuberculosis has two ClpP proteolytic subunits. Here we demonstrate that ClpP1 is essential for viability in this organism in culture, since the gene could only be deleted from the chromosome when a second functional copy was provided. Overexpression of clpP1 had no effect on growth in aerobic culture or viability under anaerobic conditions or during nutrient starvation. In contrast, clpP2 overexpression was toxic, suggesting different roles for the two homologs. We synthesized known activators of ClpP protease activity; these acyldepsipeptides (ADEPs) were active against M. tuberculosis. ADEP activity was enhanced by the addition of efflux pump inhibitors, demonstrating that ADEPs gain access to the cell but that export occurs. Taken together, the genetic and chemical validation of ClpP as a drug target leads to new avenues for drug discovery.