Virulence Pattern of Venturia inaequalis Field Isolates and Corresponding Differential Resistance in Malus x domestica

All commercially important apple cultivars are susceptible in the field to scab caused by Venturia inaequalis. The scope of this study was to investigate variation in virulence in Venturia inaequalis populations towards commercial apple cultivars. For this purpose, primary lesions were sampled in orchards with different varietal compositions and diversities. The virulence pattern of monosporic isolates, obtained by isolation of single conidia, was assessed by cross inoculations of the cv. Ananas Reinette, Boskoop, Glockenapfel, Golden Delicious, Gravenstein, James Grieve, Jonathan, Maigold, Reinette de Champagne, Spartan and Yellow Transparent. All cultivars were susceptible to some isolates and resistant to others. No cultivar behaved the same way, which suggests the presence of differential resistance in each cultivar and corresponding virulence in some isolates. Isolates from a monoculture of Golden Delicious consisted mainly of a pathotype that was virulent to Golden Delicious but not to other cultivars. In the samples from cultivar mixtures, virulence pattern variation was considerable. The results give further evidence of the existence of a large pool of differential and ephemeral resistances in Malus, which were overcome by the local scab populations during co‐evolution.     

Phenolic compounds in apple leaves after infection with apple scab

Leaves of the scab-susceptible apple (Malus domestica) cultivar Golden Delicious were harvested from May to August 2008 and 2009. Some leaves were healthy and some infected with fungus Venturia inaequalis. The phenolic compounds were analysed in healthy leaves, infected leaves and in the scab spot tissue. In comparison to healthy leaves, the infected leaves showed higher contents of hydroxycinnamic acid, flavanols and phloridzin, while lower contents on procyanidins, quercetins and phloretin. The total amount of phenolic compounds in the infected tissue was 10 to 20 % higher than in the healthy leaves. Accumulation of phenolic compounds is a post-infection response, and probably their further transformation is a prerequisite for plant resistance.     

Infection and Stroma Formation by Venturia inaequalis on Apple Leaves with Different Degrees of Susceptibility to Scab

Conidia of Venturia inaequalis germinated and formed appressoria on all leaves independently of age and origin within the first 15 hours after inoculation. On the youngest expanded leaves of the apple variety Golden Delicious 80% of the conidia developed stromata within the first 24 hours, sporulation occurred after 8 days. On the second leaf (counted from the top of the twig) stroma formation was slowed down compared to the first and sporulation occurred after 10 days only. On the third leaf the fungus rarely formed stromata and never sporulated. The fourth leaf already showed complete ontogenetic resistance. In the diploid variety Priscilla the gene Vf, which confers resistance against scab to apple leaves, was expressed as reduced stroma formation without sporulation, as in the case of ontogenetic resistance. In the triploid variety Sir Prize with the gene Vf, stroma formation was retarded and colonization and sporulation occurred later on the first leaf, similarly to the reaction of the second leaf of variety Golden Delicious.     

Scab resistance in ‘Geneva’ apple is conditioned by a resistance gene cluster with complex genetic control

Apple scab, caused by the fungal pathogen Venturia inaequalis, is one of the most severe diseases of apple worldwide. It is the most studied plant–pathogen interaction involving a woody species using modern genetic, genomic, proteomic and bioinformatic approaches in both species. Although ‘Geneva’ apple was recognized long ago as a potential source of resistance to scab, this resistance has not been characterized previously. Differential interactions between various monoconidial isolates of V. inaequalis and six segregating F1 and F2 populations indicate the presence of at least five loci governing the resistance in ‘Geneva’. The 17 chromosomes of apple were screened using genotyping‐by‐sequencing, as well as single marker mapping, to position loci controlling the V. inaequalis resistance on linkage group 4. Next, we fine mapped a 5‐cM region containing five loci conferring both dominant and recessive scab resistance to the distal end of the linkage group. This region corresponds to 2.2 Mbp (from 20.3 to 22.5 Mbp) on the physical map of ‘Golden Delicious’ containing nine candidate nucleotide‐binding site leucine‐rich repeat (NBS‐LRR) resistance genes. This study increases our understanding of the complex genetic basis of apple scab resistance conferred by ‘Geneva’, as well as the gene‐for‐gene (GfG) relationships between the effector genes in the pathogen and resistance genes in the host.     

Growth-promoting nitrogen nutrition affects flavonoid biosynthesis in young apple (Malus domestica Borkh.) leaves

Enhanced shoot growth and a decrease in flavonoid concentration in apple trees grown under high nitrogen (N) supply was observed in previous studies, along with increasing scab susceptibility of cultivar "Golden Delicious" after high N nutrition. Several hypotheses have suggested that there is a trade-off between primary and secondary metabolism because of competition for common substrates, but nothing is known about regulation at the enzyme level. In this study, a set of experiments was performed to elucidate the effect of N nutrition on the activities of key enzymes involved in flavonoid biosynthesis (phenylalanine ammonia-lyase [PAL], chalcone synthase/chalcone isomerase [CHS/CHI}, flavanone 3-hydroxylase [FHT], flavonol synthase [FLS], dihydroflavonol 4-reductase [DFR]) and the accumulation of different groups of phenylpropanoids. The inhibition of flavonoid accumulation by high N nutrition could be confirmed, but the influence of N supply on the flavonoid enzymes CHS/CHI, FHT, DFR, and FLS was not evident. However, PAL activity seems to be downregulated, thus forming a bottleneck resulting in a generally decreased flavonoid accumulation. Furthermore, the response of the scab-resistant cultivar "Rewena" to high N nutrition was not as strong as that of the susceptible cultivar "Golden Delicious".     

Expression profiling in HcrVf2-transformed apple plants in response to Venturia inaequalis

Apple scab resistance is one of the most well-characterized plant–pathogen interactions in a woody plant species. While the HcrVf2 gene from the wild apple Malus floribunda 821 has proved capable of conferring scab resistance to the susceptible cv. Gala after genetic transformation, its identification represents only the first step in understanding the molecular mechanisms and, hence, the network of genes underlying the defence response. We used a PCR-based suppression subtractive hybridization to identify apple genes that are differentially expressed after Venturia inaequalis inoculation. Subtractive hybridization was performed between cDNA from challenged leaves of HcrVf2-resistant transgenic Gala and susceptible cv. Gala plants. A library of 523 unigenes was constructed and characterized by assigning a putative function via comparison with public databases. This set of pathogen-modulated apple genes includes many defence-related genes and is therefore an important source of information for understanding the molecular basis of the Malus–V. inaequalis interaction. Electronic supplementary material  The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Functional analysis and expression profiling of <Emphasis Type="Italic">HcrVf1</Emphasis> and <Emphasis Type="Italic">HcrVf2</Emphasis> for development of scab resistant cisgenic and intragenic apples

Apple scab resistance genes, HcrVf1 and HcrVf2, were isolated including their native promoter, coding and terminator sequences. Two fragment lengths (short and long) of the native gene promoters and the strong apple rubisco gene promoter (P_MdRbc) were used for both HcrVf genes to test their effect on expression and phenotype. The scab susceptible cultivar ‘Gala’ was used for plant transformations and after selection of transformants, they were micrografted onto apple seedling rootstocks for scab disease tests. Apple transformants were also tested for HcrVf expression by quantitative RT-PCR (qRT-PCR). For HcrVf1 the long native promoter gave significantly higher expression that the short one; in case of HcrVf2 the difference between the two was not significant. The apple rubisco gene promoter proved to give the highest expression of both HcrVf1 and HcrVf2. The top four expanding leaves were used initially for inoculation with monoconidial isolate EU-B05 which belongs to race 1 of V. inaequalis. Later six other V. inaequalis isolates were used to study the resistance spectra of the individual HcrVf genes. The scab disease assays showed that HcrVf1 did not give resistance against any of the isolates tested regardless of the expression level. The HcrVf2 gene appeared to be the only functional gene for resistance against Vf avirulent isolates of V. inaequalis. HcrVf2 did not provide any resistance to Vf virulent strains, even not in case of overexpression. In conclusion, transformants carrying the apple-derived HcrVf2 gene in a cisgenic as well as in an intragenic configuration were able to reach scab resistance levels comparable to the Vf resistant control cultivar obtained by classical breeding, cv. ‘Santana’.     

Quantification of polyphenolic compounds and relative gene expression studies of phenylpropanoid pathway in apple (Malus domestica Borkh) in response to Venturia inaequalis infection

Apple (Malus domestica Borkh) is rich in phenolic compounds, which may enhance resistance to scab disease caused by Venturia inaequalis. In present study, apple cv. Golden Delicious was used for estimation of total phenols, flavonoids and quantification of six individual phenolic compounds. between control vs inoculated samples at different inoculation stages. The relative gene expression of phenylalanine ammonia lyase, chalcone synthase and flavanone 3 hydroxylase increased and polyphenolic compounds were constitutively upregulated at different post-inoculation stages. Data suggest that synthesis and accumulation of polyphenols is closely related with disease resistance against Venturia inaequalis. This study may play a vital role in understanding and finding out the governing mechanisms of scab resistance.     

Identification of a leucine-rich repeat receptor-like serine/threonine-protein kinase as a candidate gene for <Emphasis Type="Italic">Rvi12 (Vb)</Emphasis>-based apple scab resistance

Apple scab caused by Venturia inaequalis is the most important fungal disease of apples (Malus × domestica). Currently, the disease is controlled by up to 15 fungicide applications to the crop per year. Resistant apple cultivars will help promote the sustainable control of scab in commercial orchards. The breakdown of the Rvi6 (Vf) major-gene based resistance, the most used resistance gene in apple breeding, prompted the identification and characterization of new scab resistance genes. By using a large segregating population, the Rvi12 scab resistance gene was previously mapped to a genetic location flanked by molecular markers SNP_23.599 and SNP_24.482. Starting from these markers, utilizing chromosome walking of a Hansen’s baccata #2 (HB2) BAC-library; a single BAC clone spanning the Rvi12 interval was identified. Following Pacific Biosciences (PacBio) RS II sequencing and the use of the hierarchical genome assembly process (HGAP) assembly of the BAC clone sequence, the Rvi12 resistance locus was localized to a 62.3-kb genomic region. Gene prediction and in silico characterization identified a single candidate resistance gene. The gene, named here as Rvi12_Cd5, belongs to the LRR receptor-like serine/threonine-protein kinase family. In silico comparison of the resistance allele from HB2 and the susceptible allele from Golden Delicious (GD) identified the presence of an additional intron in the HB2 allele. Conserved domain analysis identified the presence of four additional LRR motifs in the susceptible allele compared to the resistance allele. The constitutive expression of Rvi12_Cd5 in HB2, together with its structural similarity to known resistance genes, makes it the most likely candidate for Rvi12 scab resistance in apple.     

Enzyme activity of the phenylpropanoid pathway as a response to apple scab infection

The study was performed on apple trees, ‘Golden Delicious' cv., which is a scab-susceptible cultivar. The phenolic content of apple fruit was determined in different parts of the peel. The phenolic compounds were analysed in the scab spot, in the tissue around the spot and in the healthy tissue. We determined the concentration of various phenolic compounds and related enzyme activities. Infection with the Venturia inaequalis fungus enhanced the metabolism of phenolic compounds at the scab spot, around the spot and in healthy peel. Compared with the healthy tissue and the tissue around the spot, the scab spot showed higher enzyme activity for all tested enzymes, except for dihydrochalcone 2′-O-glucosyltransferase, which had lower activity in the scab spot. In comparison to the healthy peel, the scab spot showed up to 3.4 times more hydroxycinnamic acids, up to 1.1 times more dihydrochalcones and up to 1.4 times more flavan-3-ols. In contrast, the healthy peel showed up to 1.6 times more flavonols than the scab spot.     

Interaction between Venturia inaequalis and Apple Callus Tissue Cultures: an Electron Microscopic Study

Untrastructural interactions between Venturia inaequalis and callus cultures from scab susceptible and resistant apple varieties, were similar. Host cell wall changes, appositions, and invagination of host plasmamembrane at sites of close contact with fungal hyphae were regularly observed. The ultrastructural observations are described and discussed. The host cell alterations as well as many fungal structures corresponded to those known in young leaves of susceptible apple varieties.     

Polyphenol metabolism of developing apple skin of a scab resistant and a susceptible apple cultivar

During fruit development, the concentration of main polyphenols (flavonols, flavanols, dihydrochalcones, hydroxycinnamic acids, anthocyanins) and the activities of related enzymes (phenylalanine ammonia lyase, chalcone synthase/chalcone isomerase, flavanone 3-hydroxylase, dihydroflavonol 4-reductase, flavonol synthase, peroxidase) were monitored in apple (Malus domestica Borkh.). The seasonal survey was performed at five different sampling dates and included the healthy peel of the resistant cultivar ‘Florina’ and healthy peel, scab symptomatic spot and the tissue around the infected spot of the susceptible cultivar ‘Golden Delicious’. From all enzymes tested, chalcone synthase/chalcone isomerase had the highest activity in both cultivars, while phenylalanine ammonia lyase had the lowest. The healthy peels of the susceptible and the resistant cultivar did not show differences in the accumulation of the main polyphenol groups present in the apple skin. However, in the resistant cultivar ‘Florina’, an increase of polyphenol enzyme activities could be observed in late stages of fruit development, which seems to be related to the anthocyanin accumulation in ripe fruits. Significant differences in the polyphenol metabolism were observed in the three different tissues of the susceptible cultivar ‘Golden Delicious’. Increased concentrations of hydroxycinnamic acids, dihydrochalcones and flavan-3-ols were found in the scab symptomatic spots and surrounding tissues. Phenylalanine ammonia-lyase, dihydroflavonol 4-reductase, flavanone 3-hydroxylase and peroxidase showed higher activities in the scab symptomatic spot compared to other analysed tissues, whereas the activities of other enzymes remained unchanged. Highest induction of polyphenol accumulation after scab infection was observed in early developmental stages, whereas enzyme activities were increased in later stages.     

Phenotypic Reaction and Genetic Analysis Using AFLP-derived SCARs for Resistance to Apple Scab

Six sequence‐characterized amplified region (SCAR) markers linked to the apple scab resistance gene Vf were evaluated for their utility in marker‐assisted selection (MAS) in apple breeding. Of the six SCARs used in this study, ACS‐6 was located left of the Vf gene, ACS‐7 and ACS‐9 co‐segregated with Vf, and ACS‐8, ACS‐4, ACS‐5 were located right of the Vf gene. Three families derived from crosses between scab‐resistant and scab‐susceptible cultivars, including ‘Liberty’ × ‘Deljub’, ‘Liberty’ × ‘Delcorf’, and ‘Florina’ בDelcorf’, previously screened for scab resistance following greenhouse inoculation with the fungal pathogen Venturia inaequalis, were genotyped and compared with phenotypic reactions to scab infection in the field. For each family, a subset progeny of 30 seedlings (propagated onto Malling 9 rootstock and of 7 years old) was selected based on fungal sporulation according to the following scheme. Ten seedlings with no visible scab sporulation on leaves were given phenotypic scores of 0 (deemed resistant); 10 seedlings with moderate scab sporulation were given phenotypic scores of 1.0 (deemed moderately resistant); and 10 seedlings with heavy sporulation were given phenotypic scores of 2.0 (deemed susceptible). DNA was isolated from leaf tissue collected from all 90 seedlings, parents and Malus floribunda 821, the original source of the Vf gene, and screened with all six SCARs. All six SCARs were present in the two scab‐resistant parents, ‘Liberty’ and ‘Florina’, and M. floribunda 821; while, the two scab‐susceptible parents, ‘Deljub’ and ‘Delcorf’, lacked all SCARs. All SCARs were either present or absent in varying numbers of seedlings in each progeny with phenotypic ratings of either 0 (resistant) or 1.0 (moderately resistant); while all seedlings with phenotypic ratings of 2.0 (susceptible) lacked all SCARs. The inconsistencies between phenotypic scab ratings and SCAR marker data are discussed.     

Multiple field and glasshouse assessments increase the reliability of linkage mapping of the Vf source of scab resistance in apple

 Apple scab, caused by the fungus Venturia inaequalis (Cke.) Wint., is an important disease in commercial apple production. A mapping population of 155 individuals, derived from a cross between the apple varieties ‘Prima’ (resistant)בFiesta’ (susceptible), was scored for response to the disease in replicated field and glasshouse trials throughout Europe. Twenty data sets were selected and cluster analysis was used to form a consensus score for the population fitting a 1 : 1 segregation ratio of resistance:susceptibility. The progeny were scored with molecular markers. A detailed map covering 54 cM of the ‘Prima’ linkage group containing the Vf gene for scab resistance was constructed using 24 molecular markers linked to the resistance gene. One isoenzyme marker (Pgm-1), six RFLP markers and 17 RAPD markers formed a linkage group with the consensus measure of resistance to scab. Four marker bridges were established with the corresponding ‘Fiesta’ linkage group with additional markers (one isozyme, one RFLP, three RAPD and one AFLP). A low chi-square value indicated a good fit of the marker ordering, which was in close agreement with previously reported linkage positions for some of the markers and Vf. Differences were observed in the ability of different scoring methods to resolve susceptible and resistant classes. The results obtained for the consensus classification of resistance to scab for the population may suggest the presence of virulent inocula at some sites, which could overcome the Vf gene for resistance. The consequences of relying on individual scoring occasions for studying Vf scab resistance are discussed in the context of linkage analysis, conventional breeding selection, and marker-assisted selection. Received: 23 July 1997 / Accepted: 31 October 1997