Myostatin (MSTN) gene duplications in Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar): evidence for different selective pressure on teleost MSTN-1 and -2

Whereas the negative muscle regulator myostatin (MSTN) in mammals is almost exclusively expressed in the muscle by a single encoding gene, teleost fish possess at least two MSTN genes which are differentially expressed in both muscular and non-muscular tissues. Duplicated MSTN-1 genes have previously been identified in the tetraploid salmonid genome. From Atlantic salmon we succeeded in isolating the paralogous genes of MSTN-2, which shared about 70% identity with MSTN-1a and -1b. The salmon MSTN-2a cDNA encoded a predicted protein of 363 residues and included the conserved C-terminal bioactive domain. MSTN-2a seemed to be primarily expressed in the brain, and a functional role of teleost MSTN-2 in the neurogenesis similar to the inhibitory action of the closely related GDF-11 in the mammalian brain was proposed. In contrast, a frame-shift mutation in exon 1 of salmon MSTN-2b would lead to the synthesis of a putatively non-functional truncated protein. The absence of processed MSTN-2b mRNA in the examined tissues indicated that this gene has become a non-functional pseudogene. The differential, but partially overlapping, expression patterns of salmon MSTN-2a, -1a and -1b in muscular and non-muscular tissues are probably due to the different arrangement of the potential cis-acting regulatory elements identified in their putative promoter regions. Single and paired E-boxes in the MSTN-1b promoter were shown to bind both homo-and hetero-dimers of the myogenic regulatory factor MyoD and E47 in vitro of importance for initiating the myogenic program. Analyses of nucleotide substitution patterns indicated that the teleost MSTNs essentially have evolved under purifying selection, but a subset of amino acid sites under positive selective pressure were identified within the MSTN1 branch. The results may reflect the evolutionary forces related to adoption of the different functional roles proposed for the teleost MSTN isoforms. The phylogenetic analysis of multiple vertebrate MSTNs suggested at least two separate gene duplication events in the fish lineage. Linkage analysis of polymorphic microsatellites within intron 2 of salmon MSTN-1a and -1b mapped the two genes to different linkage groups in agreement with the tetraploid origin of the duplicated salmonid MSTN-1 and MSTN-2 genes.     

Metabolic and mitogenic effects of IGF-I and insulin on muscle cells of rainbow trout

The relative function of IGF-I and insulin on fish muscle metabolism and growth has been investigated by the isolation and culture at different stages (myoblasts at day 1, myocytes at day 4, and myotubes at day 10) of rainbow trout muscle cells. This in vitro model avoids interactions with endogenous peptides, which could interfere with the muscle response. In these cells, the effects of IGF-I and insulin on cell proliferation, 2-deoxyglucose (2-DG), and l-alanine uptake at different development stages, and the use of inhibitors were studied and quantified. Insulin (10-1,000 nM) and IGF-I (10-100 nM) stimulated 2-DG uptake in trout myocytes at day 4 in a similar manner (maximum of 124% for insulin and of 142% for IGF-I), and this stimulation increased when cells differentiated to myotubes (maximum for IGF-I of 193%). When incubating the cells with PD-98059 and especially cytochalasin B, a reduction in 2-DG uptake was observed, suggesting that glucose transport takes place through specific facilitative transporters. IGF-I (1-100 nM) stimulated the l-alanine uptake in myocytes at day 4 (maximum of 239%), reaching higher values of stimulation than insulin (100-1,000 nM) (maximum of 160%). This stimulation decreased when cells developed to myotubes at day 10 (118% for IGF-I and 114% for insulin). IGF-I (0.125-25 nM) had a significant effect on myoblast proliferation, measured by thymidine incorporation (maximum of 170%), and required the presence of 2-5% fetal serum (FBS) to promote thymidine uptake. On the other hand, insulin was totally ineffective in stimulating thymidine uptake. We conclude that IGF-I is more effective than insulin in stimulating glucose and alanine uptake in rainbow trout myosatellite cells and that the degree of stimulation changes when cells differentiate to myotubes. IGF-I stimulates cell proliferation in this model of muscle in vitro and insulin does not. These results indicate the important role of IGF-I on growth and metabolism of fish muscle.     

Phylogenetic analysis of the myostatin gene sub-family and the differential expression of a novel member in zebrafish

The myostatin (MSTN)-null phenotype in mammals is characterized by extreme gains in skeletal muscle mass or "double muscling" as the cytokine negatively regulates skeletal muscle growth. Recent attempts, however, to reproduce a comparable phenotype in zebrafish have failed. Several aspects of MSTN biology in the fishes differ significantly from those in mammals and at least two distinct paralogs have been identified in some species, which possibly suggests functional divergence between the different vertebrate classes or between fish paralogs. We therefore conducted a phylogenetic analysis of the entire MSTN gene sub-family. Maximum likelihood, Bayesian inference, and bootstrap analyses indicated a monophyletic distribution of all MSTN genes with two distinct fish clades: MSTN-1 and -2. These analyses further indicated that all Salmonid genes described are actually MSTN-1 orthologs and that additional MSTN-2 paralogs may be present in most, if not all, teleosts. An additional zebrafish homolog was identified by BLAST searches of the zebrafish Hierarchical Tets Generation System database and was subsequently cloned. Comparative sequence analysis of both genes (zebrafish MSTN (zfMSTN)-1 and -2) revealed many differences, primarily within the latency-associated peptide regions, but also within the bioactive domains. The 2-kb promoter region of zfMSTN-2 contained many putative cis regulatory elements that are active during myogenesis, but are lacking in the zfMSTN-1 promoter. In fact, zfMSTN-2 expression was limited to the early stages of somitogenesis, whereas zfMSTN-1 was expressed throughout embryogenesis. These data suggest that zfMSTN-2 may be more closely associated with skeletal muscle growth and development. They also resolve the previous ambiguity in classification of fish MSTN genes.     

Identification of a molecular marker for type A spermatogonia by microarray analysis using gonadal cells from pvasa-GFP transgenic rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss)

The spermatogonia of fish can be classified as being either undifferentiated type A spermatogonia or differentiated type B spermatogonia. Although type A spermatogonia, which contain spermatogonial stem cells, have been demonstrated to be a suitable material for germ cell transplantation, no molecular markers for distinguishing between type A and type B spermatogonia in fish have been developed to date. We therefore sought to develop a molecular marker for type A spermatogonia in rainbow trout. Using GFP-dependent flow cytometry (FCM), enriched fractions of type A and type B spermatogonia, testicular somatic cells, and primordial germ cells were prepared from rainbow trout possessing the green fluorescent protein (GFP) gene driven by trout vasa regulatory regions (pvasa-GFP rainbow trout). The gene-expression profiles of each cell fraction were then compared with a microarray containing cDNAs representing 16,006 genes from several salmonid species. Genes exhibiting high expression for type A spermatogonia relative to above-mentioned other types of gonadal cells were identified and subjected to RT-PCR and quatitative PCR analysis. Since only the rainbow trout notch1 homologue showed significantly high expression in the type A spermatogonia-enriched fraction, we propose that notch1 may be a useful molecular marker for type A spermatogonia. The combination of GFP-dependent FCM and microarray analysis of pvasa-GFP rainbow trout can therefore be applied to the identification of potentially useful molecular markers of germ cells in fish.     

Myostatin inhibits myoblast differentiation by down-regulating MyoD expression

Myostatin, a negative regulator of myogenesis, is shown to function by controlling the proliferation of myoblasts. In this study we show that myostatin is an inhibitor of myoblast differentiation and that this inhibition is mediated through Smad 3. In vitro, increasing concentrations of recombinant mature myostatin reversibly blocked the myogenic differentiation of myoblasts, cultured in low serum media. Western and Northern blot analysis indicated that addition of myostatin to the low serum culture media repressed the levels of MyoD, Myf5, myogenin, and p21 leading to the inhibition of myogenic differentiation. The transient transfection of C(2)C(12) myoblasts with MyoD expressing constructs did not rescue myostatin-inhibited myogenic differentiation. Myostatin signaling specifically induced Smad 3 phosphorylation and increased Smad 3.MyoD association, suggesting that Smad 3 may mediate the myostatin signal by interfering with MyoD activity and expression. Consistent with this, the expression of dominant-negative Smad3 rescued the activity of a MyoD promoter-reporter in C(2)C(12) myoblasts treated with myostatin. Taken together, these results suggest that myostatin inhibits MyoD activity and expression via Smad 3 resulting in the failure of the myoblasts to differentiate into myotubes. Thus we propose that myostatin plays a critical role in myogenic differentiation and that the muscular hyperplasia and hypertrophy seen in animals that lack functional myostatin is because of deregulated proliferation and differentiation of myoblasts.     

Influence of fish size on proliferation and differentiation of cultured myosatellite cells of white axial muscle of carp (Cyprinus carpio L.)

Abstract. The in vitro proliferation [uptake of 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine (BrdU)] and the degree of differentiation (presence of desmin) of myosatellite cells isolated from white axial muscle of carp between 3 cm and 27 cm standard length (SL) were examined 17 h after isolation. The fraction of the myosatellite cells that were both desmin positive and BrdU positive never exceeded 2% of the total number of isolated myosatellite cells, irrespective of the standard length of the donor(s). This indicates that, for carp, the temporal relationship between replication and desmin expression of myosatellite cells is different from that described for myogenic cells of mammals and birds. The percentage of BrdU positive myosatellite cells was significantly correlated with standard length: it increased from 10% for carp of about 5 cm SL to 40–50% for carp between 20 cm and 27 cm SL. The percentage of desmin positive myosatellite cells was about 50–60%; it was not significantly correlated with standard length. The percentage of myosatellite cells that were both BrdU negative and desmin negative showed a stepwise difference in this percentage with increasing length. Fish smaller than 10 cm SL, had more of these cells (10–40%), than larger fish (which had 0–12%). So, apparently the composition of the myosatellite cell population changes during growth. The low percentage of proliferating cells, and the relatively high percentage of differentiated (desmin positive) myosatellite cells obtained from 3–6 cm large carp, suggests that, in these small fish, muscle growth strongly depends on the use of a pool of myogenic cells that has been formed at an earlier stage of their development.     

Effect of genetic origin of the fish on in vitro proliferation of muscle myosatellite cells of rainbow trout

In two rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss strains fed 5% of body mass for 1 week, no significant differences were observed between the two strains in the in vitro proliferation rate of myosatellite cells isolated from white axial muscle and studied for 8 days following the incorporation of 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine. Nonetheless, the differentiation process and formation of myotubes started first in the strain displaying the fastest growth and the myotubes attained a more developed stage in these fish: more numerous and bigger myotubes. When the two strains were submitted to starvation for 1 week, the fast growing strain showed a faster response to the culture medium and a significantly higher proliferation rate than the slow growing one.     

Bacillus subtilis AB1 controls Aeromonas infection in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss, Walbaum)

AIM: To develop a probiotic with effectiveness against Aeromonas sp., which was pathogenic to rainbow trout. METHODS AND RESULTS: When Bacillus subtilis AB1, which was obtained from fish intestine, was administered for 14 days to rainbow trout in feed at a concentration of 10(7) cells per gram either as viable, formalized or sonicated cells or as cell-free supernatant, the fish survived challenge with the pathogen. AB1 stimulated immune parameters, specifically stimulating respiratory burst, serum and gut lysozyme, peroxidase, phagocytic killing, total and alpha1-antiprotease and lymphocyte populations. CONCLUSIONS: Bacillus subtilis AB1 was effective as a probiotic at controlling infections by a fish-pathogenic Aeromonas sp. in rainbow trout. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: Disease control in fish is possible by means of the oral application of live and inactivated cells and their subcellular components with the mode of action reflecting stimulation of the innate immune response.     

In vitro characterization of proliferation and differentiation of trout satellite cells

Fish satellite cells have been extracted from various species, but the myogenic characteristics of these cells in culture remain largely unknown. We show here that 60%-70% of the adherent cells are myogenic based on their immunoreactivity for the myogenic regulatory factor MyoD. In DMEM containing 10% fetal calf serum (FCS), trout myoblasts display rapid expression of myogenin (18% of myogenin-positive cells at day 2) combined with rapid fusion into myotubes (50% of myogenin-positive nuclei and 30% nuclei in myosin heavy chain [MyHC]-positive cells at day 7). These kinetics of differentiation are reminiscent of the behavior of fetal myoblasts in mammals. However, not all the myogenic cells differentiate; this subpopulation of cells might correspond to the previously named “reserve” cells. More than 90% of the BrdU-positive cells are also positive for MyoD, indicating that myogenic cells proliferate in vitro. By contrast, less than 1% of myogenin-positive cells are positive for BrdU suggesting that myogenin expression occurs only in post-mitotic cells. In order to maximize either the proliferation or the differentiation of cells, we have defined new culture conditions based on the use of a proliferation medium (F10+10%FCS) and a differentiation medium (DMEM+2%FCS). Three days after switching the medium, the differentiation index (% MyHC-positive nuclei) is 40-fold higher than that in proliferation medium, whereas the proliferation index (% BrdU-positive nuclei) is three-fold lower. Stimulation of cell proliferation by insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF1), IGF2, and FGF2 is greater in F10 medium. The characterization of these extracted muscle cells thus validates the use of this in vitro system of myogenesis in further studies of the myogenic activity of growth factors in trout.     

The production of fluorescent transgenic trout to study <Emphasis Type="Italic">in vitro</Emphasis> myogenic cell differentiation

Background  

Fish skeletal muscle growth involves the activation of a resident myogenic stem cell population, referred to as satellite cells, that can fuse with pre-existing muscle fibers or among themselves to generate a new fiber. In order to monitor the regulation of myogenic cell differentiation and fusion by various extrinsic factors, we generated transgenic trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) carrying a construct containing the green fluorescent protein reporter gene driven by a fast myosin light chain 2 (MlC2f) promoter, and cultivated genetically modified myogenic cells derived from these fish.     

Wnt4 activates the canonical β-catenin pathway and regulates negatively myostatin: functional implication in myogenesis

Expression of Wnt proteins is known to be important for developmental processes such as embryonic pattern formation and determination of cell fate. Previous studies have shown that Wn4 was involved in the myogenic fate of somites, in the myogenic proliferation, and differentiation of skeletal muscle. However, the function of this factor in adult muscle homeostasis remains not well understood. Here, we focus on the roles of Wnt4 during C2C12 myoblasts and satellite cells differentiation. We analyzed its myogenic activity, its mechanism of action, and its interaction with the anti-myogenic factor myostatin during differentiation. Established expression profiles indicate clearly that both types of cells express a few Wnts, and among these, only Wnt4 was not or barely detected during proliferation and was strongly induced during differentiation. As attested by myogenic factors expression pattern analysis and fusion index determination, overexpression of Wnt4 protein caused a strong increase in satellite cells and C2C12 myoblast differentiation leading to hypertrophic myotubes. By contrast, exposure of satellite and C2C12 cells to small interfering RNA against Wnt4 strongly diminished this process, confirming the myogenic activity of Wnt4. Moreover, we reported that Wnt4, which is usually described as a noncanonical Wnt, activates the canonical β-catenin pathway during myogenic differentiation in both cell types and that this factor regulates negatively the expression of myostatin and the regulating pathways associated with myostatin. Interestingly, we found that recombinant myostatin was sufficient to antagonize the differentiation-promoting activities of Wnt4. Reciprocally, we also found that the genetic deletion of myostatin renders the satellite cells refractory to the hypertrophic effect of Wnt4. These results suggest that the Wnt4-induced decrease of myostatin plays a functional role during hypertrophy. We propose that Wnt4 protein may be a key factor that regulates the extent of differentiation in satellite and C2C12 cells.     

A stromal cell line from rainbow trout spleen, RTS34st, that supports the growth of rainbow trout macrophages and produces conditioned medium with mitogenic effects of leukocytes

Summary A rainbow trout spleen cell line, RTS34, was developed from a long-term hemopoietic culture. This cell line consisted of a mixed stromal cell layer with an associated cell population of macrophage-like cells that formed proliferative foci and released nonadherent progeny cells into the culture medium. A stromal cell line, RTS34st, was isolated from the RTS34 cell line. RTS34st cultures contained cells with fibroblast-like and epithelial-like morphologies and showed enhanced [³H]thymidine incorporation in response to either FBS or rainbow trout serum. The combination of FBS and trout serum was synergistic. Conditioned medium from RTS34st stimulated thymidine incorporation by peripheral blood and head kidney leukocytes, but not by leukocytes from the spleen. In addition, RTS34st provided a hemopoietic inductive microenvironment for immature precursor cells, selectively supporting the growth of macrophage-like cells. Therefore, RTS34st appears useful for studying the different roles of the stroma in regulating hemopoiesis in fish.